I was stoked for my pizza, but it took its sweet time getting here. Over an hour later, it arrived, and let's just say it was colder than my enthusiasm after waiting for so long. Talk about a flavor flop! read more

Last Sunday night we ordered from here. I had pizza burger and my friend had a meatball parm sandwich. Our food was absolutely delicious. The pizza burger was the best i had ever had. And the people that work there are very nice! I will definitely come back! Lisa Candito read more

Used to love their Pizza but since Cioffi's took over it's just blah. So disappointing as had been a loyal and happy Proud Papas customer for 20 years. Time to move on unfortunately... read more

At proud papas, what you see is what you get. I mean that in a good way. The pizza is great, their chicken parm is great, and their calamari is the best I've had in a while. I've read some negative reviews here about service but I've never had an issue with any of their employees. There's plenty of parking in the back and the place is pretty spacious. Since I live 2 blocks down this is a solid pizza place for the family and I. I also have twins who also love their pizza and a good alternative when we're trying to figure out what to feed them for dinner. The slices are nice and warm and the cheese is tasty. Nothing that wows me about it but they're great for what you want. read more

Excellent pizza at my son's skyzone birthday party. We were advised the pizza is from here.

Located on chestnut street Street parking and there is a large parking lot in the back which is nice Inside is ok.some tables . Kinda looks half deserted. Didn't have any issues with staff. They greeted me- I ordered. I paid. I left Just tried one simple plain slice . Wanted to try from a different place other than my regular go to. My slice was warm like I like it. Nice amount of cheese. Overall-taste was ok- like a regular slice. Not terrible but not my favorite either. I didn't see very much variety in pizza slices but then again it was past 8pm. read more

See all

they ruined this place. cioffi's took over and the pizza might be 10x worse and twice as expensive.

Ordered 2 salads via Uber Eats. Easy enough I figured. Completely wrong salads were delivered. And they were $21 each!!!! Called and they really seemed like they didn't give a s**t. I drive over there only to find about a half dozen angry patrons. Way better pizza and food in the area. They're just close in proximity... but never again. Live and learn. I hear Manny's Pizza just down the block is really good! read more

Food was ok definitely not the best slice around. Service is terrible no customer service everyone is on their cellphones and they don't even talk to customers coming in. I ordered 4 slices and the young man with a hoodie on was just rude. He took the order and then walked away and was on the phone which was on speakerphone I don't understand why everyone needed to hear his conversation. The ambiance was 0 there was literally no ambiance to this place. I don't understand how 6 people standing around couldn't say thank you or goodnight. Very disappointed. read more

As a New Yorker, it almost feels like a sin to say this about a New Jersey Pizzeria, but Proud Papa's has some of the best pizza I've had. Specifically, their buffalo chicken pizza is to die for. Proud Papa's does both delivery and dine-in. There's not a ton of seating, but it's usually not packed. Their menu also doesn't stop at pizza, but includes sandwiches, salads, soup, and just about any American Italian dish you can think of- and I've been pretty happy with my meal every single one of the many times I've been here. The service is pretty fast, and their menu has a few coupons built into it. All in all, being that this is a pretty suburban pizza spot, the prices are incredibly reasonable. read more

Proud Papa's - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Caterers Near Me - Union, New Jersey

Always good food... friendly service, quick delivery . There pizza is great i love it because it's always soft, smaller pieces and the one with chicken cutlet is great too. Also try their buffalo chicken pizza! read more

Owner called a customer a "f*cking sp*c b*tch" on the phone in front of several people waiting for food. He was openly telling people 20 minutes for orders that were taking 45-50 minutes to prepare. He was rude to every single person who interacted with him (there were probably 8 people all waiting for orders). In a town full of quality Italian food there is literally never any reason to ever eat there. Hope the racist pig gets what he deserves. read more

Been coming here for long time. We really like their thin crust pizza. Great chicken Cesar salad & minestrone soup. They even have gelato. Love that they have a rewards program which keeps you coming back. read more

Proud Papa's - Caterers Near Me - Union, New Jersey

Pizza is Always delicious. I only order from here for the past 2 years. The chicken Caesar salad and burger with fries is delicious too.

Excellent slice, one bite everybody knows the rules. 8.4. I grew up in the East village this reminds me of good New York slice. F@king Yum read more

Proud Papa's - Caterers Near Me - Union, New Jersey

Proud Papas is one of the best pizzerias in Union. The mozzarella sticks are my favorite because they are doughy and crispy. The grilled chicken salad (shown with no peppers) is to die for. The chicken has a nice char and if eaten with the fresh mozzarella, it is a perfect bite. The Old World pizza, which is basically a white pizza with basil on top, is also a must try. The calzones here are sufficiently cheesy but could use a little more toppings. The delivery is relatively quick and the delivery people are always pleasant. If I am craving pizza, Proud Papas will always be the first place I order from. read more

See all

I ordered from them for the first time. Pizza arrived piping hot within half an hour on a Saturday evening. Pie was exactly as I ordered it. Excellent crust and cheese. So much better than other pizzerias in the Union area. read more

I would save everything was done fresh just from working in many locations. Portion is Big recently I've been ordering and the chicken parm came in a separate dish and for the price I was surprised. Also bonus reward system so the more you order you accumulate points towards free food which is good that he rewards good customers or just regular customers. ordered most of the menu items and I'm yet to be disappointed I haven't been in a while but I know it's a recently-built establishment not something that's been sitting around and Dusty and dirty actually very clean plenty of seating 2 bathrooms. Has been in Union for almost 30 plus years so I guess the test of time is what proves quality and that's what I look at when I look at places to eat there's a reason they stay around for a long time under the same ownership. read more

Best pizza in town. I cant rave enough.... the sicilian is legit, plain or with any topping.

I cannot even begin to tell you how bummed I am... This was my favorite go to Italian place. I've been a customer probably 6 years.. I ordered 2 sandwiches the other day. Chicken Parm and Shrimp Parm.. THEY CHANGED THE BREAD! THEY MUST BE GETTING IT FROM A DIFFERENT SUPPLIER. IT'S AWFUL. They use to offer small or full-size subs with fantastic bread. They now offer one size and it's like eating ceiling tile. Please go back to the old vendor. I'm a customer who would pay more for quality. I cannot order a sandwich with this bread..it's really bad. read more

Would give no stars if possible. Extremely rude and terrible customer service! I didn't even get the chance to try the food which is a shame. When I walked in a little after lunchtime the display case was almost bare with 2 measly slices of plain cheese pizza left. I simply asked if they had any pepperoni pizza by the slice but as soon as the guy behind the counter started berating me for asking I walked right out. Insulting potential customers is the wrong way to do business. Avoid this spot if you can! read more

Amazing and fresh ingredients, the food is delicious.. Get the Chicken Gaspare you won't be disappointed.

it's good until you go there craving something you've had in the past and they tell you "we can't make it that way for you. It should never have been done the last time". well, if you ask me, (the customer), umm, should be taken care of. not told, rudely, no and it should have never been done the last time. the order was simply changing/requesting a different sauce as any other place has and still does if i ask them. proud papa's is a no go anymore for me. just based on that one day, and how the customer was treated, i will not go back. and i have been going for quite some time regularly. you just should not be rude to the customer. -- courtesy to the customer & service is priority, and lots of places are lacking in that dept. and proud papa's just added themselves to that list. --- disappointed customer. read more

If you can get past the owner's sometimes salty disposition and the unsightly morbid obesity of the pizza maker, Alex, you're in for a really tasty pizza. Best in the area and a Union staple for decades. Their sandwiches are great, and their customer loyalty program quickly adds up to FREE FOOD!! How can you beat that? I very highly recommend getting a pizza with sausage peppers and onions, you won't regret it read more

Food is great as usual. My review is about the charge on my statement I'm very disappointed in the charge I gave a tip and authorized only 20$ charge. Somehow the tip got changed to authorize my card for more money. I called to tell them and he said he would give me the credit back for the mischarged amt. Still waiting on that. I guess I have to call the bank and file a dispute with them read more

I Heard some bad things about this place, but I have to say that they have obviously made some significant improvements. I purchased dinner for my mom's birthday from here, and she was raving about the shrimp parmesan! The girls at the front deskthat have served me over the past couple of weeks have been phenomenal. I have no complaints I will be here regularly! read more

Proud Papa's - Caterers Near Me - Union, New Jersey

I have been going to Proud Papa's for as long​ as long as I can remember. always great food, always fresh

Been going here for years. I love the eggplant parm and chicken Caesar salad. The pizza is phenomenal too

Delicious, although a little pricey. My to-go order was perfectly packed, and everything included,!

I was very disappointed with their delivery time. This establishment has very poor customer service skills. The food is decent but I would not advise that you place an order for delivery. It took almost 90 minutes before the food arrived. read more

I order from PP weekly- sometimes twice a week. Their buffalo chicken pizza is the best, and the penne a la vodka is amazing. My son loves the thin small pizza- very good crust. Highly recommend. read more

Never a let down. Best pizza in town. Staff is always very friendly. Also, their loyalty system is a huge plus.

Just because I became aggravated reading the poor customer service comments. That's not how how you treat paying customers.

Rude owner. Poor values and service. Average pizza. In a town where the pizza is plentiful, you really hope you find a great neighborhood spot, with friendly customer service and strong family values. Unfortunately, this is not that place. We picked up a pie and witnessed the owner yelling at and degrading an employee, who was clearly a young teenage girl. My only regret was that we didn't stick up for this person. It was wrong and honestly the pizza here is average is best. If you're thinking about placing an order here, it's probably out of convenience. But, next time think about another option. We shouldn't support businesses like this. This owner is terrible and does not deserve our local business. read more

this place has the worst costumer service... they are sooo rude when you are just trying to bring something to their attention that they messed up.. I was told "to deal with" and how "I got lucky before" because the many times I ordered before the same pizza and last night they got it wrong and forgot stuff I ordered... it's so sad that a place that has such a amazing tasting pizza treats their customers rude. sad part I even told the guy I don't want. refund or a new pizza. was just letting them know so they pay attention to the orders. and I got yelled at and talk to as if I did something wrong. I will never recommend this place to anyone read more

First off I'm going to say the food is very good. I normally get the buffalo salad which tastes great. This is my 3rd time ordering from there. The first 2 times were ok but as of today I will never order from there again. I spoke to a man on the phone and place my order. I told him I was using a debit card and he goes " oooooo of corse you are because cash is just too much huh woo hoo woo hoo, card number?" At this point I was just gonna cancel but I really had a taste for the salad. From today on I will not order again from there. Their Customer service sucks read more

Ordered 2 pies last night. Dough was so salty, pies were disgusting to eat. Not the usual taste from many previous orders. Shameful if food was spike with extra salt to preserve during this health crisis. Don't feed that junk to my family. read more

I've ordered from here several times in the year I have been living in the area. I have had several of their pizzas which are good, but the crust is a little too think sometimes. Their plain pizza looks great but I haven't tried it. For some reason the crust looks thinner. Their calamari is good too! My favorite thing so far is their eggplant parm sandwich.. It was huge and only $10 for a whole. They always have nice staff working and are pretty accurate with delivery and pick up times. read more

The older woman who works there is RUDE! She seems to get hot flashes, she touched her greasy balding head than touched my food; I asked for another slice. The food is decent, however, when Proud Papa's was Genaro's pizza across the street, the service was better, and the pizza tasted BETTER as well. They changed the recipe and now the pizza doesn't taste too good. I know the people there for over 20 years, but for the past 5 years I've been going elsewhere. read more

Good Panninis. Our favorite is either the chicken or eggplant with roasted peppers and cheese pannini. They did change their bread recently and we do miss the original bread they used to make the panninis, but it's still a good pannini. They have a good selection of take out dinners too. Their chicken Vitoria is really good and one of our favorites. read more