Best deep dish crust in Hudson Valley & beyond. Gonna try the thin crust next! Can't wait.

When you are the Pizza Beast you gotta do a little bit of everything. Same plaza, 2 pizzerias, so I hit both. Grabbed a Grandma slice from Pasqualle's and a White slice with basil & balsamic drizzle from Rino's, plus some garlic knots because, well, Beast's gotta eat and I was hungry. Pasqualle's: Classic feel, decent crust, but sauce was a bit flat. Solid traditional slice, nothing wild. Rino's: Crust was the star -- nice crust crunch, well-made. Sauce was loose, slightly chunky, and garlicky. White slice had great balance with the balsamic drizzle. Garlic knots from Rino's: Super garlicky in the best way. Both places were clean and roomy, prices were fair. Service was very good. Verdict: Pasqualle's is traditional and safe. Rino's brings more flavor and flair -- and wins this round. read more

Rino's Pizza - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York

We found ourselves passing through New Paltz, and Rino's was right there when we needed some lunch. We heard it was good, and we heard right, because this is a solid slice shop that also offers up plenty of other options if you're not in the mood for pizza. They also have a spacious dining area that, while barebones, is still comfortable if you don't want to take it out. For the kids, we got a couple plain slices and some chicken fingers (for the bipolar three year old who sometimes hates pizza). The chicken fingers weren't anything revolutionary, but they fried them well, just like they did the buffalo wings that my wife was craving. Those were super saucy, but nice and crisp. Reminiscent of Western New York, and that's a compliment. We were also feeling like we needed some greens in our life, so we added a chicken caesar salad. It was better than expected, and hit the spot. Overall, I think pizza is the best choice here (it's in the name after all), but they have some variety if you need more as well. All in all, a very solid place. read more

See all

I was in need of a quick dinner and saw that this spot does pizza by the slice and decided to give it a try. They have classic NY style but I went for their grandma's style crust. It's square cut, thicker than traditional NY style but not exactly Detroit style either. I'm not precisely sure what style it would be considered, That said, it was good! I got the white pie with pesto and hot honey and the blending of flavors made for a flavorful slice. Inside the restaurant is larger than it looks with plenty of tables if you'd like to dine in. That said, the atmosphere is basic pizza shop so I opted to take it to go and enjoy my slice and a movie in my hotel room. The service was fast and friendly! Get to it! read more

Rino's Pizza - White pie with pesto and hot honey - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York

This used to be our go-to pizza spot. Unfortunately, the quality has not been consistent since the owner's son took over. Pizza is more doughy and just not as good! Maybe we'll revisit in a couple of months and give it another try but in the meantime, we're getting our pizza fix elsewhere. read more

Fantastic food, the pizza is great and they make a mean eggplant parm. The staff is super friendly and make the entire atmosphere more welcoming. I'd say it's the best pizza joint in New Paltz by a mile. read more

Got off the highway and rolled into this little college town looking for a good slice. Lotta choices here, I always go for the most recent outta the oven, in this case a slice of plain cheese and a slice of Sicilian. Guys warmed both to perfection and got me on my way. Both tasted great. read more

Pizza was delicious. Shared 2 plain, 1 pepperoni, square chicken parm and square veggie. All came out hot and were excellent. Quick service, friendly folks. Could not have been better. Highly recommend and will go again when back in the area. read more

Had a misstep with their order. While they made an attempt to correct the error, they delivered wings that were way undercooked. Appreciate the hustle and the effort to correct the mistake, but they fell short. Food was good other than the missing 1/3 of our order and the replacement raw wings. read more

The food looked and smelled amazing! We had Jersey tomato and chicken parmesan pizza. The flavors were amazing. The staff was friendly and the order was ready on time for takeout. Will drive the ten minutes for the pizza read more

Rino's Pizza - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

LOVE THIS PLACE. We stop at Rinos every time we're on our way back from Saratoga. Their pizza is so tasty and sauce. They have lots of indoor seating, very spacious. Service is really good, the guys working there are so quick and so nice. read more

Rino's Pizza - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York

This hands down the past place in town for pizza. As a pizza enthusiast I am in here once or twice a week, either for a pie or a quick slice. Their calzones and garlic knots are fantastic too. Also the staff are easy to talk to while waiting for your meal. Highly suggest if you're looking for pizza in the New Paltz area. read more

Best pizza in New Paltz hands down, best I've had this far north for sure. Pizza is subjective and everyone likes a different style but for a ny style thin crust they're the best around by far. Their Grandma and other specialty sheet pan style pizzas are great too. read more

The meatball ricotta slice and grandma slice were great, not too much sauce and not overloaded with cheese and no burnt crust. Wish had more ricotta on the slice though since made the slice so much richer in flavor. For the Italian combo, first time I seen a place use semolina bread for sandwiches and I will say I was fan of it, different but great, it's not typical crispy loaf. Plenty of meat and definitely not an air sandwich for sure. Hah. Plus made exactly as I asked with lettuce and tomato, can't tell you how many place get your sandwiches mixed up. Also a shout out to guy who despite having a case on his leg, was serving customers on his own without help, definitely great to see hard workers. read more

Rino's Pizza - Italian Classic sub - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

It was ok. Nothing special. Place is huge and decent. We ordered a cheese pie to go. I didnt care for the taste of the sauce, a bit sweet. read more

so I called Rino's at 7:44 pm for a special request and I was answered by nick and he was so accommodating and very polite on the phone. He informed me that my request wasn't a big deal and that it would be ready in fifteen minutes. He was so friendly that I am going to let all my friends know how great the service was definitely five stars thank Rino's pizza and of course Nick read more

TOTALLY Amazing , wonderful crust, sauce, attention to a quality pizza. Though not a wood fired pizza, a damn good pizza. Wonderful staff, I stop by weekly, and so good, a treasure in New Paltz. read more

This is an awesome neighborhood pizza restaurant. The grandma pie is phenomenal, their specialty slices rock, and they have the best sauce in town. They have been so generous with fundraising for our school district activities. They always give back to the community. We love coming here! read more

Quick service, very friendly staff, large menu and great pizza. Go-to spot for this area.

We live in New Paltz and this is our favorite (of many) pizza places! Conveniently located in Cherry Hill Plaza. Parking is easy because there is a free lot. Pizza is good! Many options. The people who work there are friendly and the service is fast. Nice, easy going vibe. There is a separate room if you want to eat there, but again it is a casual vibe and mainly counter service. My kids love their garlic knots. Fairly priced too and they are pretty quick even if busy! Seems like a smoothly operated business read more

Very high-quality pizza and friendly staff. I need 85 characters so here are some words.

While we were visiting family that was staying in the New Platz area, we decided to get a takeout from Rino's. This is based on a to-go order and it was a good amount of food that we got for 10 people. It took about 20 minutes for everything to be ready for pick up after calling the order in. There was antipasto, buffalo chicken wings, pasta e fagioli soup, and cheese as well as pepperoni pizza. It was enough portions for all of us and some even had seconds if they were still hungry. We were happy with the fill up for a Sunday Funday dinner. read more

See all

Great pizza and the eggplant parm sub is perfect. The marinara sauce just fantastic. Love this place!

My eggplant parm sub was bad. The bread was soggy and the eggplant not crispy. The pizzas are very good.

One of the best pizzas I have ever had! Rino's is always on our list when we travel to New Paltz (been here twice so far). Love the garlic knots here and the ricotta cheese pizza.. is heaven!! A casual place to dine in, the service is great and it's such a delight to watch them making the pizzas as you eat! Highly recommend this place!! read more

Rino's Pizza - Garlic Knots Veggie Delight Pizza Ricotta cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Incredible slice shop, enjoyed both classic and grandma style slices. Counter guy was friendly and informed, and pizza came out quick. Highly recommend if you're in the area. read more

I hear the pizza here is great and it's the only place my fiancé will order from, but if your thinking about ordering a gluten free pizza, do yourself a favor and go to the supermarket and just buy a frozen pizza or a crust and make your own, which is what I normally do. I was feeling extra hungry and lazy today (pregnant) and was craving pizza. I don't have much experience ordering gluten-free pizzas around here because I know most places don't make their own crust and it's usually frozen and not worth it; however, I figured "why not" and "how bad can it be?" I ordered over the phone and totally didn't really each topping was $3. I wish I would have known, I would have modified my order. Second, when I opened the box to the gluten free pie, I noticed that the crust was very crumbly. I got home and cut it because it doesn't come sliced it was a huge mess. The crust completely crumbled but at the same time was undercooked. It was not edible. I wasn't going to waste a $30+ pizza, so I had to put it back in the oven which defeats the whole purpose of takeout. The crust itself is not very good and toppings were mediocre. Nothing special, especially for the price. The whole thing was super disappointing and unsatisfying. I still can't get over how much it all cost! My fiancé however, loved his regular crust chicken parm pie. read more

Rino's Pizza - The LG Veggie Delight on gluten free crust that just completely crumbled apart - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

Rino's has excellent pizza and friendly staff. I tried the meat craver's pizza and it was loaded with toppings! My son is a big eater and 2 slices filled him up! They have a large casual dining area and lots of typical pizza joint menu options. Huge parking lot and convenient location are a plus. read more

Stopped at Rinos on our way home from an upstart NY trip. Got three different slices - all of which were equally delicious. Great service from the young men working behind the counter. Highly recommend!! read more

Best pizza in New Paltz! It's the go to spot for a celebratory meal after sports games.

First time at Rino's. All foot-shuffling boys in here, except the cashier. Order 2 slices: one white (a bit processed 'cheesy') and a red slice (good). At 3.50 a slice, it's a bargain. Now a New Paltz favorite! Rebel chef says: 4 read more

I wish I didn't have to write this review, but people need to know what's going on. Everyone is required to wear a mask when entering a restaurant during this unprecedented time of COVID-19. That means ALL employees as well as customers!!! Especially those working with food AND working out front where customers will be present. Having one employee in the restaurant who was putting the delivery orders together, with NO mask, shows that your business does not respect their customers. Food is really good, pizza is really good, but the lack of a mask, and the possibility of transmitting COVID-19 to a co-worker or customer, and causing illness or worse, is unacceptable. You should be ashamed of yourself. read more

Good food, probably the best restaurant in New Paltz. We ate at so many places, and this is by far the very best, and most tasty!

Good sandwich! It was bursting with chicken and easily made two meals for me. The service was terrific and atmosphere-its a pizza place. But they do have a little shop in the dining room with authentic Italian pastas and sauces. read more

Great food and pizza hands down! Very diverse slices. Customer service is top notch. Highly recommend for self, families , parties you name it. read more

I while back I did a big pickup of pizza for a bachelor party. The pizza was perfect for a bunch of ravenous guys. Let's start with the best - the grandma pie was AMAZING. If you are not sure what you want, get the grandma pie. The pepperoni pizza and the sausage and onion pizza were good but not on the same level of the grandma pie. Oh yea there were salads too. Salad. Just order pizza! read more

Ordered a vodka pie They sent me a plain pie Then when I called they said it only comes in a large Why even have the option of medium there then Complete assholes behind the counter Good food But poor people Tell me that's vodka sauce people lol read more

Rino's Pizza - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Best Pizza In New Paltz. Really nice staff. Pleasant environment. Definitely Recommended. read more

Hit Rino's twice this week. My son, who works at a nearby resort, highly recommended this place and joined us for our first visit. To keep it plain and simple - they have great food and an terrific team of guys working there. During my two stops here, we ordered eggplant parmigiana dinner, Stromboli, several different slices of pizza, Italian wedding soup and cold antipasto. This metropolitan NY/NJ guy says, "All were primo." Prices are great. Good deal of traffic coming in and out tells you the locals are "digging it". Rino's is on my radar for my next trip up to the area. read more

Rino's Pizza - Italian wedding soup, cold antipasto and mushroom pizza. - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York

I ordered a margherita pizza last week, and they only put 2 small pieces of fresh mozzarella on it. Literally 2 pieces. When I called and asked about it, the person who made the pie told me "maybe it all blended together". Ok first of all, since when does a margherita have shredded mozzarella to begin with, let alone enough of it to "blend" in with the fresh mozz. Secondly, how dare you insult me by thinking that I wouldn't notice the difference? To Rino's credit, they offered me a free margherita, which I got today. Full of optimism, I brought it home and opened it up. This time: not a single piece of fresh mozzarella. Then I began to think...maybe they don't know the difference between fresh and shredded mozzarella? Or maybe their version of a margherita for some bizarre reason contains shredded processed cheese? So I look up their menu. Sure enough, the ingredients are "homemade marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil" (they spell it margarita). read more

Rino's Pizza - Notice the obvious TWO pieces of fresh mozz, amongst the sea of processed shredded cheese. - Italian Near Me - New Paltz, New York