Located in an unassuming strip mall is the beloved Brooklyn Square Pizza. The mothership. This…read morerestaurant opened up in 2013! It was a quiet Monday, President's Day, late afternoon and coming back from a road trip. Brooklyn Square was the perfect pit stop! We had some pizza, some pasta and some salad and it was all really good. Our server highly recommended sandwich #17 and it was so good. I would have never ordered a grilled shrimp panini - - but this one was loaded with shrimp, avocado, broccoli rabe and fresh mozz -- SO GOOD - - definitely try that one! Service was also very good. Our server had so much patience - - it's hard to decide on an order because everything is so good! There's a reason Dave Portnoy gave Brooklyn Square a 8.9 rating - - the signature "upside down" pizza is so good. (Cheese on the bottom, sauce on the top). It's actually hard to even pick one slice - - so you'll have to go back and try other ones. My husband loves the eggplant rollatini....breaded eggplant rolled with ricotta, spinach, roasted red peppers with mozz on top - -that brings him back to Brooklyn Square every time! There are also quite a few other locations - Manalapan, Toms River, Bradley Beach, and the new Shrewsbury restaurant. I can't wait for them to open up their Marlboro location!

Stopped at Brooklyn Square Pizza on the way home from a weekend trip in NYC and it was the perfect…read moremove. We ordered 7 pies for our bus ride and every slice was a hit! Fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. Honestly, the only problem was that we should've ordered 10 pies because it disappeared fast. The spinach artichoke pie was especially amazing... creamy, perfectly balanced, and a standout favorite. Great pizza, great decision, and now officially a must-stop anytime we're passing through.

Food was so good! Attended a Bridal Shower and the room was perfect size. Cant wait to come back…read moreagain

Have come here several times with family and it is absolutely delicious!! Their food tastes…read moreamazing. They run a great deal 2 for $40. Such a steal. The service is great. The staff is super polite and the place is very cute inside! Would highly recommend!!

The atmosphere there is amazing, all staff are a nice guys, they have there the best food in town,…read moresandwich, hamburger, pizza, pasta and the chef Diego specials are the best, always I went I have a good experience.

Best pizza in Jackson. I only order from here and Romeo's Raintree in Freehold. I like my pizza…read morewell done and crispy, this restaurant delivers on that every time. Very consistent

I'm so glad I stumbled upon this wonderful pizzeria. I was driving around hungry, not quite sure…read morewhat I wanted for dinner, and nothing nearby was calling out to me. This spot was about 12 minutes out of the way, but my stomach said, "Do it." The parking lot is tiny -- I think there are only four spots, all of which were taken -- so I parked off to the side on an unmarked, unlit area. The restaurant itself is small as well, with just four tables, one of which was stacked with empty pizza boxes. The staff were very friendly despite being super busy, and service was impressively quick. I ordered the Pesto Vodka Sauce Grandma Pizza and had my pie in about 15 minutes. When I got home, I dug in immediately and WOW -- it was that good. I normally have only two slices and I'm done, but I ended up eating three more slices without hesitation.

Wow we were very impressed. We ordered the chicken Marsala ( Tuesday special any chicken dinner)…read morewas excellent. We ordered one dinner ( our waitress suggested)which was enough for two. Very tasty and delicious. The people working there are super friendly as bf nice. The owner is super nice. We will definitely go back and try their pizza. Glad we found this little gem m.

A mix between fast food and a diner-style restaurant. The menu is good and worth trying, portions…read moreare big, and prices are ok. The overall vibe is more toward a fast-food/ casual restaurant feel rather than anything fancy-- but food us very good. They don't have wifi. Service is ok nothing special .

Hubs and I were looking for a place to eat in the Jackson area and were originally going to go to…read morethe Jackson Diner. I saw this place and told him that I always wanted to give this place a try. Kalamata has both a restaurant and pizza place and we opted for the latter. This place also serves sushi as well. The windows were covered up so you can't see the interior but I knew it was a pizza joint. We ordered and shared the following: Eggplant parm pizza- when we got it , Hubs asked if we had the wrong pizza. This didn't look like the usual eggplant parm pizza. It was tiny pieces of eggplant and not like chunks of it. The pizza also had pesto spiral swirled around. It was a nice surprise. Hubs thought the pesto spiral was a nice touch. The pieces of eggplant was very flavorful. The sauce was very flavorful and the pizza crust was nice and soft but crispy enough on the bottom. Shakshuka- this came with 3 eggs. We thought this order was delicious. It came with a few slices of bread but it wasn't enough to sop up the sauce. Hubs brought it home to put it on top of his ramen. LOL. We also took home the tomatoes and cucumbers that came along with it as well. This place is a pleasant surprise. There were a lot of flies flying around the pizzas, but we were surprised that the flies didn't come towards us when we were eating. We were glad to not end up at the Jackson Diner. Will return to try other items on the menu.

Just finished half (all I could eat, it was so huge) Cowboy Burger delivered from Mateo's. Oneof…read morethe TOP 3 burgers I've had in New Jersey! Cooked to perfection! I can only imagine what it would have tasted like if I ate at the restaurant!!!

Ordered well done brick oven wings. Stated in notes that we wanted just wings. We don't like the…read moredrumsticks. We received 8 drumsticks and 4 wings which were far from well done. Dissappointing! Who was in the kitchen 3/26 around 6pm. Didn't pay any attention to customer's notes.

We went to the bar pie Pizza. The plain bar pie pizza was very good, but the bar pie pizza with the…read moresausage was very greasy and floppy. Overall the pizza is very good, but when you get stuff on it I guess it's just a little floppy not as Chrisp. We will be back to try the entrees.

I called to fix a mistake with my order and was talked over, yelled at, and told to "relax" instead…read moreof getting any help. No apology and no accountability. I ordered pizza and a chicken parm hero on the Slice app for pickup, but it defaulted to delivery. I called and had it switched to takeout. When I arrived, they told me it had already gone out for delivery anyway. I waited 10 minutes, the food never came back, and they refused to refund me or remake the order. All I wanted was a simple takeout order. Instead I got attitude and lost $40. I won't be back.

Please stop with all the salt..was there today me my wife and took 3 guests.fried calamari was…read moreredictous salty as was the shrimp parmigiana. Wayyyy to much salt.and 2 guest had the chicken franchise. One on plate and the other on a hero.both said it was very tough chicken.and both guests only ate have there orders.i didn't want to be embarrassed and send anything back.but I been coming there for 4 years now and never had this problem. Please pay more attention to the whats being served...especially all the salt your cooks are implementing. Wayyyy to much.you have alot of elderly people eating there with high blood pressure. Salt can be put in..but it can't be put out.so easy on the salt.and maybe pound out the chicken cutlets so there not as tough. We will be back..Hopefully dont have the same experience. Thank you.

There is a large parking lot, so you do not have to worry about parking. The staff was great --…read moresuper friendly and helpful. There is also a large seating area, so it's a good place to bring big parties. I got the chicken sandwich, and I have to say the chicken was like rubber -- very chewy. My wife had the lemon chicken, and she said the same thing about her chicken as well. Unfortunately, because of that, I'm not sure if I will be coming back.

Ordered a grilled shrimp salad that was not on the menu because I am pretty heath conscious. Did…read morenot disappoint. Huge salad. So much shrimp. Was soooo yummy! 10/10

My Wife won a $40.00 Gift Certificate for Enzo in Jackson so on 12/30/23 we went there…read more My wife ordered a salad and an Eggplant Parmigiana, well I have to say the platter was huge enough for 3 people that I told Pasquale to make them smaller, they definitely make them Extra Family Style. Cheech ordered a Margarita,medium sized thin sliced and crispy. Well we have to say that the food was delicious and fresh. This place is family friendly and family style, we met Mrs Enzo and her brother and her sons all very nice people. This is a neighborhood favorite place.

You see the special listed on the sign and also posted online, I called about it and they said I…read moreneeded the coupon. I drove there to pick up a menu, they don't have any and he still insisted I needed a coupon. I don't appreciate deceptive business practices, and if they do it once, they are comfortable with that practice. They do not need your business, don't honor their posted advertisements - even if you live in the community. In fairness of a review, the owner did offer to honor the offer this once.... and I moved on. I took the time to call, took the time to drive there, and his initial reaction was no. The business lost money today and I eat pizza frequently, so he lost much more money today than he saved....cover the deal on the sign.

They offer. Gluten free pizza. They should think about dairy free cheese. Gluten feee crust was…read moredry and crumbly. Not great. But just okay