Execution fresh sauce no burnt spot on the pizza all around 5 stars from EC (CKR SR.) BMMC DA BORO 07843 read more

See all

Good food good service and. While a little older in the restaurant it is a decent atmosphere overall. Bonus they sell beer! This place has been around for a long time always had a good local reputation. Nothing here is going to blow you away it is just a good local pizza place. Which is appreciated. read more

Close to authentic taste and mouth feel of Brooklyn pizza. Very nice staff, prices reasonable. And yes, back in the day, canned mushrooms were indeed a Brooklyn pizza motif, but it's 2025 any no one needs or wants those grey spongy things on their slice! Go fresh and it will make a difference! read more

People are nice, atmosphere is dirty, food is ok, service is fast. That's the best I can do. Next time I'll bring a fly swatter.

According to my niece, they have the "goodest penne vodka ever", very good pizza too! I've had a hard time finding a good pizza place, not many places have very good pizza anymore read more

Sorry Sal, I have truly enjoyed your food, but something has changed recently. Stopped ordering delivery after several mistakes. Ordered eat in meatball parm sandwich, very good as usual. Ordered take out sausage roll too. Brought home and found this. Hope you can fix issues, food has always been good... FYI, I don't usually do reviews. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Takeout sausage roll. Brought home and found bottom of roll burned to black. - Pizza Near Me - Stanhope, New Jersey

French fries smelled like old farts at a nursing home, pizza with was pretty bad and the place is outdated if you wanna eat food in a smelly 60s looking pizzeria go here read more

In town for a wedding. Needed a quick bite. Pizza was excellent. Shared a cheesesteak with onions and shrooms. Fresh mushrooms. Toasted roll. Very Cold beer. What else can we say! read more

We were driving through for business and we split a large cheese pie. You could really taste the quality and care that went into it. You can always count on New Jersey for great pie. Sal is a great guy. read more

My order was written down wrong and when i got there Sal was super apologetic and made sure it was corrected. He gave me the wrong items for free which he did not have to do at all and everything i got was absolutely delicious. We ordered a chicken parm pie with vodka sauce and it was accidentally made as a sandwich. But both as the sandwich and the pie were out of this world. We also ordered a Sicilian pie which was amazing. Would definitely recommend this pizza place. Best in the area read more

The food is great the service is very friendly and courteous and the ambiance is very home like family Italian oriented. Will come back here again! read more

Great pizza shop! Very small town but was delicious and the staff was incredible. I got the baked ziti pizza and had to stop myself from eating mire once I was full! My only complaint is how big the pizzas are. read more

the best of the bestgoing for years.the food is excellent. the food is alway hot when it's delvered, to your hiuse!!!.

I stopped by to get a ziti slice, and it was so good. Apparently, Sal himself served me and it seems like he gets to know his customers. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Ziti slice - Pizza Near Me - Stanhope, New Jersey

We've been going to Sal's for over 30 years and it's been fantastic every time. It's the first thing we have when we come back into town. Sal is always there turning out the pies. Service has always been great. read more

Classic, consistent and delicious. Great pizza. Sal is an angel and his staff are always great. They also do an amazing job with catering trays of food. read more

First I love the pizza. Tex Mex is my favorite. I love the calzones. My husband prefers the Italian dinners. Last night I had pasta Primavera that was to die for. My husband loved the veal Parmesan. A hidden treasure! We have been coming since he first bought it. His name is not Sals. That is the business name. read more

Great pizza and nice family business- always supply your local family owned business.

Sal never disappoints with any dish you order, whether it's pizza, an Italian dinner or a cold sub. His food is excellent and his employees are friendly and efficient. read more

See all

Delicious pizza, we really enjoyed the pizza and the service was great. Delivery was fast and the pizza was hot.

Yummy pizza and other delicious food, awesome service, super clean, I mean the pizza is so delicious, my favorite is bacon chicken ranch.

Sals makes great pizza and Zeppo's! A family favorite. We always eat here when we come to NJ to visit my family. The grandchildren really love the pizza. read more

Ordered from here, food was very good. Not interested in watching FOX NEWS. Bad choice for a business.

This place has gone downhill. Used to love it but recently in the past few months every time we order from them their pizza is soupy, super oily, and rushed. We received this pizza from delivery in the picture at 3 pm on a Saturday and it was not even cut in six like usual, it was cut in 4 so we had to cut it ourselves with the pizza slicer at home, and the pizza was falling apart! Plus it wasn't even hot when it arrived. Definitely won't be ordering from them anymore because they continue to disappoint. It was 3:00 in the afternoon why was the pizza such a mess? I doubt it was busy, and we only live about 5 mins from sal's. So wish this place was better since it's so convenient to home! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - a partially eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stanhope, New Jersey

Pizza is ok and only reason they'll get two stars. Calamari and wings extremely overcooked and inedible. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza is ok and only reason they got 2 stars. Calamari and wings extremely overcooked and inedible. - Pizza Near Me - Stanhope, New Jersey

Yum! I was in NJ for a couple of days and stopped in to this place because it was close to my hotel. The pasta marinara was so delicious. This marinara sauce is for the garlic lovers out there. It was so good that I ate my leftovers for breakfast the next morning. I wish I could have packed them up and brought them back to Charlotte, NC with me. Not only was the food good, but the staff was wonderful as well. read more

This pizzeria has a place in my heart. been going here for years. cheese, sauce, dough, all on point. just have a plain cheese pizza. amazing. read more

Go to pizza place when in the area. Grew up going here. Love the food and the staff. Always so welcoming. Good tastes great. Chicken fingers and ziti pizza are my favorite things to order. The pasta meals are also great. Always clean too. Definitely your classic/neighborhood pizza place. read more

Ordered the white pizza with tomato and basil. It was delicious. Loved how they swirled the ricotta around the whole pizza instead heaping it in certain areas on the pie like most others do. Crust was delicious only we wished it was cooked to crispy. I guess we'll have to do that with the leftovers. BTW we ordered a small which gave us 6 huge slices. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Stanhope, New Jersey

Easily the best pizzeria in New Jersey. I've been going here since I was 6 years old. And not only is their pizza perfect, all of there food options are amazing. The staff is awesome, courteous and loves to crack jokes. Go to this pizzeria and you will never want pizza from another place again. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - customers in the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Stanhope, New Jersey

Delicious food and the friendliest staff you'll ever meet. Sal brought out the freshest, delicious zeppolis. Yum yummm

A good pizza is hard to find! UNLESS you are looking at Sal's Pizza in Stanhope, NJ! I enjoy the puffy, soft crust! This is MY style of Italian Pie! The tomato sauce is 'molto delizioso' delicious! Herb spicy, almost peppery, not over salty! Again, to my taste! And the toppings! Traditional yet wonderful! I have enjoyed their meatball, their pepperoni, sausage, ham and bacon! I have had the meat toppings individually and mixed! I've always been satisfied! Their mushrooms, peppers and pineapple add zip and zest to a pie! When I have been fasting for a few days, and I plan to pig out... Sal's Garbage pie fills my empty belly! And I haven't begun to sing the praises of Sal's Pastas! Spaghetti, baked Ziti, calzone and Zeppole! Molte Bene! Do ya wanna enjoy good Italian without traveling to Naples? Stop at Sal's in Stanhope and eat up! I hear you can eat all ya want but never gain an ounce! --- well that's what someone told me! lol read more

Excellent light pizza with an airy crust....Cash only and the place is really outdated needs a restaurant makeover. Cant beat the taste. Light, airy with great gravy. Best ny stule pizza hands down. read more

Best pizza in town and they are always pleasant, a nice change from where I used to get my pizza. Sure, they deliver, but it's close to home so I can get it myself and say hi. Nice dining room if you want to dine in. Give their pizza a chance, support a local business that appreciates the customer read more

Ordered a large sausage pizza here yesterday. It was very very bland, no Taste to it at all. Paid $15 and some change for the pizza plus tip. And I was not happy. I rather eat Ellio's Pizza, at least the frozen pizzas have a better taste. It didn't take long for the pizza to be delivered but honestly it was not worth the time to order. This is the first time I didn't eat the whole pizza, I had 2 slices only because I was starving, and I gave the rest away. Will Definitely not order from here again when I am in the area. read more

Very good pizza ...im originally from hudson county where we have some great pizza and Sal's would fit in there no problem.

I am NEVER getting a pizza from Sal's Pizza in Stanhope, NJ ever again. I ordered a pizza with ham and pineapple and it cost me $20.75. It has hardly any ham and pineapple on it and when I called and spoke with Sal he said, "it was a dollar over. I'll give you $1 next time" and then said goodbye and hung up. WTF? Ok one I only spent $17 and change last time and it wasn't that long ago and two how are you going to give me a dollar back next time? You didn't take my name or anything. I am going to Carmine's in Netcong from now on. read more

I grabbed a cold sub to go. It was just okay I could have made the same thing with low grade grocery store produce and sliced meat. Also they don't take credit cards I had to use their ATM for a $2 fine. I really wanted some pizza but it looked like it had been sitting out since lunchtime. Gross. Very unlikely I will return. read more

Great place to eat, food is always cooked fresh to order. Prices are fair to most pocket. DSL & his Son can't do enough to make you feel like family. read more

Stopped here on our way to New York. Nice, friendly server. Great pizza. Fast and fresh.