Met friends for dinner. Sat outside (beautiful)! The food was great. Must try: fried zucchini. Best I've ever had! We lingered after eating and did not feel rushed to leave. I left my pizza to go box on ground and the ants ended up finding a snack. Even though it was my fault the restaurant replaced the pizza! Above and beyond customer service. Will definitely be back. read more

I've been to PP in Market District, so was thrilled to see a new location in Bridgeville. We made a reservation for a Tuesday evening. Our server was awesome (woman; name began with a J). But, this place is clearly just trying to earn a buck by smooshing tables so close together. You have zero space if you're in one of the middle dining tables. That was kind of annoying. We started with the crab and artichoke dip; delicious, but needs to be served with something other than bread. My husband and I both got pizzas, both of which were awesome. We ended with me having the limoncello (WAY more grain alcohol tasting than most limoncellos of its kind) and he had the Tiramisu. We needed boxes for the appetizer and the pizzas, and since we were seated at a 2 person table, there was zero room for our pizzas and no bag big enough to fit them. So, I put them on the table next to us. The hostess came over and asked if they were our pizzas and I said yes. She said "would you mind moving them? We are going to seat this 4 top. You can put them on the floor." I was like well, no, I'm not going to put my food on the floor. So she said she could hold them at the front. HUGE strike in my opinion. You don't tell a patron to put their food on the floor. Your hostesses need more training. The food here is good, but it's a bit overpriced, and so this is a "once in awhile" kind of joint. There are some kinks needing to be worked out. read more

Excellent food service and ambiance. Prices were great also. Can't wait to go again.

My friends and I chose Pizzaiolo Primo in South Fayette for a recent girls night/happy hour. This location had a special happy hour menu that runs from 4-6pm Monday through Friday and includes several $10 pizzas and appetizers along with $5 glasses of wine. We sat at the bar, though they do have three 4-top high top tables and three 2-top high top tables that are within the bar area, as well. They have a dining room adjacent to the bar. Our bartender was super friendly, funny, and quick to take our orders. We decided to share everything we ordered and couldn't decide on which apps. So, we ended up getting everything besides the mushroom pizza along with a few glasses of wine. The food came out quickly and was delicious. The pizza crust had that wood fire chew to it, the meatballs were hearty and fresh, the calamari had a great crunch and the marinara wasn't too sweet. I enjoyed the arabic the most because of the incredible cheese glob on the inside. We're already talking about going back. read more

See all

Came here on a Monday night and there was no wait so we got sat immediately! We initially had went to a different restaurant and it had a long wait and this place was only a short walk across the parking lot so we tried it out and i am so glad we did! The pasta was delicious and the vibes are super cute in there! I've only been to the one in Market Square before and this location is comparable except bigger and more parking. read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Penne Vodka and Caico E Pepe with chicken - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

Great food & beverage service at the bar! We ordered an appetizer, cavatelli, and a pizza. - all of them were delicious and Erica was a great server that also makes a proper martini! read more

Everything is Ala carte ordered a salad. I should have just ordered a head of lettuce no tomatoes very little bacon on it I will never go back read more

Stated in last review it is rather noisy, well more than rather noisy, extremely noisy! Our waitress was great! Started with the Artichoke Fritti, tasty with a nice sun dried tomato and pesto sauce and the Misto that has some really good cheeses and meats. We enjoyed a couple of pizza, swordfish, crab limone and a salad. All very good. read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

If there is a better Happy Hour in the area please let me know. The food, drinks, wine and beer are outstanding. Andrea and Kurt are the best bartender's taking care of you. This Bridgeville location has Happy Hour from 2-6pm. Arancini, Meatballs, Pizza and calamari are the best you can find anywhere. You will enjoy the food even after Happy Hour! Pasta is awesome! read more

I really like this restaurant. The food is always good. I am not easy to please when it comes to eating out. The service was a little slow but overall I would recommend eating here. read more

Arancini is by far my favorite appetizer, so I decided to try it here. It was DELICIOUS! I didn't even remember to take a picture before inhaling it lol. I ordered the margarita pizza for my dinner which was mediocre. It's a small place inside, but it does offer outdoor seating, weather permitted. read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

Such a wonderful date night spot! We shared a pizza and a pasta dish and everything was delicious! We can't wait to come back! read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Prosciutto Arugula Pizza and Penne with vodka sauce and the best chicken cutlet I've ever had - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

We didn't have reservations on a Friday night but we're surprisingly seated right away! That was a great start, until we sat there for about 10-15 minutes without anyone acknowledging us. Even more annoyingly, both tables next to us were seated after us and waited on before us. Once we finally got waited on, the server was very knowledgeable and let us know all about the fresh made pastas, sauces, and cheeses, made daily in house. I had the chicken parmigiana which was very good and a very large portion size. My last complaint was the bread... the server brought it out after we got our meals. I just thought that was weird and would've been nice to have earlier. read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Chicken parmigiana - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

I've been to Il Pizziolo in Wexford so I was excited to check out the new Pizzaiolo location in south fayette. What a great location! Super beautiful inside, clean! The others in my party ordered soups, which all looked good. One who ordered a daily soup special said hers was not hot though. Three of us got pizzas, and one got a salad. I got the diavola. It was good! Could have been spicier in my opinion. I think this place is insanely overpriced and I'd rather frequent my neighborhood Italian restaurant or other upscale pizza shops. $26 for a wood fired pizza is crazy to me. Service was mediocre, was expecting more. read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

Visited on a weekday for dinner with a party of 5 with a reservation. Our server immediately came with menus and water. We started of with the mozarella Fritto. Yum!! Soo good. Like a mozarella stick but adult version. A must order. And, great for sharing. For entrees: Pappardelle Funghi: solid choice, served with a variety of mushrooms and the pasta was fresh. The sauce complimented the ingredients nicely. Rigatoni Polpette: Super filling. Delicious. Large portion. Champion level eater (my husband) only ate half. All in all a solid choice. read more

See all

It was our first time here and we really enjoyed it. The food was delicious and our server, Jack was super friendly and attentive to our table. He went over the specials with us and checked back often. We are looking forward to coming back to try out their happy hour specials. They have a very nice patio on the outside as well. read more

See all

Good ambiance and great happy hour. If you like Italian food, it's definitely a must try. We enjoy the pizzas and pasta dishes.

This is so much more than a pizza shop, which is what I thought. Been here twice, pasta was cooked perfect. Sauces were amazing. We really enjoyed both visits so much. Full bar, nice music, great desserts and knowledgeable staff. I can't say enough nice things about this place. We put it on our go to list. read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Spaghetti - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

See all

Hubby was wanting brick oven pizza so we decided to make a trip. We are super early eaters so there was nobody at the bar when we arrived. Happy hour begins at 3:30pm, perfect. Service at the bar was good. We got the zucchini, it was fried perfectly & the sauce was amazing. We decided on the 10.00 happy hour pizza. It was way more than enough for us to share. I would have preferred it a little more cooked but was great. Only compliant is I would have liked some cheese or hot peppers right when my pizza was dropped but there wasn't a bartender around due to it getting busy. I did opt for a 9.00 cab but then the other bartender told me they had 5.00 happy hour blend that was good. For the price, it was amazing. By the time we left all the tables in the bar area were taken & the bar filled. You can't beat the happy hour prices. read more

See all

My wife and I dined here after attending a township meeting. We had reservations and were greeted by a friendly staff member who took us to our seats outside. We both ordered a Caesar salad, didn't forget the white anchovies, she ordered the appetizer stuffed peppers for her entree and I ordered the bolognese for my entree. We were very happy with our Caesar which tasted amazing and the bolognese was the very best I've ever had before. We definitely recommend Pizzaiola for a great meal. Oh yes, we will be back! read more

Hello to all!! Thursday was date night. We decided to to try Ohio's place since it is literally 5 minutes from home. We did not know what to expect , you have to make a reservation.The restaurant was very clean but we wanted to eat outside . Our Waitress Ava was very nice and attentive. The food was amazing. My wife had the chicken piccata , excellent!! I had the Swordfish on a bed of potato hash. To be honest it's pricy but what isn't today. If you're in the area , go here , you won't regret it .we will definitely be going back for our birthday meal.Great Place. I hope you enjoy it as much as we did. read more

Price and service/atmosphere don't match here. First, prices are high, so you come in with the expectation of an experience to justify those prices. I had a reservation for two at 5:30 on Super Bowl Sunday to catch up with a friend (neither of us cared about the game). Upon arrival, my friend (who arrives first) was told that we were the last reservation of the evening, and that the kitchen was closing at 6. Why didn't they contact me in advance to tell me that? We would've gone elsewhere if we had known. We were seated at a high top in the bar area (there only a few other tables being used in the entire place). Staff gathered two tables over, constantly shooting looks our way. It was incredibly uncomfortable. The food was good (I had the branzino) but didn't knock our socks off and didn't seem worth the price. There's no bread service and drink prices are also quite high. The number one problem was how uncomfortable we were for what was supposed to be a nice dinner. I also emailed the restaurant several days after our meal and it has been a week with no response. read more

New Year's Day, 2026. First time at this establishment. My parents and I were at the meadows casino and we definitely knew we needed to get some grub on our 1 hour trip back home. Concerned being New Year's Day, I proceeded to call not only to see if the establishment was open, but also if they took walk ins or recommended reservations. The lady on the phone recommended I would book a reservation so I obliged and did so. I had called just shy of 4 pm and they had an opening for 4:45 pm which worked perfectly because we were at the meadows casino. We showed up right at our reservation time, immediately got seated, IMMEDIATELY got greeted by this lovely young lady in blonde named Anne. We ordered three craft beers on draft, got the arancini as an appetizer, my mother got fettuccine Alfredo with crispy chicken, and a cup of wedding soup, my father got jumbo lump crab cakes and substituted gnocchi marinara for the side. And I got cacio e Pepe pasta. I have to say. Despite being a bit steep in price (the bill between the three of us was well over 100 bucks). It was absolutely worth every single penny! And our server Anne was beyond amazing too. Super attentive, super nice, everything there just awesome! Cannot wait to return! read more

This is definitely a place that we want to stick around in the Bridgeville/South Fayette area. The place had some usual start-up issues, but they have smoothed them out. The food is great. The bolognese is delicious, and the fettuccini alfredo may be the best that I have had at a restaurant. Definitely a must for garlic lovers! read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Misto plate - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

Our party of 6 recently dined here for the first time. Although the food was just ok, it was overpriced for what we ate. The drinks which were refilled many times were NOT unlimited. We paid for every refill. The appetizer we requested which was on the menu, we were told they didn't have it so we opted for the calamari w/hot peppers. It was ok, no tentacle!! The pasta was ok, but make no mistake about it no-one needed a doggie bag. Dessert was meh...The tiramis had no more than a total of 6 ladyfingers..all crème. Didn't taste right..the pumpkin cannoli was ok, the Pumpkin cheesecake was good as well as the break pudding. My hubby and my bill was over $105.00. We won't be back. Too expensive for just an ok experience. read more

The bar has huge TVs and great cocktails. A great old fashioned. I love the wood burning brick oven pizza. And the meatballs! I keep ordering them and I never do that. The misto platter was lovely. read more

See all

Went here within the first few months of opening and it was not very impressive. But always need to give it another chance and happy that I did about a year later as it was much better. Quality food, good atmosphere, great service. Would recommend! read more

Server - Carley, was fantastic! Had our drinks on the table, then appies arrived and dinner in a timely fashion. Appies: 1- Mussels. Those that liked mussels LOVED them! 2- Calamari. Got them 'hot' (with peppers) Fantastic breading, delicious marinara. Peppers were hot but were able to pick through them. Meals ordered - 1. Osobuco - Absolute Favorite amongst entire table. Best ordered! (Chef special) 2. Cavatelli Salsiccia - Delicious, flavorful but could have been more saucy. 3. Chef special : pasta/crab/ Real crab. Real good! 4. Chicken Picatta. Artichokes/capers white wine sauce w/lemon /green beans. Everything delicious except chicken. Texture was waaaay off - squeaky if you will. Unfortunate. Cheap piece of chicken, not cooked well. read more

We came here for lunch. The service was great -- Very attentive and nice staff! The restaurant is very spacious with a bar on one side and dining tables on the other. Our group got two pizzas, salads and soup. Everything was very good! read more

Our experience was great! Our server was fantastic, the restaurant itself is very nice, still new so I'd hope so lol, and we were seated right next to where they make the pizzas which was super cool to watch! Our food came out pretty quick (we started with the mozzarella which is not pictured-- which was phenomenal) and we both really enjoyed our choices. I will say the crab pasta was lacking in flavor (needed to add some salt and pepper) but was still very good! We'll be back! read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Margherita pizza - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

See all

So we're 1.20 hours in with no food. I'm walking to Dunkin for something from the drive-thru... can't wait till Raising Canes opens.... Orders one drink and was never asked again.... Oh well!!! read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Someone's eating..... - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

Extremely overpriced for a strip mall restaurant. Lunch menu is not available on the weekends so you have to pay the high dinner menu prices even if having lunch on Saturday or Sunday. $27 for bolognese, $20 for a pizza, $24 for fettuccini Alfredo, $27 for rigatoni and meatballs. My mom ordered hot tea (which was just a Lipton tea bag) and got a refill and was charged for two. They should have given a free refill when it's just hot water and a tea bag. read more

Unbelievably average for the money. This was our $25 cheese pizza. Barely half had cheese and sauce on it! What a rip off. read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

Great food and staff! We planned a late dinner for my daughter's high school graduation and the staff helped us accomplish a nearly impossible dinner for 13. The food was fantastic. Atmosphere was beautiful, and I can't say enough about their efficient, friendly staff. Definitely a new go to for us without having to go downtown. read more

Took my girlfriend here for her birthday a couple of weeks ago. We love the Pittsburgh location, so we thought we would try this one. Our server was super attentive, as was every other worker we encountered. Everyone was super friendly. Because I don't plan ahead, I made an impromptu request to see if they could pull together something for her birthday. They gave us a complimentary cannoli with a nice "happy birthday" in chocolate. The food was just as good as the Pittsburgh location, but a lot closer for us. We already made a rezzie for V-day. Highly recommend. read more

pizza diav was excellent- served hot and delicious . great service from Andrea as usual. great bartenders don't grow in trees. God Bless read more

New addition in South Fayette. We have now been here more than 5 times, as we live in SF. I may be done coming here. I thought I would give them a chance, to work out the kinks, since they're new. They have yet to get our bill correct, and tend to overcharge. They ran out of Cabernet 3 weeks ago. 2 weeks ago, they still didn't have any. So, this evening, I ordered the red blend. The first glass was really good. Unfortunately, after that , we were told they ran out of the red blend. Again, as a new business, in a complex with other restaurant options, you need to do better if you're going to make it. Ok, one last comment, apparently, if you pay with cash, they don't have coins in their register. The bartender very politely apologized, then said you can talk to my manager. No change x how many people = unbelievable! read more

Their food tends to be a hit or miss on quality. We love their spicy calamari when it's good quality but have seen it bad, as well. Their meatballs are good but tend to be a little pricey. We've ordered just apps before and they didn't offer us bread so I wonder if you have to get entrees. read more

Went for a late lunch at Pizzaiolo Primo had Homemade Papparelle Funghi,Wild Mushrooms,Pancetta,Cream,Parmigiano,White wine.My husband had Penne Salmon,Marinata,Cream,Peas,Parmigiano. Everything was absolutely delicious!!!! Shout out to Erica our server and Steve (GM). Make a trip,you will not be disappointed read more

Pizzaiolo Primo - Went for a late lunch at Pizzaiolo Primo had Homemade Papparelle Funghi,Wild Mushrooms,Pancetta,Cream,Parmigiano,White wine. - Wine Bars Near Me - Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

Showed up at 10:05.... Kitchen closes at 10:00..... no one would make eye contact- or tell us what was going on- or get us a table... I get closing time- but RUDE!!!! read more