Great pizza! Quick service. Knots were delicious! Small restaurant hometown pizza spot vibe.read more

Delicious perfect pizza at around $20-25, shared well for 2 adults. The Sunday pie was outstanding…read more Caesar salad was disappointing , for $10 it was like a tiny fast food side salad.... something needs adjusting. Really enjoyed service and vibes, small indoor area with booths and tables. Netted patio available.

Great hazy ipa and perfect service at the bar. We did. It eat but the food looked great. Typical…read morenice Hugh end brewery decor. I will be back for dinner !!

Went here with my sister, she had a Pilsner and I had a flight with an assortment. Loved everything…read morewith the exception of the porter. I usually like Porters . For lunch we had the American sandwich with chips and the Buffalo chicken wrap with fries. Everything was fresh and tasty. Bartender was helpful and very attentive, if I'm ever in the area I'll surly return.

As a NYNJ native, I believe I have certain standards for pizza and this spot was a welcome…read moresurprise. The pizza is fresh, flavorful well balanced in flavors and the right size, texture. Service is friendly and quick. Overall, this is my go to spot for pizza in the area!

My husband mentioned that this is the same owner as the Benny's next to the brewery in Jensen…read more We've been there several times, and the pizza has always been fantastic, so once we realized there was another location much closer to us, we were excited to continue supporting them. This time, my husband called in an order for one extra-large pizza, half with everything and half pepperoni. When he went inside to pick it up, he noticed there was a strong odor that smelled like marijuana. Unfortunately, the employee had taken the order incorrectly. Instead of our pizza, she handed him a small pizza that was half meat lovers and half plain cheese. She realized the mistake after my husband mentioned the error and remade our order. We ended up waiting about eight more minutes and left with both the incorrect small pizza and the correct extra-large pizza. The pizza itself was excellent, just like we've come to expect, so no complaints there. However, having our order taken incorrectly--combined with the strong odor inside the restaurant--made for a less-than-ideal pickup experience. We'll definitely be back because the pizza is worth it, but hopefully the ordering process goes much more smoothly next time.

I wasn't expecting to absolutely love this place but I did!…read more Stephanie was our waitress and she was fabulous, answered all our questions and was friendly and incredibly attentive. I had the shrimp scampi and it was the best I've had in years! The Caesar salad was good and the garlic knots were outstanding! My husband had the lasagna and loved it. His salad was good and of course the garlic knots we both loved. The dining room had more of a diner feel I thought, which is probably good since with the food being so good, people would probably linger too long lol.

I was in this restaurant earlier today with my wife and my official ADA service dog . Not only were…read morethey rude at the counter to my wife, but when I asked for a small plastic bowl of water, so my dog could drink during to the heat, they refused! They said they cannot put water on the floor, even though I offered to be careful and clean up . Their appetizer was extremely overpriced, and the pizza was below average. we used to like this however, they clearly have changed . I will never go to this restaurant again and I'm asking any lovers to boycott publicly this restaurant.

Paid $42 expecting a meat lovers with extra cheese and 2 drinks. What I got was a cheese pizza with…read moremushrooms. I tried to call immediately after opening the box, and no answer. Make it right Pappy's.

The have a neon sign that says pizza by the slice and then turn me away and say they don't have…read moreslices, offer no alternative, not that they'll make some or it's a wait. Just a nope and send me on my way

Just another show of support for Big Apple Pizza! If I'm ever in Florida, and happen to find…read moremyself in Fort Pierce, I'll be sure to stop in to shake your hand and enjoy a slice of your pie. Great job Scott! If only there were more republicans like you, as opposed to the haters who have to trash your business just because you support President Obama. I hope your business keeps going "great guns!"

Great food, great people! The place is updated and stylish! They also do wonderful things for the…read morecommunity!

Beautiful restaurant, and I'm amazing food. Nicole was the best. Definitely I'll be back! Thank you!read more

This restaurant is absolutely beautiful, with an incredible atmosphere, but Nikole made the…read moreexperience even more special. She was warm, attentive, and went above and beyond to make sure our entire group had an amazing time. The owner, Bob, also greeted our crew personally and immediately made us feel welcome and right at home. The food was absolutely delicious from beginning to end. From the appetizers to the soups and salads, and all the way through the entrées, everything was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. Our group truly left no crumbs because every dish was that good! Between the gorgeous setting, amazing food, exceptional service, and genuine hospitality, this was an unforgettable experience. We will definitely be back!

Hands down the absolute best meatball hero on the island! I grabbed one today from Goodfellas on…read moreSeaway Drive and it completely blew me away. The bread has that perfect crispy crust on the outside while staying incredibly soft on the inside. The meatballs are perfectly seasoned, savory, and juicy, topped with an amazing marinara sauce and a mountain of beautifully melted, gooey mozzarella cheese. If you are looking for an authentic, mouth-watering sub, this is the place to go. 10/10 highly recommend!

I'm visiting Hutchinson Island and thought I'd try Goodfellas. What a disappointment. I ordered the…read moreItalian sub fully loaded, a Philly cheesesteak deluxe, and a side order of chicken tenders. The Italian sub was very scarce and looked like it was prepared in a rush by a school kid, hardly any meat, dry bread and barely any oil and vinegar or seasoning. Very disappointing. The chicken tenders were tender but appeared to have been your freezer variety. The Philly cheesesteak was best and definitely prepared with more care. All in all, I don't think I'll be back.

Alyssa is a wonderful server and the food was delicious. Eggplant parm was tasty. Definitely…read morerecommend.

I haven't had their pizza in a while but when I did, it was great!!! The BEST and I'm ordering…read moreit today!

Came recommended by coworkers, decided to try for lunch. Ordered their pizza lunch special, 2…read moreslices and a drink for $5 plus tax. For lunch hour, it wasn't packed and I was greeted right away and order was placed. Didn't take long to get my food. Pizza was real good, great quality. Nice mom and pops pizza place. Will be back

The pizza we ordered was great. The garlic knots were to die for. Fresh from the oven. Our server…read morewas the best.