On vacation here in East Hampton and wanted pizza. Called in a pick up order to Springs. Friendly and easy conversation! Pick up was same. Pizza was delish. read more

Springs Pizza - Large cheese/meatball combo - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

This is a really great pizza place in the Springs. We've never dined in, but we order out all the time and their pizza is very consistent. Try the buffalo chicken pizza! It has just the right amount of buffalo sauce without being too overwhelming. Their mozzarella sticks are also great. Their service is good and they do have a small number of tables if you want to dine in. read more

I'm local, sometimes they do a great job but every time I order out there is a problem. Tonight I couldn't get thru by phone. When I went in they apologized. I ordered a spinach mushroom pie. No spinach. I ordered a small arugula salad instead no arugula. I ordered a grandmas with easy cheese, I said it 3 times. The thing was loaded with cheese, I picked 1/2 off but now it's not worth the 30 bucks. I know it's summer and we've been raped enough but come on guys. read more

love their pizza and eggplant parm hero ! great pizza for takeout! We will keep coming back.

Great food from a small local place. We take out regularly. Everything is good. Pizza, pasta and delivery -- try it.

Stopped in Springs Pizza today for lunch and had an outstanding meal. The pizza was cooked perfectly! Great undercarriage with a satisfying crunch. My favorite slice was definitely their bee sting. Pepperoni and hot honey go so well together! Also, the service was awesome. read more

Springs Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Our go-to place for ordering pizza. They have several specialty pies that we like to try. One of our favorites is the Buffalo chicken. The veggie pie is loaded with veggies and plenty of cheese! Went to pick up an order on a Friday night recently and it was so busy; people were picking up orders and ordering slices to go. It wound up taking about 30 minutes for our order, a bit longer than quoted. read more

Springs Pizza - Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

When you have a kids, or kids at heart in your group, pizza is always a safe bet. This pizza spot is off the beaten path but well worth it! We got plain and mushroom and it was delicious. Great pizza at $3/slice. Really can't go wrong. We took it to go, but they have tables to dine in and delivery. I also saw some garlic knots that looked awesome which I'll try next time. read more

Springs Pizza - Menu May 2022 - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Fuhgeddaboudit! I literally live 15 minutes from Springs Pizza and I'm still eating over an hour for my delivery. What's worse is they don't answer the phone and there is no way to contact them. Just pass - Pepperoni's is right down the street and at least their employees are paying attention. One bite, everyone knows the rules - unless you never get the product in the first place. Hard pass read more

The ice cream is good and fairly priced vanilla, chocolate and cannoli. The box is nice too. The sauce was surprisingly decent. We picked at the cheese and sauce and put the rest outside. During the night some starving deer had the misfortune of discovering the oil soaked burnt yet still doughy slab and its contorted garlic soaked brethren which we were happy to see disappear. read more

Springs Pizza - The deer ate the garlic knots and 6 slices of a grandma pie from Springs Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Really enjoyed our pizza (eggplant and meatball) and salad. Generous servings. Prompt delivery, too.

Dear springs pizza, What happened? U started the summer off strong with a great pizza. Last night I ordered cheese pizza and a Greek salad. Pizza dough was like cardboard. It was a dense flat bread with toppings that looked like it only went in the oven to melt the cheese. There was barely any sauce under there as well. I love cold pizza too but there was no way this pizza would hold up for the next day. The Greek salad was over dressed and soggy. The onions, lettuce, tomato and even the olives were drowned in dressing and was neatly covered by an unsuspecting layer of feta cheese. Ah springs. Don't do this to yourself. Get your dough game back! I know the season can get to you but finish wrong! read more

The pizza is amazing. The best pizza on the east end. Their Bee Sting pie was mentioned in The East Hampton Star. Their other food options are great like their Strombolis, chicken rolls, and chicken pesto focaccia sandwich just to name a few. They also have chicken tenders and fries and cheese burgers that are delicious. Definitely stop by if you're ever in The Hamptons! read more

Great pizza, super friendly staff. They recently got new pizzas, a menu with DECREASED prices and I heard their heros are really good read more

See all

Delicious Grandma pizza, fried calamari and the garden salad was one of the freshest we've had in a long time! Highly recommend this place if you're in the neighborhood! Friendly and attentive service too! Cozy and comfortable booths to dine in also. read more

My niece found chicken fat in her chicken tenders when we were on vacation here, other then that it was pretty good.

Love the cheese pizza. Always fresh and yummy! Crust is amazing. We order take out once a week. I have never ate there but it looks nice and clean. Service is fast. read more

Well, they are 2 for 2 with takeout and pick-up orders. They never get the order correct! The first order, they forgot the salad. Last night, and I ordered on-line so it's 100% accurately ordered, I get a chicken parm hero vs a chicken parm dinner. It was a Friday night, and they said they were busy, they delayed my pickup by 1/2 hour. So I went they suggested and by the time I got home, my pizza was cold and limpy!!!!! It was ready earlier than they said because it was sitting between other pizzas on top of the oven. For a pizza place, the food is solid, I give them a B, but really frustrating that they never get the order correctly! read more

They don't look at online orders till I went in and reminded them. And we were not the only ones who faced this issue. If you need your pies within an hour, avoid read more

Ordered take out -pizzas - peperoni, grandma's, frankie's, spaghetti & meat ball, eggplant parmigiano, pizza wheel, wings and the house salad few times when it rained last week. Hands down the best place! The salad is so fresh, and vibrant taste of the lettuce makes you want more. The tomato sauce is lovely , you can taste the olive oil in it and the meat is perfectly seasoned. A definitely must try kinda place. If I did not have to travel to Cincinnati, I would have taken the pizza dough to go. The staff are very nice as well. The ocean air and the water plays a huge role in the makings of this simple no frill delicious food. Give this place a try, esp the salad!!! read more

Our first time trying Springs Pizza. Ordering online was easy but unfortunately our order got messed up due to a system glitch. John was extremely responsive and took care of the situation. The pizzas were good and we would come back again next time we are in town. read more

tl;dr: if you like mediocre pizza with a side of racism, this is the place for you. Let me paint you a picture. A man orders a pizza. He doesn't pay for the pizza, which will be paid for when it is picked up. His fiancé and friend go to pick up said pizza. This has never been a problem in the past. His fiancé is driving the car, so she pulls up and asks her friend to run in and get the pizza. The friend goes in, says "I'm here to pick up the order placed by [exact name of person who ordered]." But the people working in the pizza place refuse to give him the pizza. If you think it's odd that someone thought a man would steal a pizza that he STILL HAS TO PAY FOR, you're not alone. However, perhaps it won't seem so odd when I say that the friend who went in (a graduate of a top 10 university and law student) is black. Perhaps you also won't find it surprising that when I (a white woman who was clearly not the MAN who ordered) came in to pick up the same pizza after they refused to give it to my friend, I was given no problems whatsoever. If you, like me, don't tolerate racism in any form, do me a favor and go to any of the other local pizza shops (there are 2). If you don't care enough to go to another shop and instead would prefer a slice of mediocre pizza with a side of racism, this is the place for you. read more

They raised the price a lot and it's not worth $39. It's only, chicken, peppers, and onions. read more

Springs Pizza - $39 for Chicken, peppers and onions, and this pie is not large. - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Nice, easy and effortless pizza shop. No frills but amazing service. Staff very kind! If you're looking for an east coast pizza shop this is it. read more

Had a more disappointing experience after straying away from the delicious everything pizza. The marguerita pizza was blan. The chicken wings were the skinniest things I've ever seen. The Caesar salad was delicious but the size large was pretty small. The chicken parm was tender, good, and came with two decent size pieces with linguini. They no longer have calamari. Perhaps in the future I'll get the everything pizza and the chicken parm. read more

Always the best pizza. Buffalo chicken, meat lovers, I've even seen Hawaiian pizza here. It's a gem in the rough for Springs eats

This is my go to pizza place. Amazing pizza & amazing staff. Ambiance is amazing. Anyone who takes the time to give this place a bad rating really needs to reevaluate their whole life. I love it here I would give it 10 stars xx read more

Best pizzeria in the Hamptons! The food is amazing there's no one like them out there. The pizza has so much flavor and comes out amazing every time. The staff is super friendly and very welcoming, always so helpful with anything that their customers need. There are so many options in their menu to chose from and every dish is delicious! This is the best food spot to be at anytime with family and friends, the vibes are great and it is always a positive environment. Springs pizza forever read more

Springs Pizza - a pizza with tomatoes and spinach - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

For the lactose and gluten intolerant, this place will serve your needs and for everyone else, you'll enjoy a well executed, classic NY pizza. read more

waited over 90 mins for our online delivery order and had to ultimately go to the store because the phone number was not in service- food wasn't even being prepared upon arrival and had to wait another 30 mins. Workers were rude, arrogant and laughed at me. They feel they have a monopoly in the Springs and it's unacceptable. Never giving them business again. They refused to give a refund or partial credit. No customer service skills- they didnt have any pizza left to order through counter service and their bathrooms are filthy. Mismanaged business. Disappointing. read more

Came in and ordered a margarita slice extra crispy. Made to order..quick and most of all great. We ate inside no rush very attentive very clean. Most of the dining places out here are too trendy This spot hits the spot..don't miss it! read more

Hard to believe that a place under new ownership could make such a bad impression on customers that have been in the area for over 30 years. Loyal customers of the old ownership, lovely lady who took care of us every time we came down. Even if we were late arriving at our cottage she took our order. The new idiot owner doesn't know what a grinder is, what a sub is, what a hero is, and thinks it's a big deal what terminology you use. They used to offer 1/2 grinders but now, despite the old menu in circulation they act like they don't know what you're talking about The girls behind the counter have no clue what they're The old owners were lovely to my wife. Now Take-out salad dressings left loose to leak all over the bags of takeout food. Left out the pizza order that we had paid for.. Had to go back for the pizza. Being the owner of a deli and a lawyer I have to say people who are in the food business should know better. Hopefully the new owner will have a short stay and a new owner will get our business again read more

In my opinion, I found the salads and the pizza are not as good as the other restaurants in the area.

Is it the best pizza in the Hamptons? Probably not. Is it the best spot in Springs for many pizzas cooked up in 30 minutes to feed a hangry share house? Absolutely. read more

This spot is a hidden gem!! And serves up waaay more than just pizza!! Ordered a bunch of the pastas: fettuccine Alfredo, penne alla vodka, and raviolis along w/pizza, Cesar salad, garlic bread, and fries! Everything was FIRE aka damn good!! It was so fresh and there were enough food for leftovers for a couple days!! Highly recommend, thank me later!! read more

Absolutely horrible, it is a shame that this pizza place became so bad,because both previous owners were great.

Coming from Brooklyn, it's rare to find slices and pies that are comparable. Honestly, Springs Pizza is even better than some of the renowned spots in the City (and definitely one of the better options in the local area). Their pies are always fresh and there are so many options for the many dietary needs these days. Highly recommend that Springs Pizza is on your go-to list if you're in the area! read more

We love love the pizza here. Just be very specific on what toppings you want on vegetable pizza sometimes they include eggplant and sometimes they don't. Their pizza is amazing and well priced. read more

We had delivery on Tuesday night. I ordered a cheese burger and it was not a burger! It was literally a smashed meatball on a bun. My dog wouldn't even eat it, it was insanely salty. The only thing they tried to get right is the medium rare on a meatball . read more

Springs Pizza - Cheese Cheeseburger - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

The pizza here is fantastic it's a hidden gem north of main st in EH, the food is excellent and the service was outstanding.