Just as good as the first time. We had to spot here on our way back from ME. It is still the best lobster roll we ever ate. And you can't say no to the lobster bisque as well. Always on our list when we are in the area. It is worth the side trip!!! read more

Rye Harbor Lobster Pound - Hot Lobster Roll - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

Adorable little shack with the freshest lobster!! I try a lot of lobster rolls( over 30 places all over Maine, NH and MA) .. this is in my top 10!! If you are coming you must also get the fluffy clam chowder, it's creamy and delicious. You can order at the shack and then there is panic tables and bathrooms if you walk a little towards the water. read more

Rye Harbor Lobster Pound - Lobster roll and fully Clam Chowder - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

Still GREAT seafood! We had lobsters, steamers and clam chowder. All were the pinnacle of freshness and flavor. You can taste the Atlantic Ocean in each and every bite. Staff are super friendly, efficient and competent. This meal was literally the best seafood meal I've had--ever! Thank you Rye Harbor Lobster Pound for a great seafood experience. read more

See all

Lobster bisque. Eat all the bisque. Actually, no then if you do there is nothing left for me. This is the best, creamiest, fluffiest and decadent chowder I have had in my entire life. I have also dipped my steamers in the bisque in lieu of butter. Do it, try it. It's amazing. I prefer the lobster bisque over the fluffy chowder. The flavor profile if you have both the chowder and bisque together for me, the stand out is the lobster bisque. Great lobster and steamer prices. They oblige when I ask for specific lobsters, and larger size steamers. read more

Rye Harbor Lobster Pound - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

The best lobster roll and lobster bisque ever. Better than anything in Maine. Could easily eat this everyday. read more

Rye Harbor Lobster Pound - Lobster bisque - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

See all

Went there with my daughter this past LaborDay weekend. It was better than advertised as the lobster bisque was better than anything I've ever had, stuffed with real lobster...amazing...best on the north coast Portsmouth!!! read more

We stopped by for the third time during our vacation -- that's how much we love this shack! The lobster bisque, lobster roll, and their trademark Fluffy Chowder™ are all incredible. This place stands out -- the chowder and bisque are truly unique, unlike anything we've had elsewhere. Everything is loaded with chunky, fresh seafood and packed with flavor. Totally mind-blowing every time! read more

Yeah wtf. Stood in line first . There was like 10 people after me. One by one they got their food. Surely they order the same thing. The kid had the nerve to ask for me after waiting a long time but said I kept disappearing on him. I stood there and he walked past by me several times, wtf. Yet I tipped. I never would tip on takeout. It's their damn job to make the food. I already paid a lot for the food. Why would I tip? After this I'm done going to this place. What have they never seen an Asian person before? So rigging rude. There is definitely way better place than this place and better service. I stood outside because there is no lobby to stand inside. Can on fit like 2-3 people before the register. I should get my tip back. I just was not impressed. read more

The food was delicious. Odd arrangement to eat. You have 30 minutes to eat, in car or not attractive picnic tables. Of course you can always drive off to another place, while your food gets cold. read more

The lobster roll was pretty good. My only complaint was the attitude of the workers. They open at 10am, we got there at 9.57am. The door open and we saw people inside so I walked in and asked if they were open yet, they asked what we wanted and we said 2 hot lobster rolls, they told us it would be 10mins. Cool. We left and went to the pier, came back at 10.10am. As we approached one boy said "here come those two again, great." Sorry we wanted to spend money in your open store and came back at the time you told us to. I know working early mornings during the summer is a bummer but maybe just don't be a dick. Also just bc it is loud inside doesn't mean people can't hear you outside read more

Simple lobster shack on water. Very nice. Lobster roll, lobster bisque, and tea. Parking can be tough, but attendant is accommodating.

If you're a lobster lover like me, this is the place to go! This is a small shop, but they certainly don't skimp out on the lobster meat. I got the cold lobster roll and small fluffy chowder. The lobster roll was stuffed with lobster chunks and smothered in mayo. They're so generous with the lobster that you wouldn't realize that you're eating out of a regular sized hot dog bun! I've had many lobster rolls across the New England area and this is probably one of the best lobster rolls I've ever had. As for the fluffy chowder, I originally got it because it was something I've never had before. It was a combination of two foods I love: clam chowder and lobster. The chowder was smooth and creamy and loaded with large chunks of buttered lobster. So you get the best of both worlds! Overall, great food at reasonable prices! read more

Rye Harbor Lobster Pound - Lobster Roll and Fluffy Chowder - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

One of the best if not the best lobster rolls I've had! Both the bread and the lobster were super buttery. Lobster tasted so fresh, tender. They also have this amazing fluffy clam chowder. It includes lobster and clam with a buttery topping. It is actually SO good - this one is definitely the best clam chowder I've ever had. Staff were super friendly, and we were served quickly. They have a cute dog greeting people at the door. Parking is free for 30 minutes, and there are a couple of outdoor tables. read more

There were no clams in the clam chowder but since we ordered the extra lobster on top that was fair The steamers were just OK no flavor Nice view overlooking the water read more

How did I live my whole life without knowing about fluffy chowder?!! Rye harbor is a little off the beaten path and there is a $5 parking charge, but it is validated back as a discount on your food order. The girls inside were super sweet and working hard - don't forget to tip them! This is a walk up, togo only type spot, but there are benches around the marina to eat and watch the boats. I had the small fluffy chowder and a lobster roll. OMG, so good - lobster roll wasn't overly wet and I'll be dreaming about the fluffy chowder. Take the time to head over to Rye Harbor - you won't regret it! read more

Fresh seafood, great service, customer driven, pricing is average but fair, always a variety of fish, shell fish and of course lobsters.

The absolute best lobster bisque and fluffy chowder! We also had a delicious lobster roll. Friendly staff and quick service.

This is one of those times that admittedly Yelp comes through with the hidden gems/quality eats. After hanging out with a friend in Portsmouth, I definitely wanted to make a seafood stop to-go for dinner. I have always seen signs for The Beach Plum, and have been curious about it, but was wary after reading a number of recent reviews. If I was going to get a lobster roll, I wanted to ensure that it was done well! I was glad with my choice of checking out Rye Harbor Lobster Pound driving south back to MA. It's definitely hidden; I honestly would not have found it if it wasn't for folks giving a heads up here. I ordered the hot lobster roll (the sherry butter/lobster/all of it! were delicious), and had the clam chowder which was also excellent. I didn't realize fluffy chowder was actually a scoop of the sherry buttered lobster into the chowder (!) but it just gives me another reason to stop by another time! As with all my experiences, if the service is kind/on point, then it truly deserves 5 stars, and I appreciated those who helped out today. Looking fwd to coming back! read more

We went here and got the Fluffy chowder! To die for!! We also got the lobster rolls and they were delicious and huge!! Great prices and the service was outstanding!! Definitely don't want to miss this casual, friendly restaurant! We will be going back this week! read more

The Best Lobster Roll we have ever had. Hands down. The lobster was the most luscious, juicy, sweet, flavorful lobster meat we've ever had in a lobster roll. And, they give you plenty of lobster meat. Out of this world. Staff was super nice. We will come back every time we are in town. read more

Oh, so decadent... the warm, butter filled lobster roll! And the bisque with the fluff! How do they get that silky smooth fluffy texture on the bisque? If you're looking for that extra decadent treat... soooo worth it!!!! read more

Rye Harbor Lobster Pound - Cute location. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

See all

Lobster bisque is the best! 10/10 and 30 minute free parking. We go here every year and love it

The portions are exceptional and the lobster is perfect! I highly recommend the lobster mac and cheese.

My first visit to Rye Harbor and the lobster roll was delicious! I am looking forward to coming back again. read more

Rye Harbor Lobster Pound - Warm lobster roll! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

Maine is supposedly known for lobster, but I'm thinking all the folks from Maine drive down to NH to get their lobster mack-on at Rye Harbor Lobster Pound! This small family-owned and -operated shack, right off of Rye Harbor, offers a very modest menu of steamed lobster of various pounds, soups (clam chowder, lobster bisque, fluffy clam chowder, and lobster gazpacho), rolls (hot or cold lobster rolls), some appetizers (shrimp cocktail, Montauk seafood salad, and coleslaw), and lobster mac & cheese. Besides this place being a local favorite for delicious fresh seafood, I had heard that this place was also known for their buttersherry sauce. YUM! We ordered: the Hot Lobster Roll (with buttersherry sauce; eat this one as soon as possible, as the roll can get super soggy from the sauce), a Fluffy Chowder (topped with lobster and buttersherry sauce; thick and creamy), Chunk Lobster Bisque (garnished with lobster in buttersherry sauce; this was absolutely one of my favorite eats on this trip, as this bisque was thick and creamy, super flavorful, and very comforting!), and a 4.2+ lb steamed female lobster (this big kahuna of a mama was super delicious - it was like an endless amount of sweet meat!). There are a couple of tables where you can sit outside and enjoy your meal. There were some patrons who came to pack their lobsters to-go, too. Parking is a little complicated, as there is a lot where you pay a fee, or 30-minute metered parking (strictly enforced!). Don't forget to say 'Hello' to the super sweet Retriever! Just don't feed him anything, as he's diabetic! Super friendly staff! +delicious steamed lobster! +Chunk Lobster Bisque! +buttersherry sauce! +fresh seafood! +couple of tables for al fresco dining +limited parking (30-minute metered parking or a paid lot) +friendly staff read more

I just don't understand how I have lived in NH for 12 years and just found out about this place. By far the freshest and most reasonably priced seafood in the state. Whether you want to take something home or enjoy a lobster roll outside while taking in the view of the harbor, this is the spot. The staff is accommodating, friendly and everything is perfectly cooked everytime. They will even give you a cooler to insulate your precious seafood morsels while you drive to your favorite sea side picnic spot (mine is Odiorne state park, about 10 minutes away). 10/10, 5/5, I would rate you guys higher if I coild read more

See all

Fluffy clam chowder, hot lobster roll, and a cold lobster roll, my new all-time favorite! Buttery goodness in the chowder and the perfectly toasted roll, and fresh tender lobster meat are absolutely perfect! read more

One of the best places around to fulfill your lobster craving. Get the "fluffy chowder" and thank me later!

This is the best bang for your Buck for lobster anywhere along the coast of New England! with awesome prices on their soft shell lobsters to the primitive experience of eating it entirely by hand while overlooking a bay filled with lobster boats, this is my favorite way and place to eat lobster! I personally prefer the lobster bisque to the fluffy chowder but to each their own. read more

See all

THE. BEST. LOBSTER. ROLL. My dad and I are always looking for hole in the wall places with great food around the Hampton area. We came across Rye Lobster Pound after looking for lobster rolls on yelp. It is a small shack on the harbor with picnic tables outside which makes for a great spot to enjoy a lobster roll. We went several times after initially going. Their lobster rolls are delicious - you can tell the lobster was caught that day. Their fluff is also amazing. It's chowder with plenty of lobster chunks in it. Prices aren't bad either. This place is a MUST! read more

Rye Harbor Lobster Pound - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

We have been super excited to come back to Rye for another lobster roll from this joint, but unfortunately they're closed for the season. If you're around when they're open, you must take advantage. You won't be disappointed. read more

My friends and I stopped here for lunch on a whim to kill some time before checking into our air bnb. This cute little restaurant on the water is such a nice surprise. But the most important thing I have to rave about is their lobster roll and fluffy clam chowder. I can't stop thinking about it!! Definitely a must stop to relax and eat lunch by the water. read more

See all

So freaking good! Lobster bisque is yummy and lobster was fresh and excellent. Lobster roll is plentiful , fresh and well prepared. Love the casual shack. They work quickly and get to everyone with good manners and service. We will be back! Only downer is the parking lot. Kind of a mess and in need of some paving.I can get past that for the food. read more

Delicious. My first trip to Maine, the lobster was fantastic! We had a nice dinner by the water.

Very disappointed after traveling out of my way to revisit Second visit to Rye Harbor Lobster and my last. Consistency is valued and not what I received. $30 for 1 clam chowder and 1 Fluffy chowder. Both were barely warm. Clam chowder had very little flavor and the large fluffy chowder had 4 SMALL bits of lobster meat, 3 of which were attached to the cartilege claw piece of lobster which has a bad texture and taste and is not actually meat. The little bit of lobster juice didn't even change the color of the chowder below it. First visited Rye Harbor Lobster in September 2023. Though the prices were a bit high, this was the best chowder in a 5 stop chowder finding mission. We had a regular chowder and a fluffy chowder. The 2023 fluffy chowder was excellent, though expensive for the spoonful of lobster meat on top. Returned for this visit in July 2024, expecting a great repeat experience and I would have enjoyed a can of Progresso clam chowder almost as much and would have saved $27. read more

Best lobster roll ever. Can't wait to go back!! I got a great soup too but can't remember the name - was 3 meals!

Ate here on friend recommendation- was expensive but lots of lobster and quite good- ate it on picnic table at nearby state park

We ordered two one and quarter pound lobsters, two pounds of steamers, and a fluffy chowder. The food was fabulous. The lobsters were super fresh, sweet, and cooked just perfectly. The steamers were equally fresh, sweet, and cooked to perfection. The fluffy chowder was delicious in a combination of thick creamy chowder with a delightful addition of lobster meat. The service was outstanding. All the staff were very friendly and attentive. The food was well packed to take it on the road, eat in the car, or find a table or bench nearby. Everything was thoughtful packed for us. The location is a short detour off I-95, in a nondescript but picturesque fisherman's harbor. Forgot to take a picture of the food, because we were enjoying it so much. Highly recommend this place! Five stars! read more

Rye Harbor Lobster Pound - View of the harbor at sunset - Seafood Markets Near Me - Rye, New Hampshire

Great little spot, friendly staff but I suspect that the hot lobster roll (lobster in sherry butter) is made with frozen lobster. Lobster meat was shredded and so dry. Roll was perfectly grilled. The Montauk seafood salad was delicious- lemon tarragon (?) dressing. But please, use Maine shrimp! Taste tested the Rye Harbor Lobster Pound hot lobster roll against the little shack at the back of the parking lot closest to the harbor. The little shack's cold lobster roll was excellent- chunks of lobster dressed lightly with mayo. Served with lemon and chips. (Btw- they had a delicious cheeseburger and chowder too) read more

Delicious lobster rolls, muscles and chowder. Very nice and friendly owner. Parking is a hustle and it basically and take away place only. Recommended. read more