It's the second time I ordered a pie from pizza master and the pizza was old it taste like cardboard

They have wonderful customer service. I don't recall her name but she brought me utensils, a place mat, my food, and took some of my trash! I wish my salad came out before my pizza but I was totally fine with the order. Pizza was delicious, sauce was incredible. The salad was absolutely delicious. I can't wait to come back and try it their pasta next. I got a fountain soda since it was free refills on it and the establishment was very clean, the service I cannot emphasize how wonderful the customer service was and I am more than thrilled to come back. Bathroom was clean, establishment was clean, lovely 10 out of 10. read more

See all

I used to be a regular a long ways back when I lived in the area. It was always solid for slices and a pie. I was recently passing thru and stopped in. Wow complete gut renovations and interior. I think some of IG/social media advertising has helped spread the work about this place. Anyhow we got 2 large pies. Still pumping out great pies. Renatos' - In! read more

Stopped at Pizza Master's wanted some PIZZA. This place on Central Avenue is an old reliable pizzeria. We ordered the square grandma slice, a buffalo chicken slice, two plain and garlic knots. The food came out quick and hot. The garlic knots are awesome we had an order of them, coming with five total. The staff were friendly and they always make sure you are taken care of. I've been here numerous times and haven't had bad meal. They have a seating area and they bring your order to you if you dine in. This is arguably the best pizzeria in the Heights. read more

See all

Great spot. Had the eggplant parm sub. Fantastic. Lightly breaded eggplant pan fried, and covered in cheese and a delicious red sauce. I'll be back to try the pizza. read more

We brought a large group on a weeknight and they accommodated us perfectly in their fine dining room. I had the personal Margherita pizza. The crust was perfectly thin and the mozzarella was fresh. Don't sleep on the garlic bread and marinara; the sauce is robust and packed with authentic tomato flavor. My friends ordered various chicken entrées, which were all generous portions and looked delicious. We were too full for dessert, but the menu looked tempting enough to come back for. Great service and even better food! read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Very solid pizza spot in The Heights! I am more of thinnnnn thin crust kind of gal, so that is my only note and it's one that might not be a big deal to most. In fact, everyone else loved it. To satisfy two different cravings, we got a half mushroom and onion & half broccoli rabe and chicken. Both were delicious! We got a few other dishes that all came out wonderful as well. We ordered for pick up and it was smooth and fast. I had never been in before, but it looked like there were plenty of tables if you plan on stopping in to stay and eat. While I love my pizza paper thin, this was a great pie and I am sure we will be back soon! read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

Renato's is well known the the neighborhood to be a great pizza spot for delivery and pickup. We were in the area and decided to actually dine in to try it. You order at the counter and can get slices or whole pies and sandwiches, salads, and pasta. We decided to order a large pie and their chicken francese sandwich. In my opionion, the pizza was good but not great. Canned mushrooms, a lot of sauce, floppy center. I like that they gave eggplant cutlets as an option for toppings. The chicken francese sandwich on garlic bread is a genius idea but fell flat for me. It lacked flavor and I didn't pick up on the garlic bread but I liked that it was served open face. Would pop in again or order delivery. read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Chicken Francese On Garlic Bread with Mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

Best pizza in the heights. This place has been here for a long time and the pizza is great. Very nice since they remodeled too. I like most of the slices I get here but my over all favorite is the buffalo chicken slice. Easily best buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had. Pepperoni and Sicilian is good here as well. My coworkers also love the sandwiches and I need to try them as well. Service is always pleasant and pretty quick. Plenty of places to sit down and eat here. Very clean and spacious. As I said best pizza in the area. read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Buffalo chicken slice - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Renatos is my go to for when my wife & kids want dinner. I've probably ordered from here over 50 times. I just never left a review. So here it is... Food is always 10 out of 10. I get a Pepperoni & Mushroom pie. Always solid. The kids love it. I always get grilled chicken or shrimp over fettuccine Alfredo....delicious. Stuffed shells are always good. And lastly, garlic knots are great. I've never actually sat down and ate here...always take out. But the servers are always kind and helpful. I'm pretty sure there's a restaurant in the back with parking and everything. The vibes are always good. Cheers to my next 50 take out orders... PS - it's not even a discussion...Renatos is in a different league over Ginos... read more

Very greasy pizza, hopefully a one off just the day I ordered. But sadly pizza was inedible because who wants a soggy greasy pizza crust? read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Great pizza! Lots of options for specialty pies. Gluten free options as well. Fast service and pizza is always still hot when delivered! read more

*This is a review for the grandma pie ONLY*. Oh man, pains me to write this. I've been to the one in Bayonne, and thought that flavor wise, this would be similar. I was wrong. The grandma pie slice is very different. The sauce is overly sweet, the mozzarella did not taste right, no basil on top, no crunch when you bite in. A let down for me personally. Maybe I caught them on an off day. I will say, that the normal pies looked delicious, although I didn't try, it. The service was excellent. Very fast, everything is very fresh. Ordered a salad and some garlic knots, both were good. Although it wasn't for me, this might fit your tastebuds, a lot of people love Renatos. Great place to have a chill bite with family and friends. Good vibes! read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Sicilian Pizza/Grandma pie - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

This place is amazing and hits the spot every single time. I find myself now craving their food. It's also always fresh and prices are reasonable for the quality and taste as well as a service if you choose to dine in. My favorites are the white pizza, pizzettes, the Caesar salad is bomb. But their soups are fire. Please bring back the artichoke bacon! Also, just wanted to add that the place is really nice and clean inside and also family friendly. My kids love the food and they are super picky eaters. Everyone always seems to find something they devour. 10/10 highly recommend. read more

(Delivered 07/15/2023 SA @ 5:30pm): Being pizza masters was such a bold statement, Renato! In my quest to explore the various cuisine scenes throughout Jersey City, my friend and I came across Renato's Pizza Masters to fill my pizza craving. With a sizable Italian community, I already ate some wonderful pizza in the neighborhood from Gino's Pizzeria and Rizzo's Bakery, I expected nothing less. A staple in Jersey City Heights for over 60 years https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=slEDkzymmezTwnnRMQe73w&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw who pride themselves on authentic Italian cuisine, we first came across this business on our many walks with the lil' black beast. Would Renato prove to be a pizza master in our minds!? PURCHASE Bread (COMP): Soft pieces of bread thrown in for the heck of it, I guess. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=HQJ_yMQwcAGQAx24pnHQ0w&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw Tomato & Red Onion Salad ($4.95): Diced tomatoes and red onions tossed with house dressing and balsamic vinegar, topped with basil, we used this tasty dish with the bread and pizza topping. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=9_YdQQItW8Rv96B3J-RskA&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw Caesar Salad ($7.50): Romaine lettuce with homemade croutons and shaved parmesan with house made caesar dressing, this arrived too limp, soaked (less dressing or on the side, please), and wimpy for our liking. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=7IiNCjKt_6mWREKE6JPokA&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw 8pc Buffalo Wings ($10.95): There was nothing really special about these, and as usual I barely touched the bleu cheese dressing. There was a good amount of meat on each piece. Otherwise, this was a one-and-done for us. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=Qh2hgOBHT6Tpga0ODvOTww&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich ($9.50): Fried seasoned eggplant topped with tomato ragu sauce and mozzarella cheese lightly toasted, this was my go-to sandwich and always had to try it. This was a hungry man's meal filled with flavor that lasted into the next day. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=fMVKBLXRpegVTFfAdEunqA&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw Signature Grandma Pizza ($19.00): Their all-time favorite made with fresh mozzarella cheese, plum tomato sauce, olive oil, garlic, on a thick crispy rectangle crust, I felt this was their version of a Detroit pizza. It was a simple straightforward pie that reminded me of the rectangular ones I enjoyed at lunch time in my lower education years. It was nice, but I wouldn't order it again. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=xxht4__Fksh2ZnTjO-nuYQ&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw 5" Cannoli ($3.00): Your standard mascarpone and chocolate chip-filled flaky pastry shell, it was sizable and blissful to eat. The shell held together well and didn't crumble, which held everything together. I'd leave a gun for this! https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=cPJGdosl0en1en2IQJvK6Q&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw Carrot Cake ($4.95): A thick slice with cream cheese filling, lots of carrot bits, and a creamy layer of icing, this was a hearty dessert that stuck to your ribs in a delightful way. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=NOaITLA216NXVr2nj8gj5A&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw Delivery Fee ($2.60): Sometimes it happened - c'est la vie. SERVICE I easily placed my order over the phone for a designated delivery time, a friendly gentleman repeated my order back to me, and about 45 minutes later, a young man was at the doorstep with our order all securely packed up - grazie! PARKING (FREE; N/A this instance) This was a moot point in this case since our food was delivered. Otherwise, they apparently had two onsite lots in addition to plenty of spots along the main drag of Central Ave. and all surrounding side streets. - nuff said. ATMOSPHERE, DÉCOR, AMBIENCE Sadly, my only recollection of this place while we walked by was a well-kept facade with a large signage. I imagined plenty of natural lighting came through the large front windows and door while electric ceiling lights filled in the rest. I had no idea about TVs or any background music. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=0wjy9B2vdmte3utRB8-R6w&userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw ATTIRE Totally casual, so I would normally be in a t-shirt, boardshorts, and flip-flops... but I was dressed-down for delivery. OVERALL Generally speaking, I was fine with Renato's Pizza Masters and would consider another visit. However, nothing really stood. The prices were comparable, good portion sizes, extensive menu, and straightforward (delivery) service. It would be nice to enjoy a sit down meal with a beer. Plus, I always preferred to support local small mom & pop businesses. I found very good value based on the prices, service, and experience noted above (TOTAL paid experience was around $68.00 BEFORE any discounts and/or tip). And, they accepted my credit card of choice... AMEX! 4.0 STARS read more

See all

Food was delicious Service sucked! Ordering food and this kid had a disgruntled attitude. After ordering entrees and a slice of pizza one of the entrees arrived while we waited for the other 2. Eventually come to find out they never made the other entree and then 10-15 mins later I asked about my slice and the kid with the attitude said it's coming with an attitude. Eventually the second entree arrived but then 5-10 mins later my slice arrived. The only person who was polite was the waitress. Food was good. Service at the front sucked really bad. Waitress was great. Hire more people like her. Next time we'll just get it delivered. I suggest you do the same read more

One of my favorites places ever. Me and family have been coming here for 10+ years. Food is always amazing, (pizza, mussels, the bread itself lmao) Service is quick, atmosphere matches the location and the food energy. It was more of a small pizza shop style before they renovated, which was also just as good lol, now it's modernized and fits all the crowds! Kudos to designer/builder! Parking is probably biggest worry, but that's how it is in JC read more

A solid 4 stars for Italian in the Heights section of jersey city. We celebrated for a party of 20+ people and were able to make reservations the night before. The food was pretty good, we ordered a number of things and had it family style. Gnocchi (pillowy and marinara sauce was just seasoned right), dinner special was scallops shrimp roasted tomatoes in a creamy pesto sauces, mussels in white wine sauce (tender and presented well), chicken Marsala with angel hair, chicken Francese, herbed crusted salmon was cooked just right, tender and not overcooked- served on a bed of salad. Penne vodka with chicken is a classic dish they've perfected. Calamari was crisp and battered thinly served with marinara. Chicken Alfredo was creamy and cheesy. Margherita pizza was great as well. Simple and classic. We had the back room which was very comfortable bright and more dressed up for gatherings. Our servers were friendly and service was prompt. For dessert we had tiramisu which was so good. The vibe is casual, neighborly and not stuffy. A lot of locals having fun. Parking is a private lot and street parking. Overall experience is a 5, and will recommend even just for take out! read more

See all

Renato's Pizza Master really mastered the art of pizza making! We ordered the margarita pizza. You can taste the freshly baked dough, and the thin crispy crust provided the Perfect foundation for the vibrant tomato sauce. The ambiance of the restaurant further enhanced the overall dining experience. The warm and inviting atmosphere, coupled with attentive staff, created a welcoming environments. read more

See all

Renato's, the beloved Italian restaurant on Central Avenue in Jersey City Heights is a local gem. The white tablecloth back room is where locals go to celebrate birthdays and anniversaries. The food and wait staff are exceptional. Portions are generous and the prices can't be beat. The margarita pizza makes for a delicious shared appetizer. Every time we bring friends to eat here, they rave about the food- eggplant rollatini has a delicate filling and the eggplant is never greasy. All the pastas are well sauced and their basic red sauce has just the right touch of sweet. We have lived in the neighborhood for 41 years and Pizza Masters has been our go to for our four decades. For a casual slice or sandwich, the main pizzeria is the place to go! read more

My Wife and me order delivery from here all the time. It's always so good. We've gone to eat at the restaurant twice and both times were fantastic The food is dead on and the staff is very friendly. The restaurant is very nice and clean I highly recommend going to eat here read more

I had a party of 10 catered with Renato's Pizza Masters. It was the first time I've catered through them although I've been going to their great restaurant for years. They couldn't have been more helpful and thorough from the ordering process to the delivery process. The food was meticulously prepared, clearly marked, packed perfectly, and delivered smoothly. The food was fresh and hot, and above all delicious! The order came with serving utensils and bread. All of my guests remarked about how good the food was! Rather than stressing out about cooking for a large group, Renato's saved the day and made it a success. Thank you so much, Renato's! read more

Probably the best spot to grab a slice in the Heights? Everything is always incredibly delicious! The only downside is that this place always seems busy. read more

Delicious pizza but a little confusing to order for newbies. I still haven't figured out why we had to get a Coke from the cooler instead of the fountain machine when they knew we were eating in. If I had to do it over again I would just get a slice of grandmas because it was super special!! I'm glad we made the home to The Heights to give this a try. Also: bathrooms are super nice. read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

Went here for a party and I kinda love this place! The food was great specially the Rigatoni Vodka! Location: It is located in Jersey City. The interior is good for like 20 people party. Service: they were nice and quick to serve. Food: so it is a set menu cause its a party. I love RIGATONI VODKA: the pasta is cooked perfectly and the sauce is so flavorful, it has a little spice at the end which I love. PORK TENDERLOIN: the pork afcourse was tender and the gravy was soo good! Price rating: 6/10, it was not bad. I will definitely come back here to try their pizza! Get the RIGATONI VODKA! read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Rigatoni vodka - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

I stopped in on a friday night during the dinner rush with my family and this place did not disappoint! Upon walking in, we were immediately greeted by the aromas coming from their open kitchen, were various pizzas and other dishes were being prepared. We walked up to the counter and placed our order, sat at a table and our food came out shortly after. We all really liked the pizza, and we liked the variety offered. Mt daughter loved the chicken parm slice, my sister had the supreme and I had the chicken buffalo. Pizza tasted fresh and not dried out from being reheated. I felt the service was great, and so was the food so that made me very happy. The dining room was also set up pretty nice and looked clean. I did not use the restrooms so I cannot extend my review there. read more

I'm the regular that always eats at Renato's, which is the restaurant in the back, but we always order takeout from Pizza Masters in the front. I haven't been inside Pizza Masters (since they renovated the front) and all I have to say is bravo! Let me set the stage for you. You walk in off Central Avenue and it's just this comfy cozy establishment, but all of sudden your nostrils are hit with the most amazing smells of garlic & oil (which of course is the smell of their homemade garlic knots). The staff is super friendly. We decided to dine in instead of takeout (it was that inviting). We ordered a slice of the veggie pizza, the penne pizza, and an antipasto. We walked in on the later side of the afternoon and there was NO shortage of pies or what was available. A++++ We ordered and sat down and you can just tell this place exudes "community." There were a group of men in the front, chatting over current events while eating their pasta dishes, a young family eating behind us, and other single diners sprinkled all over. The place was buzzing, but in the same sense you were forced to slow down and kick back. Place was immaculate. And the food, as usual, did not disappoint. The slices were dynamite, but let's talk about the dressing on the antipasto. I could put a straw in this dressing and sip it. It is one of the most delicious, refreshing dressings I have ever tasted. Anyone I take here that tries that dressing says it's delicious. Thank you for being such a happy, inviting place to be comfortable and eat delicious food. Cheers! read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

One of the best margarita slices I've had. Flavor is delicious, and the way it's heated is also great! Why I give it 3 stars vs 5. HYGIENE The staff here heating up your pizza do not wear gloves!! not sure if this is something new, but it's concerning especially with Covid being an issue. Also just general hygiene should be the main focus at all restaurants. #dobetter read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - 12" Small Pizza with: - sausage -green peppers -sun dried Tomatoes -Mushrooms -Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

I've been popping in here for about a year and a half now. The slice is great. Mushrooms are never rubbery or sour. Cheese is tight. Crust is crispy. All standard pizza needs. But the organization itself is evidently run by people who give a shit. They are actively trying to keep the pie cost low, like last decade low. And in an age where everything is higher, that matters. They even have the salty Italian descendant running the counta, runnin da slices, rolls, and mini pies. Will return. Probably for a calzone. read more

Pizza quality has changed. Prices went up and quality went down. The pizza was oily. There's no excuse for this. It's a staple food on the menu. read more

20 minutes to get a Chicken Roll heated up that was not even hot for the cheese to be melted

oh lordy, what a nice treat this was on a slow monday night. i parked out in front, in the original attempt of finally trying another pizza spot down the block, but then i saw its been around since 1959. i was skeptical, but since it boasted that year, i said let me give the ole yelp a try and see what this place is about. what a surprise, great reviews. it feels incredibly modern, and more like a chain once you walk in, but you will be smacked in the face with the enticing smell of all things italian cuisine related - you know like garlic, toasted bread, and anything that helps you slip into a food coma. head over to the left, order at the counter, take a number and seat yourself. someone will bring over your food. ill try to speed this up... vodka slice - thick enough to hold the heavy cheese, but thin enough that its a typical slice. no flop, but not too crispy. its loaded with cheese, fresh basil, with splashes of vodka sauce. one bite, and i made up my mind, id come back for another. we grabbed 1 deep dish style pie and regretted it. we needed another. its mini, but not too deep. bottom crust resembles foccacia, and its saucy. its a great snack, dont share. my date grabbed the pepperoni roll, although tasty, it was incredibly oilly. way too oilly even for his taste. it was pouring out and he had to drip dry with napkins. despite this, he ate it and even tasted better the next day. none of the desserts are made in house, but the creme brulee cheesecake was nice. top the meal off with local bottled soda, with their own label on it. were looking forward to coming back. read more

See all

Once again another great dinner at Renato's Took out My Brother in law and his Wife for there Anniversary we all had a great time, read more

Great food, great prices... great service. Get the Mussels and the chicken Italiano. You'll dream about them later.

My favorite pizzeria. All the girls and the young men I've seen working at the front are all so welcoming and provide such a fast service. Pizza masters is great whether you're coming in just for a quick bite or to dine in. read more

I grew up in Jersey City (64 years old). Pizza Masters almost as old as me (60 years) was always our go to place for fresh pies; while I've enjoyed eating at Renato's time to time, last night I went old school. Escarole + beans (plenty of garlic just like momma), baked clams (used to get their mussels on fish night Fridays, felt like clams. And 2 slices of plain. Hadn't had pizza in a couple of years. It tasted just like I remember. A little taste of the past. Lots of gooey cheese, not a real thin crust but for me just right, a nice light but flavorful marinara. A niece from San Diego was visiting, she Loved it; Pizza Masters a taste of our past still holds up today! Great job! read more

See all

I was looking for penne vodka in JC (Oh how I miss you Gino's) and stumbled onto Renato's. They're not on any of the delivery apps, so you do have to call to place your order. It's a little weird to not be able to track the delivery, but they definitely got it to me within their quoted 45 minute window. There was a $30 minimum order to deliver to my area, but that was fine. We both had an order of their penne vodka and honestly we could've done one order to share, but leftovers are always welcome. The penne vodka was quite good - not the best that I've ever had, but solid. Their bread was fantastic - I could eat that bread all day long. We also had a Caesar salad and it was just ok. I will definitely be ordering from Renato's again - some of their other pasta dishes sounded amazing. read more

It's okay pizza. Got the grandma pizza, 18" I think. Comes in a rectangular shape. I probably wouldn't go back. The grease was real. Lots of cheese. No meat. And the quality was nothing to brag about. We waited 15 minutes probably on a Tuesday night. I think price was like $21. I'm not the biggest pizza person, so it didn't stand out too much to me. But it was better than Joe's. Come at me haha read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - Grandma - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Good pizza, fast delivery. They forgot the ketchup even though I asked like 3 times. Cant complain though, thats minor but the pizza and fries are good. read more

Living in Jersey City for nearly 4 years and I just discovered Renato's. I don't know where I've been and why no one in my building knows about this spot, but it's INSANE! I've been on the hunt for a slice shop for years and like other people, I've been so disappointed with soggy, cold, gross pizza. Not only does Renato's have a pizzeria side, but they also have a dining room to host parties and intimate dinner. Ample parking lot in the back makes this place even more desirable. The staff is really vibrant and friendly. We felt right at home; not to mention you can totally come here in sweatpants and literally feel at home. Really nice community feel with unique slices daily. We tried the white, Buffalo chicken, and margherita and brought some more slices home and devoured them the next day. Super reasonable prices too and generous slices. read more

Renato's Pizza Masters - White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all