Play It Again Sam

Horrible! Placed a big online order 5 subs, 2 churros. The bread was not at all fresh, the meat was…read morescant, the toppings ie. lettuce, tomato etc. was barely even present across the board on ALL subs, and to top it off the churros were old, stale and tasteless. We will NEVER go back. I'll make my own sandwiches for less, or go elsewhere but I will never waste my money on this absolute garbage.

Re-opened location. Fast, friendly service, good subs, very economical if you catch one of their…read moredeals. always double meat--shame they got rid of the "Spicy Italian," though you can rig it up with the right selections. All in all a solid location.

See all

Sonny's Italian Market & Deli

4.6(82 reviews)

29.1 mi

We drove an hour from Lancaster, intrigued by all the good reviews. Great experience. We got the…read moreclassic Philly cheesesteak and a hot turkey. (The "hot" refers to the long hots - it's a cold sub.) Both were at least 4.5 and maybe 5/5. The turkey sub was fabulous. And huge. All the ingredients for the cheesesteak were top notch, but as always, I would have preferred less cheese and more onions. There are four or maybe five stools for eating inside; otherwise you have to take it outside where they have a couple of tables out front. We did that. As we were finishing our meal, Sonny himself came out and asked how it was. Super super nice guy who obviously takes a ton of pride in what he does. I recommend this place with no hesitation. Thanks Sonny, and we will be back!

Ableist & unhelpful. I called to ask how I could order a chicken salad sub because it's available…read moreon the menu but not on DoorDash as a hoagie, only over lettuce.. I explained that due to physical limitations I can not come in & must have it delivered. They only offer delivery thru DoorDash. She told me it was DoorDashs problem that she didn't have time to look at it. I asked if I could order ANYTHING the same price or slightly more & just add a note to make it a chicken salad sandwich. She said no. I asked why she said because you'll just have to order something off of what's there. Horrific customer service & ABLEIST. Those who are disabled - you've been warned!

Front counter and food prep area

Hot Italian

See all

Just a great Italian Deli

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

Stopped by this shop while on a road trip in September and was pleasantly surprised by their…read morechicken cheesesteak. It was juicy, Flavorful, and all things good. I didn't expect much because I often experience chicken cheesesteaks that are dry or they don't season the meat. So happy that wasn't an issue here! Kent Island is some ways away but I will definitely give their Annapolis location a try the next time I have a craving for chicken cheesesteak.

Sandwiches were better than expected after going in and realizing this wasn't a true Italian deli…read more Employees were friendly and working their tails off. Only a few people in the place but it was a rather long wait for our order. Pop machine wasn't quite calibrated correctly, after a few tries we opted to just grab a bottle from the cooler.

Cheesesteaks!

Photo 1

See all

Photo 5

Twinny's Place

4.2(61 reviews)

13.1 mi

Very delicious cheesesteak! The service was super quick. They have the best pancakes on earth here!…read moreLove this place super cute old fashioned diner feel.

Had a large cheesesteak with fried onions from here the other day. Unlike their hoagie, you can eat…read morethe whole thing in one sitting. It was very good. Well seasoned, a good amount of cheese, perfectly fried onions and a decent roll (a little soft for my liking). An overall good experience. I ordered ahead for pickup at a specific time. When I arrived one of the friendly staff brought my cheesesteak out exactly on time and it was nice and hot. I will be back for sure.

Turkey sub

See all

Cheesesteak

C and C's Country Kitchen

4.6(25 reviews)

47.5 mi

Always great here. Food is very good and worth the little wait. This is quite small in seating and…read morekitchen so everything is made to order and fresh. "Do you want onions in your home fries?" Fresh!! Service is attentive and friendly. My coffee is always full and tastes great. I will be back next weekend. Maybe even later today...

Best and Fattest cheese steaks in Seaford There lg.13"…read morecheese steaks are so big I can make 3 meals outs them for 15.95. Great tasting, cooked and chopped up nice. Great service and friendly.

Another view

Great Patty Melt loaded with tater tots!

See all

A view from our table

Giolitti Delicatessen

4.3(279 reviews)

30.4 mi

This was our 1st time ordering from here. We were pleasantly surprised with the sandwich order…read morethat we received from Giolitti's Delicatessen!! The focaccia bread was fresh, the Italian meats were delicious and the mozzarella cheese was delicious! I ordered double meat on the sandwiches and they did not disappoint! I highly recommend this place!

Got an itch for Italian Spaghetti? They might have it here. We went for some lunch recently. So…read moreI didn't look into pasta - no ride to Firenze. Sandwiches were okay. There are places in Bmore that do better. Liked the guy behind cashier. Think he was new - very enthusiastic

The Italian Hard Roll Sandwich

See all

Dunkin'

3.8(4 reviews)

0.3 mi

I'm a local of Chestertown and enjoy Dunkin's brewed ice t but the last 4 times I've purchased has…read morebeen horrible. The tea has a terrible aftertaste like the tea pitcher or bin has not bin washed. Today it tasted like someone started to pour coffee into the pitcher stopped because they realized it but was too lazy again to wash it out. I'm a good customer but not anymore I will save my money or spend it elsewhere!

I come here usually before work and mainly order at the kiosk. My average order is wake up wraps…read moreand a donut and so far they have forgotten to give me the donut three times. Not a huge deal but it can be a bit annoying.

See all

Bag

Village Market and Cafe

4.9(8 reviews)

23.0 mi

Simple, yet sophisticated local market…read more Their freshly baked pastries should be enough for me to love this place....and when you add local ice cream, local meats, local cheese, and *wines*!!...what's not to love with Village Market? They had a few tables to sit, eat, relax at. The market has an opening to the bar at Pairings. I didn't ask when I picked up my cookie and scone but I wonder if I could have had it warmed up...hmm a question for next time I'm back, I suppose! And FYI: those pastries?! Yes, so much yes. The ratio of cookie to chocolate chip is highly respectable. Dare I say 50/50?! Even slightly skewed for chocolate??!? And the scone. It was actually a scone. And done well. Have you ever bought a scone and it was really a muffin in disguise? Or some sort of a croissant in another life? Well, this was a scone. Legit scone. Not too dense, not too light. Crumbly without falling apart or being too flakey. Good flavor. Bravo, scone, bravo!

This charming spot is a small cafe on the restaurant of Pairings. Always a great meal. The menu…read moreisn't very large but what they do have is primo. I cannot get past the breakfast burrito & coffee.

Interior. They serve ice cream from two local creameries too

Pistachio Muffin

See all

Waterman's Crab House

3.3(236 reviews)

11.4 mi

Stacey was an absolute delight to have wait on us. We arrived in the middle of the day on Saturday…read moreand it was a very busy, but we got seated right away. I had a delicious cocktail of the day blueberry & lemon. Stacey was very knowledgeable about the menu. They did have limited crabs so we got the mediums as that was the only one that was available, but they were heavy and delicious and fairly priced. Perfect place for a great meal great drinks and a beautiful view on a warm day.

We keep our boat right next door at Rock Hall landing and this restaurant is always one of our…read morefavorite stops! The views are absolutely incredible, and the atmosphere is perfect for relaxing after being out on the water. The bartenders, Mike, Melissa & Angie, are awesome, they always make us feel welcome and take great care of us. And you have to try the wings and hush puppies... they're seriously the best! Great food, amazing views, and fantastic people. We always look forward to coming back!

Nice, freshened up decor inside

Seafood Trio--outstanding

See all

Waterman's patio

Mommom's Ice Cream

4.7(65 reviews)

30.3 mi

I can't speak too much on the atmosphere as my eyes went straight to the ice cream when I walked…read morein. I was able to try some of their unique flavors. I settled on two scoops (absolutely huge scoops) a scoop of coffee Oreo and a scoop of monster (the blue at the top). I'm an ice cream lover and this did not disappoint. Can't wait to get more this summer.

Ugh! Looked this place up online to go get vegan ice cream. The first thing that popped up when I…read moresearched the website was that they have vegan options!! Drove there and no vegan options-that is just something they put on the website.??? Major let down.

Store front

See all

Coffee Oreo

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Bongo G.

11 years ago

Eat or drink here at your own risk. No joke. We ordered breakfast bagels, which looked good.......on the menu chalkboard. While waiting at the counter we observed one of the food preparers start to retch, and then proceed to cut up the tomato which was part of our order.....without even stopping to wash her hands. We obviously cancelled our order and exited, never to even consider returning there. read more

Spring Breakers 2.

11 years ago

After waiting 8 years to return to this legend of a coffee shop, we were ecstatic to discover that this place remains to be exceptional. From the cozy decor to the upbeat baristas this place was worthy of a HAPPY DANCE! We ordered raspberry and piña colada smoothies with whipped cream which blew our minds with its zesty zing! Come on over to the best place in Chestertown! read more

Girard B.

12 years ago

A very nice place to get coffee. The staff are friendly, the food and drinks are prepared well and quickly, and the atmosphere allows you to relax and take your time. I've been here three times now, and have enjoyed myself each time and plan to return when I can. read more

Yanni S.

166

104

7 years ago

Great coffee and sandwich find in Chestertown! Has everything a coffee house should. Good service value and the right atmosphere. Cappuccino was on point and my breakfast sandwich was made to order and legit. Would love to see this place open in the evenings :-). read more

Danil L.

2 years ago

Cute small town coffee / brunch spot. The bacon, egg, and cheese bagel sandwich was phenomenal. Stuck around to get some work done on my laptop. Will be coming back. read more

Megan P.

Elite 12

124

271

17 years ago

Dog Friendly. Anywhere I can take my dog I am happy

Theresa G.

7 years ago

Great spot for delicious sandwiches and coffee.

Claire L.

15 years ago

Awesome place to hang out on first friday!!!

Play It Again Sam - coffee - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Play It Again Sam also viewed

Muskrat Alley Cafe

4.2

(14 reviews)

Quaint little cafe that is very cute, but it is a pass. The food items are microwaved (or taste…read morelike it) and I'm sure there are better food options elsewhere.

I hate to do this to you, Muskrat Alley Cafe, but you were a complete letdown!…read more Honestly, we drove all the way to check out this place because I fell in love with their muskrat logo and the menu looked simple and delicious! The menu features bialis, bagels, Belgian waffles, quiche, breakfast wraps, smoothies, and other breakfast/lunch eats. We ordered: +the Cappy, which was a biali with egg, cheese, and sausage - the biali itself was chewy, but not in a good way; the fillings were also not warm +a Frittata, which had swiss cheese, egg, and Canadian bacon; this was super cold in the middle When we notified the staff that the items were cold, they apologized; rather than reheating it in the oven or remaking the items, it was off to the microwave they went (we heard the beep); this resulted in the food being rubbery and dried out. We had already lost our appetite, so the food was pushed off to the side. They did run out of the Mylita's Quiche (containing crab, shrimp, and cheeses), which supposedly is their famous item that gets sold out fast - at first, I was sad that we missed out on this, but after having our meal, not so much. There were some random kitschy gifts that you can purchase, mostly seasonal items, before they closed for the winter. I'm glad I was able to give this place a try, but wouldn't return. +cold/improperly 'heated' food +friendly staff +little 'store' with various seasonal items +closes for the winter +limited spots in private gravel lot

Stam’s Luncheonette

3.6

(17 reviews)

Full of flies and bad service The older lady who must be the…read moreowner was incredibly rude. She was snide to both me and my mom, I definitely won't be coming back. I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone just based on her behavior. She offered me a sample and then was annoyed when I asked for one. Gross flies are everywhere, I understand that some might get in when people open doors but this was way too many. They were distracting and gross. Steer clear!

Delicious! So cute, great service. Ice cream is home made to perfection. Will be backread more

Happy Chicken Bakery

4.4

(13 reviews)

Happy chicken catered our wedding & we were so impressed with them during the entire process. Their…read morefood is so delicious, their ingredients are fresh & our guests are still commenting on their menu over a month later. To note a few of my favorites were their buffalo chicken puff pastry bites, sweet & sour meatballs, chicken salad & pulled pork sliders, potato salad & Mac & cheese. Martha made the most delicious wedding cake ever - I'm from the UK & wanted to pay homage to my favorite British cake, the Victoria sponge. She literally blew us away with how yummy & beautiful it was. Not to mention, Martha & Zach are the most genuine, kind & down to earth people ever. I truly can't recommend them & their food enough!

When my program manager told me of Happy Chickens Friday lunch special, " crab cake Friday" , I…read morehad to have this popular lunch special: 5 ounce Crab cake sandwich on house made griddled bun (lettuce and tomato) with ramekin of homemade tartar sauce and house made chips $15.00 . Crab meat was back fin crab meat tasting of a combination of jumbo and special crab meat and flavored just right. Loving the Walton family recipe. The homemade chips were crispy, fresh, and didn't have that store bought taste. I dipped the chips in the tartar sauce because the sauce was that good. Thanks Martha and Zach!

Doc's Riverside Grille

4.1

(147 reviews)

Nice restaurant. Super sweet waitstaff. Crab soup was divine. Homemade chips yummy! Steamed shrimp…read morewas well cooked. And, the crab cake sandwich (broiled) was very good (and very little filler). We will be back!

Friends enjoyed the Seafood quesadilla…read more I had the blackened rockfish blt. Pretty good. Our waitress was nice, but she was no where to be found for long periods of time. I had to track down another waitress for items, during lunch

313 Deli

3.0

(2 reviews)

Food is fantastic, the ladies working there are awesome, friendly. The owner visited with us and…read morewas so welcoming and personable. Will comes back over and over.

We just stopped there & while their food was good, their service was horrendous! Coffee ran out &…read moredid not refill plus the half & half was curdled . Oblivious is all I can say. Totally clueless.

Elizabeth Esther Cafe

4.0

(78 reviews)

It was a nice cute space for an evening meal. My mom loved the place and food. We had an appetizer…read moreand two entrees. The berry and dark chocolate hummus my mom took to go. We had sauvignon blanc and watermelon martini as our drinks which were refreshing for the hot day. As for the server, she was nice nothing over the top and waiting time was good in my opinion for everything food, drinks, etc. I would definitely return and look into the murder mystery they have coming up!

Food, service , ambiance wonderful. If you are gluten free they have many selections. Vegan a few…read moreselections.

Cafe On The Bay

4.4

(38 reviews)

Visited for the first time this morning. I love how homey and comfy the place looks and feels. The…read morestaff is super friendly and attentive. Once we received our order, staff asked if everything tasted okay. The cafe is small but cozy enough to sit and enjoy your food and/or drink in. Its also located right on the water, so we stopped and took a stroll while we drank our lattes. I had the strawberry shortcake latte & a sausage, egg, + cheese on wheat toast. The latte was just okay, as I like my lattes on the sweeter side but the sandwich was arguably the BEST breakfast sandwich ive ever had.

I stopped in here with a friend the other day for a good lunch! The inside is very small with…read morelimited seating, but there are plenty of benches outdoors on the water to enjoy your food if it is a nice day. It was a little hot for us, but we were able to find seating indoors. We both ordered the Bacon Turkey Avocado Panini. This sandwich also comes with your choice of cheese.The size of the sandwich is pretty substantial and the turkey meat was legit! I would have liked more avocado and less cheese, or even no cheese next time. The cafe is hard to judge just from this one experience and one menu item, but overall the cafe is cute and I would try more menu items if I happened to be in the area again!

Byler’s

4.3

(60 reviews)

Before leaving Dover, last Tuesday December 2, happen to discover Bylers that came highly…read morerecommended by other fellow Yelpers. Bylers, even though a not far drive from my hotel was scenic, and learned something new that Dover, DE had Amish. Bylers a win and an amazing find, half Amish store, home furshings, and discount grocery store, deli, some prices well below regular store prices. Service and ambience were welcoming, friendly. I would recommend and return for variety and selection , when back in town.

Great variety of discounted food and beverages as well as a deli section featuring delicious lunch…read moremeats, cheeses and sandwiches (especially subs)! They also have homemade ice cream served in cones or dishes! A great atmosphere of friendly personnel and fresh vegetables and fruits!

Cafe 10:31

4.5

(4 reviews)

The church the Cafe is in is absolutely beautiful. I've had Chai and a cookie dough latte so far…read more My husband can't stop talking about the pumpkin Nola cold brew. I'm not really a pumpkin fan, but I have to admit that it was tasty. They also have baked treats available like cookies, muffins and cinnamon buns. Lastly the manager is so nice and welcoming. Definitely check them out.

I stopped in for a latte this week and the barista was really nice. The latte was also fairly good…read morealthough they did not have that many food options. They did offer me a chicken quesadilla as their lunch special which was not what I was in the mood for, but I would stop by again for coffee.

Waterman's Crab House

3.3

(236 reviews)