If you run the numbers on the highest-rated ice cream stores across the U.S., Reeds is ranked a staggering 12th! Theoretically, it should be life changing! But we've discovered that locals in Boise tend to overrate all of their eateries. And Reeds is no exception. Despite an average customer rating of 4.76 on all platforms, the ice cream isn't nearly as good as its competition on that list (for instance, Ehlers in Louisville some 1,900 miles away will simply blow your mind). Now don't get me wrong. The flavors are clever, the taste is delicious, and the butter pecan and maple are both very good. And I greatly respect a creamery that's bold enough to make the nearly-impossible-to-find licorice ice cream! But the product just doesn't strike you as a top 15 ice cream spot. I do love the cheeses and milk offered in the refrigerated section. And believe me, you'll enjoy Reeds. Just don't expect anything 10 levels above Baskin Robbins. read more

See all

I have had Reed's Dairy on my list for awhile, and only recently ended up moving minutes away from them, so I'm happy to share that I finally gave them a try, and I'm sooooo glad I did!!! I was looking for milkshakes, but once I stepped in, ice cream was hard to resist. One of my favorite ice creams, since I was a kid, is Butter Pecan (aka Pralines and cream), but I rarely find it these days, and when I do, it's usually too sweet. Not this time! I was so excited they had it, and proceeded to try a sample of it, and it was absolutely perfect!! Rich, creamy, and perfectly sweet, with a touch of crunch. I also took home some Strawberry Cheesecake, which was also delectable. My husband's favorite ice cream is.....wait for it.....black licorice. Nobody carries this flavor....for years, he has gone without. I'm NOT a fan of black licorice, but I know some are, so I will tell you that Reed's does have it if you got a hankerin' for it, and according to my husband, it's really good, however, I cannot say, as I will not try it. All in all, this place will be a go-to for us for ice cream, but we also have yet to try their cheeses!!! read more

Super friendly staff and amazingly good, creamy, rich ice cream. Def worth return trips.

Living in Pittsburgh, PA I don't get out to Boise near as often as I'd like. However, when I come you can be sure that I will be stopping into Reed's to pickup chocolate milk ASAP! My wife introduced me to Reed's on a trip to Rexburg many years ago and I'm a convert! The potato flakes make it so creamy and nice! I've been known to freeze some and pack it in a checked bag home too... Service is usually pretty friendly and quick and the ambiance of this store is fine. It's a little minimalistic with not a lot of indoor seating, but there is outdoor seating for when the weather is warm which is probably pretty nice. read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Hours - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Love having our milk (and much more) from local dairy. On Time delivery with great service.

On the night of December 12th 2025 I entered reeds dairy with one of my friends I then proceeded to order a scoop of eggnog icecream and she ordered a scoop of chocolate unfortunately when I got up to the counter to pay my card declined but thanks to the wonderful people working there they offered to cover it for me I just wanted to say that this was quite possibly the best experience I have ever had at an ice cream shop before and I will be going back again soon read more

So glad we stopped by after our dance recital and had some great ice cream! They offer plenty of options in many sizes along with other dairy products (we picked up some cheese curds which are to die for!). We had the huckleberry, the bubble gum, and a brownie caramel combo that should be illegal! On top of what we had, we plan to go back and try more: Root Beer Milk Grilled Cheese Great little shop, nice people, and locally owned, give it a try, you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

My only 'complaint' is they're closed on Sundays! Fantastic ice cream with lots of homemade flavors. Cups or cones, also milk, and other delicious dairy products for purchase. Indoor and outdoor seating, friendly staff, and plenty of parking. A family favorite! read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Great Ice cream, but keep in mind this is yet another business who thinks it's okay to close before they say they do. It sounds petty, but what's the point of having hours if you don't actually adhere to them? read more

We stopped by! And it was pretty simple but good ice cream. Sold milk and grilled cheese and other things.

We have enjoyed Reed's Dairy home delivery for several years, yet found the delivery costs and surcharges to be more than the excellent product was worth. After we notified the Boise operation that we wanted to close our account, we were notified that an "audit" of the records would necessitate a $4.54 charge. No accounting was provided, no indication as to when this error on Reed's Dairy occurred, just a charge. What poor business practices. I cannot endorse your company and am appalled that this is the way your firm parts ways with clients. You've taken my money out of my account, I hope the ramifications are worth the money you've received. Very unhappy, Robbie Roberts Emmett, Idaho read more

This place has the best ice cream Me and my family love it and on hot days we can bike to it read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - My son after ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

I will NEVER get tired of Reeds. I've eaten a lot of good ice from all around the world but who knew I'd find some of my favorite here in my hometown. By now I've tried numerous flavors, and every single time I leave I think I've found my new favorite. On my most recent venture I walked out with the best damn scoop of cookie'n'cream that I've ever had. The ice cream is so rich and thick, and I was super appreciative of the huge globs of Oreo! read more

See all

Been here a few times now and the jury is out we love it! Great local ice cream shop with great employees. The staff is always super friendly. The ice cream selection is outstanding and you can truly taste the difference in the homemade quality of theirs. Inside is typical ice cream shop with lots of tables to sit at and every time is always very clean. They have several locations throughout the Treasure Valley this one just so happens to be the one we have most frequented. They also have other things besides homemade ice cream. They sell their milk and my favorite their chocolate milk is amazing! Plus cheeses and other dairy selections. They also have a limited food menu but in a pinch a hope bowl of soup and a homemade grilled cheese sandwich is always a good thing...great local company that everyone should support. read more

First time visiting this location! I was first introduced to reeds dairy chocolate milk when I was in school in eastern Idaho. This chocolate milk got me through college! Haha! I have been known to shout it from the rooftops that reeds chocolate milk is delicious and no other chocolate milk can even compete. My brother in law hadn't ever had it, so I got him a half gallon and he is now sold! Haha! I now live in PA and I have been known to freeze several small bottles and then put it in a bag and bring it home in my checked bag to enjoy when I get home. This time I didn't check a bag and couldn't bring some home. Truly devastating. During my 10 day visit at home, my husband and I drank two gallons worth. No regrets. This was my first time having the ice cream though. Not sure why I've never tried it...to hung up on the chocolate milk I guess! Haha! I got moms recipe and it was super good! I didn't get a single Oreo somehow, but otherwise it was phenomenal! Thank you, Reeds! Wanna ship to PA?? read more

A fun place with not just your run-of-the-mill ice cream and sherbet flavors. Mexican Hot Chocolate, or licorice anyone!

For those of you unfamiliar with eastern Idaho, Reed's dairy is a bright light of glorious, lactose paradise that gives variety to a frozen potato wonderland. The original location is in Idaho Falls. I didn't realize that they had a satellite location in Boise, and was very pleasantly surprised by them popping up on my radar. Same great ice cream, friendly staff, and they had a chance inside the store to win a year supply of ice cream if you guessed how many candies were in a jar. Totally worth it. If you're not feeling strong, sweet tooth, there, grilled cheese is to die for. Don't forget to check out their cheese curds as well as their chocolate milk. This ice cream is so good that on a recent business trip, I purchased a cooler full of dry ice to bring back a gallon to my desperate pregnant wife. The urban myth is that the ice cream is so tasty and creamy because they use potato flakes. What could be more Idahoan than that?? read more

Reed's Dairy is a staple from my childhood. The flagship store is in the town where I grew up and I spent my summers hanging on their front lawn, counting out my change so I could buy a kid's size cone for under $1. When they opened up stores in the Treasure Valley, it felt like kismet that this was the place I settled. (Though I miss the cow smell and pricing of the original) I recently went to the new Lake Hazel location and have no real new information to add. Clean and bright with an army of smiling high schoolers to scoop your ice cream. My favorite flavors are still Gorilla Munch, Licorice, Peach Cobbler and Apple Pie (which might be discontinued because I haven't seen it for years). You can get a few variations of grilled cheese sandwich combos. You also absolutely must try the chocolate milk and cheese curds. It will rock your world. On a personal note, I got a waffle size cone with the intention of sharing with my one year old but she would NOT share with me. So...maybe get everyone their own cone. :-/ read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Peach cobbler (kid size- the adult sizes are massive!) on a homemade waffle cone. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

The ice cream is sticky and strange and overly sweet. The flavors don't come through. Goody's is by far superior to Reed's.

So refreshing! Lots of flavors to choose but last time I opted to have the Huckleberry and its so good. You should try coming here too or call for delivery! read more

Awesome ice cream but their EggNog is to die for. There is a store in Kuna as well. I have been in their store many times and everytime seems to get better. It's one of those places that are worry free. You know it's going to be good read more

Awesome ice cream awesome milk awesome sandwich good service and one of the best parts third time close to my house

Such good ice cream (and huge scoops)! They also have the BEST chocolate milk ever! Perfect summer spot. read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Wow!!! This ice cream is a must stop if in Boise!! The servings are HUGE! A single scoop can be shared with 2-3 people. I got the pralines and cream which was super creamy. Like no other pralines and cream I have ever had. The strawberry cheesecake was my favorite but the coconut was also amazing. Prices are reasonable for such a great big serving and homemade waffle cones. read more

See all

So here's the thing. This place is AWESOME. They have a wide selection of delicious ice creams. But don't be fooled thinking that you're getting a home grown natural product when they add ingredients like red 40 to strawberry ice cream. I hate giving bad reviews especially for local businesses but we need our local farmers and establishments to DO BETTER. Red 40 is illegal in other countries because of its link to cancer causing properties. Of course here in the good old USA the FDA approves all sorts of things because being sick=money. Reeds if you're seeing this, sugar and milk already taste good, please take out the artificial flavors and dyes. Our community needs places we can trust. read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Red 40 Blue 1 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

I'm sure most of you think that the ice cream at reeds is somehow more natural or organic like I once did, that was until I read the ingredients. How many of you knew they add fake cancerous Ingredients like Red 40, and Blue 1. Disgusting. read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Reeds adds fake cancer causing ingredients like Red 40 and Blue 1 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

I grew up across the original Reed's Dairy in Idaho Falls, and have always loved their ice cream! Hands down the best I have ever had. My biggest problem with Reed's is the serving size of their scoops. They are either directly related to the generosity and/or strength of the individual serving you, or or they are instructed to give modest sized scoops and SOMETIMES I get someone who feels charitable. For as much as it costs, dang ... make it worth it! As far as customer service goes, it really depends on who you get. I feel for the most part it's usually a bunch of teens who don't excel in social skills. I don't want a Dutch Bros experience, but at least sort of act like you care that I am there. Aside from those two things, love their stuff! read more

I've always wanted to try the Potato Flake Chocolate Milk from Reeds Dairy and I finally had the chance during my road trip! Tbh, I don't like chocolate milk so I was hoping that the potato flakes would change my opinion -- and it really did. The potato flakes provide a creamy texture that makes the drink so much more satisfying. You can also feel bits of potato flakes, which I liked. The flavor of the chocolate milk was less sweet but still very rich. Making the drink really addicting! Didn't try the Ice Cream but I wish I did. Located in a plaza, it was easy to find parking. Friendly service. If only Seattle could have a Reed's Dairy! read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Chocolate Milk w/ Potato Flakes! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Real ice cream! So glad we stopped on this rainy day. Huckleberry and Maple nut! Wish I could have tried them all! read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Real ice cream! Huckleberry and Maple nut! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Nice local place! My family loves their ice cream and chocolate milk! The staff is kind and it has a small-town feel.

While the food and treats here are amazing the staff is less than friendly. The girl behind the counter was very stand off ish and rude. Somehow both of my shakes could not be made at the same time (even though there are two blenders). They need to work on their customer service skills. read more

Expensive and they keep taking away bubble bear. Why create a beloved flavor just to rip it away willy nilly?! There's no reliability. How is one supposed to eat their feelings after a rough day when they never know if their favorite ice cream is even available?? It's atrocious! Zero consideration for the preferences of their repeat customers. Save your money. Use coupons at Albertsons and buy a flavor from a brand that's not going to rip it away from you. The audacity to have this level of instability! Therapy is cheaper and it won't break your heart on a random Monday night. read more

This place is incredible! Not only was it my first time trying Reed's Dairy products, but this is the new location that is dangerously close to my house . My husband had the grasshopper ice cream that was his absolute favorite. The mint was perfect with the Oreo cookie and the caramel swirl. I had a kids scoop of the huckleberry ice cream on a cake cone. It was incredible. You can tell that the ice cream is fresh and made with real ingredients. I am looking forward to our next trip there to try a grilled cheese as well (it's a weakness of mine). If you are in a hurry, they do have ice cream ready for pick up in an open freezer with multiple flavor options available. Aside from ice cream milk and cheese products are also ready for pickup. Can't wait for our next visit! I'm really going to have to increase my gym time. read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Kids scoop of huckleberry ice cream on a cake cone! Delish!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

The best I've cream in the Treasure Valley! You wouldn't be disappointed with all their flavors! I also recommend the most delicious grilled cheese sandwich read more

I stopped in to try their ice cream and it was FANTASTIC!!! If you like ice cream, then this is your place. Like the Terminator, I'll be back. read more

This location was friendly and ice cream was yummy. However after visiting another location, we noticed how many more flavors were available there than at this local to us location. Def prefer a bigger variety. read more

Visiting from California and found this place on Yelp. Ice cream is awesome. Got chocolate milk and cheese curds. Both were amazing. Went back several times and each time was great! Also, service was awesome! The young ladies were sweet! read more

Wow, six bucks and you a beautifully grilled cheese sandwich, tomato basil soup, a bag of chips and a soda!!!! Such a great lunch deal but I doesn't stop there, they have amazing ice cream too! read more

Reeds Dairy - Boise - Lunch, amazing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

The eBay ice cream I've found in Boise! Always have great variety. The texture, taste and portions are awesome. They also have cheeses, milk and dairy products - or and their yummy ice creams by the pint or bigger to go too! Simple, small shop with a nice staff and FABULOUS ice cream! Go try it! read more

We tried this little joint in our neighborhood and we're not disappointed. Their flavors were amazing, rich and creamy! Love that the ice cream is from a dairy! Be prepared that their scoops are HUGE, so if you go for a double, it's like a quadruple! We will definitely be back. read more