Absolutely hits every time!! The best wings & their boom boom sauce is my favorite. The wings are flavorful & moist. Delicious! The pizza always slaps as well. 10/10. They make the best pizza & wings in the area. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very nice people & great location![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Super impressed with my Italian sub. Service was quick everyone there was great! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Super clean with attention to detail![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Sal has New York style pizza. And you can order slices and customize. Their Italian sub sandwiches are a family favorite at our house. I usually get two slices of mushroom & onion! Yumm. Today I ordered a whole pizza with meatballs and onion for a change . It was hot & fresh at my door really quickly. Lucky me read more

Sal's Pizza - Sal's pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

It's been at least 10 years since I last been here. So this place has been a staple in this area. From my memory this place was awesome and a good value. I was in area today and stop by.. prices have went up extremely. So I was worried that that they didn't meet the value. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place was extremely busy on a Saturday.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] today I ordered two large steak subs ( with add on's)and a slice of pizza. They were larger than I expected ..The sub rolls, were homemade. The steak, in the subs was good quality. Flavor could have use a little help with garlic or salt.( personal preference maybe)And the Pizza was decent.. you definitely get more in your sub than the average place.( price wise there are definitely cheaper places out there. .[[HIGHLIGHT]]the place was clean and staff was knowledgeable[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. this place is better than Jojos on Main Street. read more

Best stubs you'll ever order. Portions are HUGE, the flavors are delicious, friendly staff, [[HIGHLIGHT]]plenty of room to sit if you want to eat in.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Love how big and full the strombolies and subs are. Yummy. Definitely recommend................................... read more

Sal's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Food was great and plentiful. Service was quick and accurate. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Dining area was good but was not real roomy.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] It's not fine dining but I haven't been to too many pizza joints that are. Small Stromboli was big enough to feed at least two maybe more. Medium meat lovers pizza was enough for two meals. Can't wait to go back read more

Delicious subs at Sal's ... the hot ham & cheese is our favorite. Guys here are super friendly and the food is ready quickly. Num-num-num :-) read more

Sal's Pizza - Can't go wrong with a hot ham & cheese sub on a cold, blustery day. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

GREAT place. First time going there I ordered wings for super bowl last minute and they were amazing! They were done quick and staff was very nice. I would highly recommend. read more

We just ordered for take-out on a Tuesday night. I enjoyed the Italian sub: yummy classic Italian sub roll, loaded with meats and good amount of toppings. The pizza left much to be desired. We opted for the primavera pizza and the onions were practically raw and there was an excessive amount of them. The pizza was soggy from the heavy, wet toppings. The mushrooms were large chunks that also seemed barely cooked. The flavor of the pizza was pretty good and I enjoyed how zesty the pepperoni was, but couldn't get over the cold veggies. I arrived just as they were pulling the pizza from the oven and the house was less than a minute from the shop. To be soggy in that amount of time was odd. The pizza shop looks nice with cute decorations scattered around. The guy who gave me my order was super friendly. I might try it again bc the sub was good, but it all seems a little pricey. read more

Sal's Pizza - The mushrooms weren't as uncooked as the onions were, but still could have used more time. - Pizza Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Top tier service, meaty sandwiches, decent pizza. I've been a customer at this place for nearly 30 years.

Subs are always great and we highly recommend those but we skip their pizza. It's always undercooked. Staff seem polite.

Ordered pickup. Very busy on a Friday evening! Good signs. Well, our calamari was overdone- so not a good sign. Garlic knots were nothing to comment on... so that was meh. Combo pizza was really soggy... so, overall... not the best pizza place we've gone to. I think we'll stick to davinci's for now. read more

We travel to the area a lot for work and are always looking for local spots to bring in for lunch. We keep coming back here! They literally have something for everyone. Sandwiches, salads (and good salads with lots of fresh ingredients), strombolis (that are HUGE), pizza, and tons of appetizers. You name it, which makes it perfect to feed a large group. Everything I've had here has been so delicious, you literally can't go wrong. This spot will forever be on our local rotation! read more

Pepper cheese steak was good bun for the small, decent amount of steak taking away for a bit bland. Medium pizza was good a little doughy, but overall good flavor and size for the price. This is not on the pizza shop but grub-hub fees are ridiculous with these extra costs the price was pretty expensive. I guess places just don't deliver anymore. It's always hard and a bit of a crapshoot when traveling and looking for good food at a decent value. But I would recommend this pizza shop for good quality and overall good value if you pick up. read more

Friendly, straight from Italy service, literally. Was in town a few days liked it so much we went back the next night. Pizza was very good, have had better but we are a bit bias to New Haven, CT pies. Excellent choice if in town. You'll enjoy the atmosphere, so What entertaining. :) read more

Good traditional pizza, good ingredients, nice people, nice recently renovated restaurant. Asked for a well done pie and it was a bit undercooked, but the taste of the pie and quality of ingredients was certainly there. They're very generous with the toppings. Overall a tasty pie, but has some work to be done on the timing of how it's cooked for that good crispiness. read more

I'm rounding up to a 5-star review. It's more like a 4.5, but I'll be generous since they are locally owned and have done an awesome job during COVID. The pizza is good. The wings are good. Those are always so hard to review because people have such different ideas of what makes those excellent. I like my pizza on thin and crispy crust and I like my wings extra crispy. Other people like them completely the opposite way. Sal's is fine for both of those. If you order them, you'll be good. I'm here to tell you about the subs and bolis. They are excellent. The bread on the subs is great, they don't skimp on fillings, and they are an excellent price for the size. The bolis are crispy, larger than you expect, and have lots of fillings. My favorite subs: cheesesteak, Italian, special, and meatball. Favorite bolis: regular and special steak. The entrees are also good. Much better than Olive Garden and better than most of the swanky Italian places around here. I can give the manicotti two thumbs up. The grilled chicken Caesar salad is also good. This is worth a try. read more

Sal's is my favorite local Italian / pizza place. They have excellent pizzas and hoagies/subs. Also, their French fries are delicious. The best part about Sal's is the friendliness of the owners and staff! read more

See all

I absolutely have fallen in love with Sal's during quarantine. I have yet to have anything less than a stellar experience with them. Best subs in the area, for sure!! We recently tried Al's Pizza (the brewery) in Enola for subs and all it did was leave me craving a Sal's sub! Even on a Saturday night, our sub was ready in about 20 minutes. It was perfect! We get the Italian and add sweet peppers. A large is huge an easily feeds my husband and I! The bun is fresh and just so delicious! Thank you Sal's for being a constant source of great food during these crazy, weird times! read more

See all

If you like your subs PACKED with meat and cheese, fresh lettuce tomato onion... Sals is the place you want. Always friendly, and the food is tasty. Pizza sauce is best in the area, lots of pizza places in the area, but these guys are the best! I've never once been disappointed, you will not go away hungry. Some of the dinners are fantastic as well. Prices are very reasonable compared to others in the area. JoJos used to be the best in town, but Sals is King in Mechanicsburg. read more

Before I go into the bad I want to say the good. The food for the most part is good. I like the round pizzas though the sauce is weak , but then again nothing in central PA is good as NY Pizza or anywhere else for that matter. Seems nobody makes their own sauce and lord knows they no nothing about making bread. This place is close to me and so I do go from time to time. Again, The food isn't bad but it isn't fresh and nothing about it stands out from the other pizzerias in the area. I long for a real chicken cutlet. One that is cut from a chicken breast and pounded thinner, not a few chicken finger or strips. No place around here knows how to be Italian, just taste their sauce. They don't even try to doctor up the pre-made stuff from a jar or can. read more

Today I ordered mild wings and a slice cheese pizza both were very yummy, employee's were friendly and courteous read more

Sal's Pizza - Mild wings - Pizza Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Food is excellent. Service is efficient. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambiance is better than most pizza and sub places.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]].

Sauce isn't bad. Pizza stops a little short. Needs more sauce and cheese. If you ask for well done with extra cheese, it can do the trick. If you live around the corner, it's not bad. But I wouldn't travel for it. The Italian sub is ok. Also stops a little short. Just being honest. read more

My husband and I ordered from here for the first time yesterday. We called and placed an order for pick up. The person who answered the phone was incredibly nice and efficient, ending the call by restating our order and providing an estimated time for pick up. My husband went with a large italian sub and I opted for a grilled chicken caesar salad. The sub was huge and more than enough for two meals. The salad came with complimentary garlic bread. My salad was okay but I found the chicken to be a bit tough and the dressing to be too little. I also would have preferred romaine instead of the softer lettuce that was used. My husband thought the inside of the restaurant was deceptively warm and cozy, which was a contrast to its typical exterior storefront appearance. The total cost for our food came to $24.00, which we was more than fair for the amount of food we were given. I would be willing to try something else and give this place another shot. read more

Oh my goodness! The food is amazing! The pizza is authentic, and the dough is awesome! We had an amazing cheese calzone and a New York style pizza....both, soooo good! Please try this place! read more

BEST SUBS AROUND!!! Size is great, bread is awesome, loaded with meat(s), price is good. Large will feed 2 people for sure. Employees are nice. Always clean. Definitely best sub in town, hands down. read more

MY FAVORITE CHEESESTEAK PLACE!!! Any cheesesteak I've ever gotten doesn't compare to Sal's. I love this place, highly recommend. The staff is so sweet as well & prompt with their service. read more

Sal's Pizza - Chicken Cheese Steak Hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

My wife loves this place. She has been going here for years and says it is the best sub she has ever had. The chicken cheesesteak was phenomenal. Their small size sub is about the size of a large many other places. I would say about 12 inches. The only thing I would change next time is I will ask for light mayonnaise. There was a generous serving of mayonnaise on my sub and I am not a huge fan of mayonnaise. Overall great service and delicious food highly recommend read more

Sal's Pizza - Chicken Cheese Steak - Pizza Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

Don't order the margarita pizza. It is the worst. They never ate this in Italy for sure! Other pizza's are better.

We wanted Pizza for dinner and we've just moved to Mechanicsburg. We've ordered from other places but they were closed and Sal's came up close to us so I thought we'd give them a try. Quick delivery and excellent Grandma pizza! Nice crispy crust that wasn't too bready. Tasty toppings. Excellent pie. We'll be repeat customers! read more

The food is always great here. Delicious pizza, subs, and wings. They also make a great antipasto salad.

So typical small pizza place including how much seating. The guy doesn't wip off tables. There 3 TVs if you dine in. The food is pretty good I got a steak stromboli it was huge for a small I wonder how big is a large. Mom and our friend Step shared a taco pizza and mom thought she got a side salad but it looked like a fancy dinner salad with garlic bread. So lots to choose from. The one guy was nice at the cash register. So main reason why 4 instead of 5 was could have done better with or without Covid please clean and have your mask up to your nose (cashier). One thing for a small place worth going to again. read more

This place should have more ratings considering most townies choose sals as their go to for pizzeria style food. The food is consistently delicious. Pizza is always on point. Subs are delicious. Customer service is spot on. If you're in the area and looking for quality pizza made by real Italians you won't be disappointed by trying sals. read more

Sal's Pizza is my favorite area pizza. I'm a huge fan of the supreme combo - it's the closest I've ever had to my fav childhood pizza (Gino Gianelli's in Greensburg), and its amazing. The staff is all amazing. Pete (the owner) know most of his customers by name and is just the kindest man. You can tell lots of love goes into the pizza, just like a true homemade pie from an oven in Italy! read more

Sal's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

Ordered a pizza tonight with extra sauce and two toppings, the sauce looks like it was applied with a paintbrush and the toppings were meager at best. Decent flavor and crust but nothing special. Disappointed. read more

Great margarita pizza and Italian sub! Will be back for both. Nice staff and decent seating area. On cold day, sit to the right, the door opening and closing (because popular place for takeout) made my wife cold when we sat down on the left. Moved to the right and no issue. We will be back. read more

Missing like three inches off each side of my sub. And $50 for wings mott sticks and basically half a sub?!! Says it has delivery but doesn't. I normally recommend this place to everyone. Don't know what happened here read more

Sal's Pizza - 15$ and I'm missing 3 inches on each side? - Pizza Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

My boyfriend and I ordered a hoagie for dinner. Normally we would each get one but decided to share an Italian sub. The large subs are HUGE and filled with meat for a very reasonable price. I was only able to eat 1/4 of it. Take out service was quick. read more