I've been going to Sam's since I was a kid, and it still feels like a treat every time.Warm, wood-paneled atmosphere, cozy booths, and thin (ish)-crust, New England-style pies. Under new management for the past few years, it remains, to quote Talking Heads, same as it ever was. Which is a good thing. read more

Mom n pop spots are always the best. When u walk in, you really feel a welcoming vibe. Food was great and so was the service..portions are very generous as well. Enjoy!!! read more

Love Mediterranean pizza and mussel with white wine sauce. My friend obsessed with the mussel. Good service and really helpful. Good for the easy dinner night out. read more

If you want a regular normal unpretentious pizza, pasta and are sick to death of the affected folks who come to town, Sam's is perfect. Old school italian American eats...thank goodness it has survived because they don't kneel down to "Potter" LOL! read more

Great food..quick service..friendly staff..will definitely return..buffalo chicken wings would be a great addition to the menu

Sub-par food that was barely edible. Service was slow and the waitress was icy. If you like eating at the Olive Garden, this place is several steps down, and you will probably be disappointed. If you are a Chef Boyardee type, maybe it will be to your liking. I wish we had something better to say about this place, but it was an absolutely horrendous meal. The only plus was that it was cheap. read more

Pretty great pizza for take out. Just don't make the mistake of eating there! So many loud and unruly kids running around- it's a loud and unpleasant ambiance. I know this is obviously not the staff's fault but there was garbage and food chunks all over the floor from a particularly obnoxious table next to us- some people really have no manners. read more

I've given a review for Sams before, I go here frequently it's my 14 year old daughters favorite restaurant, I like to say pizza pasta salad, they are all quite good. My favorite is the salads, there are over 10 different salads and all of them are super fresh with the most amazing homemade dressings, grilled shrimp or grilled chicken can be added to any of them. The pizza menu is extensive and built with years of expertise. I'm a linguine and white clam sauce person and there version is the best I've ever had. Hamptons summer the place is jumping, no reservations. Nice bar you can eat and drink at with two of the best bartenders in the Hamptons. This place has character, it's been in business over 70 years , and it's also inexpensive which is rare in the Hamptons. One thing it can be a little noisy early in the evening with families with young children be prepared, it settles down as the evening progresses. read more

Good pizza Nice and friendly people service was excellent

This old standby has great pizza, salads, beer, and often excellent specials like lobster rolls. Sam's is a real local place, family friendly and unpretentious. Often crowded especially after movies during the summer, but bigger than it looks so seating is often faster than you would expect. read more

Sat right down on a busy Saturday night. Very old school 60's style bar and restaurant that was clean, family friendly, warm and inviting. Got the pizza, and wife got Chicken Parm and both were very good. Will return! read more

The food here is really good. It's a casual dine. They charge for individual soda drinks which irks me at any restaurant. The service is a bit slow. We waited for our check for about 20 minutes after we finished eating. read more

This place is very cute from the outside. The hostess was not very friendly or helpful. Our server was great and attentive. Pizza was good. Nothing to write home about. read more

We went to Sam's to get a pizza. OMG wast very delicious. We love the local people too. Nice place, we will be going back soon!

I love the pizza here! It's a great little restaurant if your looking for a cozy and yummy meal. Their pizzas are thin and crunchy, which I like. They have many pizza options, as well as typical Italian meals. The reason I gave it 4 stars is because they could put more love into the restaurant. Some of the decor and furniture are a bit tattered and the place could use a little bit of a face lift. I haven't been there in a while (over a year), so they may have spruced the place up a bit while I was away. But in general this is a nice place to go for dinner. read more

The pizza is not good and everything else is worse. The decor looks like its from 1978.

Honestly I cannot day enough about this family friendly place! The pizza's are awesome and the salads are great too! We like to go at 5 when they open to get a seat! Everyone is so nice and the owner is the best! I go for a drink and sometimes order take out and the drinks are so good! I love all of the food at Sams read more

Great pizza. If you're in the mood, you don't need to think about it long, this is your place. Great price for great food. Greek salad had fresh and delicious ingredients. The TNT pizza was a cosmo of pizzas and delicious. A large was more than enough for two with leftovers for tomorrow. Only holding back a five star because it wasn't "unforgettable," yet I still have no regrets and easily recommend it. If you don't want to over think dinner, go to Sam's. read more

one of the tastiest pizzas i've ever had, and the tiramisu was great as well. I wasn't even hungry when I went to Sam's just because of the good reviews and I ended up eating a pizza and ordering the same for takeout as well. Must go if you are in East Hampton ! read more

We stopped in for lunch on a Saturday afternoon...small selection of good draft beers, delightful bartender/waitress and delicious pizza... Will definitely be back read more

The food was good, it wasn't great but for a casual place...its decent. I do think the restaurant is a bit run down and as for value ...there is none, but its the Hamptons so I guess its expected. read more

Must be newer owner since I was last there several years ago, just didn't have the feel of the old place. Food was OK! read more

Received raw chicken Parmesan. Asked the return and they gave us a hard time. Wouldn't take it off the bill. Will not return.

The key here is to understand where you are going. It probably hasn't had one remodel since the 70's which is crazy talk. It's dark inside and somewhat dingy. I have eaten in the place once only to say 100 times, never again, never again. Too many kids, yelling and running around. Parents weren't helping the situation at all. I only had pizza, which is fine, and it was good but I have to question whether or not the place is clean. To me when a place is so dark it only means they are covering up filth. I've spoken with other friends about it and they agree that it's not the cleanest place. I also don't understand how it opens at 5pm....they would probably do well during the day since there isn't any other good pizza in town. May not ever go back. Too bad, so sad. read more

Sam's is a cozy classic. Comfort Italian and casual family atmosphere. Great pizza. Solid pasta dishes.

Love The place . Food is excellent and service is outstanding viisiting from finger lakes area going back for second time this week

I am not a Pink Elephant-Hampton type fellow so I appreciate a restaurant that is down-to-earth with great food. The only con I can think of is that they don't take reservations and are extremely popular. One of the MANY pros I can point out though is that they make some of the BEST pizzas I have ever enjoyed. A true small town restaurant with great service that has tasty food. Enough said. read more

4 stars for the terrific thin crust pizza made the same way since Sam opened the place in the late 40s. Nothing else is notable. Not inexpensive but its a far cry from a dive. Decent service, good beer, no reservations and always busy in season. Unfortunately, Sams descendants who still own the building have it for sale. read more

Reliable, consistent, and Graham and the staff are very friendly. Portions are generous, food is good, and the pizza is exceptional - thin crust, make your own. (Try mushroom, goat cheese, and hamburger!) read more

Perfect spot for a relaxed family dinner. If you're looking for something shmancy or super chic, Sam's is not for you. Otherwise, the food is great and it's a classic EH spot for a reason. read more

One of my favourite places in EH. Food is excellent. Ambiance is authentic and the location is excellent. Try the Greek salad with chicken for a healthy but amazingly tasty meal read more

Went here for dinner on a busy Saturday and although we had to wait 40+ minutes (which was to be expected) the food was great, the service was also quick. If your in east Hampton and want some good Italian food go check this place out. read more

Awful customer service. Rude rude rude. But the pizza was good!

I have to say that Sam's was an Oasis in the desert of East Hampton...what a great little place to grab Lunch and a Beer....I had a fabulous Lunch Special of one of the absolute best Lobster Rolls that I've ever had, served with Cole Slaw and a nice dill pickle spear for the LOW LOW price of $15.95....IN THE HAMPTONS? GTFO! I've had Lobster Rolls at the famed Lunch Box on Montauk Highway on the way out to Montauk and they aren't quite as good and I paid $37.50 each....ridiculous....GO TO SAM'S! read more

its an old school pizzeria thats been there forever and it has decent salad and pizzas! it was better when you didnt have as many options but now i tend to rarely frequent it! perfect place when its raining outside and you wanna have a quick bite read more

Had a great meal here with the family. local favorite in east Hampton for 40 years and I see why. worth a casual visit food was delicious...

Cozy atmosphere, affordable and solid pizzas = winner for me. My family and I have been coming here for years now!

The absolute best Italian restaurant in the Hamptons. Their salads, pastas, and pizzas are to die for. Consistently delicious! Service is always great. Lovely casual atmosphere, a local's favorite! I would recommend them to the moon and back! read more

Great food... I always go for the Sams special pizza (no anchovies) and it never disappoints. Each meal is a two or three bucks overpriced but that's East Hampton... if you want casual, good Italian food in East Hampton, then this is your best bet... an establishment with character, and quality meals....be prepared: the service sucks, but the food makes up for it. read more

Love the pizza & ambiance here! Plus saw Andy Cohen there last summer :)