Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Post Office Pies

    3.5 (46 reviews)

    Order Post Office Pies Takeout or Delivery

    Post Office Pies Photos

    POST OFFICE PIES ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Post Office Pies

    Recommended Reviews - Post Office Pies

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Bar area
    Joanne J.

    Post office pies used to be one of our favorite spots for pizza, but now competition is steep in Birmingham. They do have a unique menu of wood fired pizzas, but we do find their quality inconsistent. If you like a cheese heavy pizza, this may be more of your taste. The sidewinder app was a pleasant surprise - great bite and a tasty sauce to accompany. The bartenders and servers are always friendly and fun! Overall, this local spot is a fun casual place with great art and TVs to catch a game with your food.

    Pepperoni
    Zhigen L.

    We got the Pepperoni and Chicken Pesto. We like the pepperoni one better. The sauce was delicious and large slices of pepperoni so that you get it with each bite. Chicken pesto was ok. The chicken pieces were too dry for my liking. The staff were friendly. I will visit again.

    Supreme Pizza

    We always enjoy our time at Post Office Pies! Great pizza and good service. There's a pizza for everyone here.

    Birds eye view of the 12" White Pizza
    Nicole C.

    Post Office Pies wasn't exactly a part of the original Sunday plans, but I'm glad it ended up to be! We stumbled across this cute eatery in the Mountain Brook area after visiting the Birmingham Botanical Gardens. It's only like 0.3 miles away and right next to Char Bar. P.O.P. Is also within walking distance of the Grand Bohemian Hotel if you ever stay there. This whole little Mountain Brook retail area where Post Office Pies is, is just a few steps away. We ate on the patio where they have a number of umbrellas available for shade, higher seating as well as traditional lounge areas and lower tables too. It wasn't too busy when we went (around 4pm) but even inside is pretty spacious if you still have any concerns with crowds and congestion. You can easily dine indoors at a table, at the bar or out on the patio. It was a gorgeous day out, and we opted for the patio. The service was great - server was masked and attentive but not overbearing. While they don't seem to require masks for entry, all staff members are wearing masks. The two of us in my party split a 12" White Pizza which was delicious, just slightly oily as expected with those cheeses. It comes with multiple white cheeses like mozzarella, Parmesan, ricotta & topped with a few basil leaves. The crust was good and must've been baked in a brick or woodfire oven. The 12" was plenty for us to share, and we even left with two slices to go. Oh and the menus are adorable....created to look like little postcards or envelopes, right in line with the restaurant brand. You may notice the regular post office is across the street but likely closed during weekend hours. For once you can find a post office open on a Sunday afternoon, and with this one serving fresh pizza pies it definitely has my stamp of approval!

    Bar area
    Jason B.

    This is a neat place that I didn't know was situated in Mt Brook. Their main dishes I'd say is pizza, however the staff is super friendly, especially the Asst GM. Very cordial and inviting. The premise is well kept, prices very reasonable, and parking very adequate. If you're look to bring out some friends, then this is a must stop. It's my understanding that this location is rather new, so lets see how they do as time goes by. As of yet, I've been there several times, and have yet to be disappointed. Hope you enjoy this place as much as I have. The only thing I ask is practice social distancing.

    Patio
    Katrina P.

    It's just ok. If I could give half stars, I think it really just deserves 3.5 stars. My daughters pepperoni pizza came out burned, but my husbands Margherita pizza and my own Swine pizza came out ok. Nothing tasted special though. We came at about 2-3pm, so it was probably shift change, as was apparent by the scene of half the tables all being dirty. The one guy that was working the front was friendly though. Might go back another time for a 2nd chance. Not sure.

    Cheese pizza

    See all

    4 years ago

    Yum! Had four different types of pizzas and all were excellent. Flavorful and crust was perfect, not chewy or soggy. Can't wait to go back!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of SH N.
    56
    63
    17

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Post Office Pies

    You might also consider

    Capella Pizzeria

    Capella Pizzeria

    4.8
    (194 reviews)
    6.2 mi
    $$

    Simply superb pizza. Capella's sources their ingredients from Italy and it shows in the freshness…read moreand taste. I have been a few times now and settled on the margherita pizza. It's what you might think of as a cheese pizza, the add garlic and fresh basil to the mix and it is a wonderful result. It's a hand tossed pizza with a fairly thin crust. The chew and the flavors are excellent. The staff are friendly, but don't wait on the tables, you order at the counter, they deliver you eat happily. They have TVs playing one soccer or F1 racing feed or another. It' is a European feel for sure. They have picnic tables indoors and a few small chairs outdoors with a bit of shade. Bring your dog for the outdoors maybe? My friends have done so. Capella has a large selection of bottled drinks, gelato and other Italian desserts. But the pizza is the headliner.

    Capella Pizzeria definitely deserves their high ratings…read more I came here with some others to pick up some pizzas for a family gathering. I was pleased that the had a large variety of options but even had gelato and desserts as well. Large pizzas run $21-$27 are thin crust. For pizzas, we got two of their Margheritas, Meat Buster and Palermo. They were all good and a hit at the family party. The meat Buster and Palermo had meat but honestly not a whole lot. They were good though. All the pizzas were lots of flavor and the sauce to cheese ratio was perfect. I loved that they had chili oil, extra dipping sauce, cheese, and peppers on the side for you to grab. While our time there we even had some gelato which was good and got some cheese cake to go. Our pizzas came out quick. The shop is very large with plenty of places to sit, even good for a large party. I loved that they even had plates on the table ready to go. This was a solid pizza spot and worth checking out if you prefer thinner crust.

    Photos
    Indoor seating
    Indoor seating
    My pizza was perfect
    My pizza was perfect
    Sausage and peppers on the left, mushrooms and chopped onions on the right

    See all

    Sausage and peppers on the left, mushrooms and chopped onions on the right
    Trattoria Zaza

    Trattoria Zaza

    4.5
    (497 reviews)
    2.8 mi
    $$

    This place is the best spot I been to downtown birmingham. Ive visited a few times now and the only…read moretime it wasnt great and smooth was sunday morning. I foun d out later that theyre very popular and busy for brunch so keep that in mind if you go for weekend brunch. I would suggest trying to get ahead of the 11 oclock rush or after the 1pm rush The pizza is amazing the owner cares a great deal and the menu is inspired

    This place is my type of vibe!…read more Trattoria ZaZa has been on my list of places to stop at for several years. Parking often deters me but after attending the Italian Festival earlier that day, we had a craving for pizza. I ordered the combo that includes 2 slices of the day with salad. Since I wasn't overly hungry, I offered him one of my slices and he added another slice to the order. We paid and were given a number to place on our selected table. Jazzy music played in the background while we waited on our order to be brought to the table. The natural lighting, while beautiful, made it a little warm in the building. One of the waitresses propped the door open that leads to the restrooms (which are in the hallway near the elevators) in order for cooler air to make its way in. That wasn't a deal breaker, but do be aware of that on warmer days. Our food came out after a short wait. I kept my 3 cheese slice, and gave him the pepperoni one. The cheeses were very rich and the salad, while simple without the frills, was perfectly sized and drizzled with a balsamic vinaigrette that was just the right amount. While I enjoyed my meal very much and the ambiance, he wasn't overly impressed with his. He didn't want the fresh herbs on his slices and knocked all of them off, lol. He's a simple guy with simple taste. This is definitely a place I will be revisiting with one of my girlfriends and not him next time as he didn't appreciate what ZaZA had to offer. Everyone we encountered was helpful and courteous. Our food, including drinks, was around $28, which was not bad for a cute, eclectic spot downtown. If you haven't been, make sure to try them out soon. Just don't wait as long as I did to visit!

    Photos
    Inside wait in line to order then pick your own seat inside or out
    Inside wait in line to order then pick your own seat inside or out
    Baked Feta
    Baked Feta
    Inside wait in line to order then pick your own seat

    See all

    Inside wait in line to order then pick your own seat
    Davenport's Pizza Palace

    Davenport's Pizza Palace

    4.0
    (69 reviews)
    2.9 mi
    $$

    This pizza place is located next to the AMC theater in Vestavia Hills. I was surprised to discover…read moreit because I never noticed it before. It's pretty big inside and they have a small outdoor seating area. We came here to grab some pizza before the movie. I liked that you can get an individual pizza. I just got plain but it was really good! I liked that it was a thinner crust pizza. The girl that served us was super nice and very helpful, she answered all our questions. I will definitely get pizza here again!

    Davenport's Pizza Palace gave me such a fun, memorable dining experience. I ate inside, and the…read morewhole place had this lively, nostalgic energy thanks to the arcade noise humming in the background. Instead of feeling chaotic, it actually made the vibe feel super homey, like a spot where families, friends, and regulars all blend together. The staff was wonderful, and our waiter especially was incredibly helpful! I ordered a pizza with bacon, and halfway through I realized I completely forgot to add pineapple. When I mentioned it, our waiter didn't hesitate, he brought out a side of pineapple so I could still enjoy it exactly how I wanted. That small gesture made the whole visit feel even more personal. If you're looking for great pizza, warm service, and a fun, energetic atmosphere, Davenport's is definitely worth the stop.

    Photos
    Davenport's Pizza Palace
    Pizza for One Lunch Special with Pepperoni & Sausage
    Pizza for One Lunch Special with Pepperoni & Sausage
    Large Pizza

    See all

    Large Pizza

    Post Office Pies - pizza - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...