My husband and I went to Salvatore's for Mother's Day. Excellent service (Lisbeth). We decided to order from the specials menu and we were not disappointed! The shrimp appetizer was one of the best and the salad was fresh. I had the shrimp alfredo which was enough for 2 meals! My husband had the salmon and pasta and the salmon was tender and juicy! Best ice cream sandwiches ever for dessert! read more

I ordered in the food at 2 and they said it would take 10-15 min and instead I got my food at 2:40but that isn't the worst part.the worst part is I ordered 8 chiken tenders tossed in bbq and I received five tenders with sauce on the side then I asked them to mix the sauce in with the chicken tenders and add the 3 tenders that where missing and I received a pile of unmixed sauce and 5 tenders again I do not recommend this place read more

I had what may be the best pizza I have ever eaten. Grandma's pizza with eggplant and artichoke. I highly recommend you give it a try.

Pizza was okay. Did not hold up after a while. Got soggy. I would highly recommend the grandma's pizza though. That was good. We ordered six pizzas and four salads, but the delivery driver didn't bring plates, napkins, utensils, etc. I had to drive back to the store for said plates, napkins, utensils, and I was charged $21 For paper plates, and forks. Pretty ridiculous when you place such a large order. I will not be a return customer. read more

Salvatore's Wood Fired Pizza - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Red Hook, New York

See all

This is my no fuss go to. I've never dined in or had their wood fire pies. I grab their slices to go and I'm rarely disappointed. I'm a huge fan of their Classic Grandma square slice. read more

Well, 5 years of decent food is not enough to not write marginal review today . Chicken bacon ranch square slice. It's always a delicious house slice reliable but Ok not what I hoped for . The chicken cutlet was dry and very tough, Like card board. Truly. Hope other customers back me up on this today. I had the second portion from the pan Ok, could've been great feed back but the server, by being ignorant actually said that's the way it's cooked . Like duh, bruh , we cook it twice. Hmm why don't other restaurants bake it that way Actually they don't. Dont you think the gold standard is fresh cutlets for a custom slice. should always toothsome and appetizing throughout the Process ? Either older cutlets or over cooked ones Either way a bad experience Thanks read more

I want to like this place a lot, but the service has problems. It's trying to be a takeout place, slice counter, sit down restaurant at once and the resulting vibe is confusing in all three directions. Generally, one person is handling the phone, the counter, and waiting tables - it's too much. Last night, I asked for a couple slices and a salad "for here." One slice comes out, with no napkins or silverware. It's cheese, it's great. Thirty minutes pass, I finally ask about the other food. The person at the counter says "you probably ordered it to go?" I explain they've already given me one slice and I've been sitting right in view for 30 minutes. They clearly forgot about the rest on a slow night. Eventually a decent salad comes out, still no napkins or silverware. I have to walk back up and ask for those and the person seems annoyed. Garden vegetable slice comes out completely cold. I love pizza, I want to love this place, but get the act together. read more

I'm not sure where the negative reviews come from here? But we stopped in for dinner today and thoroughly enjoyed our meal. Our server was enthusiastic and conscientious and attentive. The fried calamari were great, salads were well portioned and our pizza. (Verdura? sp) was excellent. The outdoor dining was super comfortable and the design and architecture of the dining room and outdoor space were very well done. Thanks for a great visit. read more

Any port in a storm as they say. This is a solid pizzeria, and they know how to make a pizza with a decent crust. The tomato sauce was well balanced, which is a very common weak spot these days. Luckily, they know how to make a sauce. I ordered the chicken roll instead of a calzone, not sure I made the right choice. It was very tasty, don't get me wrong, just more bread than I was looking for. The meatball sandwich was somewhat disappointing , mainly because of the role, which was to "bread heavy." This could be saved by a bread with a better, crunchy or crust. That said, when in Redhook New York and eating pizza, I recommend this place. read more

Salvatore's Wood Fired Pizza - Chicken roll (with eggplant) - Pizza Near Me - Red Hook, New York

See all

The slices are some of the best I have hade in a long time. The honey, jalapeño and pepperoni is out of this world.

On countless occasion grandmas pizza is delicious...tonight was absolutely dry with little to No sauce & cheese leaving me very disappointed. Consistency & not stretching profits by skimping is the only way to keep the customer. read more

Salvatore's Wood Fired Pizza - Receipt. - Pizza Near Me - Red Hook, New York

Just had a great dinner at Salvatores ... Not sure why there are so many h@ters here- food was great. Baked Ziti, Eggplant Rolatini, Pear salad, Garlic knots andwood fired brick oven pizza - thin crust. Service was equally good... read more

anyone giving this place less than a 5 star review is ordering the wrong food. Just get the grandma's pizza. And Sal's, prob just change your name to grandma's, thats the best thing on the menu and the only thing i'll order - but that alone is worth the 5 stars! read more

Horrible in EVERY way! Service almost nonexistent Food sucked Ambience loud and people were screaming and fighting Disgusting and unclean James the manager totally unreachable and later unreasonable ! DON'T GO there! U will regret it! read more

I wish there were a way to leave zero stars. This place is an absolute joke - came in with a large party and half our party literally had to get up and leave since they never had service. "Manager" James was no where to be found and didn't pick up the phone. Have lived in the area for over 20 years and I can honestly say this was the worst overall experience we've had. Avoid at all costs. read more

very very delicious. the ready to go slices are always fresh and yummy, and their garlic knots are to DIE for; super garlicky and flavorful. only complaint is that their tiramisu is more of a mousse than a layered dessert, as it had no lady fingers cookies. read more

Stopped here after visiting my favorite winery down the road, and believe me you don't want to pass this place up. I havent had pizza this good in along time. To soak up my alcohol, I had a corner BBQ chicken slice, when I tell u to die for, holy crap SOOOO GOOD. Then I had a regular slice, sprinkled some parmesean on it, again, so good. Definitely need to stop here for a meal and see what that's like, but as far as the pizza, the staff, the inside is really nice to sit too....I recommend read more

Food was very good. The waitress was very attentive and the owner Angelo was very friendly.

A favorite among locals on pizza night. Upgrades done to the place are nice. Service is curtious. I took a star off because the gluten-free pizza leaves much to be desired. This day and age gluten-free doesn't have to taste or feel like cardboard or leather. I would pay more for a quality crust! read more

Its a shame I could not have left a zero star. I ordered a large pie, and a meatball hero, and a Philly cheese steak. On the Philly cheese steak there was almost no cheese , peppers or onions. The Pizza was soggy !! As for the meatball hero, the sauce was quite sour and I could barely stomach it the following morning, I woke up with diarrhea due to such garbage. I would never frequent that overpriced and inadequate establishment again read more

This is the best pizza north of the city made with only the best ingredients. Been going here for years and I've never had a single meal that was not amazing. The hot honey pizza, margherita pizza, Sicilian slices, pepperoni, they do it all very very well. Their pasta dishes are also amazing and you can tell that they the ingredients are all fresh and high quality. It is a great atmosphere and the staff are all very friendly and welcoming making the experience even better. If you're in the area it is a must try you will not be disappointed with anything you choose. read more

Such a disappointing experience at Salvatore's last night. I came for dinner and ended up leaving before we ever got service. Understaffed and poorly managed - if you are looking for a stressful evening then this is your place. Go anywhere but here... read more

This place went down hill. We loved this place for years. When they moved, I don't know what happened. We have been ordering the same thing for 10 years +. One Large Pie well done, one Grandma's well done. The last 5 times we ordered the pizza wasn't well done at all, barely cooked . The 4 th time I checked it and told them to put it back in, it was almost raw. The owner was apologizing and gave me a gift card for one large pie. When the pizza came back out , it was awesome.. He told me next time I order, tell them well done and burn it.... Well, we ordered tonight and once again it wasn't cooked.... What The Hell....... Same people, same ingredients, they just don't care anymore. We are done..... there will not be a sixth time to waste our money in this place. read more

See all

Came here for lunch with family and friends. Amazing pizzas Gluten free custom made pizza Took care of my allergies Dessert nutella pizza was also delicious Great staff very friendly. read more

Being across the parking lot and in the new location is a big plus for this place! We had the buffalo chicken pizza and the margarita pizza. Both were good, but the margarita was really good. The crust on the wood fired was very crisp and flavorful! Our server was very attentive as well. read more

Stopped for lunch. Food was excellent! I had a gluten free pizza and the crust was crispy and tasty. My partner had the arugula pear salad and she loved it. The service was prompt and attentive. If you're in Red Hook, stop by! read more

We have been long time customers of Sal's but like most of the other reviews it was up until they moved locations everything changed. Customer service went down hill, did not cook the pie to what we ordered, and would tell us it will be ready in 25 minutes but apon arrival it would actually be over an hour or more wait. It's really sad because their sauce and pizza is very good, but each time recently when things would go south, I wouldn't even get an apology either. It's really not how you conduct a business. At their old location for years this never happened! Tonight was the last straw. I ordered a pie and I was told " we'll see you in 25 minutes, thanks for your order." When I arrived 40 minutes later thinking it wouldn't of been ready in time as it's a Friday night, and I knew it, it wasn't even ready yet and they told me it will be another 25 minutes. Making it an hour and a half to be ready after I called. I understand when it's Friday and places like any pizza spot will be busy. That's fine and understandable. BUT, to tell someone we'll see you in 25 minutes and that it would be ready then is not ok. To top it off, when I asked the young girl behind the counter "why another 25 minutes, you told me 25 minutes 40 minutes ago? " she then replied " I did not tell you that, I told you an hour and I wouldn't of said that." That is Completely false and wrong. I think she was trying to cover up the fact that my order was never put in. Either way, I didn't receive an apology from her or anyone, and best part is, when I left they gave me the wrong pizza and had to chase me out to my car and then bring it back in for the correct one. Sorry, but I would avoid Salvatore's at all cost. There are sooo many other options in Red Hook and in the close proximity that treat customers with sooo much respect, and if mistakes happen they atleast apologies and or throw in something as a kind gesture to make up for the mistake. Sal's did not and has not done that in a long time since the move to their new location. Shame on them. read more

Best pizza in the area, hands down. I eat here about once a week or so because I work nearby. I almost always have a pizza slice from the case which they heat up. My co-worker and I LOVE their pizza. My sister LOVES their pizza. Anyone I recommend this place to loves their pizza. Their meat lovers' is to die for. They also have a few veggie options and their Grandma's variety is de-lish. In general regarding the slices; the crust is chewy but not doughy, the toppings are always plentiful and the slices aren't greasy. One slice can probably fill you up but I've been known to have two. I usually down the crust too. They also have Italian food, and while I think their prices are a tad high for a small casual joint, I love their plain old spaghetti and meatballs (about $15 with salad). You can grab beer, soda or ice teas from the fridge. The place is cozy, comfy, casual, and has great service. It may be a little chilly in winter; dress warm. read more

Salvatore's Wood Fired Pizza - Spaghetti and meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Red Hook, New York

Calamari tough as rubber bands, Wood fired pizza is cooked in a gas oven. Alfredo not tasty and like paste, service and other food was good. There prices are high for a pizza joint, you can get better food up the road for the same price. read more

Although things are getting better on the delivery front, I'm still not thoroughly convinced that their products are getting that way too. Deliveries have been taking less and less every time we buy from there (to a point where yesterdays order was said to be at my place about hour from the time of purchase though it took 30-40 minutes instead, or a few times before this when the order arrived about 20 minutes later). I know things shifted when you dropped the third-party delivery services, but it seems something else changed because quality just isn't there. Yesterday, I had a chicken BLT sandwich that I was told was about a little more than a footlong. However, when it arrived, it was cut in half and placed in a cardboard box. It wasn't hot at all, and the taste just was unpleasant. The stringy lettuce kept falling off my sandwich, and so did some of the tomatoes which my doggie helped clean up at my home. The dressing (which was never mentioned) kept falling on my hands, and it just felt greasy. It was white and didn't clean away very well when washed. I know I live five minutes north of your current location, but there has to be more quality control on your items. i keep saying to my mom how I don't like Salvatore's yet when I'm asked (rather randomly) what I want from the restaurant, without being told where: I'm always saying "I don't want anything from Salvatore's" but I'm always pushed to get something more (in hopes that things one day will change)...just don't know when that day will appear. read more

Where do I start? The food was terrible the service was non existent and we were greeted by a big rat at the rear parking lot absolutely would not go there again read more

Have been here before with no issues, however our recent visit was an absolute horror show. Was going there with family to celebrate a milestone birthday but when we arrived there was no table for us. This dinner was arranged in advance to ensure the restaurant could accommodate us for our special celebration. The night was ruined due to the scene that unfolded by the rude manager. We were horrified by his behavior. If the owner is also the manager, there's no hope for this place. If James the manager is not the owner, he should be fired. We won't be returning nor will anyone else we know. There are many far better places to spend your hard earned money. read more

Absurdly understaffed. One girl to waitress, tend bar and answer the phone for takeout orders. Painful.

Single worst dining experience of my life. Spoke to the manager, James twice to make a reservation for a large party of 12 for last night. I even called to confirm. Walked into the restaurant and they had never heard of me. No table set up had no idea. It went from bad to worse and half of my family stormed out of the restaurant without eating at all they just couldn't take another minute of it. One young girl was answering the phone, taking orders, waiting on every table and making drinks.absolutely horrendous experience needless to say never again read more

Cant go wrong with a Grandmas pizza from here. Ordered for pickup and was ready in 20 minutes. You can get with toppings or the Classic. We got mushroom, broccoli, pepperoni, and bacon. Delicious, one of my favorite style pizzas in the area. read more

Salvatore's Wood Fired Pizza - a pizza in a box with a slice missing - Pizza Near Me - Red Hook, New York

Angelo loves his customers. He is super nice and a wonderful chef. Food is yummy as can be. Music selection could use a little work, but the staff make up for it in kindness. read more

We ordered a Pizza to be delivered on Friday, 8/16/2024. We were told 45 to 55 minutes. After an hour and a half, it had not arrived. We called and they "were so busy" and the phone person rude and unhelpful. It finally arrived an hour and 45 minutes after we ordered - cold. We live less than 1 mile away - how could it possibly be cold. They have lost our business. read more

The most unauthentic Italian food I've ever had - in 55 years. It's bland, the sauce is orange. The bread is some odd super soft, Wonder bread type of grossness . Ordered chicken parm which were only small, cut up small pieces of chicken not even equaling one cutlet. Then there was this fake white cheese smothering this mess. Why? Are you in business to cook Italian or something else?' read more

Love this place and have been ordering from here for years. I love the garlic pizza and the fried calzone.

Had the Eggplant Parm last night. It is by far the best I've ever had. Tremendous. I have had it many times but felt like I should tell everyone else!!! read more