We returned to Scarpino's to try other menu options and found each time we've returned the staff are as outgoing and personable as the last. The food is always made to order and the results have been excellent. There hasn't been one item with which we haven't been extremely satisfied. This time our server was Sophie and she was exceptionally accommodating and helpful. From the wine choice to adding or subtracting ingredients in our meal she went out of her way to ensure our order was perfect. All of the servers are very well trained and Sophie was no exception. We'll continue to frequent Scarpino's with their outstanding service and food. read more

Let's start with ambiance - No major changes from when it was Nabruzzi's. Some paint, updated decor, window into the kitchen, etc. Layout is the same. Not super upscale, and much nicer than the corner pizza shop. Moving on to food - Ordered meatballs as an app, cheese pizza, and a house salad. Meatballs were ok, not cooked in the sauce, just had sauce poured over them and chunks of cut up mozzarella. Ricotta would have been better. Meatballs and sauce were barely warm. Despite ordering them as an appetizer, they arrived after the pizza. (execution error by the kitchen). Salad was ok, just arrived pre dressed (waiter never asked what dressing) Way too much dressing as well. Pizza was just bland. Was expecting more seasoning, crispier crust and a blend of cheeses. What we received was a barely cooked pizza with run of the mill tomato sauce and cheese. Just disappointing considering the premium prices. Last, the service - Hostess was excellent, seated us promptly at the pizza bar. Waiter offered garlic rolls and water to start while we looked over the menu. Garlic rolls were good (lots of garlic). Ordered a bottle of wine and waited for our food. Salad was out quickly, pizza arrived next, followed by our lukewarm appetizer meatballs. Our waiter was nice enough to pack to go boxes and our leftover wine for us. Overall just a disappointing experience. Was really looking forward to trying it out. Unless they fix things, this was a one and done. read more

Scarpino's Classic Italian - Meatballs and mozz. - Italian Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

Decided to try based on reviews and left feeling the reviews I read were fake. Ordered Calamari appetizer for $16.00 and we laughed at how little was on the plate. I said to my wife, "whose is this, mine or yours?" They have a wood fired pizza oven, nice. They don't cook the gluten free pizza in it and they don't tell you they don't cook it in there. I believe it went under a heat lamp in the kitchen. My wife's pizza was raw on the bottom and the meat balls on it looked like dog food and not Nonna's meatballs like we were expecting. I had the chicken marsala. The chicken was not pounded flat which is always a bad sign. The menu said, served with broccoli; yes, 1 sprig of it. Lastly, it was served in a bowl and had enough sauce for my wife to ask me, "how's the soup?". The staff was nice, it's nice inside for where it is but we left disappointed for the $100.00 spent. read more

Scarpino's took over the old Nabruzzi location. Atmosphere and service were great. Food, not so much. Nothing was terrible, was just bland, especially for Italian. I had the Lasagna (an Italian staple that should be easy) and it was greasy, loaded with cheese and very little meat. The description says "layers of beer and Italian sausage bolognese ". Not sure what happened to those layers. My with had stuffed shells and a side of Italian sausage. It was fine, nothing special. Our friends the Spaghetti Tutto Mare in white sauce. Again, the sauce was very bland. The mussels were super tiny and everything tasted frozen. Garlic nots are okay. The Carpaccio was great. We noticed that the majority of the staff were young people / kids. Including the majority of the kitchen. Maybe this had something to do with the food quality? They have a couple of locations. They are new in this location, hopefully they figure it out otherwise they will not last. Word spreads quick. read more

The food here is just okay. The prices are a little high ($21 for a 12 inch pizza) but the portions are large. I would be fine to pay the prices if the food was better... even if the portion size went down. It was similar to an Olive Garden to me. Just subpar "Italian," nothing authentic or that would make me want to come back. My party tried the calamari and zucchini fritte to start. The zucchini were bland. The calamari was the best part of the entire meal, typical calamari appetizer. For my entree I had the pesto gnocchi. The portion was huge, it looked like an entire package of gnocchi. But the sauce hardly had any flavor. So yeah, it's nice that you get a ton of food, but if it's bland does it even matter? It's too bad, because the inside is really cute. read more

Scarpino's Classic Italian - Gnocchi - Italian Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

We came for a birthday lunch celebration. We ate bruschetta for our appetizer-large portions. Three of us got pizzas and the other two ate pasta fagioli soup, Caesar salad, and meatballs. In addition to the complimentary cannoli we also ate the scrumptious tiramisu. Our waitress was attentive. She cleared the table to create more space and she boxed up our leftovers. The restaurant had an elegant ambience with the ceiling decorated and nice tablecloths and settings. read more

See all

New! Hurry, don't sleep on this well rounded Italian place in Lutz! Less than a mile from the veterans! The place is Instagramable with irs beautiful ceiling treatment and the lounge nook near the wine wall. We were a large party, so we had a room that had a literal garden on the ceiling. Our waitress, Maddie was a Star. She paced everything beautifully, made sure we knew the story behind the chef, and even happily answered questions, got refills and bread. The food was delicious! I ordered the Zucchini Fritte and chicken Parmagiana. The batter on the zucchini was so light and crisp. It was delicious. The chicken Parmigiana was nicely done, though i prefer the chicken to be a bit crispier. All in all it was an amazing birthday for our Mina! Will most definitely come back in the near future, If I can get a reservation! read more

See all

Came here to try since the grand opening was on April 1. I must say in general if you are looking for good authentic italian food in a great atmosphere this is your place. The owners all came up to the table and introduced themselves and the server Savannah was excellent. She was on top of everything. Had a long conversation with the owner Rob about the concept. You can definitely see his passion in this place. We started with Nona's meatballs and the Margarita pizza. Both were great. The meatballs were perfect without the over taste of fennel as well as not being overpacked with breadcrumbs. The pizza was amazing, the sauce was so fresh. We also got the Alfredo that is flambéed in the Parmesan wheel. This was not only a great meal for more than 2 people but also an awesome show. This will be a new date night spot for us. Definitely recommend making reservations. read more

See all

Tried this new Italian restaurant for lunch- definitely had some big shoes to fill after Nabruzzi. The crispy calamari was nicely cooked but needed a little more flavor. Mussels were overcooked. Pasta dishes were very good, and the lunch specials and portion sizes made it worth it. Service wasn't the best and felt a bit slow, but overall the food showed promise. Will give it another try in the future, maybe after having some time to grow. read more

Scarpino's Classic Italian - Italian Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

My issue has been resolved by my own means. That's all I wish to speak about the matter. read more

Scarpino's Classic Italian - Italian Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

Overall this place is like a 2/5 for me. I'll preface this with saying that they did comp my eggplant parm meal so I appreciate that. The restaurant looks nice and definitely is brighter than the last place that was at this location. Glass of wine was fine. To start, staff seems a bit immature and unprofessional. The garlic knots they bring out are unpalatable, the garlic is just scooped out of a jar- it was just not good at all. I ordered the eggplant parm and almost choked on the cheese. There was no crispiness or crust on the eggplant as described in the menu, it was all soggy and bare. Additionally, the dish only included approximately 2 little slices of eggplant and like half a box of spaghetti. The spaghetti had absolutely no flavor and the sauce was just plopped on top. While they did comp my food, the dish costs $25!!! That is a lot of money for something of such low quality. I hate to leave a bad review, but I do not recommend this restaurant. read more

See all

The food was quite good and the the restaurant is huge and decor is unique. Pricing on point as well. But I am specifically writing this to call out the AMAZING service by the Asst. GM Bree. Bree went above and beyond to ensure that we had a good experience. Some hiccups at the start but I won't even mention them because Bree treated us like VIP and checked in with us throughout the meal. It was my hubby's bday and she had 3 desserts personally brought to our table. We will be back. Make a reservation because the place is crowded. read more

See all

Great little Italian place. All the usual suspects prepared fresh. Very nice for a casual dinner. Make a reservation! They will turn you away even if it's mostly empty when you arrive, they fill up quickly! read more

See all

They say classic Italian but my goodness this food is not good. Caesar salad had the wrong dressing, etc. spaghetti overcooked and watery...service was sincere but slow. So disappointed. read more

This is a new Italian restaurant where Nabruzzi Trattoria was located. What an impressive improvement! First of all, from the entry into the restaurant, a friendly greeting from a manager, to the vastly improved interior decor, beautifully designed greenery from the ceiling, a floral theme in the "Red Room" to lighting that makes you feel welcomed and in an actual Italian setting! Our server , Brielle, on both visits, has a smile that makes you happy to be there! She explains all the dishes, spotlights special flambé dinners and appetizers and is quick to notice your drinks need refreshing, to complimentary garlic knots! Hand fired stone oven pizzas are excellent and all the food is plentiful, hot and delicious! Weekdays they have lunch specials, my next visit will be lunch! Make a point of making a reservation at Scarpino's Lutz location, their newest gem! You'll certainly leave happy AND full! read more

Very disappointed we took clients there 2 orders of eggplant parmesan asked for the eggplant to be crispy it was soggy. Pasta dishes ordered the spaghetti was under cooked and very flavor not much flavor to be Italian dished. Will not recommend to others. read more

Food is delish. Service is great , Brielle is a wonderful waitress.it's beautiful inside the restaurant. Very clean . You have to see for yourself. read more

Scarpino's Classic Italian - One part of the dinning area- very open & bright and inviting. - Italian Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

Was hoping for another good italian option nearby. Clams and mussels were tough and shriveled up. White wine sauce had no flavor...tasted like eating wet oily noodles. Former nabruzzi was better. Much better options locally...villagio, sacred pepper, epositos, etc. read more

Wow, what a delicious meal from start to finish! We came here to celebrate my husband's birthday. He got a complimentary cannoli for his birthday dessert. This wasn't your average cannoli; it was different from the usual in that tasted like it had cinnamon in the dough. Even my husband who normally doesn't like cannolis loved this one. Our waitress Savannah was also very attentive. For example, she noticed when our drinks were getting low, she would get them refilled quickly. The ambiance is also nice and cozy. We'll definitely come back! read more

Service and Ambiance was great. I was disappointed in the Bolognese. I am use to the ground meat sauce with wine. This was just regular sauce. Very bland not much flavor. Maybe next time I will try something different. Then I will decide to go back. I have to give them another chance. I was so hoping it would be a good genuine Italian restaurant. read more

Rayna is a Rock Star!! Her recommendation for the Lasagna was spot on!! The Caprese Salad was unbelievable! The beefsteak tomato's and the thick mozzarella were outstanding and Rayna was able to provide some extra Balsamic Vinegar! Daniel (Owner) and John (Director) both made it a point to stop by and check on our food and service! They've got a great formula! read more

Scarpino's Classic Italian - Lasagna! Excellent recommendation from our server, Rayna! - Italian Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

We thoroughly enjoyed our lunch at Scarpino's this past Friday! The menu features a wide variety of options to cater to many preferences. The desserts were especially delicious, with the Pina Colada Cheesecake standing out as excellent! The atmosphere was refreshing, and the service was outstanding. We also had a delightful conversation with the owner, whose enthusiasm for the new restaurant was clear. They are committed to maintaining high quality and providing generous service. We will definitely return and plan to bring friends and family with us! read more

We tried Scarpino's for the first time last night, and we left genuinely impressed, not just by the food, but by the people. There was a very large party in the back room, which caused a delay in getting our meals. Our waiter let us know right away, and when we asked about timing, the manager came over to speak with us. Their transparency and sincerity meant a lot to us, and we truly appreciated how attentive and respectful they were of our time. They even offered to comp our meal (completely unnecessary, but very kind), which we declined. Ethan and Patrick took such great care of us! They were warm, professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely fun to interact with. The manager was just as thoughtful and accommodating. You can tell this team really cares about their guests, and that level of service does not go unnoticed. We're grateful for the experience and will absolutely be back. If you're considering trying Scarpino's, do it! You'll be in great hands, and the food and portions are just as wonderful as their team! read more

Very good Italian food, plenty of appetizers, courteous service, and a bright and clean atmosphere. I would recommend to anyone

Our wedding soup only had meatballs, no noodles and barely any spinach. The pepperoni pizza was very good.

Me and my family went to Scarpino's for the first time on Mother's Day and had an excellent experience. We loved the atmosphere, and on top of our meals, we ordered three appetizers -- everything was delicious. The service was great, and everyone there was so friendly and welcoming. I'm looking forward to going back soon to try the chicken piccata! read more

Me and my family went to Scarpino's for the first time on Mother's Day and had an excellent experience. We loved the atmosphere, and on top of our meals, we ordered three appetizers -- everything was delicious. The service was great, and everyone there was so friendly and welcoming. I'm looking forward to going back soon to try the chicken piccata! read more

Arrived at 5:50 for 6:00 reservation and we had to wait til 6 to be seated. No other parties came in or left, kinda weird. I ordered chicken Marsala. Pan was too hat, chicken was over "seared" inside was fine. Mushrooms were so finely chopped I wasn't sure they were mushrooms. No taste of Marsala and sauce was like a gravy. Won't be back read more

First visit, service was good, server was friendly and made an effort to make us feel welcome. Food is mixed, build your own pizza is a nice option but to pay $2.25 for a few pieces of broccoli on a pizza wasn't worth it. Fettuccine Alfredo had good flavor just not enough sauce. Overall is a was a nice evening with friends, willing to try again. read more

Service was outstanding and ty he food was excellent and the Ambulance was like icing on the cake. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Met Nate one of the owners and wished him the best. We will be going back read more

The service and my server were excellent. The food (Lasagna) was amazing. Highly recommend.

The food was absolutely amazing. There was four of us and we had the lasagna, pizza and gnocchi with bolognese sauce. The portions were huge and it was so good. The service was very good and the staff was very knowledgeable. I would totally recommend! read more

First, could not find our reservation. Second, the tables are placed so close that you could enjoy the conversation of those next to you. Third, the quality of the food is far below expected. Pork medallions were tough. Spaghetti bolognaise was tasteless. Finally, overpriced for the below par quality. Far different that previous restaurant-Nebruzzi. Will not return. read more

Let me start by saying we were very excited to try this new place. We did not realize you could only dine here if you had a reservation only- I don't remember seeing this anywhere. We showed up at 530pm this past Saturday and were turned away, and we were told since we did not have a reservation, we could not be seated. We were willing to wait but were turned away! Now the interesting thing is we were on a waiting list on open table that if a reservation opens up between 6-8pm we would be notified- 15 mins after we were sent away 3 reservations opened up in a row. starting with 6pm- By this time, we were not heading back. I think this was very unprofessional of the restaurant especially if we were willing to wait- all restaurants should expect some reservation's to maybe cancel. Definitely opting out of this restaurant. read more