Fish. Cod. shrimp Delicious Love the cheeseburger with…read morefried onions then. Of coarse. Fr Fries Oh well no custard The meals are hearty so come back another time for the delicious Custard.

Breakfast is good . The food is ok. Friday fish fry give it a 3 star . No soup or Salad. Our salad…read morewas a small dish and cost us 6.00 for very little lettuce one tomato and one cucumber it was sad.

Still a great experience. Classic supper club atmosphere with friendly service from everyone;…read morehostess, bartenders and the server. Real wood fire in the fireplace. Stopped in New Year's Eve and they were busy as expected. We had a cocktail at the bar and a nice chat with other patrons while we waited for a table. Our meals came quickly after we were seated and we were very pleased with everything. Pricy, but never disappointed.

A traditional supper club. Good old fashions. Short ceilings and darker interior. A sloping…read moredinner area. Not sure I liked that. I had the duck which was very good. Pork belly as a appetizer along with deep fried brussels sprouts. Very good. I had the duck as a dinner item. Very good. Walleye and shrimp menu items were very good. A true classic restaurant.

The food is amazing and the staff is incredible!!! Can't recommend enough!! It's very nice inside…read moreas well. Delicious!!

So excited to go there and what an utter disappointment.. $90 for 2 people no drinks…read more. The food wasn't good, flavorless. We had high hopes. The place is beautiful, staff attentive but the food..sorry to say wasn't even good. Left without the intention of eating the leftovers

Food is the best ever. Employees are really nice. Good music and vibes. 5…read morestars......................................

Nice facility, great staff that are friendly and efficient. We were disappointed in the cod fish…read morefry dinner itself as portions were small, but quickly delivered. Good selection of draft beers.

pretty solid seafood, price and combos are very fair priced and the atmosphere is alright.read more

Decent seafood boil in Madison! The servers were really nice, and they sat us down immediately…read more(there was ample seating). I ordered a Combo E to share with my boyfriend and they let us sub the crawfish with mussels which was great! There was soooo much food. The sauce was a little bland in my opinion, so I wish it was more flavorful (cajun sauce, medium heat). We also found multiple pea crabs in our mussels, which negatively affected the experience since the mussels weren't cleaned to remove them. Great portion for the price though!

Fun and lovely atmosphere, New Orleans decor, went on a Sunday for brunch/lunch. There was plenty…read moreof seating, service was great, and a huge menu selection and variety to choose from. My friend and I split the fish tacos and breakfast burrito (meat on the side), and waiter was accommodating. The portion sizes are good for the price! One downside for the rice and beans - rice flavor was good but there was a crunch (rice was maybe over cooked / cooked inconsistently). Friends enjoyed the snapper and seafood pasta!

We came in just before kitchen close (9pm) and were seated right away. Unfortunately, it look about…read more10 minutes to get service. While slightly annoying, we were mostly just concerned that the kitchen was going to close on us. Luckily, it didn't, and when we did flag a server down she was super friendly and apologetic and the service was very attentive from there forward. They even comped us a desert for the wait! Over all the meal was delicious. My wife loves the blackened snapper and I tried the po boy this time. I think it could use a little more fish or less bread, but overall the seasoning was solid and the fish was flaky and delicious. We will be back!

Stopped in on a cold Wednesday night and walked in to find it warm and cozy with great Christmas…read moredecorations adding to the normal northern charm. It was busy but they were able to seat us right away. Our pleasant server provided us with drinks an our orders came quickly. I had the Wednesday special queen cut prime rib with 4 deep fried shrimp, along with sides of salad, au gratin potatoes and chicken dumpling soup. I enjoyed it all. My prime was very tender. and My wife had the breaded pork tenderloin. There were two huge tenderloins that had thin and crispy breading and were moist inside. She enjoyed them but noted a little more seasoning in the breading would have been nice. Great atmosphere and set, good food with very filling portions. 4.5

The dinner itself was good. Relish dishes did not have a lot of flavor and bread was store bought…read morerolls. Wait staff were excellent.

We had such a nice server! The Blackjack chicken sandwich was probably our favorite. The homemade…read morepub chips were great! The restaurant is casual with really nice natural light. They also have a nice outdoor seating section.

Pretty darn good fish fry ! Get the smothered bake potato. The drinks were well made and the…read moreservice was pretty good too. I would definitely go back as it's perfect to take a date ? Take your parents ? Take your friends who are looking for a place not too far away . Great view of the river to help calm the nerves

We thought Gordon Ramsey was in the house! AMAZING steaks! Our dining experience started out a…read morelittle concerning with our server. She was very nice, but seemed a bit distracted, and then we didn't see her anymore after she took our order. Another server, "Q", took over and he was delightful! Very personable, nice, patient and attentive! We eat out a lot and are no strangers to a great cut of meat grilled just right! My husband had the 18 oz ribeye (bone in) and it was perfection! He said it was one of the best steaks he's eaten in a while! He also had the split pea and ham soup and he said it was delicious! His garden salad had house-made blue cheese he said was wonderful! I chose the tenderloin, and oh my goodness, it was delicious! Cooked to perfection; great cut of meat! My Caesar salad had authentic house-made dressing. The ambiance was nice and relaxing. The bar is in another room, but it wasn't too loud being separated by a wall. We will definitely be back! Some locals told us they have the best crab cake and hamburger! He showed us his hamburger and it was so thick that he couldn't finish it! Highly recommend!

Shouting from the rooftop…read more.. We went to Theo's 24 and to say I was NOT disappointed is an understatement. We started the night getting a specialty drink of salted caramel martini. It was delicious. Now for the star of the night I got the garlic stuffed fillet. When I say it was outstanding, that is an understatement. The steak was perfectly done, and the Demi glaze was indescribable. The beefy flavor with a splash of burgundy (totally guessing) was incredible. The scallops were lightly crispy on the outside and done to perfection on the inside. Again not one complaint. We also had an amazing server, Quentin, very professional, knowledgeable, and a dash of carisma. A fabulous birthday dinner. Thank you Dave and Theo's 24 for making it a great night! People save up your $'s and visit this place.

After it being recommended to us by several people, books my birthday dinner for a Thursday evening…read morefor the Alaskan King crab legs. Opted for for the 1/2 add-on to the 5oz petite filet. Was a lot of food. But it was delicious. From the focaccia bread basket with garlic herb butter to the complimentary birthday cheesecake with caramel sauce, every bite was fantastic. We arrived early for our reservation planning to have a drink at the bar while we waited but our table was ready so we were given the option to be seated right away. Definitely see why people recommend it.

CANNOT say enough great things about this place!!…read more We made a reservation for 12 to celebrate a birthday. We had to sit at two 6 tops but that ended up being ok. The place is decorated well and has a great vibe. We were sat immediately. Can't say enough amazing things about our server. We all agreed it's the best service we've had in years!! They really pay attention to detail and are so personable. We started with some drinks. All tasted perfect. You are served focaccia bread before dinner and we could've eaten 5 bread baskets of it. So soft and fresh. The garlic butter was just the cherry on top! We ordered calamari. I only got a picture of the last two because we ate the so fast. Best calamari in Wisconsin. The oysters were super delicious as well! As good as Madison! Lobster bisque was super creamy and had adequate lobster chunks. I ordered the ribeye with onions and mushrooms. They are generous with the add ons! The halibut was amazing! It should be on the regular menu!! Well seasoned and not dry at all. This will be one of our new regular spots. It'll be nice not to drive to Madison everytime we want oysters :)