We ordered pizza to be delivered to the dock at Timmer's Resort on Big Cedar Lake. Not only did they kindly agree to bring it right to the dock, the pizza was fantastic and very reasonably priced. The delivery driver was very nice as well. Will order again!! read more

Had heard that they had good gyros so decided to stop in and try. The gyros were excellent and so were the fries and breaded/fried mushrooms!! We ate in and found the restaurant to have a very pleasant atmosphere with awesome music. The staff was exceptionally nice and helpful. Would definitely go back and recommend! The prices were very reasonable as well. Good quality food at good prices! read more

I LOVE this pizza! I've been to Chicago, Italy and New York and Sal's is still one of my favorite pizzas. A slice, soda and garlic roll is just $5. The gyros are fantastic, too. You can have a stromboli made with gyro meat - it's very good. read more

You walk in Tell the person behind the glass where all the fresh pizza is ready. It's cool about 90% of the way and when you order your slice. They throw it back in. each slice gets a dough garlic knot. So buttery and good. So far I've had pepperoni, bbq chicken, chicken bacon ranch, and another. Not at the same time! Cheap Quick And excellent! read more

I've had some great pizza in my days and I'm lucky to say this place is close enough for me to drive to and enjoy the pizza. Price is right for portion sizes and if you need just a slice that will work too. Too bad it's not a bigger place. Adding a Gelato Bar would take it over the top. That aside, the pizza, onion rings, breaded mushrooms, mozzarella sticks and garlic knots will not disappoint you. Great pizza place. Enjoy. read more

I eat here when I feel like indulging. It's very greasy, but good. I have never been disappointed with the food or service. I recommend it if you're not on a strict diet. read more

First pizza by the slice place in West Bend. You can get a whole pie or just a slice. Each slice is served with one of their delicious garlic knots. Daily slices include things like hawaiian, lasagna, BBQ chicken, margherita, spinach and feta, plus your typical cheese, sausage and pepperoni. They also have calzones, stombolis, stuffed pizza slices and some pasta dishes. For about $3.50 you get a huge slice of pizza and a garlic knot. Enough for a meal. read more

Ok You know you like the pizza. New York style by the slice or the pie. Good pizza. I wanted a gyro. Not a lot of choices in the Bend. Sal's has gyros, decent meat, fresh tomatoes, onions, Tzatziki sauce. Pretty good when you need a gyro. read more

Had a great experience here at Sals. Called in an order for pick up. Pizza was done and hot right on time. Cannoli however was floury wasn't the best. Service was nice , pizza was great. read more

I was looking for a local pizza place New York style. I learned of Sals. Wow! Had sausage pizza and a cinnamon roll. Excellent. Thin crust the way I like it. Sauce is tasty not overbearing. Italian sausage was wonderful I most strongly urge you to have this pizza from folks raised in NYC. read more

Prices are reasonable for the amount of food you get! The fried mushrooms are frozen and they fry them, but they were yummy. You also get a TON. There are some interesting choices as well, and I enjoyed the barbecue chicken pizza. Great for a quick bite just down the block from where I work, so I'll definitely go back. read more

We ordered a Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza from this restaurant. The guy taking my order had no idea what he was doing and it took 5 minutes to place an order for a single pizza. The delivery time wasn't too bad, about 30 minutes. But when we opened the box, he must have tipped the box and the pizza had slid and crunched up on one side of the box. It was also clear that they didn't use any type of shredded cheese on the pizza. It looked and tasted like they put sliced velveeta cheese on top of this pizza. Overall, not a good experience and not good pizza at all. I will not be coming back. read more

I love the knowledge that when the hubs and I order a pizza from Sal's, we will not have to cook for days--- literally. I think the large pizza is 18 inches. Each slice is basically a meal. (I confess, I have eaten two pieces in one sitting, but I immediately slipped into a food coma and was stuck on the couch for a while.) The Vegetarian pizza has all kinds of goodness for toppings--- artichoke hearts, olives (green and black most days), tomatoes, mushrooms, onions--- Yum! The Stuffed Spinach pizza is pretty darn good, but I'd suggest asking for extra sides of sauce if you are getting a full pizza. The sauce has just enough salt to really bring out the flavors in the cheese and spinach mixture. I unfortunately don't have a lot of experience with the meaty pizzas--- my better half doesn't chomp on animals--- but did have one piece of some kind of chicken pizza. I probably wouldn't have it again as the chicken really had no seasoning. The garlic knots are yummy all of the time, but on very magical days they are super-duper garlic-y. Good times... It is really nice to be able to try a slice for a reasonable price and base your future whole pizza orders off of your experiments. Seriously, If there are only a couple of people munching on a large Sal's pizza, it's gonna be a commitment. You will have lots of delicious leftovers. Helpful hint for the day: To reheat your Sal's pizza you can cook one slice in your Toast-r-Oven OR if you are so lucky to own one, you can reheat two slices on your Pizzazz Pizza cooker. Either of these methods will get your pizza nice and warm and crispy! On a side note--- Sal's is the first place where I ever saw someone toss the pizza dough (you know, like they do in the movies!) and I think that is neat-o. read more

I know my pizza - had it from chicago to NY and this place was underwhelming at best...i understand the concept of pre made pizza behind glass but I feel the turnover here is too slow to justify warmed up pizza slices... The pepperoni was so greasy we has to drain it off before it was edible and the crust was soggy. Stromboli was tasteless consisting of processed chicken cubes and gummy mozzarella cheese with no seasoning what so ever and cold marinara with no means to heat it up, whats the point of having hit food with cold sauce. Garlic dough knots served with heavy handed garlic...way too much dough for one meal. Salad would have been great. Friendly staff but Sterile atmosphere . read more

nice addition to West Bend. when i came back home last time i was excited to try it out, and ended up going 3 times in my 2 week stay. Not the best quaility pizza i have encountered, but probably one of the better places in West Bend. Always nice to see non-chain restaurants here. read more

The best pizza around !! Also they have the best gyro around !! Service was fast and everyone was very nice! (You have had the rest know try the BEST)!!! Great saying on everyone's shirt that worked at Sal's!! read more

Love this place. Best pizza around. I especially like the unusual flavors. The Mac n Cheese and the Gyro pizza are simply the best. Would highly recommend visit when your in West Bend! read more

Sal's Pizza is a great place to get pizza if you're hanging out at Music on Main or if you're just cruising Main Street. The food is great and fair priced and although small, there is room for comfort. read more

Terrific pizza!! Really good. Reminds me of the good old days when first started eating pizza. Wish I would have tried this sooner. bw read more

We went here based upon the Yelp reviews, and we were not disappointed. It's a very casual, kid-friendly place. They sell pizza by the slice, and they are huge slices. I got the sicilian which is a deep dish one. It was delicious! Every order comes with a garlic knot which was also great. Our kids loved it too. The staff was very friendly and helpful as well. The delivery drivers looked pretty busy- a whole pizza must feed an average family for days. read more

I have to confess that I am addicted to Sal's Pizza. Every time I am in town I make an excuse to stop by. The pizza is great, and me and my husband can eat a full meal for $8.00. You can't beat those kind of prices. I have never had a bad slice and the people who work there are very sweet. Last time they gave me a free cannoli because I am there so much and they said they appreciated my business. Also they have homemade Gyro's that are awesome. read more

Had the most amazing pizza here the other day. Couldn't believe that I got a huge gyro slice of pizza, a roll and soda for five dollars. The staff was extremely pleasant and boxed it up for me to go, best pizza I've had in awhile thank you. read more

We now have another reason to come to West Bend besides visiting family. Having grown up in West Bend and lusting after the original Dick's Pizza, Sal's is a different style, but ohhhhh so good. As good a New York Style as it gets, and I've tried lots!!! Great crust and just the right amount of toppings. Don't change a thing. Our carry out order was great and a good value too. Nice people and very clean. Wish we had one in our town. read more

A massively large slice of pizza, a garlic knot and a medium sized drink, all for $5! Best deal in downtown West Bend. Not only are. Their slices of pizza big, but their large pizza's are massive and will feed a bunch of people. read more

I love Sal's for various reasons. 1) You can walk in and purchase a single slice of basically any kind of pizza on their menu. 2) They have unique pizza's that you cannot get anywhere else in town. 3) The combination of the two listed above reminded me of a visit in Southern CA I once had for the Margarita pizza had the same toppings and same purchase by slice (minus the garlic knot you get at Sal's with each slice). 4) Staff and owner is friendly. read more

Hands down the VERY BEST pizza I have ever had! Premium products used and the cheese is delicious, not all waxy from cheap shredded cheese like other pizza joints! It is a little on the greasy side, but hey, let's face it that's why it taste so good! Delivery takes a little longer but that's okay because the wait is definitely worth it! read more

Delicious pizza by slice or whole pizza. Loved the garlic knots and sauce. Supreme pizza was also very good!

I am from New York and by far the best pizza I have tasted in Wisconsin. This truly hits the mark. It is oily and greasy just like NY pizza should be. If the oil is not running down your arm it is not NY pizza and this one certainly does. Prices are reasonable. Fast delivery really nice people. I order a minimum of once a week. read more

Pizza is always great. Its good, pretty greasy but still good. Family owned which is cook. Friendly staff and a nice little outside dining area. read more

I picked the place somewhat randomly, the only requirement being that delivery was available. Pizza was excellent, but I wanted garlic bread. They have these rolls out of a can they brush with garlic butter and call them "garlic knots". I prefer the crunch of the crust of real garlic bread. I'll order the pizza again, but they can keep the garlic knots. read more

They really need to deal with the flies first and foremost. Still kinda the same, variations of their personal favorites/taste preferences, onions on everything (I hate onions, not a fan of pepperoni or sausage either). I was actually excited because the last time we were there, there was a slice of bbq chicken ranch left (my son's favorite) and what appeared to be a semi-veggie pizza, ham, mushrooms and green olive (MY favorite). The guys before us bought the last slice of bbq chicken, and the slice I got had like 2 mushrooms, was bacon (not ham), and green peppers (which I also dislike, not olives) AND onions. I ended up picking everything off, giving my son the bacon, and my garlic knot. They could probably save a TON of money making MUCH smaller pizzas to sell by the slice (cut way back on the crust or make it a replacement for the "garlic knot" they offer-as in a garlic/butter thick crust around the edge?) and offering MANY DIFFERENT combinations, little waste to experiment, personal preference aside (each pizza topping combo is an exact report of what people like, BUT, it's not to say people aren't choosing their "least disliked" combo in order to eat something, doesn't mean it should be continued to be 'pushed). The other thing; no one even knows about their offering of gyros, which, being from Madison, and one of my FAVORITE dishes, I KNOW would be a HUGE hit, def something different from all the other local offerings. But, the price for those is just a little too steep for me to take a chance (i.e. almost the same price as a small pizza). A lot of people actually DON'T like onions and a Lot of people DO like mushrooms, olives. I knew a lot of people love onions, but they mage me gag, just shouldn't be on every pizza Auf from deep dish pepperoni or sausage. read more

We eaten at Sal's twice and had pizza delivered several times as well. Really good NY Style Pizza. Consistent and delicious. Garlic knots are good as well. read more

Wanted to check this place out while visiting West Bend. We ordered cheese pizza but we were quickly informed "they are all out of cheese pizza". Huh??? Most likely will not return read more