My husband and I went by there last night, but they we closed. Their hours aren't posted, and they don't seem consistent with them. However, we went back today for their cheese danish, canolis, & cream puffs. Their cream puffs are absolutely delicious! ;D read more

Never a bad cake or pastry from prestano. Their items are always fresh and they have made some pretty amazing customs cakes for my kids parties. Their pricing is super competitive and their homemade donuts are out of this world. read more

Great local bakery. Love the "mom n pop" store feeling when you walk in. And their egg sandwiches aren't too bad.

Everytime I walk into this bakery, my mouth waters. I love the cupcakes here and it goes without saying that the cookies are to die for. A MUST try. I'm happy to make a stop at Prestano Bakery any day of the week!! read more

The bakery is not good and the people were very rude. I could not agree more with all the other yelpers I went in when they were closing about five or 10 minutes before they were closing they were cleaning up and the lady said what do you want and I walked out. I've eaten there a few times and got different cookies and everything is just OK I would never go back because the food is not that good but mostly because the people there are so rude. read more

This is a hidden jem for lunch. They have over a dozen signature sandwiches all served on their fresh roll or hero for a lot less than a deli and served with a side of potato, macaroni or coleslaw. Try The Mess. read more

People who work there or/ own place were verbally and emotionally abusive! They cursed and screamed a me, said the F word more times than i can count. Apparently this is not the first time they treated customers like this. They are BULLYS! This should mot be tolerated read more

I don't see how this bakery can have any good reviews. Went there Wednesday around 5:00 for a birthday cake. Place was empty, 2 women working there. They kept talking to each other and pretty much ignoring me. There was not much selection and they acted put out that I asked what kind of cakes they were. I settled on a cheesecake. Didn't think it was possible to get a bad cheesecake but this bakery managed it. We threw it in the garbage after tasting it. Also tried a cannoli. The filling was awful and so runny, it was escaping the ends and ran out while eating it. Needless to say, I won't be returning to this bakery. Unfriendly atmosphere and stale, bad tasting baked goods. read more

I love the bread here at this bakery, BUT there's something wrong when you have to wait 25 minutes to purchase a loaf of bread because the 2 girls working here on a Saturday morning are both cooking many egg sandwiches! Isn't this a bakery first, not a deli? Take my advice... one girl should cook on the grill while the other takes care of its patrons! There's no excuse for someone having to wait that long for a bakery item. read more

Very average bakery, nothing more. Downgraded because in addition to their so-so quality (a lot of stuff seemed stale), their selection is impossibly small. Worst of all, service here is the pits! read more

Went there this morning purchased 4 crumb buns and what was supposed to be a small round loaf of Italian bread. When I got home the crumb buns were stale dry and hard the bread was not really Italian bread total disappointed. We used to go to the Prestano bakery in Nesconset was never disappointed but they are now closed. The search is on for a good Italian bakery read more

I first visited this bakery 3 years ago while visiting Family in Ronkonkoma. We bought Cheesecakes to bring home to my daughter-in-laws who love Cheesecakes!! They were a big hit! We were up visiting this past week, brought home 5 more of their Cheesecakes to share with my family in NC. Absolutely the Best, so light, creamy and absolutely delicious! Their Raisin Bread and Their Rye Bread was Fabulous! I am not a fan of Rye bread, but theirs was delicious! Can't wait to go back for another Visit!! The Staff were very helpful and extremely nice! read more

your average italian bakery, very friendly staff.. Has a wide variety of desserts, cookies and cakes.. i recommend trying there fresh strawberry cheesecakes well worth the money. I forget to mention they also have a deli as well. affordable lunch deals. read more

Quick services. Excellent banana pudding and amazing soda and pop homemade design in a affordable cost. I gone two times.