I had Maddie as my server, she was amazing! The food was so good and Maddie made sure that everything was perfect for us. If anything was wrong or we needed anything more she was on it so quick. The restaurant was quiet and very comfortable! I will be coming back :) read more

The portions of a large and the food was good. The gentleman waited on us was very nice as we sat at the counter and it was very fast.. The only thing I can say is that the bathroom needed to be cleaned better the ambience was a little outdated and could've been a little better upkeep. read more

I always enjoy their seafood, and their Neopolitan style cheese pizza. The Fried Calamari has always been done perfect. The shrimp dishes are fresh and portions are plentiful. The dining room is always clean and relaxed. The service is great, always very nice staff. read more

So sad.. I loved Sal's .. it was my go to place when I lived in the area. I came for a visit friends and insisted on Sal's. Very disappointing. I ordered Chicken Marsala... it was awful. No flavor! The Marsala sauce was watery with no flavor. The bread was stale....The salad was awesome... the service was great, and it is super clean in the restaurant. Food not as good as it used to be. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Chicken Marsala - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Have been going to Sals for awhile. Seating is booths or tables. Service is quick, knowledgeable and attentive. Food is good and a great value for the cost. Salads are large and fresh. Bathrooms are clean and stocked. Beverages are Coca Cola products and it is BYOB. Parking is in the strip mall parking lot. read more

We stopped at S C C F P a few days ago for lunch. My daughter, and I ordered French Onion soup which was really good, and we split a cheesesteak which was just average. Bruschetta came out was similar to a this pizza with a little basil, cropped onion, and tomato. We also ordered a personal pan cheese pizza. read more

Nice place to eat and relax. Pizza is very good! We loved going there when we lived in NJ

Sal's Bruschetta pizza in Northfield, NJ, is THE most disgusting pizza I have ever eaten in my life. It was cold, disgusting, soggy, wet, and smelled like rotten socks. DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PLACE. Save your money and go anywhere but here. Look at at the photo of what I ordered..... I wouldnt even feed this to my worst enemy. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Sal's Bruschetta Pizza - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Excellent place they have great pizzas and a full Italian menu. Staff there is very nice and always accommodating. I got there a half hour before close and there's no problem getting food from the friendly staff. read more

My family and grandchildren went to Sal's last night ... great dinners and as always wonderful service by Alex. The seafood pescatore was delicious and sumptuous. The huge shrimp was perfectly cooked, the clams, mussels and big chunks of lump crabmeat was expertly blended with the red sauce. The calamari was tender and altogether a dish to remember! My granddaughter had two slices of pepperoni pizza and all smiles... we can't wait till we come back for more beautiful memories! read more

So can someone explain to me, is there any downside to cooking ALL pizzas in a coal fired oven? The reason is, why would this place only use the coal fired oven for certain pizzas and not for all pizzas? I ordered a plain cheese pizza and it was was a very meh football level pizza. Cooked in a regular pizza oven Very very bland. To a point of having close to no taste. The cheese is OK. The crust is thin but it wasn't crispy. If it was cooked in a coal fire oven, I bet you would be as crisp as a delicious cracker but it's not. this pizza is not the worst by any stretch but it literally will leave you with no memories of the pizza once you eat it. There are many other places to try. read more

Breakfast time !! Sal's Cafe , Friendly atmosphere, Great server thank you Sonia, IT WAS ALL SO YUMMY... Found a Delicious Breakfast spot !!! read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Avocado toast served with arugula tomatoes onions poached egg . Roast Pork omelette YUM - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

This review is based on their delivery service. I would also like to note that we did not order pizza. Myself and two other coworkers ordered a cheesesteak, mozzarella sticks, and spaghetti. The delivery was a little faster than I had expected (only about 40 minutes, which is the reason why I added a star) but upon the delivery guy's arrival my coworker accepting the order asked him why the bag of food was leaking. He said, "all orders tend to do that." Do they really? I opened the bag and... well, I've attached a photo of my mozzarella sticks. I did not eat my food. My two coworkers were disappointed with their food's quality as well, so we decided to call them soon as they opened for breakfast the next morning. Because it was a new day, they did not want to give us a refund - just a discount for a future purchase. Sorry, but no thanks. Too disappointing. We will not be giving them another shot. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Mozzarella sticks...? - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

This place consistently has great service, food, and a clean atmosphere. We're always seated quickly even when it's busy. Food is fresh and delicious. Even the salad I got was delicious. Highly recommend this location! read more

My husband and I went for lunch on a weekday afternoon. I chose the lunch special--tortellini with meat sauce and he went with the chicken parm sandwich. The soup which was included with my special was homemade and hot. Ditto for my tortellini entree. The chicken parm was crispy and served on a fresh roll. Thumbs up given by my husband. Our server Megan was very professional and attentive. The only downside was price, it was a bit expensive but the food was good. read more

This overcooked chicken carbonara was $27 but barely worth $10. Won't be doing that again read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - This overcooked chicken carbonara was $27 but barely worth $10. Won't be doing that again - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Spaghetti and meatballs good. Margarita pizza. Well. Not sure what was served but it was not a margarita pie. Very unusual. Service very good. Interior is like a cheap diner. Oh well. People nice But seems like an Italian diner. Not what we were hoping for. read more

In the mood for some Monday soup and traveling near Sal's so why not? Picked a slow time of day and although service was leisurely I felt welcome. When I heard lobster crab bisque I knew my choice! The orange broth in a very big bowl gave off an appealing scent and the flavor was wonderful. It was accompanied by wrapped saltine crackers. Ok, I would have enjoyed oyster crackers or bread. Never understood the appeal of plastic wrapped plain saltines. Blah The bisque had a great lobster bisque flavor but it needed more crab to keep me less crabby. Seriously ... It was a good lunch break. I was satisfied with just the bisque (And the crackers.). read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Lobster crab bisque - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Love to dine in but delivery never again forgot things food was cold and definitely did not taste like in restaurant plus they delivered us too other dinners that we did not order sorry for those people who did not get their meals sorry I had to do this but it was a lot of money and we could not eat it read more

Sals! We love your food and we get pick or delivery often. But I'd say 50% of the time you forget something! Mostly the garlic knots ! I don't call and complain for $3 but it's starting to add up! Please , find a way to pack the complete order. Thank you. read more

Ordered an avocado and chicken salad, very disappointed. It was overloaded with tomatoes cucumbers peppers and onions. Literally had a slice of avocado with black spots on. Never again read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

See all

Order was not taken as specified, pizza was a mess when it arrived (cheese all over the box and not on the pizza). I ordered 15 piece buffalo wings. Was asked what sauce?.. I said, buffalo!! Wings showed up dry, no sauce. I asked if it came with blue cheese.. Sal said, yes... Sal didn't include blue cheese. Everything was cold to the touch. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Sorry excuse for a pizza - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Wanted to post a review and thank Sal's for last Saturday's catering for my sons 30th birthday!! Everything's was delicious, and delivered at the right time, and set up efficiently. You guys know what you are doing!! So many guests wanted to get your info from me.. so expect a lot of new customers!! Thanks so, so much! read more

Based on other reviews we decided to try their pizza. I drove 20 minutes to pick up. What a disappointment! 2 stars is for the crust. 0 stars for the overall pizza. One was Italian with minimal toppings and the fresh mozzarella was congealed. Very little flavor. The white on white again very little flavor.will not try again! read more

Third time eating here was always good but last nite had mussels most of the shells were broken with sharp edges small pieces of shell in sauce throughout entire dish Do not understand how this happened told waitress she said she would tell owner nothing happened asked her again to check she said he would take 10% off cost of dish he never came out to look or speak to us which I found odd, I told the waitress to take it off the check because I refused to pay for garbage. So my recommendation would be to be careful if you are eating there I kind of wonder when an owner will not come out and meet with customers what is he hiding read more

Good coal-fired pizza, friendly staff. Nice local place ... bring your own bottle of wine and enjoy. We tried the fried calamari ... definitely different and to be honest quite good. The white pizza was tasty. Quick service and clean place. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Let me start this by saying the only reason I am giving them 3 stars is their cheesesteaks which are the best in Somers point. That's where the niceties stop. I just ordered an 18 dollar entree for delivery and let me tell you the best part was the side salad. Which an untrained monkey could throw together. The actual entree included chicken which was as bland as chicken found in a TV dinner. Also it included crab meat but I'm not kidding when I say this, there probably wasn't even a claws worth of crab in the dish. Then I'll move on to the pasta, mushy as all hell. If your going to use fresh pasta at least learn how long to cook it for. And here's what made me want to write this yelp review. I ordered a slice of chocolate cake which was 6 dollars I expected a pretty ok size piece. Boy did I get my hopes way to high. This thing was insulting when I opened it. We're talking smaller than a slice of cake u take at a party when you don't want people to see what you would really do to a cake if left alone. I actually had to take a picture to show to people so they could guess how much it costs, so I can see their face when I say 6 DOLLARS! My wife called to complain and when the manager got on the phone he was extremely rude. And pretty much said there's nothing he can do about it. From her reaction he was a dick. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Smallest 6 dollar slice of cake ever. - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Tonight was the 6th time we ordered from Sal's since moving to Somers Point recently. All I can say is wow. We have had the pizza, veal parm sandwich, veal parm dinner, chicken francaise, penne vodka, penne vodka with shrimp, ravioli, gnocchi and most of the desserts. Every meal, every single time was fabulous. Although this is a pizzeria style restaurant with delivery, it will rival the rest of the fine Somers Point establishments. Please do not change your chef . read more

I sought out Sal's Coal Fired Pizza because I had just been handed $500 in cold hard Cash for winning Employee of the month, and was looking for a new place to have a memorable meal. Sal's delivers for the most part. After briefly perusing the menu, I had difficulty finding a coal fired pizza that I was interested in. I spoke with the waitress who informed me that it was possible to order a small pizza and have it coal fired! Score! Naturally the carnivore in me needed meat, and I promptly ordered a small pepperoni and sausage pizza (coal fired, of course), The wife ordered a vegetarian Stromboli, citing that i'm eating enough meat for the both of us. The water we ordered was free, and was refilled often. The pizza arrived hot and gorgeous looking, The crust was thin, but not too thin that I couldn't fold the pizza in half. Wife was making love to her rabbit food Stromboli. While Sal's isn't an upscale sort of coal fired pizza place, it will do just fine for a casual outing. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Small, coal fired pepperoni and sausage pizza , Stromboli in the background - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

WOW! Probably the best fries I have ever had. The cheesesteak was amazing. The burger was a 8 out of 10. You get a lot of food for the price you pay. The staff was super friendly. I cannot wait to return! read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

First time here, brought the family. Very happy with the whole experience. My wife had the margarita pizza and I tried the bruschetta pizza. My son had the cheeseburger, it was huge. My daughter got plain small pizza and my youngest just got a plain slice. The Margarita pizza was the best. The bruschetta pizza was good, but really could of used some balsamic vinager on it. Now for my only COMPLAINT. I would have given them 4 stars, but when my wife went to use the bathroom she came right back. Said that the bathrooms were disgusting. She refused to use them. Out of curiosity I went and checked the men's room and they were okay. With that being said we would definitely come back again. They're menu is huge, lots of choices. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Fried shrimp - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Usually I really enjoy sals but this time they've let us down. We ordered several things, most okay. My cousin ordered a plain cheesesteak wrap and got lettuce and tomato- fine. But we got a large order of cheese fries with a little bit of cheese on it which is whatever but it looked like they had to scrape the crust off the side of the container to put any on at all which is what was the most disappointing. If you don't have it just say that. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Cheese fries with cheese crust - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Absolutely great brick oven pizza. Bring a bottle of wine and share a spring mix salad for a perfect Friday night meal. read more

Sal's Cafe Coal Fired Pizza - Italian Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

I wish I took a picture of my food because it looked beautiful but it smelled too tasty not to dig right in. I ordered the chicken Fantasia (chicken breast in a white wine and lemon sauce covered in melted mozzarella) over pasta and the fried calamari and I was blown away. I usually expect to be a little disappointed when it comes to take out food but Sals never disappoints. I appreciate their quality food and their speedy service. Next time I'll be getting the before picture lol read more

We held a small luncheon celebration of 26 people for our 50th Wedding Anniversary in Sal's private room. They let us order off the menu rather than having to pick two items from a banquet menu. We brought Champagne and they supplied lovely glass champagne flutes. We also brought a cake which was served. Our waitress Megan was very attentive and professional. The food was great and plentiful. I would recommend them for any small private affair. read more

Ordered dinners and pizzas in the past always good. Ordered two margarita pizzas the other day very disappointed. Burned crust, hard pieces of dough, didn't taste right tomato sauce had a off taste. read more

Located in Groveland center. I had passed it many times. Never gave it much thought until I noticed the family special. We got a cheese steak, large pizza, pan of chicken parmigiana with penne and a 2 liter of soda Everything for $50.00. Everything was very good. I am now hooked. I will definitely be going back again and recommending it to friends. read more

Average pizza, we had the margarita, wish it was cooked longer so it had a crisp to it. Nice staff clean place. I'd go again and just ask them to cook it well done read more

Extended family stayed at the house and ordered food. When my husband and I got home from work we ate and asked where the food was from. We've been ordering from there ever since. I love their pizza, salad and pasta dinners. read more

My wife and I order pizza and dessert from this place and we were very disappointing. My cannoli hardly had any filling and the wife's chocolate bunt cake was terrible. The pizza was ok not the best. Thought we should give this place a shot but rather go back to the original spot in Somers Point. Italian Street which has better food and desserts. read more