I hate stopping for pizza and it's cold. I asked her to put it back to make it hot. They need to get a timer, so it's not left to chance. Sorry to botch, but I done get pizza often. I love it, but it doesn't t love me read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Cold pizza, so sad - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

I see the hype with their square pizza. The dough is not to thick and tender and the sauces (both the normal marinara and the vodka sauce) is absolutely divine! I ordered their square pizza that was 1/2 grandma (tomato sauce and cheese) and 1/2 grandpa (with their vodka sauce) for +$1. I preferred the grandpa squares a teensy bit more but you can't go wrong with either. Had absolutely no complaints and would highly recommend if you're in the area! read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - 1/2 grandma and 1/2 grandpa square pizza - $23.50 as 0f 2/2025 - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Didn't get a chance to take pics of the good because my staff and I devoured it! The service here is not optimal! They are a bit unorganized but their pizzas are bomb! Thin crispy crust, quality cheese and tasty marinara make for a great pie! Out go are the Buffalo chicken and margherita pies! read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Fort Lee Pizza has become a shadow of its' former legacy pizzeria. Pizza had nothing going for it as compared to the original pie reviewed by Portnoy on Barstool Pizza. What a shame. read more

We have been coming here on regular basis, and the Pizza is delicious and Fresh. Staff are caring and friendly. Always coming back for more read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Delicious extra cheese slice. Thin and crispy - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Fort Lee pizza has been a place I've visited many times in my life. Back in the 80's it was my go to spot for pizza. I haven't been there for a while so I decided to give them another try. It was just as great as it always was. The crust is thin and crisp. The cheese just the right amount and the sauce tastes good. I got a couple of pies and both were delicious. The service is great with the pies ready when I got there and they even brought them out to my car. The people who I assume bought the place from the original owners were smart enough to not mess with the recipes because everything is just the way I remember it. Consistency is everything when it comes to a successful restaurant and this place has been consistent for so many years it amazes me. read more

Best pizza in town! Meatballs pasta and subs too! I adore the staff - they treat you like family. Always a pleasure to dine in or take out. The service is exceptional. read more

Solid chicken parm' hero, garlic bread was absolutely saturated in butter. I'd try it again. read more

Great pizza. The white sauce with onions was great and the sandwich was hearty! I will definitely will go back

We dined in on a Friday night, and the restaurant was busy with delivery and take outs. There are about 5 tables, each seating 4 people . Plenty of street parking. Pro-Overall, pizza slices were delicious. I love the thinner crusts, less doughy compared to other pizzerias. Pizza crust makes a great breadstick with a side of marinara sauce. Con- I've never had ANY pizzerias include an 18% gratuity for a party of 4. Very aggressive and this is definitely not a fancy restaurant. $108 for 3 Medium sz pizza pies, 1 fried calamari, 2 orders of garlic knots, and three cans of soda!! Garlic knots- served room temperature and cold at the core, wish they warmed it up longer. Mild garlic taste. Fried calamari- so light and airy. Perfect amount of crispy and arrived to our table piping hot. Hawaiian pizza- ample amount of pineapple and ham. Delicious right out of the oven. Could use more cheese. Pepe's eggplant pizza- freshly breaded eggplants, motzarella, and sliced tomatoes. Eggplants are crispy, pizza sauce could use some seasoning. Five cheese pizza- motzarella, ricotta, parmigiana, fonita, and feta cheese. There were more motzarella cheese than any other varieties. Surprisingly, it tasted bland without the tomatoe sauce. read more

See all

Ordered a rush catering for our friends on Thursday afternoon for Friday delivery. The woman (Neefy) who helped me was absolutely wonderful! She was super thoughtful with her recommendations and made the process so easy. . The food was delicious and highly appreciated by the family. read more

What happened to Fort Lee Pizza?!? It used to be a very good pizza place. Just ordered a sausage pie, like I always used to, and the sausage was crumbled sausage, not the link sausage of the past. Sauce was sub-par. Dough was thicker than in the past. It's now a below-average pie, whereas before it was an above average pie. I'm kinda sad it's changed so much for the worse ever since the original owner sold the store. Won't be going back again, bummer... read more

Authentic, reasonably priced Italian classics. I've been coming here since I was a kid with my parents since it's an easy spot to pass by when heading home from the city. I also know of some celebrities that have been here recently, like Cardi B. This place has made some renovations the past decade but has kept that old school, local feel. They used to serve Italian ice, I hope they still do. Some of the best pizza around. I always get the cold antipasto and some garlic knots. Nice and big drink selection. I'll keep coming here as long as I can! read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Cold Antipasto Platter Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

One of the best Pizza shops anywhere. One of my top five favorite slices ever. I live in Brooklyn now so I rarely get a chance to come to Fort Lee but whenever I pass through I make it a stop along my route. This place never disappoints. One of the best tasting slices you will ever try and it is absolutely consistent. read more

See all

Ordered a sicilian slice and a spinach and ricotta calzone. This place always hits. The sicilian slice was crispy, cheesy, and the marinara had a nice depth of flavor. The calzone was great as well. The ricotta tasted fresh and flavorful and the marinara sauce on the side paired extremely well with the flavor of the calzone. Cheers! read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Before I even tasted the pizza, I already knew I wasn't coming back. The lady at the counter seemed annoyed or like she didn't really want to talk to me. Definitely didn't make me feel comfortable... and customer service is becoming more and more important to me. All of that to come home to a flavorless pizza...? I won't be back. This place looks a little old and worn inside and I'd only recommend take out and honestly only going if you're absolutely starving. read more

Fort lee pizzeria did not disappoint. Heard many great things about this place and reviews were always great. Was craving Chicken Parm and they were the best place in the area and also the cheapest by a few bucks. Would definitely get food from here if its not too busy! Pasta dishes come with an option of 3-4 different pastas, super great service, got the angel hair. Was a huge meal portion for I think under 25$. Would definitely recommend to anyone to try out their pizza or pasta. read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Chicken Parmigiana Dinner - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Well, it saddens me to write this review because I have been going to this place since I was 15 years old, and I am in my 50s. I grew up knowing Maria and her husband. Though they are no longer in this establishment, they indicated it would be the same. However, the last three times, our order has been messed up - this time takes the cake. I got baked ziti with no sauce well in cups, so I guess it makes your own; the chicken had no side, and the other pasta was not cooked. The $64.00 order - turned into a double cost for dinner tonight because I had to pay for another meal. I should also say it's my fault because, at 8, when I placed the order, they luedsaud they closed at 830 guessed they were in a rush It was a 77.00 night for me, thanks to their screw up Nice if you don't want the sauce read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Make your own sauce bake zitti But better then pasta that could breaknyiyr teeth - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Beside the pizza being amazing, we found the staff to be fun and helpful! Honestly, can't wait to go back for a slice of Grandma's pizza! Specialty pizza was tasty too! read more

See all

Grandma is best here, regular slices are good Delivery takes like an hour since they are so busy. Worth the wait for grandma read more

See all

Great pizza and have been going there for ten years but in recent months, we really feel ripped off. How is a three item pizza $37? It's even worse if you use Grub Hub or Door Dash. Their special pizza, which is full of ingredients is only $28.50 but be careful, they don't charge you how they price extra toppings in their menu. It reads $6.50 for first full topping and then $2 for each additional full topping so a three item pizza should be $28. However, they charge $37. $6.50 PER ingredient. We even questioned it and they confirmed that's correct so be careful. They're not pricing it the way they advertise it. Will be looking for a new pizza place for sure. read more

Best pizza in the area (original NYer here and we know pizza). If you expect pizza to be thin and tasty and manageable to eat (being able to fold and walk around with it), then this is for you. Most pizza these days, even in NYC is not what it's supposed to be, so finding good,. actual pizza in NJ is rare. The garlic-knot sliders are interesting and novel, but the somewhat uncooked garlic isn't for me. The grandma pizza was good too: great texture to the dough. The balance of cheese and sauce at this place is just right. read more

Best pizzaria in the area. The food here is solid. Prices are good. I love that they offer lunch specials for under $10. Very hard to find in this area these days. The only downside of this place is that they only have street parking and because the area is popular, parking is limited. read more

Great pizza place in fort lee. Ordered a grandma pie with extra sauce online for pickup and was a very easy process. When I went in I added some slices to the order and they just redid the online purchase instead of creating two separate charges. Tried the veggie, plain slice, and Sicilian. All were good due to the excellent dough but the grandma pizza was the star of the show. The crust is light but flavorful, with the right amount of cheese and sauce. The pizza almost melts in your mouth it's that good. The people working there were very friendly when picking up the pizza. Great choice if you are in the area. read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Grandma pizza with extra sauce - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

The in-laws wanted pizza for lunch and I happened to have this place bookmarked for their grandma pizzas. I placed an order through their website (for 10% off) for pickup and got Half Grandma Square pizza (with sausage), Half Grandpa Square pizza (with vodka sauce and mushrooms). The pie itself came out to $25, which is a pretty pricey pizza IMO. I think it was the toppings and making it half/half because according to the menu, a regular square pie is $17 so I may just do that next time and add my own toppings. But aside from the price, the pizza was amazing. Probably one of the better square pizzas I've had. The crust was thin but still chewy; I don't like crispy crusts. Actually, I don't really like crust in general but I would gladly eat a corner piece of this pie. Both of the sauces were great too. Could have probably used a bit more toppings for the price that we paid but it wasn't the worst. We also ordered some fried shrimp. I wasn't expecting it to be good, since it's a pizza place but we were all pleasantly surprised. I'm pretty sure they make it fresh and it's not one of those pre-cooked frozen shrimp. The shrimp were sizeable and they were butterflied, then deep fried. They were still crispy when we ate it 20 minutes after the fact. This might be a new addition to my list of favorite pizza places. read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Half grandma with sausage, half grandpa with mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

See all

Best Pizza that I've had in Jersey! Omg this pizza right here I don't even know where to begin but I do know that my mouth was having a party once I took a bite of this pizza I know one thing I will never eat at another pizzeria other than this place! And they even have dessert so with that being said I gotta try the tiramisu which I have a strong feeling that it will be good too anyways I will end this review here but I promise you I will definitely be back for more of this yumminess. read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Five Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Ordered the Granma pie- fantastic. Ordered a cheese pie, unimpressed but my 4 year old nephew loved it!

Service not as good lately. Oh well. Disappointing to have my patromage returned with longer waits. read more

Great pizza, easy to find restaurant, kinda small interior but don't let that sway you from the great service and good food.

My GO TO SPOT for pizza. All the workers are extremely nice and friendly. If it's your first time I recommend the grandma pie. It's perfection. I also recommend the plain cheese pie and the grandpa pie. I usually get grandma pie with half sausage, broccoli and garlic. The grandpa I usually get half chicken cutlet. read more

See all

We used to live closer so it wasn't an issue getting their amazing pizza whenever but since we moved about 30 mins away. It has been a bit challenging. However, we continue to make a trip to fort Lee pizzaria! We tried other places but no place is like Fort Lee pizza! Friendly staffs... amazing pizzas! Highly recommended! read more

See all

4 stars for the pizza but added 1 star for Friendly service. I was happy and would order again when in the area

10/10! Friendly and patient staff. I had this pie FRESH out of the oven and it was AMAZING! If they weren't closing I'm very sure I would've stayed and finished the entire thing. We gave our compliments to the staff it was so good! I'll will most definitely be back. read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Grandma Pizza with half pepperoni and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

As an Italian American who's experience includes making pizza at home and in a bar, I must say that, in my opinion, the star of a pizza is the bread or crust, and their pizzas as amazing! Best I can find read more

Good pizza. Crispy crust, not soggy, not greasy. Perf amt of cheese and sauce. The place was busy so make sure you give yourself time between ordering and picking up read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Fort Lee Pizzeria is an institution in the area. I randomly stumbled on this place and after stopping in I realized I saw it on Barstool pizza reviews. El Prez gave it a 8.0 which is a big time score! I thought it was good but not an 8. The grandma slice had a good crisp to it and decent flavor. The sauce is light and didn't make the crust soggy. I will say it was a touch greasy. The chicken parm slice was good but I feel like I had a slice like this in 50 other places. It is a small shop that gets busy which is a positive thing. They come with a high reputation but for Yelp purposes I would put it at a 4. read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Delicious food and generous servings! Had gone with the manicotti and garlic knots unaware it came with a lid of bread! Strongly recommend! read more

Fort Lee Pizzeria - Yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

I've had their awesome food for our podcast studio open houses and at home! The sandwiches and pizzas are always on point! Service and ambiance has an old school feel that's always welcome! read more

I order from here a few times a year when I'm visiting family. Pizza is always cooked perfect, tastes great and honestly the best pies I can find around Fort Lee. Customer service has also been really great. Would highly recommend. read more

Always seen this spot and didn't think of trying it till recently. The grandma pie is just delicious! Be ready to have a group because it is a large pizza! I also got a pasta dish with meat sauce. It was a bit on the pricier side but when I opened everything, I just understood why the price is so high. The portions were enormous! Definitely full of flavor and just overall fantastic. Will recommend. read more