Reservation, and free street parking, with a little wait outside on the street until we were seated, on a table that welcomed our party by name on the paper tablecloth. Nice touch. Our server Katie was excellent throughout the evening, chatty but quick, informative and helpful, making sure we had everything we needed and that we were happy. They were short staffed (most restaurants in Lahaina are now) and didn't have a bartender that night, so no cocktails, but luckily one of the mocktails came bottled so hubby enjoyed his Phony Negroni, while I shared a bottle of the Slovenian Giocato Pinot Grigio with honey tones that complimented the meal nicely, and was an unusual addition to their wine menu. What did we eat you ask? Salumi e Formaggi - We chose the Mortadella and Fontina which came with pickled tomatoes and grapes (oh so moreish). The Mortadella with pistachio wasn't as tasty as we expected but the cheese was nutty and excellent, and the little crackers accompanying them had a pleasant aniseed flavour. A smaller size charcuterie plate for 2 for $25 but everything is imported hence the price. Calabrese Piccante Pizza - their pizzas are cooked in a pizza oven right in front of you and they smell heavenly. Crunchy, crisp base, a really fresh tomato sauce (simple but amazing) with a bite to it, and thin layers of Calabrese salami and just a touch of char on the crust. Very tasty Strozzapreti con Kale e Salsiccia - a special of the day, twisted pasta with a rich sauce of cooked kale and pork sausage. Very savoury and a good portion. (Portions are more Italian than American sized here) Acciughe Pizza - another special, and my fave, fresh anchovy pizza with fresh tomato sauce. Every slice had a fillet of anchovy on it and it was delicious! Such a treat to get fresh anchovy on island Tiramisu - served in a glass and decadent, creamy with a hit Affogato with Gelato - vanilla gelato with a strong coffee poured over, a classic, and good strong coffee Vin Santo e biscotti - a sweet dessert wine with 3 small biscotti to dip into it and savor, sweet and crunchy The restaurant is in 3 areas, a patio for outside dining, a downstairs area, and an upstairs. It is a small restaurant and popular so reservations are recommended. Nice restrooms playing jazz, quirky decor, underlit bar, small but eclectic menu, and obviously as a James Beard pick they are world renowned. The owners work hard in their restaurant and rebuilt it after the tragic Lahaina fires and they truly are making magical Italian food, true to the chef's roots. You are not only supporting a local business but also eating some of the best Italian food in the USA too! Our receipt was itemized which is a nice touch if you want to work out a bill or remember what you ordered for a Yelp review :) read more

If we could give 10 stars we would! From start to finish amazing meal!!! Homemade EVERYTHING! Started with meatballs, arancini cacio e Pepe ( homemade rice balls stuffed with cheese served over homemade pomodoro sauce), mortadella and pistachio pizza, homemade rigatoni with speck and saffron cream, tagliatelle alla bolognese... the vanilla panna cotta was so amazing! Fresh tiramisu mind blowing, Affogato with hazelnut homemade gelato! Insane flavors! I can't say enough about the ambiance, service, food quality and presentation! Not to be missed by tourists and locals!! Grazie read more

See all

I am incredibly disappointed with our experience here. We had a reservation for 7:45 PM and arrived early at 7:30 PM. Despite having open space, they made us wait until exactly 7:45 PM to be seated. The irony is that their policy charges guests a $15 fee if they are 15 minutes late, yet the restaurant shows absolutely no respect for the guests' time once they arrive. The atmosphere was chaotic and full of loud kids, but the service was the real letdown. Our waiter spent most of his night chatting and sparking long conversations with other tables while completely ignoring us. I had to flag him down just to remind him about a beer I had ordered 10 minutes prior. When it came to ordering, we trusted his recommendations--which was a massive mistake. I paid $45 for an entree that turned out to be exactly eight pieces of ravioli. The portion size was so small it felt like a child's plate, which was especially frustrating because my wife ordered the gnocchi, which was actually cheaper and way more plentiful than my micro-portion. To wrap up the night, we had to wait another 15 minutes just to get the bill while our waiter caught up with his other tables again but I blame the annoying customer he kept entertaining . When he finally brought the card reader over, he shoved the screen in my face where the minimum preset tip option was 20%. I ended up shelling out a $25 tip for someone I literally had to beg for basic service. To top it all off, the birthday dessert we ordered was a massive letdown and cost a ridiculous $20 for something that was very disappointing . Save your money and go somewhere that actually values its customers, serves proper portions, and makes you feel welcome. read more

Secret treasure. Tucked away from the crowds and Lahaina's hidden Italian gem. Scratch kitchen (and you can tell) along with great service made this place a definite go to again. The Lasagna was the best I have ever had (and I've tried a lot) and the squid ink pasta was perfectly balanced (not salty like how other restaurants serve it). The two special for the appetizer (speck on a crostini) and the bombalino for dessert were amazing. Can't wait to come back and try new things!! read more

See all

We heard great things about this restaurant so we decided to try it out. Make sure you have a reservation or you probably won't get a table. We ordered the insalata verde salad to split and it was really good. We then ordered the rigatoni con speck and the Quattro pizza and shared both of those as well. The food was delicious and very flavorful. Our server, Kate, was very knowledgeable when it came to what wine to order based on the food we ordered. We sat upstairs, it was nice but there are no windows. If you get a chance to eat there I would definitely recommend it. read more

Sale Pepe - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

When I think of dining in Maui, I didn't expect one of my most memorable dinners would be an Italian restaurant... But here we are! I am so happy I listened to the reviews and booked a table for dinner (make reservations! I booked same day) we sat on the patio with the stars overhead and a pleasant warm wind. Every table was filled with happy patrons, both inside and out. Our waitress was lovely and provided great recommendations for each section, always remembered to check on us, and even had great conversation. The food- The pancetta with egg pizza. Incredible. Their flour is imported from Italy and you can truly taste the difference. My husband and I are pizza obsessed people and we truly felt the lightness in the crust and how it didn't make you feel bloated was due to that. The ingredients were flavorful and fresh and all around a top notch pie. The shrimp pasta. Honestly? A perfect dish. The star of the show. The pasta was cooked perfectly al dente and is homemade. The shrimp was jumbo and not overcooked. The chopped garlic and sauce was just delightful and I found myself dipping my pizza crust into it (lol). 10/10 The tiramisu was light and delicious with a thick creamy consistency. Paired with espresso just ended the night perfectly. Tip- if you want a N/A drink try the phony Negroni!! To wrap this up, the food is stellar. The service was great. The ambience warm and inviting. All around a great dining experience. Would come back in a heartbeat! read more

See all

Of course, when in Maui, you want Italian. Well, my kids did, and we ended up here, inside the food court of Whaler's Village in Lahaina. They both loved it and didn't have a single negative thing to say. The wait was a bit for a bowl of pasta and a slice of pizza, but they had just opened, so I understand. They would totally come back to this place and that's saying a lot coming from my picky kiddos. read more

Sale Pepe - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Amazing food and service! Italian dinner and Hawaii never crossed my mind, but thanks to several recommendations by people at our hotel, we made a reservation. Our meals were incredible. Some of the best gnocchi with a light but flavorful cream sauce that I have ever had! The whipped ricotta and bread for an app was incredible as well! read more

See all

I loved Qiana and Michele's story of resilience, being the first restaurant to open after the 2023 fires, and I expected my family and I to have a wonderful experience for dinner last night. But we didn't. And it was due to logistical decisions made by staff. Let me explain... We had a 7:15pm reservation but arrived to a large crowd waiting out front and no one at the hostess stand. We were able to check in closer to 7:30. I felt assured when Qiana politely told an impatient patron that she had to seat those with reservations first. But that party of four, and others, were seated before us. After 40+ minutes waiting, Qiana apologized for a table that was lingering and asked if we wanted to wait for a table upstairs or be seated on the crowded lanai (with several young children) or wait a bit for a table upstairs. I chose upstairs. We waited for that lingering party to depart; no one left. Then 15-20 minutes later, we were seated upstairs. That was one hour after our reservation at 8:15pm. The logistical decisions and bad luck continued because there was a large party of ~10 also seated upstairs and they took priority over us. Our entrees arrived 45 minutes later (9pm by now). By this time, my family was very hungry and a little mad at the situation. I felt disrespected for the circumstances. The staff was nice, but actions were speaking louder than words. I usually rave about food in my reviews, but the long wait and how situations were handled (there were more I'm not describing) colored our special evening out and how the bites were received. Our evening at Sale Pepe turned out to be a low light, instead of the highlight I expected, from our Maui holiday. read more

See all

We had a reservation for 5/21 and had the best time. The staff is very kind and welcoming. Our server (older gentleman) was the best, he was funny and very knowledgeable when it came to the menu. The pizza is AMAZING, def try the pizza. The pasta (pesto sauce) was sooooo yummmm. You can def taste how fresh the pasta is. Everything was so good we came back the next night LOL. The staff even remembered us which was sweet. This was our favorite dinner spot and so excited to come back on our next trip to Maui. After having burrata here I won't be able to have it anywhere else haha. The hazelnut gelato was also very delicious, very fresh. read more

Sale Pepe - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

This is by far our favorite restaurant on the west side of Maui. I saw Sale Pepe pop up in my feed, but it was rarely mentioned in my Maui Facebook groups. The menu looked good so we decided to try it. We went thinking that we were going to pick up a couple of pizzas and head back to our resort after a long day of sight seeing. However, we stayed for what felt like an intimate home cooked Italian dinner. Everything was so delicious we decided to make a second trip back before we left the island. The food is superb. The staff is extremely knowledgeable about food and Italian cuisine. We enjoyed every single bite. Sale Pepe was definitely a highlight of our trip. Our servers were Kas and Jason. ‍ read more

See all

What a gem in Maui! We arrived after 8 pm on a weekday without a reservation in September. After a short wait, we were seated at the bar. Service was excellent. The hostess clearly prioritized reservations (and seems to held tables for late arrivals), so I'd definitely recommend booking ahead. We tried a salad, the Spaghetti Neri con Gamberi e 'Nduja, and a special sardine pizza. Everything was absolutely delicious. The oil from the shrimp heads paired beautifully with the squid ink pasta, and the pizza dough was perfect. The chefs' love story and the re-opening after the fire make this place even more special. Truly a must-visit. read more

See all

Amazing legit Italian food! This place has the best pizza I've ever had. I'm talking gourmet wood fired pizza, not the cheap stuff that you just want to get full on. We had the mortadella pizza but can't wait to try others. Arancini balls were also amazing. House made pastas were good too but the pizza is what I'll remember. Super friendly service. We sat downstairs which is a little tight and this place is buzzing which is part of the fun. Makes you feel like you're in little hole in the wall in Italy. read more

Amazing! One of the best food experiences I've had in my travels. Everything was 10/10 delicious. Wait staff and atmosphere was also phenomenal. My only regret is not having enough room for dessert. Everyone was eating it but I was already over the top stuffed. We added lobster to the gnocchi and did not regret it for a second. They have several non-alcoholic drink options as well. Great experience. Who would have known Maui would have great Italian food?! read more

See all

We discovered this Maui treasure earlier this year. Sadly, the original was lost in the Lahaina fire but determination and will led the owners to reopen in a new location up the hill from their original. Everything served here is either from Maui or Italy. The owners are truly engaged with their customers and our server (Katie) was attentive, knowledgeable about the food and wine and very friendly. She is a treasure! The puffy dough was amazing. Very light puff pizza dough with olive oil. Light, flavorful and delicious. The pizzas are Neapolitan and I've never had a better one, even in Italy. The next night we had a prawns, shredded zucchini, linguini in olive oil and a lasagna. Perfection! The mahi was grilled over a wood fired grill and was fantastic. I could go on endlessly but it's just easier to go yourself and try it. You won't be disappointed!- we went there 4 times on our last trip to Maui read more

See all

Where is the check in stand!? This was my first question, and clearly a lot of other people's as well. I think what made this the most difficult was that the person checking people in was not at the podium and it was weird that you have to walk up the ramp and stand basically right in front of someone's table to check in. I think this falls down to the line that this is clearly a business complex and they made do. I recommend making a reservation as it can get busy, but you can also select where you want to sit. The food was fantastic, and it all comes down to the ingredients. The import their flower and another ingredients directly from Italy and you can tell the difference. The vibe of the restaurant is intimate yet casual. And huge shoutout to Sierra (hope I spelled it correctly) for making us feel at home and for helping us with our dietary restrictions! read more

Sale Pepe - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Horrible... don't waste your money or time. I cancelled my reservation well in advance and they charged me a $50 cancellation fee nine days later? Point Break pizza blows this place out of the water. read more

Service is amazing, from the hostess who greeted us, to our server, Katie, to the food runners. Everyone was very attentive and friendly. Couldn't ask for any better. We got there 15 minutes before our reservation and were seated right away. They even had a nice little "happy anniversary" note on the table for us. We dined outside and unfortunately was super windy that evening due to a hurricane a few islands over. The temperature was nice and despite the wind gusts on occasion which can't be helped, the outdoor dining experience was very nice. I couldn't even tell you how the inside looks, we never stepped foot inside. Ok, so the food. I think we're spoiled by Italian food in our neighborhood at home. Sale Pepe was good but it didn't knock our socks off. You could tell everything was homemade and was very good, not incredible. The pasta dishes were good and I believe handmade pasta. I think it just lacked a bit of flavor we are used to. Would we go back, absolutely, for the service alone. I wouldn't go out of my way to tell my friends of Italian heritage that they must try but when on vacation and craving Italian, Sale Pepe is a good choice. read more

Was excited when they reopened! We went on 7/3 and they were packed the whole time we were there with people waiting. Server was so helpful and friendly and food was devine. We ordered the focaccia bread to share. It wasn't what I was expecting but it was so good! I got the eggplant Parmesan. It was so delightful and delicious that I can't wait to go back to get it again. They got the ravioli and thoroughly enjoyed it as well. We missed dessert because we were stuffed but will definitely save room next time. We sat outside which had a great breeze. Went inside to check it out and it has a great vibe all around. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Pricey $$$$ We ordered the Alfredo gnocchi and the porchini mushroom pasta special. Really good...I will definitely be thinking about these rich alfredo gnocchi. Tgey have the absolute best texture I have ever had woth gnocci. I reccomend adding a vegetable or mushroom to break up the richness. The mushroom pasta was also tasty. Lots of big mushroom flavor. Rich in a good way. Rich foods are so filling. Good service. Sat outside in a small cramped tiny 2 top table but worth it. read more

Sale Pepe - Porchini mushroom pasta special - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

We never visited the previous location, but decided to check out this new location. We got a spot on the lanai which faced a road that wasn't very busy but had ample shade. It was a bit crowded on the patio but not too bad. Our server was excellent. She brought new place settings between courses and paced the food well. The food was excellent. We tried aranchini, focaccia, chicken liver pâté, mushroom pizza, and guanciale pasta. It was all incredible. The pizza crust and focaccia was perfect. The tomato sauce and the guanciale had so much flavor but still felt fresh. The arancini were a perfect texture. I've already made another reservation to go back. read more

See all

AUTHENTIC. That's the one word I would use to describe here! Simple ingredients, and flavor punch! We've been to Italy and the first bite from here brought us back! Between the 2 of us we had a bottle of wine, the crostini de gamberi, their special pasta (basically a bolognese with beef cheek... drool), their tomato pesto pasta, and a calabrese salami pizza. Yes.. we ate like "typical Americans" and over indulged and didn't regret it at all. The flour is imported from Italy, so you don't get that "bloated, full feeling" gluten intolerant ppl can eat here without having an episode, and the staff.. was beyond helpful! We had Francesco idk if he's the owner but a lovely person. They had indoor and outdoor seating, the cutest little spot away from the madness of the resorts. A must stop when in town! read more

Sale Pepe - Crostini de gamberi - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

This is truly your authentic Italian restaurant to experience. The vibe was nice, and our server Makaila, was awesome & very informative. We actually ate outside and never experienced the indoors while eating. Here is a list of things we ordered: FOCACCIA GONFIA (bread) ARANCINI CACIO PEPE (fried appetizer) INSALATA VERDE (salad) INSALATA ROMANA (salad) LASAGNA MALFALDE CON GUANCIALE DI MANZO (pasta) RIGATONI CON SPECK E ZAFFERANO (pasta) DON'T CALL ME ALFREDO (pasta) This was probably one of our best food experiences and we LOVE Italian! Can't wait to go back and try the pizza. read more

Sale Pepe - Focaccia Gonfia - "Swollen" bread - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

The food and service were fantastic. We arrived without a reservation and sat at the bar. Be sure to have a reservation if you want a table! We had the meatballs, a pizza, and a ravioli special. I didn't take photos because we were at the bar talking with the bartender and I thought that would be weird. We sat in front of the pizza oven and the restaurant chef was making the pizzas. He talked to us a bit, which was great. They shared about their experience with the fire and it was interesting to hear the journey so many locals are on. The bartender also gave us some tips of places to visit while we were talking. Great food, great service, great people. read more

So glad we could get a table just before closing tonight. Service was excellent and they were able to accommodate us without a reservation. We tried the rigatoni, the calzone special, bufala mozzarella pizza, the risotto, and the beef cheek pasta. All were amazing and would absolutely recommend. I love the intimate atmosphere and ambience. Lahaina is lucky to have Sale Pepe back! read more

See all

Amazing food and great service. We will definitely be back. Their pizza's are wonderful as is their homemade pasta.

So happy they have reopened in Lahaina! Such amazing food and service always! My personal favorite is always the squid ink pasta with lobster and the lasagna . The Tirimisu is also incredible! Can't miss it's always so good! read more

See all

SO SLOW. we waited 45 min after seating to get *water* and kept asking for refills food was so-so, after another 45 min wait. Waiter was at times rude, jokingly complaining that we "drank so much water" appetizers were small and spendy. $43 for Lasagna, hardly any meat (I understand that Italian food is not big on meat) average size portions. This place is way over-hyped. read more

Wait time for the food was incredible long and room they made upstairs was so uncomfortable. We decided to get our food to go after a long wait and portions were so small. We didn't even want to eat anymore read more

Really happy to see Lahaina restaurants doing so well. We were seated upstairs (made reservations ahead of time) and requested this. Glad to have chosen that as it was nice and quiet. Downstairs is a bit more lively but just as adorable. Seating outside also available. There was a huge line and people waiting around 7pm showing how popular it is. The food and pasta was cooked to perfection. The service was great and we had Jason who was wonderful. He knew the food would take long and encouraged us to order bread but we weren't in a rush or super hungry so we enjoyed the atmosphere and waited. They have great dessert options but we were already full. There's a nice mix of locals and tourists. Highly recommend for everyone! read more

See all

Got too excited when the food came for before pics lol. The gnocchi is a must get- it was pillowy and the sauce was so good (it's the empty plate). The risotto was very cheesy and creamy. The pizzas were ok. Was hoping for more sauce from the pistachio pizza. The other was a basic burrata pizza. Our server was friendly. Service was a bit slow because they were busy. We sat on the lanai which was cozy but lots of traffic from people coming and going. read more

Sale Pepe - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

This place needs no intros!! What a great spot for gatherings -- date night, family dinners or for out of towners. SALE PEPE is THE SPOT. It's such a nice local treat owned by a wonderful couple duo. Everything is good so I'd say not one thing is better than the other. It's like picking a favorite child, you just can't :) We were a family of 4 trying this place for the first time. We ordered 4 appetizers to start and was definitely enough to share and pregame. The Caponata, Panzanella, the salad special, and Polpette aka delicious meatballs. Drinks are a must and if you're feeling extra fun order a bottle, we got the Buche wine... light red and slightly sweet. Then we all ordered our own entrees. Fun Fact: All the pastas are made fresh daily so you are getting it first! The eggplant parm and lasagna were a hit with our parents. We ordered the Rigatoni Con Speck E Zafferano and my husband ordered the pasta special with red sauce and ground lamb. (the plates were wiped clean) Sooo good. Leave room for desert. We enjoyed the Affogato and Panna Cotta Del Giorno -- aka cooked cream" custard, ask your server for the daily flavor. Will have to go back to try the other things. Carbs never let us down (im not wrong) so try it out and then go again. read more

See all

The staff is incredibly friendly, however I gave 3 stars for very slow service and the price for what you get. We sat at the bar and waited 45min to order our food. The bartender was prioritizing everybody's drink order instead of our food order. After we received our food maybe 70min in, the bartender kept asking if we needed anything else multiple times. I think he either knew he messed up being slow or he was continuously trying to get us to buy more drinks. That being said, the lasagna is excellent, but not for $34. I prefer going to Marlow. read more

Sale Pepe - Spritz (needs more Aperol) - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

This is the perfect date night spot! It is a small romantic setting, very welcoming staff, and fantastic food. You can really taste how fresh everything is. They ship in a lot of their products from Italy. I highly suggest trying their sorbet special as it is always delicately balanced. read more

Sale Pepe - Aperol Spritz - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

The best Italian food and service I have ever had. The place has a unique dining experience where the server actually tel you the story behind the restaurant and also walks you through the menu. Ambience was great, loved the vibe. What stood out was the service and the food was too good. read more

Sale Pepe - Pizza and pasta - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

One of our favorite spots . We love everything on the menu ! They make their own pasta! Portions are perfect ! Their pizzas are incredible as well. read more

My heart is so full! Sale Pepe is back after their previous location burnt down in the Lahaina fires and they are better than ever. The owners have truly outdone themselves. Had the best lasagna of my life (don't tell my mother). The menu changes monthly and all of their ingredients are straight from Italy. The restaurant was beautifully designed and I love the Lahaina strong sentiment upstairs. If you haven't checked out Sale Pepe's new location- this is your sign!!! read more

Sale Pepe - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

It's a small restaurant that requires a reservation. We ordered not your alfredo pasta and margarita pizza. It's the most overpriced food we've eaten in Maui. The pizza was burnt, and the pasta was starchy. The servers and bartender were really nice and polite, and they made sure we were all attended to. read more

10/10- no notes. From the moment you walk in, the staff is welcoming. After that, I saw my name saying "Ciao, Jacqueline!" which just made this experience extremely personalized, I loved it. Our waitress was on par with anything and everything we needed. On top of that, the food was absolutely spectacular! If you are on the hunt for a beautiful, delicious, and worthy Italian place, this one is the best on the Island! read more

Sale Pepe - Gnocci - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

We all have a crush on our server. We all payed $6 for a can of sanpelligrino. Why do we keep putting mushrooms in everything. read more

Sale Pepe - Gnocchi, etc - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii