I've gotten food from here a few times - cheesesteaks, hot pastramis, cold subs, fries - it's…read moreconvenient when in a pinch for dinner. The food is always just ok; cheesesteaks too greasy, fries either overcooked or stale. The chicken cutlet sandwich was, by far, the worst. It had the smallest single cutlet on it; it barely covered the center of the round roll.

This is a legit great sub. Bread is fresh. They don't skimp on meat. Good ratio of bread meats and…read moreveggies. Didn't skimp on jalapeños either Reel Magic - Italian sub plus mayo and jalapeños

I had an omelette for lunch and one hour later it was gone. . .passed through me like a caboose on…read morea train, straight into the toilet. I have a strong stomach so I have no idea what went wrong on that one. My co-workers who ordered food on the same order had missing food, so that's two strikes. I wish I had better news but nope, this is not going to be my go-to for Fairfield trips in the future.

Excellent roast pork and broccoli rabe hero. There was a gentleman sitting at the counter eating a…read morecheesesteak and that look really good as well.

Amazing subs for a great price! Don't sleep on this place even though it looks so random!read more

The sandwiches are absolutely fantastic. I'm not the biggest consumer of alcohol amongst my peers…read morebut I'm sure they'll have something for everyone. The staff there are friendly. Place seems kinda homey. I would definitely recommend going there if you want something to eat.

I waked in and the owner told me he made the best bacon egg and cheese on a roll in NJ. No lie, It…read morewas great!, 5 stars!

I am back in North Jersey for work. I have no idea of this is a "hidden gem," or if I am way late…read moreto the party. What a great dive-y sandwich shop/deli. Having lived in New England the last decade or so, I was so tired of living in the "sandwich desert." Knowing I could go anywhere in the area for dinner, I was craving a NJ deli. This was terrific. Service was great. The place is old-school convenience-style, clearly serving the marina. It's located perfectly. It was clean-ish/maybe...but what I was after was the food. I got a really good, and BIG Taylor ham, egg, and cheese with S/P/K. I figured it would be my appetizer (as they're typically a polite 3-bite size). This was delicious and substantial. The only thing keeping it from perfect was the ketchup was oddly tasteless. Typically the sweetness of the Heinz balances the salty of the cheese and Taylor ham. This may have been less than Heinz brand and was tasteless. For the main event, I got their Italian Sub. Add hot peppers. Holy cow! GIGANTIC AND REALLY FRESH AND TASTY!!! All of this was way more than I imagined and made me so happy to be back in the 973. Really great find by me (lucky). If this is lesser-known, go and tell everyone you know. If I'm the last to know, then you are all one step ahead! Taylor Ham was $8. Fantastic deal. Italian sub was $15. Could easily feed 2. I'll be back.

I had such a great experience with Natale's Bagel Nosh and felt like it deserved a shoutout…read more They accidentally gave me the wrong order, but honestly it was close enough to what I had ordered that I didn't even think twice about it. Mistakes happen. What really stood out was what they did after. They tried calling and texting me to let me know (I had just gotten to work so I totally missed it), and when I finally connected with them, they insisted on delivering my correct order to me and told me to keep the original one too. Just incredibly kind and thoughtful, and definitely not something you see everywhere. The food is delicious, but the customer service is what really stuck with me. You can tell they genuinely care about their customers. Will absolutely be going back

Meh. Bagels are not made there, they are made somewhere else and delivered to them. Small selection…read moreof bagels. Bagels tasted okay, not great. We were the only ones in the store and our orders got mixed up. Coffee service is self-serve style. The place itself is roomy and clean, so that's a plus. They are apparently trying to transform themselves into a deli rather than a bagel place, Hoping they do better with that.

Stopped in for lunch on March 11th and ordered a turkey and provolone sub with lettuce tomato's…read moreonions and mayo, unfortunately never received onions due to the clear language barrier between me and the owner, received a ticket to go pay at the counter guy behind the counter didn't say one word, no, how are you, thank you , have a good day which was a bit rude but regardless sub was ok and wasn't to overpriced 3/5

This was my second time coming here- my niece and I tried it a few weeks ago - all I kept thinking…read moreabout was one of their sandwiches called the fat boy3 . Who would think to put chicken fingers, cheese steak-mozzarella sticks, all together, in one sandwich it was amazing !!!The food is amazing. I had family members over today and ordered a bunch of sandwiches. They all came out amazing. Everybody has a smile. They were all perfect and everybody was satisfied -The food's great I would definitely go back to this place. There was even a little mixup with one of my orders in one sandwich... there was a mishap with one of my sandwiches miscommunication, but they were very accommodating and respectful to me and Changed it for me immediately. definitely telling everybody about this place and definitely going back again can tell that they're hard workers always have a smile on their face definitely a pleasant experience

My husband stopped in over the weekend to grab a few subs. Sandwiches were delicious! Grabbed 4…read moredifferent options. The staff helping didn't seem to know if they had prosciutto or arugula. They were quite young and probably new. I'm sure with time they will get familiar with the menu. Really enjoyed it and can't wait to come back to get more!! Keep in mind - Closed on Mondays

I was in town for training and had lunch here several days. Nice little sub shop/deli on a quaint…read moreMain Street. Staff was friendly and created their masterpieces quickly. Had subs 2 of the days and the bread was very fresh and they were packed with meat. No scales used here. Final day I decided to try the roast beef Sloppy Joe. Not what most people think of a Sloppy Joe (see pic). It was a great double decker sandwich with coleslaw and Russian dressing along with a few other items and a ton of roast beef(ok maybe slight exaggeration. If you are hungry and want a sub or sandwich this is a great place to stop. Make sure you are hungry or ready to take some home!

It's about time I wrote this place a review! It's been here forever and they seem to actually be…read moredoing okay despite the Jersey Mike's coming in a few doors down. I do believe it is family owned an independent and that's one thing I love about New Jersey is there is plenty of delis and other food options that are still independent! They must have over 50 bagel sandwich options here for you to choose from. So many choices and just pick one that works well with you and roll with it. My husband had one of their breakfast bagels that had a lot of pretzel salt on the bottom and I was there for it. It's very salty and not for everyone but I loved it and I kept sneaking little bites of his bagel where I could. There's about five or six tables to sit at and it's a small place but so glad it's there and hope they stick around for a while! Very friendly service From the staff at the counter with a nice family friendly ambience.

Realizing how far away my favorite bagel joint is, and that it really is only my favorite because I…read morenever found better, I decided to check out a few places closer to home. Enter Boonton Bagels. Just like Time for a Bagel in Morris Plains, you walk into a long, narrow building where it's awkward to find a place to stand and wait. I ordered a double egg, and cheese on a poppy - with egg prices as of 2025, I'll take them where I can get them. Food came out fairly quick, and I had a chance to look at all the spreads - again, typical bagel joint. The verdict? Not quite ready to commit yet. I enjoy the poppy saturation of the bagel, done well so most of them actually stayed on as I ate. I requested no toast, my bagel was untoasted. But the bagel was a bit thin and underflavored to earn a 5th star. The egg was fresh cooked, cheese was a bit sparse, again maybe a little lacking in flavor. Overall? A pleasant breakfast nook in Boonton. If the other places nearby don't top it, I can see myself coming back here, trying different bagels (like the French Toast!) and schmears, maybe working this into my regular food rotation. Four for now.