Stopped in here the other day after someone told me it was a lot better than it used to be. They were right. The tall gentleman that seems to be running the place from behind the bar is doing a great job. Food and service was good. They have GF drinks and food. Place is a little dated, but it was clean. Will stop back for sure. read more

Wings, cheese fries, Maryland crab soup, and of course adult beverages. All delicious!!!! We sat at the bar. The owner was who waited on us (Noland). He was a super nice and professional guy. Easy to talk to. The place has a "hidden gem" vibe. I wish more people knew about this place. The food is delicious! Service was super fast, and food quality was high. I will return! Thanks Noland! read more

Arrived ~6:30pm on a Saturday (9/27/25.) Greeted warmly by Hostess and seated immediately. The atmosphere seems friendly, quiet and the air smells delicious. They have a three page menu full of delicious-sounding foods, plus a separate page of weekend specials. Had to wait 10 minutes before our server arrived at the table. But he was friendly, professional and energetic once he came over. Salads were good, though I would've loved a little onion in mine. Balsamic dressing was delicious. It was a 25 minute wait from ordering until our food arrived, but I'd say it was worth the wait. My salmon was moist and deliciously seasoned the grille sauce that came with it was scrumptious. I used it to dip my thick sweet potato fries in! Yum! My tastebuds are still enjoying the flavors from my meal! My husband loved the chicken parmigiana and the raspberry iced tea. He thought the huge cheesecake for dessert was delicious! We will return for more yummy food! read more

See all

My family stopped here randomly on our way home from a vacation in Virginia on our way home to Pennsylvania. It was early on Friday afternoon. The manager could not have been nicer (maybe Neal, Nelson ... something that starts with an N ... I apologize for forgetting). He welcomed us to relax on the outdoor patio with our Golden Retriever as well as the rest of the humans. We ordered burgers, sandwiches, fries and coffee for all seven of us. The food was really delicious and the service was excellent. I wish this place was in my home town because it would definitely become my regular haunt. If you're in the area or traveling past, definitely stop. Well worth it. read more

I have lived in the area my entire life and this is the first time I visited Cassell's. I've heard mixed reviews in the past, but like everything else, I thought I'd give it a try. I ordered a Cobb salad with chicken. When it arrived it looked decent; however, when I dug under the egg, tomato, bacon, avocado, etc. to get to the lettuce, I was extremely disappointed. The lettuce was brown and wilted and looked like it had been sitting around for quite some time. Considering it cost $16.99, I expected a better quality salad. I wish I had taken a photo to post, but I wasn't thinking about it at the time. The server seemed a bit rushed - but it was not busy at all. The seating area was a basic bar/grill area with tables and booths surrounding the bar. It was comfortable, but the food was lacking. If I do choose to return, I will try something different. If I have a better experience next time around, I will change my opinion. However at this point I have to say that I was not impressed. read more

Good food at a great price! Staff members were attentive and genuine. Potato soup was amazing! We will definitely be back. read more

We've been here a couple of times now first chance I had to review! The still conform to COVID-19 regulations and indoor seating is limited we chose the deck because we were visiting on a beautiful day! We decided on Cassell's while we were out on a road trip and it was a great spot on the way to another destination. My wife loves their Potato soup and Decided on an order of Chicken Fingers while I Chose a favorite Beef Brisket Ruben with an order of Sweet Potato Fries! Cassell's has the best sweet potato fries around! We'll be back again and I'll fill you in on a Dinner Menu! read more

Cassell's Grille - Beef Brisket Ruben with Sweet Potato Fries! - New American Near Me - Mount Holly Springs, Pennsylvania

Cassell's is a quiet getaway for a nice meal, fair prices, diverse selection and amazingly gracious hosts! We enjoyed another good dinner last night, with no waiting. Their Guinness draft is correctly poured and served! Our server, Savannah, did a great job and thought ahead on any needs. Already looking forward to the next visit. But don't forget the homemade chips, like I did! read more

Home town vibe where the owner greets you at the door and makes sure you feel welcome and have a table. Patio seating is available ... though I've never sat outside. Great drinks ... great food ... great specials ... great service. Gotta order the cheese fries with bacon ... every time! The horseradish dip makes the app special. If you are in Mount Holly - hit them up! read more

My family was coming to town during a busy weekend in Carlisle and we decided for give Cassell's a try and we weren't disappointed! Being gluten free they accommodated two of our parties needs. My father (who is from out of town) still brings up how he had the best crab cakes of his life at Cassell's. The staff and servers couldn't be nicer and we loved the old school feeling. We can't wait to go back and try more of the menu! read more

Food is always good and fresh. The chef makes original specials, which are always worth a try. Classics are fish sandwiches, burgers, and homemade chips with dipping sauce. Staff is friendly, and service is prompt. Enjoy! read more

See all

Excellent scallops, great salads and much more. Nice atmosphere and friendly staff. I wish they had better hours. I would recommend this place read more

Cassell's was a great stop in while we were camping in the area. The service was great, the food was good, and we enjoyed watching the Olympics while we soaked in the AC! read more

Coldest beer and friendliest service! Love the menu and deck. Best linguini with clams I ever had in my life

Great local spot with friendly welcoming hosts/owners! I want to drink the horseradish sauce it's so good! We will be back to try more of the yummy things on the menu. read more

Cassell's Grille - New American Near Me - Mount Holly Springs, Pennsylvania

Cassell's has the friendly vibe of a neighborhood pub. The staff are pleasant and efficient. The food is terrific. The chef does an excellent job on every dish she prepares. The quality, quantity and value of the food are the best in our area. read more

Fantastic prime rib tonight, great service and atmosphere. Highly recommend stopping here.

The owners treat customers like they are doing us a favor when they service us. Prices keep going higher. Not returning.

Standard food at an elevated price. Typical dining area and local grille food. Service sometimes is lacking. Average dining experience.

Awesome service friendly food was excellent top notch every time consistently, have been here three times

Excellent!! Love their home made chips. The burgers are good and also the Reubens. Owner very friendly and always asks how everything is. Servers great and accommodating. We go back quite often. On the weekend, you should make a reservation. It gets you in faster. Very busy restaurant. read more

We stumbled into Cassell's Grille by fate. And I need to say incredible!!! We cannot wait to come back to try the food ( which look so good! ). Super friendly and inviting atmosphere! read more

See all

Whoever the cook is... tell them to find another calling. Only good for a beer. First time here was for a quick drink w/my father, didn't seem bad; however, we had not had anything from the food menu... that's where things go bad. Stopped by a few months later with family for dinner. Our children were served soured milk, and the staff looked surprised! How does one not open up a milk jug and not smell the milk, or have a 'good by' date to check things with? Next time to arrive was from the Daily Special menu. There was a bisque ordered that had a baked cheese topping. How the cook did not realize that this was putrid, smelly, old and rotting cheese, I have no idea. Not even one of the staff members questioned it! My sandwich said it comes with a pickle... ... ... there were two, TWO, slices of a pickle for a burger! Who the heck does that? All the vegetables and fruit is overpriced and comes front a can. The server was joyful to mention that the children could have cinnamon on their applesauce, yet failed to bring out any. Whoever the cook is... tell them to find another calling. If you know of a health and good inspector in need of a gig, turn them to Cassell's. Again, if you're only looking to have a beer, this is a good place. read more

This place is probably a great place to hang out, play darts and eat ok food. Not great, but probably more in line with a Denny's as far as the quality of the food. read more

Own is an ass old man with glass. So rude! Both me and my friend are latino. Saying shit under his breath about us. Guess what we can hear you. We get shots so awful bottom shelf vodka. Are used to be a bartender I know what the shot is supposed to taste like and have it re-Deculus. Totally wrong still paid had to pay read more

Dry rub wings and all American burger are fantastic. Great French onion soup. It's really nice sitting outside.

The food and drinks are decent, but way overpriced. My friend and I stopped for drinks one night. We are both in our twenties and were looking to have a fun time. The place was empty by ten o'clock. The bartender was sweeping up as we were sitting at the bar. We ordered two appetizers, which were about eight/nine dollars each. More what I would expect to pay for my meal. AND I have had a meal there before. I felt kind of ripped off when it came time for the check. Don't get me wrong, the food is good. Just not good enough for their prices. read more

I was part of a large group that went to Cassels on Sunday afternoon . as stated earlier no we didn't call ahead it was a last minute deal but when we arrived there were only two tables with customers and a few people at the bar. We were greeted by a manager who was upset we didn't call ahead and had a poor attitude. The waitress was rude and it was clear she was unhappy about serving us. We did consider leaving but she said they called in more help. Service-poor, food was overpriced and fair . We were not concerned about the amount of time it took for the food as we knew we had a group but not once did our waitress ask if we needed drink refills and everyone at my end of the table had empty glasses. One man finally asked for a refill and she took his glass and no one else's We will not being going back. read more

This is a great place to go for dinner and drinks. Locally owned and great bartender Nolan very knowledgeable on the libations he serves. 14 beers on tap! They have great weekly specials and the regular menu is just as great. Anything from the wings to Prime Rib is great. My personal favorite is the Scrod, a very nice mild fish with a butter cream sauce. The Salmon Spoons they served on New Years Eve were outstanding. Definitely a favorite restaurant for us! read more

Here's the story with the varying quality of customer service and wait times for food: this place is a husband and wife team. The wife cooks/runs the entire kitchen, the husband runs everything else. As in life, when one isn't happy in a team, the other isn't happy and the team suffers. Just like the reality TV shows about failing restaurants with high-strung owners, Central PA has it's very own! It's just not famous... Food quality: very good (PS you get your Boom-boom sauce from Sheetz, don't lie), quantity was decent, however...for the price, they just don't match the quality. Everything was good. The server was very friendly. The husband (co-owner) was upfront about the kitchen being backed up, and our server apologized for the "long wait" even though our wait time wasn't out of the norm for a crowded restaurant. Good eats, high price. Come for the food, stay for the drama! read more

Four of us stopped for lunch there yesterday and everything was awesome. We only got sandwiches but they were incredible. Mine was so good I boxed up half just so I could enjoy it again later. Service was also top notch and very friendly but in fairness they weren't very busy when we were there. read more

Barry Cassell has managed several restaurants and done it well. His food never disappoints. His customer service is superior. An example - we reserved for Thanksgiving buffet & my 94 year old mother cancelled at the last minute because she was not feeling well. I asked to 'buy' a doggie bag and they went above and beyond to make sure she and I were happy. I always feel like an honored customer here. And everything I have ever ordered has been great. read more

Great food, nice people, good service and the best Mojito I have ever had! Family owned. We are not from this area but we are here a lot in the summer and we always come here. Their chips, salmon and wings are the best. Enjoy read more

Cassell's Grille - Best mojito in the world! Noland is the man! - New American Near Me - Mount Holly Springs, Pennsylvania

Won't serve you if your not wearing sleeves..was asked to change shirts or leave...you in mt holly springs for shit sake...so bikers,,,, got on down town to the other bars. This place don't need our money... read more

One of the worst experiences I've had with service. I'm assuming it was the owners who served us and right off the bat you could tell they did not want us there. They made snide comments the entire time we were there and then when we decided to get our check their computer system went down. We spent 20 minutes waiting for them to tell us they couldn't process the check through credit and then the man told us we had to go to the sheetz up the road to use the ATM. Never in my life have I had such poor customer service. Both the man and woman were rude and disrespectful. Will never go back. read more

Stopped in during a Sunday afternoon drive. My wife had peel and eat shrimp and fries. I had French Onion Soup and a Cobb salad. Let me say the soup was/is the best I have ever had. The shrimps and the salad were fine too, but the soup is what stood out for us. The place is very nice and the service is also good. A very good selection of beers on tap. Needless to say, we will be back read more

Sister and her baby were treated poorly last night by manager. Kicked cup across floor to them instead of picking it up. Very rude. Will not be returning read more

Cassell's Grille - New American Near Me - Mount Holly Springs, Pennsylvania

I heard their burger was good so I should have went with that as instead I found myself regretting my order. The California cob salad sounded like a great addition but their avocado topping was simply a scoop of guacamole (not really what I want on a cobb and not making for good leftovers). The wings do not compare to another area favorite that I will not name. Crab cake was meh but within the area I have had way better. Favorite part was my onion string straws. Note this was a to go order so might have just had different experience based on that. read more

We sat at the bar in this cozy, Cheers-like atmosphere of an establishment. Delicious hamburger, but you must try the House Chips! Other coup de gras was the chocolate martini made by Nolan. I have never liked chocolate Martinis, but not only did I like this, I will go back and back and back again. It was like dessert! It's my last night in town, and I think I will have to revisit before I leave. read more

We had a bad experience the moment we walked in the door, and opted not to stay for dinner so we can't comment on the food. The owner greeted us at the door, about 5:30 on a Saturday evening. The room was nearly empty and he offered "pick a table." So my wife pointed to a booth and he said, 'that's reserved. You can sit here or here,' pointing to two tables that looked like they'd been picked up at a yard sale. We have no explanation for the attitude that he projected, but we felt like he was saying 'here's your seats, take it or leave it.' So after a few minutes' deliberation we left. The owner didn't notice as he was watching TV when we walked by him on the way out. We followed up with a phone call right back to the restaurant explaining why we had left and how we felt insulted by the treatment. There was no apology although it was explained to us that a large party was coming any minute to claim all the booths. Which meant that not only were we seated at the yard sale tables but were about to be surrounded by a private party without fair warning or apology. Nice. And instead of offering an apology for the unwarranted attitude, the owner was condescending on the phone. Maybe you have to be a regular customer or a local to get good service there. Fortunately we found a Perkins a few miles south and had a great dining experience there. read more