Casual dining spot with a nice outdoor area consisting of picnic tables. The inside seemed nice as…read morewell. Very friendly and pleasant waiter. Drinks were just ok, the fish and chips were great!! The batter had a sweet flavor, very good and perfectly cooked. Music from the speakers was a bit loud outside (not a live band, which they have on weekends)

Even on a Monday night, getting into a restaurant was tough without reservations (we were there on…read morean impromptu day trip). Duke's to the rescue! We got really solid, good food with no wait, right by the docks. Server/bartender was super friendly, and his drinks were on the money (my spicy margarita was refreshing as heck). The spicy shrimp dip was terrific, a must try. My platter of fish and chips was very satisfying. My only minor criticism: They had a live singer (singing along to a tape or something) out on the patio, and she was a bit hard on the ears. We sat inside, where they were blasting Green Day (which was fine). But the problem was that with the doors open to the patio, the two different musics were heard simultaneously which was a bit jarring. I'd suggest one or the other.

Rarely leave reviews, this place deserves the best possible one. My wife and i have been to half a…read moredozen restaurants on our trip and this was by far the best (and fairest price). Incredibly fresh seafood and produce, and ask for the cocktail sauce. Strange but it's the best I've ever had.

We stopped here on a rainy April day after a hike through Camp Hero. A lot of places weren't open…read moreyet and Hooked got good reviews. Know that there is picnic table seating outdoors on nice days or a pretty big parking lot to enjoy your meal. I'm sure it gets packed during peak summer hours. The portions are huge! For 3 people we ordered lobster bisque, tuna bites, lobster Mac and cheese, a tuna poke bowl, sweet potato fries, and regular fries. Everything is made fresh to order and it was delicious! Literally the best lobster bisque I ever had. And the tuna bites were so unique - fresh tuna, breaded and deep fried. We aren't local but we will be back every time we are on the east end. The owner was also really nice and we wound up talking about camping in the area and things to do during the summer. Super friendly and welcoming!

Base my reviews off what you pay:…read more *Place was jammed at 7:00 on a Thursday. Price - ~$80-$100 (appetizer, entree, drink, tip) Food - 4/5 - much better than anticipated. Service - 3/5 - fine service, nothing remarkable. Ambiance - 4/5 - chill vibe with live music. Overall - 4/5 - place turned out to be much better than anticipated. Food was incredibly tasty, good variety, and fine portions. Smashed potatoes and lamb sliders were awesome. Service was fine, fast but nothing beyond that. Ambiance was nice with the live music. Although could've been some breaks here or there with it, it created a nice spot. Would definitely return. Best Dish - Smashed potatoes and lamb sliders Would Return - Definitely

Super Fantastic food!…read more From the outside kind of looks like laid back casual taco spot! Inside very causal yet cool surfer vibe. Service and margaritas were great. Not fancy! Laid back, casual! The menu and what came out of the kitchen was exceptional and "5" worthy alone. We had some sushi grade tuna tacos with crispy wonton style shells. The tacos were dressed with all the right flavors and additions you would expect from a top sushi joint. Excellent! We also had Moroccan spiced lamb sliders! Wow good! Perfect! Go to the Gig Shack just to get this! 100% worthy the trip. Id say the menu is somewhat surfer-fusion with California taco influence. There are lots of options. We are glad we tried Gig Shack and will return. Highly recommended casual, cool vibe location, with fantastic food!

The property and restaurant are decorated beautifully - that and being on the water/the view is the…read morestar of the show. Can eat dinner then walk down on the grass or to the water and have another drink (bar on the grass and near the water). The food was very good! No complaints at all, but the menu is a little limited. I'm sure they'd substitute things for you, but very picky eaters might have trouble here. Walk ins only, show up early for no wait. Expensive but expected.

The ambiance and beach bar were breathtaking , literally feels like you're in Europe. The food was…read moredelicious, that I will give. we got the peppers with halloumi , tartare, lobster pasta and swordfish Kebob. The drinks were EH. The Muddah Freqqin wait of 2 hours and 45 minutes to be seated, is absolutely, positively not worth it, leave. It was a one and done for me dawg. ** upset me the most ** waited almost three hours to be seated inside by the bar , could've ate quicker at the bar hours ago

The nicest owner/bouncer Michael (unsure which??) and a great spot with a live band! Cute set up…read moreoutside with very reasonable priced food in Montauk. The prime rib was delish and the onion rings were fire. Everyone should go here!!

If you're looking for good food in Montauk keep looking…read more My girlfriend and I recently decided to take advantage of a deal for a hotel in the offseason in Montauk. We were looking for dinner Saturday night and of the limited options this place looked potentially good. I was terribly wrong. We walked in to see one other table occupied. Sure, it's the offseason, whatever. We ordered a couple of frozen drinks and the problems immediately started. The bartender used way too much ice in the blender. The drinks were obviously undrinkable but served anyway. The drinks did not melt by the time we left. Maybe the food would be good. Wrong again. The lobster in the lobster pasta was tough. I almost hope it wasn't fresh because it would have been a waste. The linguine with clams was no better. At the end of the meal my girlfriend remarked that she had never seen me not finish my dinner. We both knew why I hadn't. Awful restaurant. The owners should be ashamed.

Lovely place with beautiful cozy decor, great service and amazing food. I had the broiled flounder…read morew brown rice and Cole slaw and yes it's pricey at $40 but was a generous portion. Simply cooked, not fancy but the fish was like butter. Amazing!

So glad we decided to try this place for dinner tonight. We wanted to be near a great area to view…read morethe sunset and The Dock was close by. ( sunset was just around the corner on Mermaid Beach). Our server was very friendly and had great advice on food choices. I had the chicken quesadillas- delicious. My husband had New England scallop chowder ( delicious) and fried coconut shrimp ( tender & tasty). And the peanut butter pie is yummy. Quirky, fun decor too!

Montauk Brewing hosted our wedding welcome drinks last week and we could not have been happier with…read morethe event. We worked with Erin, the taproom and events manager there, to plan the event, and she was extremely flexible, thoughtful, and organized every step of the way. We had about 90 guests there on a Thursday from 7-10pm, and this was truly a highlight of the wedding weekend! Our guests absolutely loved trying all the different beers on tap and getting a taste of beautiful Montauk. We had pizza from Sausages delivered and Montauk Brewing had tables set up outside for us. It was the PERFECT casual welcome drinks we were looking for and we feel so happy Montauk Brewing has begun doing these private events. The back room has also been turned into more indoor event space, with high top tables among the brewery tanks. Highly recommend planning an event with Erin & Montauk Brewing -- you will love it!!

Montauk Brewing Company, tucked inside a charming red barn, has been a go-to craft beer spot in…read moreMontauk since 2012. It features a small, cozy taproom with just a few bar stools, along with a sunny outdoor patio lined with picnic tables--making it a great place to relax and enjoy brews like the Driftwood Ale or Wave Chaser IPA. As for pet-friendliness, this spot is top-notch. Well-behaved, leashed dogs are welcome both inside the taproom and out on the patio, which is a huge plus. They even released a PAWesome IPA that supports local animal rescue efforts-just one more reason we loved stopping by with our pup!

Price - pricey Their morning health drinks are yum…read moreespecially the green goddess. Their crab cake Benedict was just ok, their French toast was but everything else was just subpar. The pastry basket is the one thing I do recommend with the green goddess (if you don't like ginger though don't get it); the price is great $12 and the assortment is perfect with each one tasting amazing. And service was great; he was patient and courteous. We sat by the water window view and it was very pretty. Their charcuterie board is very overpriced for the amount and variety. Their burger is good; the pretzel is as good as a pretzel is and the tuna tacos are tiny and only two of them but packed with tuna - very fishey though.

Tillie's is Scarpetta at night. Tillie's breakfast is simply amazing. The eggs are cooked well. I…read morehighly suggest the omelets. Not sure why folks are complaining about price. If you can afford staying at Gurney's then the price of food shouldn't be an issue.