Rex's on a Saturday night. Drinks before dinner were fine, but a little more expensive than I am used to for a rural supper club. Apparently the proximity to Madison means they can have higher prices... The salad bar wasn't bad, though the greens left something to be desired. But the steak. Oh the steak. I ordered mine "Medium" and it came out rare, and cold. Fries were fine but felt like they had been shaken out of a frozen bag and tossed in a fryer. Waitress wasn't even around to try to send the steak back, and never came over to check on us - so I ate it because I was starving. There are plenty of good supper clubs out there - I likely won't be back to this one. read more

We have gone to Rex's for years - I mean years back into 80's and it has always been great food for reasonable prices. I feel like Rex's must have had a management change it was so below our expectations. Cost was higher, portions were smaller and salad bar was not at all up to usual standard. $3.95 extra for salad bar with fish special which usually would be worth it but not so last night. The lettuce had big chunk ends of heads and several parts of the lettuce was brown . Had different things on each side of bar so people were crossing over and running into each other. The cheese spread fortunately was good as usual . Just so very disappointed- little picky things like asking if you want ketchup or tartar sauce instead of bringing both. No house wine. read more

Great family restaurant with great salad bar and great food. Has the old supper club atmosphere

Came here with family for a Friday Night Fish fry. We had a reservation for 5:30 and were seated promptly, although I was the youngest one there by 30 years! Traditional supper club, outdated decor. They make a great old fashioned. The fish was definately frozen and overcooked, chewy and lacking flavor. It was actually hard to cut. Fish should flake, this didn't . It was extreely disappointing. We also ordered cheese curds. They were ok. The cheese wasn't melted so either they wern't cooked enough or sat in a window to die. I woudn't recommend this place to anyone else. It did look like they had a beautiful salad bar although for $3 extra, I didn't need it. Our server was wonderful however. She was attentive and the pace of the meal was nice. read more

We went as a group of 8 for dinner last night. The roads were awful so our entire group didn't get there on time. The hostesses weren't particularly friendly upon arrival. After we were seated, we decided on drinks. Most of us had old fashioneds which were average. The bread and salad bar were the best part of our experience. I ordered the special, Steak Oscar. I ordered it medium and it came out well done. No pink anywhere. The asparagus cane from a can or frozen and the crab on the steak was imitation. At $26 dollars a plate, I expected fresh asparagus and real crab meat so it was incredibly disappointing. This should not be considered a "special". Finally, the hash browns had a piece of kraft singles cheese thrown on them. Bummer-will not be back. read more

Perhaps because I did not grow up in Wisconsin and grew up in a big city, I simply don't "get" supper clubs. While I would like that to be the reason I was disappointed with my experience at Rex's, it's not. The lack of quality in food is the reason I was disappointed. Another Yelp reviewer mentioned that Rex's fried fish might be Van de Kamp's frozen fish filets, and I'm afraid I have to agree. I enjoy Culver's fried fish better than Rex's! The hash browns, rolls and coleslaw I ate at Rex's also were not up to par. I never -- NEVER -- reach for a salt shaker to add salt to my food. I had to at Rex's to give the hash browns any flavor. The coleslaw furthermore was bland, and the rolls did not seem fresh. They were on the chewy side and did not have the texture of a freshly baked dinner roll. The gothic/Medieval (not sure what it's called?) decor is creepy, in my opinion, and the carpeting inside Rex's is "seasoned," to quote my husband! I won't go back. read more

I've been coming to Rex's since he bought the restaurant 30years ago. I've lost track of how many meals, drinks or weddings I've enjoyed at this place. Rex's seems to always be there and working too. Best salad bar around and large menu to pick from. I don't recall ever having a bad meal here and will continue to come as long as he is in business. read more

I've been to several weddings at Rex's and the food is always amazing and the decor is homey and feels like a nice supper club! The recrption and DJ area is fantastic and we plan to have our youngest daughter's wedding here in the future! read more

I avoid Rex's when I can, but large group meals or when dining out with friends will often bring me there. I've eaten there easily a dozen times, both lunch and dinner. The food is adequate. Generally more institutional than you would expect for the price (soups are not homemade, potatoes are instant, meat is usually pre-sliced and merely heated). The service is decent and usually not offensive. The bar is pretty decent. read more

Stopped in late on a Saturday night. Traditional supper club with a European theme to it. We wanted to stay in Waunakee for dinner (as opposed to going in to Madison). It met our needs but, was just average. Hostess/servers were friendly and efficient but, not overly so. I felt the A-OK rating fit best. Considered a fourth star though. read more

Salad bar is great, has extra things like pasta salad, and unusual items such beets and chickpeas. Wait was only 30 mins and got to sit at the bar until called to dining room. Bar prices were cheap, good, strong drinks. . Prices for meal were excellent. Friday fish fry -cod & haddock under $12. Amount of fish was adequate, not an all you can eat but with the large salad bar you left full and often with a to go bag. Walleye was excellent. Bands play weekends after 9 in bar area. Great experience for us just passing through. read more

Rex's Innkeeper - Deep fried cod - Seafood Near Me - Waunakee, Wisconsin

So first I find it hilarious that this place has been around for how long and only has 27 reviews. But upon further thinking, if the average age of the customer here is what maybe 55+...then the use of Yelp is probably semi-lacking, haha. But anyways. We came here last night with neighbors because we live in Waunakee and we were pretty sure its like a Waunakee icon so a visit needed to happen. It was exactly what I expected, "charming" old school supper club decor, with food that was edible but nothing that blew me away. However, my husband's medium-rare Steak Oscar was cooked fantastic and was probably the best part of everything on the table. My broiled haddock and baked potato were alright but nothing I couldn't do at home. The fun part about a supper club is the soup and salad bar that comes with your order. I did enjoy their turkey & rice soup and the salad bar section was your average. Definitely can't say I'm dying to return but I am glad we gave it a shot and can say we supported a local biz! read more

Fantastic salad bar! My wife and I were both stuffed before our meals came out. There was a lot of variety and something for everyone. Food came out piping hot. Service is very friendly. Glad we came here! read more

Rex's Innkeeper - Wonderful salad bar. - Seafood Near Me - Waunakee, Wisconsin

We have been to more than a few supper clubs for Friday Fish Fry and this one needs some help. The decor was fine. When visiting a super club you expect it to be dated and a little dingy; which Rex's fits. However, the service was bad, the fish took forever, and it was over-priced. There must have been 10 waitresses working, but no one was getting regular service. I guess everyone is smoking cigarettes. The salad bar is Not included in the fish special; it's 3.99 extra. Every other night of the week it's free with the special. WTF? The fish took 35 minutes to show up. It doesn't take that long to fry and there weren't a lot of people in there. This place needs a restaurant makeover. Go to maple tree in McFarland. Don't go to Rex's. read more

I have a soft spot for outdated salad bars and supper clubs in general, so I liked this place. I wouldn't say it's very memorable in its own right, though. The interior is done up in a kitschy, vaguely Olive Garden-style theme--hints of a retirement home, especially since hardly anyone was under 50 except for our table and the servers. The salad bar was decent, with a good range of toppings and a few pasta-salad type sides, though the soup and the dressing tasted very institutional. I can't speak for anything else on the menu, except for the shrimp cocktail, which was bland and clearly straight from a freezer. The bar area is a bit interesting, there seems to be a space for polkas or something and a semi-divided room where dozens of old people were playing cards. read more

So the owner is super nice and the bar has some really good craft beers available, but the food wasn't that great. Really good service too, just wish that the food was better. read more

Food average at best,but salad bar was good.Breading on broasted chicken way "too heavy"..Service OK.No happy hour in bar.On "plus side" I felt like the youngest person there. read more

Good place for one with an older palate. Food is extremely bland. I've been here a few times and have had the broasted chicken, steak tenderloin, and "grilled" chicken- that chicken was actually pan fried with no seasoning. Decor is very odd, very dark in there. Our server for each visit was very good. They do have a children's menu. As a family, we are always the youngest diners there at each visit. Salad bar is good. I would recommend the salad bar alone, unless you are a senior then you will probably enjoy everything. read more

food ok. woman at reservation desk rude, inconsiderate and incompetent. This was our second bad similar experience. cold day before we eat there again. read more

Just went to Rex's tonight. We've been going there for years. We drive 2 hours to get there, but not anymore. I'm afraid to say tonight was the last time. Broasted chicken was ok, not the usual. My baked potato was fine, but who can ruin one of those! My husband's ribs were not as good as usual, and what's up with the hash browns with a piece of Velveeta cheese half melted on the top. The salad bar was good. But, we sat at 5:00, and at 6:10 I was tapped on the shoulder and told that they needed our table!!!! I guess I was so surprised by that I didn't say anything, and we left. But, on our 2 hour drive home I had plenty of time to think about it! That was rude! There were 6 other open tables behind us. I didn't see her go up to anybody else and "need" their table. I've never experienced that at a restaurant, and I don't expect it to start now. Good luck, Rex. read more

We have been patrons of Rex's since he bought the place. His restaurant holds the ability to accommodate large groups, just call for a reservation, even on a Friday! The food is good (not outstanding) the service and drinks are always good and you can have unlimited popcorn. Yes the prices have gone up, whose haven't? As far as its being a place for the elderly, it beats Loud, warehouse beer bars, where you get to sit on a hard bench and eat micro food. read more

Terrific supper club. Went for the first time on Sunday and was very pleased with the food and service. The resturant provides a good value for the price and has a great salid bar. read more

My fiancé and I just moved here and so we were excited to try one of the many restaurants in waunakee. However we stood around for 15 min and was never even greeted. We walked to the bar and didn't see anyone. We said excuse me to the ladies standing and talking they completely ignored us. So then as I was leaving I decided to call and just let them know they lost our business and that is when Taylor decided to tell me I was wrong and she has worked there for six years and doesn't care if I call a manager......this was by far the most unprofessional and horrible experience I have had in quite some time. We will be king out what the rest of waunakee has to offer. read more

When we go out for a fish we always go to Rex's. The staff is very friendly and the wait is never that long. They also have an amazing salad bar that alot of fish frys in town no longer have. read more

This place is great! I'm from Chicago and it was a nice change of pace coming here. The staff was friendly and very accommodating. Everyone I was with had the broasted chicken or ribs. The chicken was excellent and the ribs were falling off the bone. The salad bar was great and so was the beef and vegetable soup. The cheese curds were my favorite appetizer. You definitely get a lot of bang for your buck here read more

This is an old place. Very dark and old fashioned. The food reflects this. Bland and non-creative. They do have a great salad bar that is always well stocked and is not expensive. I would go for the salad bar. read more

Bad menu and ambiance, expensive, my steak was overcooked and not grilled. Also, an NRA supporter.

We had lunch at Rex's. Great salad bar. Everything was fresh, plentiful, and a nice variety. The mushroom soup was delicious. You can definitely make a meal of the salad bar. We also had the cod. Very good. We ate at the bar, great service from Belinda. Will be back. read more

I love Rex's! The coconut shrimp is hands down my favorite in southern Wisconsin. I feel connected to my Wisconsin roots whenever I stop in, the people that eat at Rex's are super nice and there to have a good time. The cocktails are old school and great! read more

Consistently good, amazing fried chicken, solid salad and soup bar. (This is weird to yelp about a place I don't remember first visiting.)

The restaurant has very old decor needing of many renovations. The steak was very tough and chewy. My wife ordered the barbecue ribs which were very dry and hard to eat off the bone. Salad bar had a good variety, which was the best part of our dining experience. Location is good if you live in Waunakee.. read more

Meh. I've experienced better. I think my expectations of Rex's were too high because they let me down. The salad bar was good, but the French dressing was out and the staff did not refill it once it was gone, so I was disappointed to have to pick something else. Our waiter seemed to be working in the background. He was very quiet, but effecient. I ordered Chicken Cordon Bleu with green beans. The chicken was very good, but the green beans were overcooked, as if they were sitting in a steam table too long. Also, the chicken came with a side of sauce that turned out to be only chicken gravy. The atmosphere was typical supperclub, although I am not sure how good it will look once the Christmas lights and decorations are removed. Overall, I wouldn't go out of my way to eat there. read more

Very disappointing! $17 for buffet-with hardly any choices. Our waitress was rude-only showed up twice-the last time with our bill and was then angry because we wanted our bill separated. Our table was charged 54% gratuity because we spilt our bill! Is this even legal?? Will never return!! read more

Recently went to this restaurant with my family. The bar was nice and so was the service but the food was a little too expensive. The salad bar was nice but the eggs were still frozen and they were out of both croutons and bacon bits. I ended up ordering the *NEW* chicken strips for a whopping $9.50 and I was less than amazed. Only a few chicken strips and a very small portion of fries. You would get more and better quality for less at Culvers. However, everyone else's steaks looked really good. I probably wouldn't eat here again for a while and If I do then I will definitely order something else. read more

When I lived in both Madison and Waunakkee during the 70s,80s and 90s this place was always awesome in all respects. Rex and all his employees were great and so was all the food and drinks. The entire place was always kept clean too. Many many good time were spent there. Keep up the good work. Dennis Niehoff, Boise / Meridian,Idaho read more

This old school supper club was an absolute gem we found! Great salad bar, awesome food and our waitress was exceptional (thanks Becky)...we also loved the beautiful entrance! read more

Supper clubs are unfortunately starting to fade away in our society and that is why I was so happy when I recently discovered Rex's Innkeeper in Waunakee. I went with a couple family members who raved about the food and salad bar and they were exactly right. Cannot even remember the last time I attended a restaurant and been this satisfied with every single item I ordered! Thank you! Service was friendly, the salad bar was stacked with fresh items and various choices: had homemade croutons, multiple types of wrapped crackers (sure sign of a classic supper club), the best mushroom soup I have ever tasted (creamy and homemade), A+! I ordered one of their specials for my entree which was a salmon dish and it was prepared perfectly and adorned with a creamy/tasty sauce on top. Bread and butter is complimentery item for each guest. Yes the decor is a bit dated (80's)...but truly who cares??!!! With food this good it's no big deal! Will be back:) read more

I am a Waunakee native and Rex's has been around for as long as I can remember. I have eaten there a few times and I'm sad to say I have never been impressed. One positive thing I have to say is the salad bar is good. Besides that I have never been overly impressed with the food, especially considering the prices. One of the worst times we had is when we went and ordered steak. The service was very slow. They finally took our order after a half hour of trying to flag down our server. Then it took almost a half hour for food to arrive at the table and it was only my daughters food. We were told it would be a few minutes for our steaks. About 15 minutes later (after my daughter was almost finished eating) we got our steaks. We asked for medium well and both got steaks that were barely warm, still raw and bleeding. We were so sick of sitting there we got boxes and left. I cooked the steaks when we got home. I was too mad to eat. My husband ate some and said it tasted old and a little off. Such a waste of money. We have not been back since. read more

Posting on behalf of of all the 2017 Waunakee graduates. Rex's again provided support for the post Graduation activities in the form of food. TERRIFIC chicken tenders were a huge hit with the kids and adult volunteers. Outstanding quality and wonderful community benefactor. read more

No glitz...not fancy...just an older Wisconsin supper club with great service, great food, and good prices.