At face value, self-storage is an easy business. In exchange for money, you provide customers with 1. A space to store their things, 2. A reasonably easy yay to get to that space, and 3. Some reassurance that other people can't get your stuff.
The Public Storage at 511 S Fair Oaks is zero for three.
*A space to store things*
We booked a 10x10 air-conditioned space on the Public Storage website. $200 a month, first month for $120 - easy enough. The day before our reservation, an employee called us to confirm that we were planning to move in. Odd, but sure!
On the day of, we show up with a car full of things and the manager explains that, as it turns out, there is no space for us - the computer must be wrong. They do have a 10x11, but the extra foot makes it a completely different unit, she says, and we'll have to pay $270/month. Or we could go elsewhere. After an hour of protests and many "calls to her manager", she agrees to let us move in for $200, but the first-month discount has vanished.
*A reasonable way to get to your space - part 1*
Day 2. As we are moving our things in, the only elevator breaks with us inside. The door opens on a random floor, with a 2 inch vertical gap between the elevator and the floor. We manage to drag our things out and call the front desk - they can call maintenance, but they have no idea of when it will be repaired. We explain that we are stranded in the wrong floor with a 500-lb cart - could we perhaps use the service elevator? Nope, they tell us to drag our things up and down the stairs. After an hour of polite disbelief and many "calls to their manager", they agree to let us store our things in an empty locker on the floor, but they warn us that we will have to get them out "as soon as the elevator is repaired". Also, they charge us $20 for a lock.
Update: the next day, I get a threatening call from Public Storage while at work. The elevator has just been repaired, and I had better take the day off work and empty the unit before 6 p.m. or I will be charged for the full month. That afternoon, the elevator breaks again.
*A reasonable way to get to your space - part 2*
There are two ways to get to our unit - the elevator and the stairs. The elevator and the stairs are behind different electronic door locks. I ask the front desk twice whether our code will unlock both the doors, since the elevator is broken. Of course, they say as they leave for the day. Shortly after, we find out that, indeed, our code does not open the door lock for the stairs. And the elevator is broken. We are locked out.
The district manager won't pick up the phone. The corporate call center tells us they will get in touch with the district manager, who will get back to us "within 15 minutes". That was yesterday, and we haven't heard back yet - but maybe soon!
Update: the front desk explains that they would never give us access to the door, because "it is a security risk". So (i) they lied to us on Day 2, and (ii) customers with units on the first floor can get to our unit when the elevator is broken, but we cannot. The district manager never returned our calls and voicemails.
*Security so others won't steal your stuff*
Maybe the fact that nobody can get into the building because the elevator is broken is not such a bad thing, after all. The $20 lock that Public Storage will happily sell you connects to a L-shaped plate held to the wall by two screws. The screw heads are exposed in the hallway, and there is no retaining bolt on the inside. So anyone is a screwdriver away from your things. Our unit, and several more units on our floor, have fingerprint dust around the lock area - it looks like theft is a very common occurrence. You meet interesting people in the parking lot around closing time. We met a couple whose unit had just been broken into - they told us that the Public Storage employees were unsurprised and did not care in the least. Another woman retold us how she had her units burglarized three times. The front desk person tells us that "theft happens everywhere" and that they could install a better plate if we really want - but they don't know when, and we'd have to leave them a key. Maybe not.
In summary: If you like being bait-and-switched, getting locked out of your unit, and being two screws away from losing your stuff, then Public Storage is great!
If not, do not make the mistake we did - go anywhere else but here. read more