Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Roosevelt tavern

    3.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Roosevelt tavern Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Roosevelt tavern

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Bob F.
    0
    18
    0

    6 years ago

    Has run downhill fast the last few years. Used to frequent often but haven given up now.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 2,752 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The First Post

    The First Post

    4.3
    (673 reviews)
    5.0 mi
    $$

    I will start with - we have dined here at least a half dozen times and realized i never reviewed…read more This is one of the best restaurants in the York area we have been to. They are a class act! Every staff member we have interacted with have all been professional & friendly. The restaurant has warm inviting decor & we love the bar area. Lots of great choices on the menu & wonderful daily specials. We love this restaurant so much that we hosted a baby shower may of 2026 in one of their upstairs private rooms. The event planner was great to work. She had wonderful suggestions on menu & set up. We chose a brunch buffet & added some of their appetizers & fresh fruit. We had rave reviews from all who attended on the venue, staff & food. We will continue to dine here and would highly recommend the space upstairs for private events. Ample parking - but one suggestion is make a reservation, as they are always busy

    Nice restaurant in York County with an interesting menu and a variety of seating, all of which are…read morecomfortable. Had a dish with chicken and pasta that was very nice. My wife had the fish and chips. Food was good and plentiful. Service was very good, ate with some old friends, there was no rush, they gave us plenty of space. The menu is varied, specials are not typical fare, but also do not become science projects like so many "creations" do. The food is left to speak for itself. Affordable. Two small criticisms, can be loud in certain areas. They are very accommodating in moving you. The parking lot. Walking over the bridge can be an issue with cars. Worth the trip.

    Photos
    Decor In the beautiful room upstairs (pic from baby shower may 2026)
    Decor In the beautiful room upstairs (pic from baby shower may 2026)
    Charred octopus
    Charred octopus
    Fireplace

    See all

    Fireplace
    Rockfish Public House

    Rockfish Public House

    4.3
    (266 reviews)
    0.5 mi
    $$

    found this establishment on yelp. lived up to reputation of awesome seafood. clean and pleasant…read moreatmosphere. Metered street parking. one downside is that 2 pieces of 1/4 inch toasted sliced bread that we thought were complimentary were actually $2 per plate and our waitress never mentioned that to us, so 3 plates later...

    Darwin would be displeased with you. As am I, because it's never good to have a tired teacher…read moreresearch any kind of history on her day off. You see, back in 17th century England, private houses would open their homes to the public and sell food and beer. Hence, public house. Over time, they dropped the "lic house" and just called them pubs. Because you never dropped the "lic house" makes me think that you haven't evolved like you should have. And frankly, your food is proof. In fact, it even made me nostalgic. But not in the way you might think. You see, I loved making fun food concoctions when I was a kid. My sister and I would watch this corny show called "Zoom" on Maryland public television, where the kid hosts would make recipes sent in from all over the country. We'd make homemade peanut butter cups using Jif and semisweet chocolate chips. Or weird sandwich combinations like pickles and potato chips and cheese and jelly. The seafood egg rolls weren't the worst part of my meal, but they were definitely sophomoric--as if a kid chef-in-training was asked to whip something up from Chinese food leftovers. Seafood should never taste fishy, yet these did. One bite hit me like something that had been sitting a little too long above the waterline. Not to mention, they were laying on a greasy glob of some mayonnaise accompaniment disguised as a fancy garnish you'd see on MasterChef. One word: Ick. The ahi tacos. Oh boy. My mind fills with seawater the moment I think of them because they tasted as if they had been fished right out of the ocean and then placed on my plate. They were wet. Soaked. Drenched. The gelatinous seaweed clump on each taco wasn't culinary-forward, just unappetizing. I took one bite and wished I could spit it back out, but I reluctantly swallowed it. My esophagus is now aquaphobic thanks to you. The moment the coconut jasmine rice hit my mouth, my tastebuds took the red eye to the coconut tree haven of the Maldives. Normally, this wouldn't be a bad thing, but the rice and coconut had no cohesion. It tasted like my younger self dumping a handful of shredded coconut--the sweetened kind my mom kept in the pantry for the wool on her Easter-shaped lamb cake--into a cup of microwaveable rice. The only redeeming aspect of our meal was your kind, charismatic waiter. He was lovely in every way--attentive, sweet, and helpful. He would have been an incredible host on "Zoom." If only his personality made the food taste better. For your sake, I hope you learn to evolve your kitchen's offerings beyond the amateurish trio I experienced. If not, your restaurant's bones may end up fossilized alongside every other place that couldn't adapt.

    Photos
    Bar
    Bar
    HOT LOBSTER ROLL
    HOT LOBSTER ROLL
    Strawberry 75

    See all

    Strawberry 75
    The Paddock On Market

    The Paddock On Market

    3.1
    (196 reviews)
    4.4 mi
    $$

    After receiving multiple "oh no" responses to my 5 star review from 8 months ago even as late as…read moretoday, I realized that something is up and I needed to investigate. I quickly found out that one month after my visit, the owner of this establishment was captured on video in an apparent road rage incident yelling expletives at another person and repeatedly saying "your 1/2 N word brother" as an insult. He then looked directly into the camera and said "I am a racist" when pressed about using such a derogatory word. He held a press conference to apologize afterward but it was only because he was caught and this revelation was affecting his business. As a woman of color I am deeply offended and will never patronize this restaurant again. Thank you to the yelpers that alerted me to this

    Stopped for dinner after a trying week - had to cancel our vacation the weeks before due to a…read morefamily illness among other issues. Suffice it to say I wanted to have one great meal with hubs to close out our nay-cation. I haven't been to the Paddock for decades. This was a great place for an excellent seafood dinner. Best jumbo lump crab cakes - no filler here. The filet was butter soft - extremely delicious. The shrimp were large and juicy. And the scallops were great. Our waitress Connie was great. In fact all of the servers were - they took empty dishes / glasses when they were walking by. The price is what I'd expect for fresh seafood and delicious steaks. My filet / crab cake was a special that came with 2 sides for $58 - was worth every penny! I also had a bloody mart which was very good as well! Will bring hubs back again when we are in town next time.

    Photos
    New Fireplace
    New Fireplace
    The Paddock On Market
    Crab cakes were very good.

    See all

    Crab cakes were very good.

    Roosevelt tavern - newamerican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...