The best pizza and service in Rohnert/Cotati. Every time i go to Sal's they never disappoint. Even the pretty young gals are very nice. Sal service is on point you get that family feel inside. No pretty gals acting stuck up stuck on there cell phones giving attitude. Like you interrupted there conversation lol. The food is so good i think i would tolerate it, if service was bad. The crust on the pizza is very good probably the best I've tried ever. Ingredients all ways taste fresh. I wonder if there produce is source locally. I guess my wife feels different about the service. She has walk in to Sal's and got the complete opposite service. She said one of the girls ignored her for a while, focused on customers dinning in. That sucks $#%@* read more

Tried Sal's based on other Yelp reviews. Pizza was good, thin crust. Next time will try the sandwich but sounds like you must dine in to receive the salad or chips? Deterred me a bit for take-out as you pay the same cost... Ordered the half spinach salad, which was simple, spinach, dried Craisins®, sliced almonds and a poppy seed vinaigrette. Small seating area, which can be cozy but bad if it gets busy. Waitress was friendly, so overall good experience. Maybe they could start a punch card for frequent patronage? read more

Sal's Pizza is the best pizza in Northern California, I come from the East Coast where they throw the dough, Sal's Pizza throws the dough and has excellent choices, and excellent staff. Great place to eat. read more

I had a couple bad experiences a few months back and they handled it better than anybody could hope for in a similar situation. I wrote a negative review because my food was delivered late burnt and cold. When I called to check on the pizza before it was delivered and when I called back to complain I was met with pure apathy. So I write a negative review. The owner responded to me promptly and thoroughly. She took my complaint very seriously and made every effort to quell it. Since our exchange I have eaten here several times since and it has been excellent every time and the staff has been helpful. My only regret is that it took me so long to change my review back. Still my favorite spot in my neighborhood read more

Best. Pizza. Ever! Everything is made fresh in the restaurant, using as many organic ingredients as possible, and the staff are all friendly and outgoing no matter how hectic things can get. I try to stop in whenever I'm in cotati whether I'm hungry or not!! read more

Raw chicken!! Just went to dinner here tonight hoping for great pizza based off the reviews. Worst experience ever, we ordered chicken tenders for our young boys (6 and 3) which to my absolute horror I realized after several bites was undercooked!! So much so that it was literally raw in many of the pieces. I have never thought to check the doneness of Chicken tenders, how do you mess that up??!! I was totally disgusted and am completely beside myself waiting and worrying to see if my boys come down with salmonella poisoning. The waitress did comp our whole meal and apologized but the severity of the offense was not really acknowledged. No manager came to us. Avoid this place. read more

This hole in the wall joint packs a punch in their food. A must try for any pizza connoisseur. Definitely try the meat pizza-has pepperoni, sausage, meatball, salami and ham. It is amazing! Also, don't pass up the cheesy pesto twists and garlic knots or you will regret it. In total we ordered two large pizzas, two kids pizzas, salads, garlic knots, cheesy pesto twists and drinks-all for $100. Better than Chicago pizza at that price. Go and try it! read more

I've been coming here since before they were named "Best Pizza in Sonoma County." Quality is always awesome, ingredients are super fresh, and there's a good beer selection! Always a great meal.. the chicken parm is also awesome in case you need a change of pace. read more

Dropped into Sals on our way back from Russian River...kids were hungry we were all indecisive about what to get, so we got a little bit of everything...the food was absolutely delicious Robert was such a great host..we definitely left there with alot of food. Awesome service top with delicious food thats top #1 in our books. Definitely going back again !!! read more

See all

Pretty decent spot. Their pizza is alright and they have friendly staff. It did take awhile for the food to be ready, but I can't complain. I'm just not giving a higher review due to the place not wowing me. read more

so the food and service where beyond explanation. this is the most unprofessional establishment i've ever been, i went in for the first time and was treated horribly, the cashier who took the order needs to be re trained you dont eat and talk you need to give me your upmost service as your getting paid for it right? so i expect to be treated more as a customer and not like that. on top the terrible service you guys add insult to injury by condescending me and my significant other as we leave. save your time and money by going elsewhere this place is unprofessional and extremely rude read more

I am a huge fan of New York pizza but it's very rare to find pizza in California that compares. This pizzeria comes super close to the real deal. I highly recommend. They have cannoli's too! read more

Picked up a veggie pizza last night from Sal's. It was my first time. I've been looking for really good pizza since moving from Berkeley (really miss Zachary's inimitable deep dish). Sal's was great. It smelled just like the pizzeria in Boston we loved when I was growing up. Not sure what that particular smell is exactly (authenticity, care, ???) but you definitely don't get it everywhere. We loved the pizza, which seemed just right in every way....crisp edge, chewy bottom, nice fresh ingredients. Will definitely be back for more. read more

Thank you Sal's for making my day. Had a rotten day but their service, smiles, and awesome food made up for it. First time customer, definite repeat fan! We had the meat calzone and meatball sandwich and both were delicious. It's tucked away in tiny Cotati mainstreet downtown with very close and free (2 hour) parking. read more

Excellent Napoli-style crust, great balance on toppings, good service. Talked with the owner for a bit after, great place. Only issue is I went on a hot day, and in that regard it's a typical pizza place on a hot day... even hotter. Could use more/more active fans. read more

We've eaten here twice now with a peanut allergy. Very accommodating ... and very delicious. My wife enjoyed the lasagna. The pizza is authentic New York style. Our calzone was also cooked perfectly. Definitely returning again (and again). read more

So This is an Ode to the Pesto Sticks!!! I like to think I am a pesto stick aficionado.... these are the BEST I have ever had!!! And with their fresh Ranch and Pizza Sauce you can't loose!! Sooooo good!! It's a must get when your there!!!!! read more

I had a 14" with pesto sauce, cheese, sausage, artichoke, and chicken. It was great. The lady that answered the phone was polite and the delivery person was too. Sal's delivers within a 5 mile radius for a $3 surcharge which is reasonable. read more

Simple, delicious salads. My kiddo and I shared a calzone and it was very yummy. The small was actually quite big and more than enough for lunch and leftovers. Thank you! read more

First time going to Sal's and all I can say is it will not be the last. We loved the pizza and pesto bread sticks. The staff on the phone and in person were wonderful. If you have not tried Sal's you are doing yourself an injustice. Can't wait to try the sandwiches. read more

When I think about pizza, I think about Sal's! Love the Pesto Twists! Friendly place, great quality, quantity and price!

I'm not the huge pizza fans BUT I have to say this is THE ONE! Highly recommend this Italian restaurant ,it's a bomb!:)

The best New York style pizza in Sonoma County! I love the zesty tomato sauce so much so that I will lick it off my plate! The veggies have a fresh taste and they do not skimp on it. I always order take out and it usually takes around 20 minutes to prepare which is not bad at all. The inside of the pizzeria is not large which gives more one on one interaction with the staff. If you are craving quality pizza - this is the place to go! read more

Delish, got a large pizza, crust was nice and crispy. Everything tasted fresh. Love supporting the locals!

My husband and I recently moved to Cotati. We have had a lot of fun trying out all the restaurants in the area. This past Saturday we decided to try pizza and after reading other reviews of Sal's we had to try it for ourselves! My family is from New York and VERY opinionated when it comes to good NY style pizza. After trying Sals, I must say I was extremely impressed! We shared a house salad, pesto bread twists and a sausage, mushroom and ricotta pie, and cannoli for dessert. The salad was underwhelming but the twists, pizza, and cannoli were to die for! The pizza was cooked just right - crispy crust, ooey gooey cheese and the toppings were DELISH. I can't wait to bring my dad here who is from Brooklyn- I am 99% sure he will agree this is as close as you can get to traditional NY pizza. I would also like to add that our server was great! She was very friendly, smiley, and attentive. We will definitely be back with friends and family! read more

Great food and the best ranch dressing I've ever had! Service is great and friendly. The prices are reasonable. I highly recommend.

This is my favorite pizza place. When you walk it you just know this place is going to be good because it smells amazing. Every pizza I've had here tastes great, but my absolute favorite are the pesto twists. They're so good I could have them as my meal. Not a lot of seating inside but if it's not too busy you can get a table. Otherwise take out or delivery is how I go. read more

this place is small. the food is. not! meatball sub is huge and tastes awesome. if you eat inside, sandwiches. come with beautiful organic side. salad. dressings all homemade. plaza is slew arriving, all made to order. plenty of beers and wine. service always above avg. pizza is quality and topping is plentiful. I highly reccomend. read more

If you're an East Coast transplant like myself, you know that the West Coast is great, but their pizza sucks. Thank god for Sal's.

2nd time here in a few years and don't know why it took so long. Excellent combo pie, huge half house salad with a superb champagne vinaigrette and a healthy wine pour. Extremely friendly staff and owner, quick service and clean. Everything made in house and will be back for the lasagna soon for a nice comforting, cold night dinner. read more

Best pizza I've ever eaten. There salads are also very good as they have all homemade dressings......then get a cannoli for dessert. This place rocks. read more

Tonight was my 16th wedding anniversary. My husband and I have a very busy life with kids, sports, work, etc. We just wanted to have a nice dinner together in the small amount of time that we had. We randomly chose Sals as it is very close to our house and have never been here. We were served after 1 hour of waiting (a glass of wine was comped) the food was sub-par for the price. Calzone was crisp on the outside and cold on the inside and the lasagna was the same. Very disappointed. read more

Wow! Fabulous pizza, excellent service. The vibe in there has completely changed with the new ownership. I will definitely be coming here a lot! So happy to have a good affordable pizza place around. Highly recommended! read more

I have had a lot of pizza, but this place is by far one of the best I've EVER had. I had a pepperoni pizza and boy do they sure load in the garlic!! I also had an order of cannoli which was probably the best I've had and I'm ALWAYS looking for good cannoli. I will most certainly be back!! read more

The pizza here is downright amazing. That being said, the customer service is awful. Just order to go every time. I promise the pizza will still be delicious when you get home, and you won't have to deal with waitresses who don't want anything to do with you. read more

We went here because our friends have been raving about it & it has some gluten free options, which matters to me because I'm allergic (granted they prepare on a shared surface, so you are definitely getting some cross-contamination, which can be a huge no-go depending on your allergy level/type...but if you're pregnant & seriously wanting something resembling real pizza, you might *ignore* this, as an example). My husband ordered a 14" Combo & was totally thrilled. We shared a large Caesar salad, sans croutons, which was delicious & the dressing was obviously house-made amazingness. I ordered a GF meatball sandwich. Everything about it was incredible. I also ordered a GF pizza to go but had one slice in-house so I could taste it fresh. I ate some left-overs today (got it yesterday), and...not only is this hands-down the best GF pizza dough I've EVER had (I got a little suspicious about it for a minute, like it was too good to be true, honestly) but it actually still tastes amazing the next day, which I've never had happen with other GF pizzas no matter how decent they were initially. I believe I've tried all of the GF pizzas available in Santa Rosa, RP, & Cotati & can definitely say this is easily the best. It was so beyond wonderful to have what tasted, not only like "real" pizza, but an exceptionally made one at that! The ingredients are fresh (they also try to source locally, I noticed, which is awesome), they don't skimp on the toppings, the prices are great, & I think I'm going to have to go heat up another slice right now! I am SO glad we found this place! read more

We had our first pizza from Sal's the other night -- a classic Pepperoni pie. It was delivered in far less time than we expected (by Sal himself!) and it was delicious! Hope that Sal's is in business for a long time. We will be adding their number to our speed dial...! read more

One of the better Pizza Places I have been too!! Great service great product! Five Stars definitely!! Try the Pizza and go from there, you will not be disappointed. read more

Stopped in on opening day & ordered a pizza & salad, which was delicious! Went back a couple days later to try the cannoli dessert (wonderful) which I'd seen advertised on their Facebook page. Took home some chicken strips & garlic bread sticks for dinner later. All great tasting food & they have gluten free on the menu. Can't wait to try more & so glad to have them in the Cotati/Rohnert Park neighborhood of great little mom & pop restaurants. And they deliver! read more

This is the only place my husband and I will order delivery from. They are friendly and efficient. Their pizzas are high quality and delicious read more