What a rip off!! A medium pizza is the size of a frozen pizza. That used to be the size of a small pizza. So they are way over charging for what you get. Will never order their pizza again. There are many better ones out there. read more

Tough experience here. I called ahead for a larger party to see if it would work to come in at 8:15 given their published 9 PM close. The person on the call was very accommodating but we weren't so lucky with the person on staff once we arrived. We ended up leaving rather than feel like a bother. read more

2022 written revisit: for whatever reason, we love this place and it's one of our favorites in Eau Claire. Mainly, it's the friendly ambiance. There's a culture of constant friendliness here. It doesn't matter who's there, it seems. Also, we love their salads and salad bar, as well as their cauliflower wings. They make the cauliflower the way that you'd expect, but most places don't do it that way: you can get the sauce fried in or drizzled on top. Most places throw the sauce on after they're fried, which seems wrong to me. I want it baked or fried in. So Sammy's gets an extra star for that and for all the good-natured goodness or whatever you want to call it. read more

See all

Great place for good times with friends. Pizza? Off the charts good! Good selection of beers too! I'd say this is the best place for pizza around! read more

Service was great, and the food was fabulous.. Best pizza around.. So if you want the best pizza this is the place to go..

Soooo good. Pizza has crunchy crust, sauce is excellent, toppings are bountiful (we had the 4 Meat). Also had the cheese curds and they were crunchy, chewy, and even had a hint of squeak. Service was fast and friendly. They even had a great red blend. read more

Sammy's Pizza Restaurant & Pub - Dining room - Pizza Near Me - Eau Claire, Wisconsin

See all

Consistently been here over the years. The service is always FANTASTIC. Very cool vibe, great music, and the pizza is the best in EC in my opinion. Love the crisp personally. Excited to be back, and you should try them out. read more

Overall good tasting pizza. We got the double crust and it was so unbelievably chewy a knife could not even cut it. Felt like it was made two weeks ago and sitting uncovered in a fridge. I also don't mind squares, but 1.5"x1.5" is a bit ridiculous. read more

Sammy's Pizza Restaurant & Pub - 1.5"x1.5 pizza "slice" - Pizza Near Me - Eau Claire, Wisconsin

Ive eaten there 3 times over the last couple of years while visiting family. The pizza and broasted chicken is great. My mom loves it also. The servers have been great as well. Will be there again in a couple of days. Cant wait. read more

Pizza is amazing. Service was terrible tonight. Took an hour to get pizza, 20 minutes to even get waters for the table. didn't get our cheese bread, and they messed up one of the pizzas. They had 7 or 8 people cooking pizzas and 3 taking orders and handling the dining room. Will order for delivery. Won't be back to the location until service is fixed. read more

Posting a review based on your server. He was great, seemed to be the only one taking orders for the entire room and there were a few tables. Wasn't rushed, very chill. Think his name was Johnny. Working in guest service you can recognize who can control a room without getting frazzled. He was nice and attentive. Just thought you should know. We ordered pizza, garlic cheese bread, and salad bar. My son who barely ever clears his plate, cleared it that night! Good food, good service, we will be back! read more

Went there for pizza with my entire family--who are regulars and go there often, and frankly, I've also enjoyed Sammy's before too, but tonight... there was a metal screw in the pizza. I repeat, A METAL SCREW. Not only is this a health code violation, it could cause major damage to someone's teeth and/or internal organs. The best this place could offer? Comped one of four pizzas. You comp a pizza when maybe the service is slow--not when you've potentially broken someone's teeth. You can find me at Pizza del Re instead. read more

Excellent pizza but very expensive. The pizza is very thin with good quality cheese but one person can easily eat a 16" one by themselves.

I like to eat their pizza on a train and on a plane and I swear I am not playing. If you are looking to kick back with the homies and just sip on the brewskis while you hang with the broskis, Sammy's is where it's at. This place f*cks. Only recommendation is to turn on some music y'all, we tryin to eat pizza, drink spotted cow, AND turn up to Sinatra yo. All in all, Sammy's good. Life is good. :) read more

Sammy's has been a family tradition for 50 years! I've been coming for 25 years and now have to visit every time I am in town. My family always orders the Sammy's special. The thin crust, cheese, and sauce are amazing. No pizza compares to Sammy's! read more

Sammy's Pizza Restaurant & Pub - Half cheese, half sammy's special! Mm mm - Pizza Near Me - Eau Claire, Wisconsin

I ordered their brosted chicken dinner to be delivered from my hotel room, it was delivered in 20 minutes pipping hot, and delishous

Eh... first time ordering due to a coupon I received. Mozzarella sticks are amazing and still pretty hot even after delivery. However, got the Chicken Alfredo pizza and it's not the best. No sauce, but I'm not sure it would be that great even if extra sauce were added. Definitely want to try a regular pepperoni next time to decide if we'll be eating here after that. read more

Sammy's Pizza Restaurant & Pub - Mozzarella sticks and Chicken Alfredo pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eau Claire, Wisconsin

Amazing pizza commenting from this self admitted pizza snob. Best I've had in Wisconsin...and believe me I search as Chicago here lol. Made as I asked ... fast and just great. I will detour when near for sure any time I can for this pie !!!! read more

Sammy's is a Great place to meet friends or have a casual business lunch. They have an awesome and tasty buffet with pizza, salad, chicken wings, Mac and cheese, and a couple of different soups. The Chicken Dumping Soup has to be homemade, it's to die for. In the evening is your standard pizzeria with a bar in a private area. So if you're not into bars you won't even know it is there. If you're into bars it a very friendly place. Some nights you're likely to find entertainment. read more

We enjoy eating at pizza joints that are not big box chains and our local joint we usually eat at is under construction so we tried this place out for the first and the last time. I assume they only offer thin crust pizza because we were not offered a choice and that is what we received. The crust was thin as a piece of paper and still managed to be soggy and greasy. They couldn't even cut the pizza for us! We carried out and it was completed on time. Also ordered breadsticks. Which were also one star quality. read more

Two out of three pizzas were so burnt it was barely edible. The waiter was so slow it took ten minutes to get a single drink. Also the waiter couldn't get two receipts straightened out. read more

Sammy's Pizza Restaurant & Pub - The pizza was horribly burnt. Practically inedible. The waiter was horribly slow. Took minimum of 10 minutes to get a single drink. - Pizza Near Me - Eau Claire, Wisconsin

Called in an order to go- Pizza, garlic bread, and marinara sauce. Got there and paid for my stuff. Lady at register wasn't friendly. Once my order came up I got my pizza and had to ask where the rest of my order was. They asked me, "you had garlic bread also?" While I was waiting I was looking at their on line menu and noticed on Wednesday it is buy one get one free. I asked the lady if I could order a half off pizza as well. I was told "no, you already made the purchase." DO NOT SUPPORT THIS BUSINESS. 7-8 people in the back and two up front that don't know customer service well. read more

This review is simple. The . Very. Best. Pizza. Ever. We get extras to eat it cold for leftovers. We come through town several times a year and never miss it! read more

I was hanging out in Eau Claire and ordering a pizza became the thing we were going to do. Papa John's and Pizza Hut were suggested. Having had both unfortunate examples of pizza my wife and I were on the edge of desperation. We called a local friend and asked for a recommendation. She told us to go for the Sammy's Special, which was onion, green pepper and sausage. What arrived clearly blew the doors off of what either aforementioned chain had to offer. Sammy's delivery arrived quicker than they said it would. The crust was thin. It was tasty. Great pizza? No. Delicious? Yes. More power to them! read more

Great pizza! Enjoyable cheese curds but could had used a dipping sauce.

In my family all pizza is compared to Sammy's. My parents grew up here and then moved away, so we all get back to visit relatives about once a year. When we are in town, we hit up Sammy's 3-4 times. It is that good! The pizza is super-thin crust cut into squares instead of slices. The Sammy's Special with sausage (in cute little balls), onion, and green pepper is my absolute favorite. When it's just come out of the oven, the cheese goos off the slice. Good sauce, good toppings, good pitchers of beer. read more

Every summer when I return to Eau Claire I make a point enjoying Sammy's pizza. Their square cut thin crust never disappoints. Service can be a bit slow sometimes but the food is definitely worth it. read more

Sammy's is a classic staple in Eau Claire. Family owned, cozy and traditional joint. Really solid spot for families - we go here when everyone is in town. And their pizza is hands down the tastiest thin crust pie around. read more

We have been eating Sammys special for 40 plus year and have always loved them. Always been one of our favorite pizza's in Eau Claire. The pizza we had tonight was not the Sammys that we are used to hardly any cheese and way to much sauce. Will be thinking twice about ordering again. If we do and it is delivered like this again we will never order from you again. read more

I ordered from Sammy's twice. The first time was decent. Not the best pizza in the world, but worth giving a second shot. The second time it took 2 hours for the pizza to get to my house. When the pizza was finally dropped off it wasn't even close to what I ordered and half of the pizza was burnt. They then made me return the pizza (which then even the edible part has to be tossed) and wait another hour to get my food. No refund or any sort of compensation was ever offered. It's safe to say I haven't ordered from here since. Terrible customer service. read more

The lunch buffet is overpriced and the food is not very good. The pizzas out are small and overcooked with not much flavor.

Hello I ordered for the first time a cheeseburger and fries. He it delivered the cheeseburger and fries was great. Now the next time I order it will be a pizza. Dan Hanson from Eau Claire. read more

Thank you for bringing the Italian Gondola back. My alternate favorite is the Crew Special (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, extra cheese). Good! read more

Every ingredient is either canned or frozen including the cheese (frozen) mushrooms (canned) and sauce (canned). A completely canned and tasteless atmosphere follows this truly inedible food, watered down sauces and no true sense of Italian food, even in American sense. (Antipasto literally means "no pasta", their antipasto is a pasta dish with chopped up crap) A family favorite, none of the less, of many Eau Claire locals whom will never know a a truly great pizza thanks to places like Sammy's Pizza and Sammy's Pizza and Pub. I think you are better off enjoying the fare from New York Pizza and Deli on Water in pure take out form or even Pizza Hut. read more

The wings were pretty disgusting. They shouldn't be swimming in sauce and rubbery when you get them.

When I was a kid, I used to go and get a pizza and eat it all by myself! It was the best pizza I ever had. Wish you would build one in the South East Milwaukee area. Been a fan since 1976! read more

Sammy's is THE place to go for GREAT Pizza in Eau Claire! I have been a Sammy's customer for literally over 40 years. I had Sammy's every Friday night as a child. My Dad was a police officer who "bounced" for Sammy's, when it was downtown. EVERY Friday night after closing meant a Sammy's House Special Pizza enjoyed by my whole family. The leftovers were eaten cold Saturday morning at 7:00 in front of the TV, watching Popeye. Very fond memories remembered every time I enjoy a Sammy's Pizza, freshly made, or out of the 'fridge, the next day, cold, even to this day! Pizza doesn't get any better than this! Homemade ingredients, especially the sausage, with lots of gooey cheese! Yummmm :-) read more

Yuck. There has to be better pizza places in Eau Claire. Terrible, slow service. Took over an hour to get our orders. I ordered a cup of soup and it was lukewarm and it was really icky. It looks like they just opened a can of Campbell's soup - not worth it. The pizza was pretty good, but I am not sure if it was because it is actually good pizza, or if it was because I was starving and ready to gnaw off my own arm. Kind of shoddy decoration on the inside, the furniture in there is kind of rickety and the bathroom was positively filthy! I am really not impressed with this place. read more

Pizza was average and not memorable. Place looks very dated and in need of a fresh look. I was there during lunch hour and took pizza home. On the other hand it was busy with families so I might be in the minority. Will likely give it another chance at some point. read more

I used to live in Eau Claire and loved Sammy's pizza. Now when I visit, which is often, I have to get eat there. I love crust. My favorite is a basic cheese pizza. Love it! read more