I walked into Sarge's Blvd Pizza absolutely starving, and as a firm believer that when it is good it is great and when it is bad it is still pretty good, I was relieved to find out these slices land firmly in the good category. Actually better than good. The slice hit the spot immediately with a perfectly crispy undercarriage supporting a cheesy and saucy top. Exactly what you want when you are craving a classic New Jersey slice. I would go back without hesitation. Pizza well done. The gentleman behind the counter was awesome too. He was friendly, welcoming, and clearly proud of what they serve. The place itself has that old school charm with the countertop front and center, the kind of spot where you stand, fold your slice, and enjoy the moment. Overall it is solid pizza with a great vibe and truly worth the stop. read more

Local Italian Bergen County staple. Community gathering spot, comfort food destination. read more

Forget hip pizza spots or chain pizza locations. IF YOU WANT REAL PIZZA! You just found the right spot. This is Brooklyn style pizza located in New Jersey. This place is the definition and example of what is "OLD SCHOOL" pizza. Sauce though a bit too much oregano is spot on for flavor. Cheese is real and not the cheap greasy cheese chain pizza uses. The dough is not thin crust and not fluffy pizza it also is spot on. If you're fortunate enough to live within 20 minutes from Sarge's you hit pizza lotto jackpot. Service is above average even from the owner (don't fall for the bullshit negative post) and entire staff are just pleasant people. The ambiance matches the pizza "SPOT ON" for old school, so much so that I eat and remember my youthful pizza experiences with friends. Flavor just awakens good memories. DO YOURSELF A FAVOR! Order, Sit, Shut up and Eat. You're welcome... read more

If I could leave a zero, I would. Very disrespectful owner. It's a very hot day outside, and I wanted a slice of pizza. The owner demanded to quickly close the door since the "A/C" was running. As a first time guest, I was looking at the menu, not even for 2 minutes, stated either I order, or leave. Will never return. Absolutely ridiculous behavior. read more

It's not just pizza, make sure to try out their pasta too! I got the penne vodka and added grilled chicken. The chicken was tender and juicy to perfection! Moreover, the portion size for a roughly $13 pasta is VERY generous! If you are looking for a good price and looking to leave with a full stomach, then this is the place for you!!! read more

Don't understand how this has good pizza reviews. Rude customer service and greasy pizza. Skimping on ingredients. What else is there to describe? read more

We were in town from Upstate NY for the Yankees/Dodgers series and were looking for a good neighborhood pizza place. Sarge's did not disappoint! The prices are very reasonable and the pizza was outstanding! We definitely recommend a visit! read more

Frankly this place has been a staple within Ridgefield for many many years and has always been excellent when it comes to taste and price. I have memories with the place even getting a free slice when talking with friends when I didn't have any money. Even after the entirety of the pandemic the prices have only raised a dollar within the menu. Only problem would have to be the space of the area only housing about 24 people. read more

Sarges is the best pizza in town. Been buying for years. Chicken wings are the best. Their baked zitty is amazing. I recomnend them 100%.

Order pizza froM this placeC and it's amazing, sauce right on the money, cheese excellent read more

Sarge's Blvd Pizza - Pizza Ham & Pineapple - Pizza Near Me - Ridgefield, New Jersey

Excellent chicken sandwiches. To die for Pizza was good. Service on time very polite. Recommend highly

I have been ordering delivery from here for quite some time and over the years. And would like to inform you all that this place has always been consistently satisfying and reliable. Delivery time ranges from 35-40 mins. Prices are highly reasonable for all of their food items. Sandwiches are always fresh and filling. Their pizza I wouldn't say is the best in the area, however, it is still not ruled out if I am in the mood for it. I must say, they make the most AMAZING mixed wings. I am completely obsessed with the sauce that are on these bad boys. Simply delicious. Easily, these are the best in the area. I can almost never resist ordering them from this place because they are THAT GOOD! read more

The pizza was ok, but the staff.... I had gone with some friends and right when we got up to leave, we had left our empty plates on the table. This lady came outside screaming at us and said "Clean up your trash. I don't give a shit come clean it up now." She proceeded to scream at us, and I went inside to clean up our mess. Isn't restaurant staff supposed to clean up after their customer? This behavior is disgusting and disrespectful. I do not recommend going here or having anything to do with them. read more

The pizza was ok, but the staff... I had gone with some friends and right when we got up to leave, we had left our empty plates on the table This lady cameoutside screaming at us and said "Clean up your trash. I don't give a shit come clean it up now." She proceeded to scream at us and I went inside to clean up our mess. Isn't restaurant staff supposed to clean up after their customer? read more

This is a wonderful local pizza parlor. It has been in Ridgefield for many, many years. My grandfather used to bring home pizza from Sarges. The owners work the store and it makes a difference. The red sauce is very tasty which results in fabulous pizza and other food. The pizza crust is always crispy. They are very generous with the toppings. The meals are delicious. They will gladly tailor anything to your liking. The delivery is fast and the food is always hot when it comes. We like our pies very well done, and they always come very dark and crispy. There are about four or five booths to sit inside and benches outside and a tv so it is a great place to stop in with friends for a slice. read more

Love this place with all my heart! Found a piece of hair in my chicken special today, I almost projectile vomited :D

This is one of the MUST try pizza places in New jersey!! The owner is so nice food is so nice!!!! But most importantly the taste of pizza is soooo AMaZiNG!!!!! read more

Sarge's Blvd Pizza - a slice missing - Pizza Near Me - Ridgefield, New Jersey

Pizza is okay but the guys there are so mean it's not even worth delivering if you take more then 30 seconds on the phone they get frustrated and hang up. Don't waste ur time order from urban tomato way better pizza anyways read more

I grew up on this pizza. I love this pizza. This shaped what pizza means to me. This is where I learned to put hot sauce on pizza. This place is an institution in this town. Every kid to ever live in ridgefield has been to Sarges more times than they can count (on the way home from school, after a football game, after concerts and playing in the park). I recommend sausage topping and getting the sandwiches here. Chicken special with cheese. THATS ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW. CHICKEN MOTHER FUCKING SPECIAL. read more

I've enjoyed both the pizza and the sandwiches from here. The food is fresh and good. I like that they deliver, and pick-up is also pretty convenient. I wouldn't eat there unless I was swinging through quick. It's just not really the sit-down kind of place. The employees don't have much personality, and will only speak to you when necessary. They don't even really acknowledge you came in until they've finished whatever they're doing. I guess that's what can be expected from high school kids at a local joint. I'd suggest calling your order in ahead of possible, since it takes a while to cook. read more

See all

Can't say much about Pizza as I've never had it from here, but their Chicken Cutlet Hero and their baked ziti is pretty darn tasty. When I think Chicken Cutlet hero, i'll think Sarges. Live like 1/4 mile away so we always call in a pick up order and it's always ready on time all the time normally about 10-15 minutes. It's right on the corner of a T intersection so you can park right on that street, run right in to grab the food and come right back. read more

I think this establishment used to be called Shaler Pizza back in the mid-80's. My sister and I skipped school (lunch hour), I was 6 and she was 8, just to go to this place for a slice. Ended up getting hit by a drunk driver... ...ouch! Nevertheless this joint was awesome. Fantastic pizza. Hope it still is... :) Cheers! read more

Been coming here for years now and love it. Great pizza, and great dinner options. Really enjoy the chicken parm.

Great pizza, amazing cheese fries and their chicken cutlet sandwich special is a must try

The chicken cutlet hot hero is amazing! The staff is friendly. It's definitely a family favorite.

The place is great. Service is on point. Everything you get there is good. I do not like the pizza though. The cheese always falls off and it doesn't have a good taste. If you go there and order anything get anything but pizza because pretty much everything there is extremely good. read more

I really enjoy the sandwich from here. Chicken Specials (similar to chicken cutlet) is made with generous servings of breaded chicken and really good bread!! I like to have mine made with all toppings (lettuce, mayo, tomato, cheese, and probably oil/vinegar?). Such a satisfying meal. Thank you Sarge's :) read more

My job recently moved to Ridgefield and we are always looking for a decent place to eat. Our normal orders are for 10/12 dinners plus appetizers and 4/5 pies 3 or 4 times a week. So I looked up places in the area on Google Sarges popped up so I decided to try them out. I call my order in and they wrote my credit card # down incorrectly so they had to call me back no big deal. The food comes I ordered Mac & Cheese bites they were OK nothing special but not bad. I also ordered a slice (Granted I'm spoiled from working in a pizzeria off and on for over 20 years) it was horrible the sauce was too sweet like they added 5 pds of sugar to it. OK so we won't order pizza but we can give the other food a shot right? Well then I'm going to put the receipt in my wallet and I see a $3.00 charge added to the bill so I call to see what that was for, I was informed they charge $1.25 for delivery that's fine and expected and then they tell me they charge $1.75 if you use a credit card over the phone. I asked why when I placed my order no one informed me, the response how are we supposed to know your a new customer? I told them I felt $1.75 was a bit excessive (I didn't say it to them but I'm not sure it's even legal) the response was that's nice Thank you and hung up on me. I called back and ask for the owner and the nasty lady on the phone told me she was the owner and that's what they do they have been in business for over 30 years and they aren't changing for anyone. Well guess what you just lost our business. I called the place we used to order from in Carlstadt Piazza Di Pizza to ask if they would deliver to us in Ridgefield the response of course we will you guys are Great customers!! Thank God there are still places that care about their businesses!! For the record I have no issues with delivery charges and tipping but to charge additional fees and not inform your customers is totally unacceptable!!! read more

I live in Ridgefield so this pizzeria is like a stable in our town. The food is good and extremely fresh. The pizza is outstanding. The owner is very hands on, which makes everything better. Fast service and prompted delivery. Give it a try, you won't regret it. read more

Honestly I've been coming to Sarge's since the 2nd grade, you just cannot beat the family oriented aura you get when coming here as well as that traditional Italian aura. To anyone who stops by the area I definitely recommend you stop by Sarge's to grab a slice you won't regret it read more

The pizza was so good when I used to be highshool. The pizza doesn't taste as good as it used. The cheese is always falling of the pizza. My friends don't go there anymore either now. read more

Located on Shaler Boulevard, this was my first experience with Sarge's. I parked in the lot a little past the pizzeria and walked over. As soon as I placed my order, the woman working behind the counter was very friendly and welcoming and I mentioned it being my first time there. She had a smile on her face. I had two regular slices with a Coke. I sat down at a table against the window and ate my slices. They were good and had a nice flavor. I surveyed the place for several minutes as I do anywhere I will Yelp about. There was no ambience, the decor was average, or close to it. But the pizza was a winner. I then paid and the man by the register was also very friendly and asked how was everything. Their prices were fair. I responded in saying it was good and thanked him for asking. I will go back and try a dinner sometime, also will get another slice. read more

Absolutely love this place!!!! Order from there all the time! My fav thing to order is a chicken parm hero on garlic bread!!! Highly recommended!! read more

Pizza is pizza, regardless of what the other reviewer wrote. Pizza with fresh mozarella is how it used to be made. Due to cost cutting measures in the past 50+ years, you now have this pizza made with fake cheese and uninspiring tomato sauce. So, it's really comparing fresh apples to rotten apples. Why would you choose rotten apples??? read more

The Italian Subs and Antipasto Salad are delicious! Unbeatable for the area. I would recommend to everyone!

This is a real neighborhood kind of place. There are hundreds of them all around this part of NJ. Now there are trendy brick oven, coal-fire, wood-fire places too, but this is not that kind of Pizzeria. This is the kind of place that you stop by at on the way home from work, if you want to walk there from your house or if you want a local delivery. The Pizza is standard New York Style. But it is good standard New York Style Pizza. The crust is real, the cheese is real, and the sauce is tasty. The toppings are good too. We have also had a few of the sandwiches and the dinner items. These were not as good as the pizza in my opinion, but we have less experience with the non-pizza items. I will mention that the bread does not seem to be made there which surprises me. After all Italian bread is made from the same dough as the Pizza, so we were surprised that the bread seemed soft and store bought. Seating is a problem here. When we have tried to go with more than two or three people, it was a mistake. So taking out is better and I think they serve slices too, so for a quick Pizza fix, this place id probably fine. read more

Everything is delicious! The owners and staff are super cool! Love this place

Nothing special with the place. Is always packed with young kids from the area with 1 or 2 kids eating andf the rest of them just hanging out. I ordered 2 slices of pizza plain. They charged me $2.50 EACH for the smallest plains slices of pizza. I believe its family owed and they dont look to happy to be working there. They all look miserable. read more

I would give it a half star....Pizza is not pizza and this pizza in particular is sucky. Theres other way better pizzerias in the area that have a whole lot more flavor. Its cafeteria pizza because they actually make the pizza for the local high schools cafeteria and they pass it off on the lunch lines in the h.s. read more

I never met a pizza I didn't like from Sarge's. It's all that you would expect from a mom and pop pizzeria. I can't stand pizza from pizza chains so it's great to have Sarge's nearby. read more