Pizza was fresh, well seasoned, not greasy . The sausage pie was amazing…read more Highly recommend!

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and some fried shrimp w/ fries. We were a bit underwhelmed by the…read morepizza, wasn't horrible, just filling. We were not crazy about the coating on the fried shrimp either, and the fries were soggy (but that often happens with takeout FF's). Overall, a disappointing takeout experience. A weak 3 Star rating, doubtful we'll order here in the future.

Needed something easy for a large group, ordered pizza. Sister picked up and it was ready on…read morearrival. Chicken Parm Pizza- A bit in the thicker side overall and not tons of chicken, but still was tasty. Cheese pizza- traditional style, thinner which I liked, also good flavor in the sauce. Pepperoni pizza- mini pepperonis, well cooked, with a bit if crispiness. Worth a try if near the area and looking for a simple solution for dinner!

We came after a busy day an hour before closing and were all impressed with the food. I loved the…read morechicken and farfalle vodka sauce. Super flavorful and huge portions (came with a side salad too). My friend loved her chicken wrap too, but one thing she would have changed was less dressing or dressing on the side (it was a little messy). The eggplant parm was not my friend's favorite, she said it had an off taste to it she couldn't place. Would definitely come back, their vodka sauce is probably one of the best I've had in NJ/NY!

Back for a retry after a number of years. It's okay, nothing to write home about…read more I suppose a safe place to bring family. This time around our service was 5 . The pizza - dirty calm pie was good. The Italian chicken dish was a miss for us... tough chicken pieces and lacking flavor even though it had nice chucks of cut up vegetables. The lentil soup was adequate, it met base line flavor and presentation. I guess what locks and information is I noticed the population that's coming in. It's a much older crowd. Certainly the menu items are on the lower price side so it makes it affordable to go out. It's hard when you cook at home and you want to go out a couple nights a week at the weekend and for what we've been paying with inflation and the impact of tariffs we would expect a higher level of them when I'm putting out of my own kitchen. Again, a safe place a consistent place a busy place and if this is acceptable for you, then this is your go to.

Stopped in on our way home. My husband and I were greeted and seated immediately. There is plenty…read moreof seating and the place looked pretty clean. We ordered some water along with mussels in red sauce, medium pizza with half onions. The mussels were very meaty with a delicious chunky tomato sauce. The pizza had a thin crust with more sauce than cheese, more of a tomato pie taste. It was okay but not the best ratio of tomato sauce to cheese. This place probably has a great tomato pie. I would definitely return just for the mussels alone. But if I ordered a pizza, I'd be a little more specific about its preparation.

The most incredible pie. We went large tomato pie. No tables. No chairs. No BS. The best pizza in…read moreNJ. Yes. All of the usual suspects nearby have been frequented and this place beats the 2nd best in the state which is down the street. iykyk

I'm at about 3.5 stars for the Corleone pie I recently had here. It's similar to a Sicilian but…read morethinner, possibly Detroit size. The sauce was robust and not sweet, nice cheese to sauce ratio too. I just had it with fresh garlic that seemed to be skimped on, but I liked it overall. As another reviewer pointed out, this is strictly takeout unless you want to stand outside. With that caveat I might return to try a regular or specialty slice, probably not a whole pie place for me. Service was fine.

Always ask for pizza well done Cooked great all the time…read moreTry best chicken wings anywhere Fresh made calzone Is excellent

My In-Laws wanted to give this place a try since it isn't too far from where they live. So, we did…read morea takeout order last night. Was a bit difficult placing an order via phone, they had the TV blasting the background at the restaurant. But everything was ready when we picked it up, the total for one large pepperoni pizza, a medium cheesesteak, and a medium Italian Hoagie came to just over $30. Brought the food home, everything was decent. Pizza was NY style, we all liked it. My wife is very particular about her cheesesteaks, but she thought this one was pretty good, very tasty. We also wolfed down the Italian Hoagie. All in all, Red Star II gets the nod of approval from us, we'll be return customers. I want to try the Chicken Parm next time.

Hidden gem in Browns Mills, Food second to none, take it…read morefrom someone that grew up in a family where everyone cooked, atmosphere is like grandmas house. This is a long revive but please read it all. I think its important that people know something like this exists in a small town like Browns Mills when it could hold its own against any Italian restaurant in the New Jersey Philly area I recently had the opportunity to visit Riccardo's with my daughter and grandsons. when we planned to meet in town. I was familiar with this place back when the original owner Sal was running it and Vito was a little guy. It was primarily a pizza shop, in my opinion one of the best pizza shops around, with a sit down restaurant and always good authentic Italian food. Great surprise, Vito turned this place on it's head, to call it a pizza shop does not do it justice. It can unequivocally be called an Italian Restaurant that serves pizza. The entire place was revamped, the exterior looks immaculate and the interior is upscale. The second we walked in we were greeted by Vito and it felt like going to my grandparents for dinner. Everyone was all smiles and friendly with warm greetings. This to me is the hall mark of how the owner treats his staff and by extension his customers. Everything we ordered was exceptional from the gratis surprise Vito's special garlic bread to the imported Gelato and home made deserts. You will notice numerous awards on the walls and this place deserves every one of them. In my opinion Vito would be welcome as a chef in any 5 start restaurant. With all that being said the best part was the feeling Vito and his staff gives the place as a truly homy place with great Italian food. Browns Mills is beyond lucky to have this place and should appreciate it.

My sister and I stopped by for lunch today and we had such a wonderful experience. The server was…read moreso pleasant, the food was absolutely delicious and with generous portions, and the ambiance was so enjoyable. Everytime I have passed by, the palm trees and red/white umbrellas catch my attention. And now finally I was able to experience the deliciousness of this gem. Too many more successful years!

Very friendly and kind staff, i was a bit skeptical because the owner was guaranteeing that I'd…read morelike it and be back for more. It was pretty good, no real complaints, it was made fresh and it was the perfect crisp. Classic pizza joint, but they don't have ready to go slices on display.

My wife and I went into this amazing place on our trip to New Jersey. They set us up with a table…read morein the back and catered to us the whole time! Everyone was so friendly and the food was the BEST! We tried so many new things and it was all so good! The dessert i already miss because it was so good! I can't wait to go back and visit this place again. I don't understand how some people did not leave a good review because it was all BOMB! Thank you to all the amazing staff!! We miss yall already ! -From the two Cali women

Phil's takeout has been around for a long time but switched owners since the last time I visited…read more It's takeout only with a small grocery section of staples like eggs, condiments, dry pasta and half gallons of ice cream. I saw they recently added some new items to the menu and decided to order some pasta dinners. Nothing fancy but the pasta was cooked well, Alfredo sauce flavorful and portions were large. The homemade rolls were huge! I noticed they had some specialty pizza by the slice during my last visit and decided to grab some slices tonight. They were delicious. The rectangle slice has a thin flavorful crust. The sauce was perfectly fresh and the fresh mozzarella had that slightly sweet milky taste I love. The chicken slice was also good with tender chunks and lots of Parmesan cheese. I will definitely return to try other meals.

Food is always fresh and tasty. Service is prompt. This takeout place has a homey feel and an…read moreextensive menu.