An incredible selection of cupcakes. And a prompt response to my request for making and delivering…read morecustom options. Highly recommend it!

Absolutely amazing cake and cupcakes!! Was able to put in an…read moreorder just a week ahead of time for 2 dozen vegan cupcakes and a small personalized smash cake. Everything was beautiful and tasted awesome, the non vegans were blown away. Will be coming back for all future orders.

Tinker's cakes are amazing! The owner is an awesome individual. Reputable business and…read moreconsistently good.

Absolutely beautiful wedding cake for my daughter and there were only a few pieces left!!…read moreOutstanding - highly recommend!

**Update: I received a very heartfelt message from the owner explaining their tough situation due…read moreto Covid, and asking that I please give them a chance to make this right..... in the end, all we want is to be heard and appreciated if we are choosing to spend our money and support a business- and after this message I felt both of those things. So, they may not have the rum cake I ordered, and they may be having some issues with their technology... but it seems like they have really delicious baked goods (according to other reviews), and they are working to solve the other problem. So, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt.** I wish I had pictures to prove this..... but here is my experience. I placed an order for their rum cake ($45 for a Bundt cake). I did this through their website and it said it would be available to pick up at 11:50 a.m. I paid using their Squarespace website. I got a confirmation email, and was so excited because this is what my hubby wanted for his bday. I was just about to leave to pick it up at 1:15pm, when I got a call from the bakery saying "we don't know what your ordered, but you need to cancel the payment because we don't use our website. We only take orders over the phone or in person." What???? If you don't use it, why is it active? Turn it the eff off. It's very simple to do- I know bc I have used several Squarespace websites. This should be the end of my rant- but wait! It gets so much better! I proceeded to give them my order over the phone.... They told it would be ready in 30 minutes. I should have asked myself how they would bake a cake in 30 minutes- but, I'm a glutton for punishment.... And instead drove 30 minutes from my house to go get the desired rum cake. When I got there to pick it up- it was a 9" two layer cake with frosting. That is not a rum cake, nor is it what is pictured on their website! When I said, that isn't what I ordered- the response was "well, this is our rum cake". I left without the cake. And, now I have to contact my credit card company to dispute a charge that they claim they won't receive. Also- in case you're looking for quality, freshly made cakes..... they have 5 gallon buckets in their cooler at the front with long stem roses in them..... the buckets have labels on them that say "Sam's vanilla whipped icing". What a joke!

Ok here's my updated review after we ate it. It was DELICIOUS! So moist and not too sweet. I truly…read moreloved the cake but I am still upset at the quality of my "custom" experience and lack there of on my cake. I was charged too much (more than regular off the shelf cake) and was given a less than customized product. I didn't appreciate her saying that the cake I chose from the Yelp picture was what they "used to do" but the picture was from 3 months ago. I have made future customers from everyone I had try it but I hope they don't receive a bad experience because I truly believe in this company and their product.

thank you to all the previous reviews that allowed me to select Selena's. Terrie responded quickly…read moreto my questions and inquiry about their availability. I live in Ohio but was traveling to Tennessee for my son's graduation. i needed two cakes to celebrate his graduation from medical school and another member's 21st birthday the same time. I didn't give much notice to ask for these special occasion cakes. Both cakes exceeded my expectations in both creativity in the few details I gave as well as the taste of the cakes. We did one cake in snickerdoodle and the other funfetti. The buttercream icing was so delicious. They even delivered the cakes to my son in Lexington, Ky. I highly recommend. And, if I am ever in the area again, I will be ordering from Selena's. Thanks Terrie.

So friendly! And she was able to help me last minute which I couldn't believe for a close friend's…read morebirthday. To say they are incredibly savory & to die for is an UNDERSTATEMENT!!! AND they delivered! I'll never go anywhere else!

Love the witchy vibe. Peanut butter banana pudding was amazing. Several fun cakes, puddings and…read morecookies. Friendly staff

Solid bakery on the corner of Catfish Alley and Main Street. They make cakes but what is in the…read morecase is predominantly cupcakes, and cookies. The cupcakes were presented well. Had a good frosting ratio and had fun flavors like pistachio and oatmeal cream cookie. They seem to have weekly rotating flavors maybe even daily. We got the oatmeal cream cookie and it was crazy yummy I was very impressed with the cookies. They were a good size. The price point was nice. You don't get gouged for a cookie here. I bought the Nutella, which seems to be a chocolate hazelnut cookie with Nutella filled in the middle. Wow wow it was delicious. I also got pistachio cookies and those were amazing. That's so good that I went back and bought six to bring home. The guy that help me select cookies was very helpful in describing which flavors he thought I would like, and he was spot on. Thank you whom ever you were. Very helpful! As far as ambience has a spooky theme, which is fun. I liked the bakery. I would definitely come back. I would definitely recommend it.

Carol Codell works from home as an amazing baker-I can honestly say I've never had cake that I've…read moreloved so much that I continually talk about-all the time. All my friends that have tried it feel the same way! She bakes cakes, cupcakes, pastries and all sweet treats for any occasion. We had a cake of hers tonight for my brothers birthday-we had the vanilla with chocolate frosting. I've had many of her cakes and I honestly can't choose a favorite! HIGHLY RECOMMEND

For my friend's birthday I ordered six cupcakes . Birthday cake, chocolate, carrot cake, key lime…read morepie cupcake , chocolate peanut butter cup cake , and a traditional yellow cake cupcake with chocolate frosting . I didn't have time to go to the bakery itself so I ordered on door dash and had them delivered . I've never had them before but I'll have them again. All of the cupcakes were so good !No one had a complaint about them . In terms of pricing I think it was fairly priced and the quality is definitely there .

In the area and spotted this cute little bake shop. Got treats for one of my offices and everyone…read moreenjoyed them. The young lady who worked there was helpful and pleasant. They had various options and flavors or cookies, cupcakes and treats. You can also order cakes for whatever event you are having. They do need notice on cake orders. I'll definitely be back.

Had such an amazing time at this place doing the cake decorating class. Ashley was so kind and…read morehelpful and the cake was so good. It sits on a beautiful vineyard which sells delicious food and wine. You can bring blankets and chairs and look over the rolling hills.

Took a cake decorating class and could not have had a better time. The venue was amazing, with…read moresmaller plates to have while you enjoy the views of the farm. Large selection of wine and other low ABV drinks. All of the workers are very friendly, especially Ashley. She led a great and comfortable class, and everyone who attended seemed very happy to be there. Great for dates, mothers day, nights out with friends. Great experience, food was tasty, do not have many bad things to say.