So delicious! Quick service, great vegetarian options, and very cute little restaurant. Loved itread more

Yummy yummy meal. We…read moregot the Meat Pierogi & Tatarskie Pierogi, Golabki (Stuffed Cabbage) / Meat & Rice, and Kielbasa Dish w/ Murray's Cheese Pierogi. The pierogis were my favorite. Food was ready slower than anticipated but wanted to give the benefit of the doubt. Inside was cute. I liked seeing the kitchen. I'll definitely be back to try more Pierogis.

This is a great place. Food is home made. Had borscht and pierogi. Light and flavorful. Transports…read moreyou to Poland. The addition of sour cream makes everything better. Bliniz with cheese and blueberries are incredible. It is worth the trip. Am coming back for sure Apologies for not having taken photos As for the decor, exposed brick, simple and elegant.

My friend and I went to Polonica around 2pm on a Saturday. I was getting my nails done across the…read morestreet, and the restaurant had decent reviews, so we decided to check it out. We were the only people in the restaurant the entire time, though there were a few delivery orders. The restaurant has a homey interior, with callouts to their historic presence in Bay Ridge. We ordered the chicken klopsiki ($15.65) and the Hungarian pancakes ($20). Each dish comes with a house salad, which consists of red cabbage, sauerkraut, cole slaw, beets, shredded carrots, and lettuce. The salad had nice flavors and tasted fresh! I really enjoyed the chicken klopsiki, which is a chicken meatball. The meatball was moist, and the sauce had a nice flavor, like chicken soup. The only downside was that the mashed potatoes had no flavor and tasted like powdered mashed potatoes. I liked the flavor of the Hungarian pancakes, but the ratio of pancake to filling was heavily skewed toward the pancake, which was just fried potato with minimal flavor. Therefore, I would pass on the pancakes and just get the goulash if I decided to return. Service was okay. When I asked the server for recommendations, she wasn't enthusiastic, but I was asking generally, and I could have been more specific. She left during our meal, and we had to call someone to give us the check. So after giving us the food, service was nonexistent. Overall, I liked some parts of the dishes, but nothing was so amazing that I would be itching to return again!

DELICIOUS cash only hole in the wall. The most authentic Polish home food according to me friend…read more My sister said she'd come here everyday if she lived nearby. Food came out quick and the service was so kind and nice

**CASH ONLY**…read more Visited this Polish lunchroom as well as Relax (few blocks away) on the same day. This was the better spot! Came on a Saturday at 1:30 PM. Polish plate was perfect for 2 of us, with the kielbasa and stuffed cabbage being the standouts.

Baba's Pierogies is a cozy establishment with a warm and clean first impression. There is only a…read morehandful of tables, but when I visited on a Sunday evening around 7:30pm, I was seated immediately without a wait. The server was friendly and helpful with my questions on the menu. I got the Bryndzové which is their traditional Pierogi. I got it prepared as recommended, which is boiled and with bacon. It was tasty! The bacon definitely adds a salty bite to mellow out the richness of the pierogi. I was worried the sheep cheese would be too pungent, but it wasn't. The filling I chose only comes as a full order of 9. If you are torn between a couple choices, I would do two half orders of 5. On the side I got their Fresh Cut Fries. These were excellent. I love a fry, and these checked every box for me. They were well salted though. If you have any aversion to salt, I would ask for light salt. Hoping to return again before my Brooklyn trip is over - there's several more I want to try!

Solid local spot! Came here with my pierogi pals to share a bunch of bites. My thoughts:…read more - Mac and cheese pierogies weren't for me, but my friend loved them so would say comes down to personal preference... next time I'd try jalapeno I think! - mamas fave were freaking fantastic - potato pancakes good but not particularly noteworthy - sliders I wish had more meat, the roll and onion really overpowered in my opinion - didn't get to try the schnitzel bites since they were out, but definitely want to come back to give them a try - chocolate pierogies were fun! served with housemade whipped cream - friendly service, didn't feel rushed at all - a little pricey but would gladly pay extra to support family/local biz All in all, would recommend!

Once upon a time I was obsessed with Chris's white borscht. But prior to 2025, it'd been nearly a…read moredecade since my last visit, so I was hesitant. Would it hold up, or was the disappointment inevitable? I'm happy to report that I've returned twice this year, and the white borscht is still as delicious as I remembered. It's warm, comforting, and a little tart, with slices of smoky, meaty kielbasa and hard-boiled eggs. You can get a 12-ounce "cup" or 16-ounce "bowl," and I like opting for the latter so I can bring the rest home and make it last a little longer. For other standouts on the menu, their fried cheese and potato pierogis are great, with a decent amount of filling and perfectly caramelized onions on top. The sour cream's a must, though I hate that it was an extra 75 cents. Their platters are also hearty and can easily be split into two portions. You can't go wrong with the flavorful Polish platter, which features stuffed cabbage, kielbasa, hot sauerkraut with meat (my mouth is watering just thinking about this), and three pierogis. My partner's enjoyed both the Hungarian-style potato pancake with beef goulash and the stuffed cabbage with mushroom sauce.

I was craving pierogies and found this restaurant and they didn't disappoint! It wasn't packed at…read moreall but the food was good! The ambiance is classy and it also has a bar so it has a real authentic Polish vibe. Our waitress was very friendly and answered any question we had about their menu. The borscht soup was a pleasant surprise - it tastes better than it looks, i swear! I couldn't decide whether to do boiled or fried but tbh they're both good options- you can't do any wrong picking either. I would recommend this place if you like to eat good food in peace :)

The people who work at Varenyk House are nice and not chatty. There isn't seating available. I was…read morejust in the other day and it looks like they got a bunch of new freezers and offer hot food to go now, too, not just fresh frozen! I bought a bag of frozen potato and cheese varenyk (pirogies), and they were delicious. Attaching a photo of what they looked like after I cooked them at home (boiled and then sautéed in butter with diced onion and spices).

Came on a Thursday night a few minutes before closing and they had such a large selection of…read moreUkrainian goodies! the staff were still hard away making dumplings in the back. Once stepping into the store, you are met with large freezers and fridges stuffed to the brim with all things Ukrainian. Many of their dumpling items are in large packages (2-3lbs a pack) and range from $8-$15 per lb depending on the filling. $15 a pound for their lamb and short rib Pierogis. Price-wise, it's very fair! And you can taste to quality and heart they put into these Pierogis. Can't go wrong with any flavor. I got the lamb and it was stuffed with tender lamb pieces, no filler. And they make for great quick meals! I also snagged a box of cabbage rolls stuffed with a pork and rice filling. Simple home-y flavor and better than rolls I've gotten from restaurants. Just reheat and it's ready to go! $15 for 5 large cabbage rolls was a great deal as well! Would get again. The only thing I wouldn't get again is their soup dumplings, as it was a bit difficult to cook and was a little too doughy near the top of the dumpling. Flavor wise, it was delicious and had a nice broth (assuming you didn't pop them. Only 1 didn't pop). But it was a difficult item to cook right in boiling water, like the instructions mention. Perhaps, user error. Every item is sold by weight and labeled after selecting your items. But they're happy to check the weight/explain price before purchasing.

Visited Relax and Pyza (a few blocks away) on the same day. Pyza was the better spot, though they…read moredo have amazing pierogis here! Came for lunch on a Saturday at 2:15 PM and there was no wait. I tried the fried potato and cheese pierogis (fave), the fried meat pierogis, and the stuffed cabbage. The cabbage came with sides and sadly they were out of all of our first choices, but the carrots with horseradish and coleslaw were fine.

Absolutely wonderful! A cozy but spacious dining room with nearly endless menu choice. $16 for a…read moredinner of meat, potatoes, and 2 other veggies is unheard of in NYC these days except here. Can't wait to go back.

One of my last meals on my first trip to NYC and it perfectly captured the culinary variety the…read morecity has to offer. We found Pierogi Boys tucked inside the underground Dekalb Market Hall food hall in Brooklyn. It's a small stall specializing in Polish comfort food. We decided to split their sampler platter for two. - Pierogi Sampler Platter -- included potato & cheese, sauerkraut & mushroom, and meat pierogi, all served with sour cream, caramelized onions, Polish bacon cubes, and fresh herbs. Super flavorful and comforting bites; loved the fragrant dill, savory bacon topping, and juicy dumpling fillings The ambience is modern food hall energy with lots of different vendors surrounding the space, though it wasn't too crowded on a Friday afternoon. Service was fast and our pierogi came out quickly. Definitely a memorable food hall find, I'll have to track this spot down again next time I'm in NYC.

5/5 stars for service 4/5 stars for taste…read more Have I had better pierogies? Yes. But, these were extremely good for being a food hall dish! The staff were friendly and a platter comes with a side dish of delicious borscht soup!