Paid $42 expecting a meat lovers with extra cheese and 2 drinks. What I got was a cheese pizza with mushrooms. I tried to call immediately after opening the box, and no answer. Make it right Pappy's. read more

Pappy's Pizza - Cheese and mushroom pizza. Not a meat lovers! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

The have a neon sign that says pizza by the slice and then turn me away and say they don't have slices, offer no alternative, not that they'll make some or it's a wait. Just a nope and send me on my way read more

We are Rhode Island Italians that spent the last eight years in Louisville Kentucky. Loved the place, the bourbon, and the great local food. Pizza was not one of them! So, when we moved to Fort Pierce, we were hopeful for better pizza. Pappy's pizza is our new favorite pizza place. We get the hand tossed version cooked well done. The crust is crispy and chewy, sauce is tangy and tasty and topping are generous. I picked up the first time and the store as seating for about 20 people. The staff is friendly. We ordered delivery this time and have to say, it was a little slow. But when we got it, just as good! read more

Pappy's Pizza - Hand tossed with pepperoni and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

The pizza is really good, they've been here for years and are really good and fast at what they do. Some nights they do karaoke which is a riot, we had a lot of fun. Order anything and you'll be pleased with the service and quality! read more

Quick stop on our way back to Ft Laud. I checked Maps and Yelp and Pappy's came up w/good reviews so we stopped in for a slice. Pizza was delicious-thin crisp NY Style, large slices and sauce was perfect. Hard to find pizza this good. Owner was very nice and service was quick. Highly recommend. We will definitely be back. read more

First time eating here I'm glad I did I ordered the meat lovers med pizza The flavors are there. Stop here you'll be satisfied too I'm an over the road truck driver Truck stops near by. Friendly staff I'll have pizza leftovers . A must try read more

The pizza was great. But this is honestly the third time we got some of the rudest service we've ever encountered. We just get food and sit down. The front desk treats you like trash, you're bothering them by existing. read more

The food was hot and amazing and the staff was pleasant and nice to talk too. We enjoyed our food and sitting together. Always sports to watch on the tv ! read more

See all

Really good food here, we had the meatlovers pizza which was very flavorful and I loved the thin crispy crust. The pinwheels were awesome as well as the garlic knots. Our waitress was friendly and let us know that their dough was made fresh daily. Definitely a must try. read more

See all

The pappy wheels live up to the hype! 5 stars and delicious. They came out fast and the staff was friendly. Totally worth a return visit. Reasonably priced and filling. Restaurant was clean. Lots of parking. Fyi it can get busy around the lunch hour so you may want to call in ahead of time read more

Pappy's Pizza - The pappy wheels - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Small restaurant off the highway. Delicious pappy wheels. Nice staff, clean bathrooms.

Deep dish was not that good, total disgrace to deep dish please remove from menu. Other pizza looked better, I just love a good deep dish pizza. read more

The best calzone I've had and great prices, but unfortunately, tonight they ran out of dough and wouldn't have any until 20 minutes before they closed, but still refused to take my order. (Not the first time they ran out of ingredients and couldn't take my order.) I gave it because of the service. If it weren't for that I would have given read more

The service was adequate. Walk in ordered pizza and was brought to our table in no time. Very flavorful and the crust is just right. Not to thick and not to thin. They should turn up the AC for the dine in diners. It was a bit warm in there. Will be a return visit there. read more

The pizza I received in my opinion was not a deep dish or look anything like it does on the website picture. Said I would like pizza even though it wasn't what I ordered. read more

Super great za! I thought the crust was especially good and the cheese and sauce combo really was mouth watering no doubt. 10/10 would recommend. read more

Try the pappy wheels. AMAZING. Oh yeah pizza is good to. Definitely a place to eat ........ zzzzx nnnnkknbh jhghhb read more

Awesome service. Great food. We got the hot wings, and garlic parm. Hot wings have a great flavor. Not just your normal hot sauce. Isn't over the top spicy, but has great flavor. Everyone there was nice. We loved it read more

Ordered a calzone and a Caesar salad. Can't really mess up a Caesar salad. But the calzone is horrible the entire bottom is soaking wet with soggy soggy bread is pretty nasty not sure how your supposed to eat this giant lump of wet pizza dough read more

Pappy's Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Easy to pull into and out of, and continue your commute to wherever you're headed. Right off I95. Well worth the wait (which was only a couple minutes) for a delicious, piping hot fresh pie and you CANNOT STOP HERE WITHOUT HAVING THE PAPPY WHEELS! The marinara sauce is really delicious. The service was great. The woman who took care of us was so attentive. We just happened to bump into it and we're so glad we did! We don't know when we will be back in the area but we will definitely stop here. They told us that there are some great specials on the Pappy wheels on Wednesday's too! read more

See all

The pizza is not the best, but not the worst, the pappy wheels are phenomenal, when you walk inside it's hot and filled with smoke, and delivery takes hours. read more

It's ok nothing wrong with it but it's not my taste I'm more of a frank and Als slw kinda of guy lovely people. By the way the food was alright read more

Not the best, not the worst, extremely greasy pizza. Drive about 15 minutes to pick up a pie and salad and the pizza was not the best, wouldn't go back. read more

Pappy's Pizza - Greasy pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Super good pizza I recommend! We got the deep dish with half pepperoni. It had just the right amount of cheese , sauce and pepperoni!! Also the people were super nice. We ordered the pizza through their website and it was easy to order ! :)) read more

Pappy's Pizza - Deep-Dish Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Delicious food, ready quickly, good price. I placed an order online. The food was ready when promised. Everything was fresh and delicious.

Had food delivered to our hotel room - incredibly delicious!! Super prompt and friendly service. Pizza came exactly as ordered

Meat lovers pizza was outstanding and the price was right. Would definitely recommend 100%

We enjoy this place! Love the pappy wheels! The calzone was so huge and yummy !! Nothing bad we can say! Their desert is awesome to boot!

I live 3 miles from this restaurant, but they won't deliver to me because I'm too close to Midway. What a joke.

Food is always hot and ready when when it's supposed to be. The Papa's wheels are the best. A must have with every order.

The girl here touch the phone taking orders then took money touch the change then went and made my garlic knots did not wash hands or get sanitizer gross threw my whole order away when I got home read more

The pizza was good quality for the price. The service was fast and friendly. I would definitely come back again.

I won't order from them any longer. On at least two occasions I've ordered delivery or picked up and the order wasn't correct. The last time I placed an order two hours in advance and they still got it wrong. When I said the order wasn't correct they accused me of being "hostile." Then the owner's daughter started shouting profanities at me. I haven't been back since. read more

Pizza was hot and fresh and was really good. My order was ready in no time at all. Nice little place

Delicious & perfectly cooked every time. Made with fresh ingredients & great crust. Highly recommended read more

We got a pizza, a full order of Pappy's Pinwheels, and Pappy Balls with Reese's. It was a Friday night and we waited about an hour and a half but it was well worth it. The food was hot and amazing. As good as the pizza was we wish we would have just gotten two orders of the pinwheels. Pappy's is just a small pizza shop in not the best area but don't be fooled, the food is wonderful. Again the pinwheels are amazing!!!! read more

Im strict on my policy "positive reviews only" But i was so disturbed with my interaction with pappys pizza i had to review. First off the reviews here are misleading The pizza is not that good!! Papa johns is better and I absolutely hate corporate everything! The sauce needs some salt or garlic, or both with a splash of love! And the crush sucks. Im all for NY style thin pizza but i expect some flavor to be in the dough! Bland bland bland I drove 15 min to pay $33 for two pies that i left on top of the stove! I planned on going back and trying the pizza wheels , but oh no!! Im alright. Im not even going too begin on the delivery service. Maybe they need to take a step back and re evaluate there restaurant as a whole. I can only see down hill from here :/ read more

Just visited this place for the first time and was NOT DISAPPOINTED!! We had a medium Supreme and (of course!) the Pappy Rolls!! Sooo good. Will definitely be back!! read more

Ok first time here, gonna give two stars, food was ok and beer cold. For being in south Florida I guess that's something by their standards. Would come back again for the food if nothing else. Has a bar and a package store right next door in the same lot. And for you drunks that are on the clock, the package store has a drive through!!!! read more

The place was quiet but the young lady that waited on me and my family was rude. I will not be going back.