So glad this restaurant has opened! I have heard nothing but great reviews and I can now fully agree. We had a great meal here. Service very friendly and helpful. Very reasonable price. Will be back! read more

Had the chile Colorado and it was perfect. Chile Colorado can be hard to find at Mexican spots around here (I am not sure why, it's basically just steak tips in red sauce). They definitely have a big menu and wide range of alcohol options. I did not find the service as friendly as some have said, but it was efficient and without problems, which is more important than being friendly. read more

Passing through the area on a Thursday night, we were recommended dinner at Pueblo by a local. We walked in and chose two seats at the bar. I'm not exaggerating when I say, these bar seats were the most comfortable seats I've ever sat in. The bartender was very friendly and quick to take our order. Our food was out within 3 minutes, no kidding. Everything was hot and fresh. My bf ordered a tall beer and didn't have the chance to drink it before the food showed up, but it stayed cold the entire meal. The bar has several TVs and the staff were more than welcome to accommodate the requests from the patrons. The ladies bathroom was newly renovated and even though the floor tile wasn't finished, the marble walls and sink were beautiful. We could easily see why this is a local favorite. read more

See all

I have always liked Mexican but this place makes me LOVE Mexican food. The service, drinks, atmosphere and food are all fantastic. I will for sure be back. I can't wait to have this be my favorite place to eat. The best margaritas ever! read more

Pueblo Real - Mango margarita (size small) perfection! - Mexican Near Me - Mayville, New York

Excellent food, spiced perfectly! My companion had the taco flight- four tacos with steak, pork, chicken and ground beef, which were all good. I had the pineapple stuffed with shrimp, pork and steak. Both were served with rice and beans. The rice was awesome. I really liked the refried beans, and my partner liked the charro beans, but felt they could have added more spice. Service was excellent! We also had the medium margaritas, which seemed large to us! read more

Pueblo Real - Tacos and copy and stuffed pineapple - Mexican Near Me - Mayville, New York

The chips and queso are sooo good here, I enjoyed the tacos and rice a lot too. The service was very attentive, and we had a big group so I applaud them for that. The seating area is nice and has several tables and booths. I will say that it is a cramped area, especially at the tables and not very accessible. read more

Pueblo Real - Barría Tacos, rice, beans, and Au jus - Mexican Near Me - Mayville, New York

It was nice to see this Mexican restaurant opened up in town. The food was delicious and very authentic tasting. The staff did a great job. As for the ambiance made us feel like we were in Mexico. All in all a great experience. read more

We wanted to give it one more try. Unfortunately for me it was still a miss. My wife did enjoy her burrito a bit more without the canned cheese poured over the top but everything else was still lacking in flavor. Short of enjoyable on many levels. read more

Pueblo Real - Her meal - Mexican Near Me - Mayville, New York

See all

Great food, great margaritas and great service. Very friendly staff. My go to spot in Mayville.

Beautiful murals, friendly quick service and great food!! Everything tasted very fresh and their margs were spot on read more

Pueblo Real - Flan - Mexican Near Me - Mayville, New York

See all

Very good Mexican food. Refreshing to have a consistent ethnic food offering in Mayville. Service was spot on. I ordered the Grande Quesadilla and she had the enchilada taco combo plate. Food was served fast and hot. Tasty, but it wasn't made from scratch. The restaurant has been updated and now has a bar along with four large screen TVs. Recommend stop in eatery when in Mayville. read more

See all

We were so excited to try this place and it's great! We've been multiple times now and the atmosphere and staff are both great. I really enjoy the quesadilla with pineapple and bacon, I wasn't sure at first but happy I tried it!! Great addition to the restaurant scene around the lake. read more

The salsa and dips were wonderful. My husband liked his food a lot and I did too but it was cool. It could have gone in the microwave for a bit. I'm not sure why it was cold but you could put your hand under the plate without any issues. I took most of it home to eat next day. The portions were great and service was good. read more

Pueblo Real - Fajitas chicken - Mexican Near Me - Mayville, New York

See all

This is one of best if not the best Mexican restaurant I have ever been to... ...And I have been to many all over the country. Very authentic food seasoned perfectly, Right between sweet and spicy. A full menu with a lot of choices. Margaritas were amazing. The flan dessert was delicious. Topped off with quick service and a great decor. One of my favorite places to eat!!! read more

Very, very good food here. Chips and salsa were good, queso fundido was plentiful and hot! I had the Burrito Mexico and hubby had Enchiladas Roja - both were extremely delicious and if course, the plates had a ton of food on each but we managed to eat it all! read more

See all

Ok. We are from the southwest and it's different Mexican than what we have at home. Service is great. Salsa is pretty mild. Burritos are served wet covered in a water down cheese sauce, and the soft tacos came in tin foil making them soggy. Refied beans had no flavor and were really watery as well. For this area, it was pretty good. Huge margaritas!! read more

The service was excellent, hosts and waiters were friendly and attentive. There was no wait time at lunch but a steady stream of happy customers was a good sign for us first timers. The drinks and food came out within minutes of ordering, it was hot, fresh and everything was homemade down to the sauces. We ordered margaritas which were delicious (homemade, not from a mix), birria tacos melted in your mouth and the flavor was epic, the chicken chimichangas were also great. We visited around Halloween and the place was decorated to the T. On top of the Halloween decorations the walls are beautifully hand-painted with Mexican style murals. Everything from top to bottom was extremely clean. The bar also looks like a nice place to have a few drinks with friends even if you're not hungry! We will definitely be back and recommend this place to all family and friends. read more

See all

The Enchilada Jalisco and the Vallarta Special were amazing. The restaurant was very busy but we got right in. I noticed they have take out also. Please be patient as they are new and very busy. We will be returning in the near future. read more

Pueblo Real - Vallarta Special... Enchilada Jalisco... - Mexican Near Me - Mayville, New York

Everything was great The food was outstanding, the service was great and the ambience was marvelous! With reasonable prices and generous portions this is a winner! read more

This place rocks. I've never seen a brand new restaurant so "ready to go" on day one. These guys are absolute pros at getting everything right. Great menu, speed of service, portions, flavor, ambiance. Just a ten out of ten. Don't miss it. read more

Really good food their taco is really good and the fries really really good fries and sports on the TV really good

excellent food, excellent service. comfortable seats! I can't believe how fast they are! read more

Pueblo Real - Mexican Near Me - Mayville, New York

Fresh and delicious authentic food, high quality ingredients with the flavors of Mexico. Tamales are excellent, tacos de camarones are bursting with jumbo shrimp perfectly cooked. Service is attentive, and polite, hard-working, good people. The bar is finally open and the freshly muddled margaritas are delicious. It's worth the trip from anywhere. Don't wait, you must go. read more

Carne asada tacos had an unreal amount of flavor. Complementary chips and dips were fresh and tasty. The friendliest staff and server also.

We loved it. Very authentic. Great staff. Beautiful bar but waiting for their liquor license. A must go

The service is excellent! They bring tortilla chips and salsa to you as soon as you sit down. Food is hot and tastes wonderful.

Nice ambiance and fast service. Best Mexican food i have had in the area. The Birria tacos are delicious and they load you up with sauces to accompany them read more

Great service, excellent food. The ambiance is pretty good as well! Will definitely make this a return to place regularly. My wife and I reside in Aurizona but spend the summers at our cottage on Chautauqua lake and this Mexican food is as good as we get back home! read more

The art work was disheartening. I'm not in to Santaria and find it very offensive. The food is good but I almost got sick having to look at the pictures read more

Very good. Small round tables and big square plates made for a slightly challenging dining experience. I hate to complain about a big menu, but honestly I'd have been happy with a much shorter one! So many choices... everything you'd expect to find, in every variety. I'd love to see something a little more original/fresh/unusual. Service was pleasant, but my request to add a tip to the credit card payment was ignored, so I'm glad I checked the receipt. Complimentary salsa was especially nice, just hot enough without blasting the tastebuds. I'll be back. read more

This is the third time I've been there. I had their Vegetable Quesadilla. It was delicious! The service was also very good.

I don't care how great the food is. If I put an order in an hour and a half early, for a specific time in the future. Your job is to deliver at said time. I put the order online so that I could sit and relax on my lunch break that is only 30 minutes. This way I could spend 10 minutes grabbing the food and 20 minutes eating. I got to the restaurant and waited for 20 minutes for my order to be made. What's the point of ordering online if you are going to wait until I get there to start making it? My time is valuable and if you don't care about MY time then I don't care about YOUR business! read more