Visiting from Texas. Our second time here. We were there on a Thursday for "Chicken Night" with a party of 8! Food was great! Service was terrific as well! Great value and like that they allow BYOB for a reasonable cost. Great family atmosphere! read more

Ok.. Wonderful service but I was just shocked when the large chicken veggie soup I ordered to go came with very little chicken and veggie. I rarely complain but in these times I want my money's worth. I called and got a credit , which was wonderful but I hope by calling this out , things will be better for the next customer !The food was great but they need to work on the portions that's all. read more

Solid slice. Bunch of different speciality slices, all looks good, I'm a regular slice guy and it was good. Plenty of seating, dining area for bigger meals with more guests. Service was good and place looks clean. read more

Rosemarie Pizza - Rosemaries Farmingdale, NY - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

When ordering takeout and if the cook didn't cook right it should not be given to the consumer burnt clams no lemon $18. Plus I ordered fettuccine Alfredo that was dry. read more

Very disappointed with Rosemarie's recent quality of pizza. Have been eating their pizza for years and it was never this bad. I called the restaurant to tell them that their slices were too thin and they told me to call next time and ask them to make the crust a little thicker, and I said, it's not the crust, it's the whole pie. Their pizza is paper thin. The pizza barely covered the box it came in. So many other better choices in Farmingdale. read more

Rosemarie Pizza - Paper thin slice - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

In addition to fettuccine Alfredo, which was on the dry side and baked claims for $18.00, with no lemon, ordered both as take out on August 24 on my way home from work. Mostly small claims and the few larger ones were burnt and tasted burnt. Price came to 45.00 which included a small bottle of soda. Why do businesses think it's OK to give food that is not cooked properly they should be the ones that have to eat the poor quality not the consumer. Those baked clams should've been redone. And the fettuccine Alfredo should've had more Alfredo sauce. read more

I been here a few times, the place itself self looks clean and well lit, the service was good and friendly, and the food today wasn't as good as am used to having there, I had the Veal Parmigiana and my mom had the Shrimp Scampi, they were both ok, but we thought that the sauce in both dishes was to acid. Like I said, not my first time there, but I thought that the food wasn't as good as they usually make it. read more

See all

Food is pretty good!!! Great pizza!!! Got a catering from here and it was good but could have been better seasoned and not crammed so tightly in the pans read more

I used to go here all the times years ago. I went here recently and didn't think it was as good as it used to be. I got the vodka slice and some regular slices. Definitely wasn't how I remembered. read more

Rosemarie Pizza - the tvs in the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

Sad to say our all time Farmingdale Long Island favorite pizza joint Rosemarie's, seems to have hit a rut. We are up on the Island for a few weeks and we heard their pizza wasn't stellar any longer. We had to see for ourselves and we did unfortunately. I hate leaving anyone a two star review let alone my ole fav, but i believe it's warranted on their pizza alone in a very competitive market with the countries best pizza on almost each street corner. Their sauce surely looked and tasted like Tomato purée right out of the can. Added some pepper and garlic and it got better but... We did love the sliced Italian sausage on that pie. Too many places, IMHO, use ground sausage. Sliced length wise and thick is what we love and got tonight. Rosemaries dough preformed it's basic foundational function but that is all. Crust wasn't crisp, had no leopard spotting and was just plain boring. I have seen Rosemaries Pizza Rise to multi year glory over that past 10-15 years and now based on tonight's dinner and local reports a drastic fall. I will try and find time to grab another pie before I leave to be fair but for now I can't justify more than a 2. It's not uncommon to lose control of quality and taste in the pizza biz from time to time. I hope they will be back to their former pizza glory!!! read more

See all

We celebrated my niece/Goddaughters Baptism here on June 22, 2025. The food was great. Everything we had was excellent. The staff was very attentive to us. We had Sophia as our server/bartender, and she was wonderful. The restaurant itself was very clean as well. I am giving 3 stars for the following reason: On one of the hottest days of the year, their A/C wasn't working. The thermostat in the restaurant was reading 85 degrees at one point and that was the temp inside the place. Imagine being served hot and heavy Italian food and eating it at that temperature. It's not easy and we ended up taking a lot of our food home. By the time we left, our faces were flushed, and we were so hot from sitting there in the heat. Even the carafes of ice water on the tables melted and the water was room temperature from the heat. If the restaurant reads this, you guys need better A/C. You can't expect people to sit and eat your food (heavy, cheesy Italian food at that) in that heat. If you're in the area and want to eat here, order the food to go. read more

This place used to be much better. I think the ownership changed. I've tried a number of things recently but lately I've gotten better food at other local Italian places. read more

Good food Hefty portions Great service We went there on a recommendation from my brother-in-law. We were not disappointed. read more

Awesome, delicious Italian food !!!! A must try for the whole family . Very reasonable prices and great atmosphere !! !

Went to dinner with a party of 7 adults and 2 kids We were the only ones dining on our side of the restaurant. We placed our order relatively quickly and waited over an hour for our food. We had 2 toddlers with us and asked for the kids food to come out first. The waitress told us multiple times it would be out in a minute and they had a large party on the other side. Long story short - our meals came out one at a time with a few mins in between each. The kids food came out LAST and they got the wrong pasta. When we told the waitress she was visually annoyed rolling her eyes. We were there for 2 hours without even getting dessert. The food was decent but I would never go back due to the poor service. read more

I went in to get a quick dinner and found out Thursday is chicken night. 15.95 your choice of chicken any style, a hefty salad, bread and a dessert of cheesecake or mini cannoli. Their homemade house dressing was on the money and the chicken with artichokes, mozzarella, tomato and wine sauce was excellent. Will have to go back for seafood or pasta nights! read more

I work at the Car Wash Washville around the corner . I went there and asked Manny to make me a special pizza instead of tomato sauce with fried Diablo sauce and sausage with mozzarella and it was the best pizza I have ever had. I'm not exaggerating thank you Manny. read more

Here for an afternoon occasion. Ambiance in private room was nice very comfortable. Wait staff service was very good. Food was good I didn't see any of the problems other reviewers mentioned. Chicken parm, chicken Marsala, penne ala vodka and a delicious Caesar salad. There was also vegetarian option. I would go back the pizza looked enticing on the way in. read more

It's sad that this restaurant's reviews are lowered because of reviews dated 3-5 years ago. Those reviews are not relevant to today's Rosemarie's! There is no "disappointment" here. The Pizza side is amazing, the restaurant side is amazing. The party rooms are amazing. The catering is my latest review since we just had a retirement party yesterday. Yelp should have a shelf life on older reviews. So... Our retirement party for one of our employees at our Massapequa Highway Department was for 60 people. For other employees that had retirement parties, I was not in charge of the food. This time I was, and I knew that I wanted restaurant food. I've been to Rosemarie's many times and went there to discuss catering. Gianna and I sat down at a quiet table in the middle room and looked over what I had picked out. She had her paperwork with her and amazing knowledge of the catering business. After two sentences, I knew that I should sit back and just listen. She really did know what I needed after just a few questions that I answered. If this was just about price, then I would say they gave me the greatest deal imaginable. It was about the food, the amount of food, the on time delivery. Everything that I asked, she said, "we supply that". My plan was to go shopping for other things like water, soda, a six-foot hero to add to the hot food, and much more. Gianna said, we have all that. On the day of the party, one week later, tons of food came in all by the recommendations of Gianna and also by the generosity of her boss. Yes, I got a fantastic deal. My only job was to buy ice. The party was a blast, the food was more than ample, Gianna's suggestions were right on target, so, I really did nothing, it was all Rosemarie's! Thank you, Thank you! There is no other place that I will go to for catering and no other place I would recommend except for Rosemarie's Restaurant. 10 Stars! read more

Used to go here often over ten years ago. Returned to check it out again, and they must have renovated in the intervening years. The place is very tastefully decorated and it would be cool to dine-in here one day. Tale of the tape: Garlic Knots Medium sized, with a heavy, doughy chew. Unfortunately there is practically no garlic flavor present, barely even from the top where a few granules of garlic are located. Tastes like what it's made from - a twisted knot of pizza dough. Grandma alla Vodka Crust is thick, but has a crunch when heated properly, with a medium chew. The sauce, unfortunately, doesn't cover the entire surface of the slice, as there is no sauce under the cheese. The taste is merely creamy, with virtually no additional flavor. Disappointing. read more

Rosemarie Pizza - Grandma alla Vodka slice: rather disappointing. Sauce is on top of the cheese, and what sauce there is isn't flavorful, only creamy. - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

How else am I supposed to eat this...OPEN SESAME! Rosemarie doesn't just offer sesame seeds on the edge of their crust, they offer on the entire pizza! We're talking game changer for sesame seed fans this is how you do sesame pizza but always remember you gotta ask for it extra well done! read more

Rosemarie Pizza - Sesame seed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

So quick back story.... My current pizza shop changed ownership and we were looking for a new place. So we gave it a shot.... We ordered a chicken dish and a slice of pizza. Pizza was ok, but the chicken dish how do I start the sauce tasted like straight oil it was supposed to be white wine but for some reason it was almost red. the chicken was very chewy and tasted like it's been sitting around for weeks.I did call and they offered me my money back or something else to eat but I declined. They were very nice and apologetic.. So I will continue on my journey for a new place read more

Just not good. Grilled chicken was stale, chicken parm hero was poorly made, sauce is meh. It has fallen last on my list of local pizza places. read more

Didn't know what to expect. At first we thought it was a pizza joint, but it's is also a real Italian restaurant. Prices are moderate, food was very good (baked clams a bit fishy, but not terrible). The service could not have better read more

Absolutely distusting behavior. Tried to place an order 5 times on Christmas Eve. Girl gigling and placing me on hold, Called 5 x the same thing. The 4th time they told me they had an order put in for the wrong food. Then asked for a manager and again same thing. Manager wouldnt get on the phone We order from there all the time but the behavior of the employees on Christmas Eve was horrible. WE will never order from them again for anything. I would think twice if you actually need to depend on the food being done or correct. read more

Omgggg so I went to Rosemaries again tonight. Ordered a ham calzone. Watched a young girl answer the phone ring up people at the register. Then grab a calzone with her bare hands. Slice it open ( full hand of jewelry) reach into a container for ham. Then slice open my calzone and literally stuffed it with her fully bare ungloved hands. Are we kidding??? Then I have the audacity to bring all of this to her attention??? How dare I??? Not even an apology!!! Simply asked someone to make me another calzone. If this is what goes on in plain sight. God only knows wtf if happening behind closed doors. Hmm wonder who got my first calzone ? You know this place didn't throw it out! read more

Ordered a delivery one large pie and one personal pie with meatballs. Asked for the personal pie to be well done so I would not inconvenience the rest of the family. Both pizzas came and the personal pizza is as doughy as possible. I feel like this was a joke!!!! I called and they left me on hold for (5) minutes so I just hung up. This is ridiculous !!!! We used to order from here all the time. The new owners need to get their sh** together. read more

We used to order from here a lot and the portions were always perfect, recently we noticed the chicken Francese has very thin sliced chicken as opposed to what we were used to. Not too thrilled. read more

Picked up a chicken, Parm, hero and chicken dish with tomato onions. It said they were supposed to be much at all. There's nothing and in the chicken Parm hero there was dog hair called back to let them know, and they offered me only a credit not a refund definitely will not be coming here in the future ever waste of $50 read more

Rosemarie Pizza - Dog hair - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

I cannot express my deep appreciation for Sean, Lenny and their team enough but I will try. First their food is splendid. Sauce is the essence of any Italian eatery and all of theirs are delicious. The food is beautifully prepared and presented. The restaurant itself is an elegant gem in a neighborhood shopping center - white table cloths in one room and casual pizzeria style dining in another. I grew up in Farmingale and moved away, but when needing a place to host my mother's 90th birthday, Sean was so easy to work with though I was time zones away. Flexible, accommodating and prompt to make me confident my party would be flawless. Circumstances happened and we had to "postpone" the party the morning of due to mom's health. I was treated with care and respect though I know especially in these times, when you've prepared for a large group, it is not easy to just say, "No problem." but that's what Sean did. I am so thankful. We will have that party when mom is better and we'll have it for sure at Rosemaries. read more

Always a good experience. The waitresses are super friendly and helpful. Food is great. Ambiance is comfortable. Will be back

Very disappointed. Chicken cutlet parm hero was so dry ..pieces of dried up cutlet thrown on a hero. And it was expensive..would have been worth it if it was good. read more

returned to farmingdale after a few years away. always held this place in the highest esteem ..... no longer .. new management , terrible Sicilian pie.. no hint of oil in the pan ...... flat terrible dough.... never going back.....so sad read more

Our family enjoyed yet another amazing meal from Rosemaries! My meatball Parm hero was moist, saucy, cheesy and had an abundance of their terrific meatballs! My hubby had their cheese raviolis and they too were so delicious! Our daughter enjoyed a side of meatballs because she prefers to make herself Angel hair pasta with butter at home. The staff-members answering the phones are always kind and patient while I ask for special attention to my order like "please don't burn the bread on my meatball Parm hero, or plz make sure the cheese topping is melted" and if they hang up and say ugh about me then oh well. I never hear annoyance in their voices when they're helping me. We have met friends in their dining room several times for an early weekday dinner and it's quite lovely with soft lighting and classic white tablecloths. The servers treated us so well and once again- the food was fresh and hot and delicious! I don't know why people want to do all the work at home when for $18-20 per person you can have a great Italian meal close to home! Thank you! -Donna & Rob H. read more

Delivery for 2 pies took almost 2 hours and it was burnt. Very disappointed because the First time we ordered a month ago it was very good. read more

we had such a wonderful experience! Sophia, our waitress, was so amazing! She was such a wonderful waitress and so sweet and helpful! The food was delicious, but what made the experience that much more enjoyable was our amazing waitress Sophia! Highly recommend and definitely ask for her, if she is available!!! The chicken rosemary dish was delicious!!! Highly recommend! read more

2 Stars for sentimentality, only Heard this place had changed hands - they answer the phone as "RoseMARY's - order to take out - Last time: been customers since the 70's- sadly, not any longer. Orders are wrong, prices are crazy and food, not-so-great. Last visit: Ordered an eggplant parm hero, sauce on the side, pie and large caesar salad- pie was not so good, hero had about 3 slices of eggplant, was cold inside with burnt bread, salad was nothing more than some romaine lettuce and half a dozen croutons. AND, we were told 15 minutes- my husband waited another half-hour after getting there!!! The cost was $46+!!!!!!! Could have gotten the same order with a coupon @ Pizza Cove for $23. Never again....bye forever to RoseMARY's. read more

I had a party here last weekend it was amazing...Lenny was amazing at helping us planning it the two girls working the room were amazing as well. We will definitely be coming back for many more family dinners read more

Stopped in for dinner the other night and I have to say the place looks clean and the food was really great. The waiter Lenny could not have been better, he was great and really took care of all the tables. They have updated the dinning room and made more space for party's. The new management really knows what they are doing. Just wish they had some fresh fish dishes. read more

Serviceable pizza, nothing special. My parents got half meatball half sausage, and they said the crust was too soft door their liking and the topping placement was entirely uneven (some slices had nothing, other slices had "mounds," says my father). They were fine with it, but said they'll try somewhere else next time. I got the gluten-free personal pizza. Appropriate pricing for what you get, but the crust was very thin and crispy (if you like that sort of thing, which I don't--I probably would've liked the regular pizza crust my parents got if I could eat it). But the big thing about my crust was that it simply tasted stale/tough, even after reheating it in the microwave. They do practice plenty of appropriate COVID precautions, which is what gets them 3 instead of 2 stars in this review. read more