not sure about the bad reviews. my manager ordered a bunch of bagels for st patricks day. they were…read moregreen. they gave us a couple of cream cheese options. one of the whipped cream cheese was dyed green. the bagels tasted good. was not disappointed. and it was a fun green treat for the holiday.

I just ordered the maple honey turkey on roll and the bread was hard as a brick. The sandwich…read moreinside was so dry and the lettuce just fell out of it. A waste of money.

Crowded! Tons of people cramming into a small space. There is a bunch of staff also crammed into…read morea small space. But everything is calm and relaxed. The staff is friendly. I ordered a sesame bagel with TH/E/CH. I got the same for my wife but on a Kaiser roll. Then, I ordered 30 bagels, different varieties. All in all, this is a good shop, loyal following and the bagels have a solid chew and decent flavor. Check them out. Parking is a bit tight with it being next to a busy road so be careful.

I'm not sure why there was a long line out the door for this bagel shop. One line only and from…read moretime to time staff would ask if someone was just buying bagels. But no separate line for bagels; so it wasn't efficient. I waited in line for about 15 mins, at one point I was waiting outside on a cold day. I asked for 2 plain and 1 raisin. The guy gave me an extra plain so it was a total of 4. I also ordered a 16 oz. Coffee (their house brew) it came out to $6.25. Not bad. Ifor some reason 2 bagels had grill marks on them, I'm assuming they were placed on a rack while still hot and it left marks on it. Strange. It wasn't about the bagels for me but the coffee was really good! Rivals the well known commercial coffee houses. The bagels were on the sweet side; they were big and crusty but the sweetness turned me off. After trying out Bagel Nosh, I would only return for the coffee not the bagels. The long line is not worth it; but maybe the sandwiches are good? Maybe I'll come back and try something else. But as far as bagels, I'd go somewhere else. This is my honest review.

My name is Peter I am working in town doing Epoxy flooring I walked immediately was offered some of…read morethe best service. I was welcomed and given some of the best experience I ever had the food is amazing the staff is great. I had a chance to talk to the employees and owner very nice people. I recommend this place to anyone who loves good food.Im a customer for life

I came here 4 times before... 1st they didn't have the…read moreturkey sausage 2nd they forgot to put the turkey sausage (had to go back) 3rd order was good bagel with cream cheese 4th order was a brick with cream cheese ‍ The lady in there was super nice she forgot to toast my bagel the 4th time and I went back she made my order over but then it was a brick. so yeah I will never be returning but the lady very nice..

They take the extra time to make sure my order is right, which surprisingly is not something that…read morehappens everywhere. I like my bagel toasted extremely dark and they take the time to do so. I only go here when possible, the food is fresh and they have a huge lunch selection of wraps, heroes and salads. A corporate person's dream for a varied lunch selection at an affordable price. Also a huge selection of drinks.

Stopped by for the first time today. Good bagels are sorely lacking in this area but Buono Bagels…read morewas a better option. Having lived in NY most of my life, I admit that I'm a bagel snob so the bagel I had here wasn't special by any means but the owner was kind and had a warmth about him that makes me want to visit again. I got an everything bagel with cream cheese. Bagel wasn't as pillowy on the inside as I would've liked but the taste was decent with enough everything seasoning to make it an actual everything bagel. It had a fair amount of cream cheese, although my spoiled NY taste buds would've prefered a tad bit more. Overall, it was better than Bagel Shack. And since there are no good bagel places around, I'll probably be back.

Excellent food. Friendly staff. I was traveling through and this hit my tri-state nostalgic cord…read moreperfectly.

Been going to Bagel Boys for years. Has gone downhill since Mark & Eric sold the business. There's…read moreone crabby lady behind the counter who is quite edgy & impatient. After repeating my order twice, to her annoyance, she messed it up anyway. Their BEC sandwich has become mediocre & not very tasty. I won't be going back anytime soon. Miss the old bagels & service.

I love the bagels here! One of the best but the service today with that young lady…read more She was impatient because I asked her to please put cc on both sides of the bagel Gave me some attitude

Just an OK bagel. Wouldn't drive out of my way to stop here, but I was in the area. Feel that they…read moreare on the smaller side. Service is a bit slow so when popping in here, I tend to call in my order for pick up otherwise I find myself waiting quite a bit.

First time walking in and this place slapped me in the face with options. You know how most bagel…read moreshops give you the classics? Nope. Here it's like: "Oh you want a simple bagel? Cute. But have you considered 47 cream cheeses, 19 sandwiches, and a few items that made me stop and ask... wait, why is this here?" Not complaining though, it's actually impressive. There are choices that make perfect sense for a bagel shop, and then there are choices that feel like someone said, "Let's keep them guessing." Honestly? Respect. Variety for every type of mood and personality. If you're decisive, you'll walk out with something amazing. If you get overwhelmed easily... you might just stand there staring at the menu like it's a final exam. (Good problem to have.) Staff was super nice, friendly, and efficient. I was in and out ridiculously fast. No chaos, no attitude, just smooth operation. Place itself is small and clean, but comfortable and well kept.

Context: Mo - owner…read more Fantastic selection. He offered to increase my drink at most cost - which when you compare with the great food means I willl always visit here whenever around the area. Got the bagel sandwich warm with eggs, bacon, avocado as well as a coffee. Food was great!

Stopped by BNG Bagels and had a great experience. The blueberry bagel was fresh and delicious, and…read moreboth the pistachio muffin and blueberry muffin were excellent--moist, flavorful, and clearly made with quality ingredients. We also took home a couple trays of assorted cookies, and every one of them was outstanding. Everything tasted fresh and homemade. Friendly service and great selection. We'll definitely be back for more!

Drove here early in the morning craving a sausage, egg and cheese. This spot satisfied my craving…read morebut I was very confused at the whole situation. So I ordered a SOBO: sausage, egg and cheese on a roll. The sign said the sandwich "with home fries" so I get my sandwich and run out because I was already late, right before I open my car door I realize there were no home fries. I return and the worker there said "the home fries" is a actually a "hash brown" in the sandwich Overall, the whole wording and terms had me confused but the sandwich was good and they prepared it pretty quickly. Will I be back? Probably, there's this "Waldwick Wrapl that looked enticing!