Amazingly delicious vegan and gluten-free options! Plus, they have a gluten-free vegan waffle cone that is fantastic!

Yummy.I came here with some friends today and and all orded different things.I ordered the strawberry ice cream in a cup.Very delicious My friends all enjoyed their treats Employees are very nice We sat inside and ate our treats read more

See all

Absolutely outstanding ice cream spot!!! Probably in my top three ever! I'm staying at an AirBnB in Sebastopol and this ice cream spot was recommended as the best ice cream spot in town. Went here after having dinner at Fern Bar on Saturday night and it was packed! My wife and I got sundaes and they were ready in 5-10 minutes. The staff were super friendly and it's a fun ambience in there. Not like a BR or cold stone with the fluorescent lights. It's clear this is a cherished local spot. We loved it so much we went back the very next night and got the same stuff! Both nights we were helped by Audrey and she was super friendly and accommodating of our indecisiveness. My wife and I come to Sebastopol for our anniversary and this ice cream spot will DEFINITELY become a yearly tradition for us!! read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Sundaes! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

In the mood for ice cream? This is the spot. I will go here any hour of the day, rain or shine. Screamin' Mimi's is delicious. The ice cream is tastes so fresh, and not overly sweet. There's not a flavor I don't like. I really enjoy that they offer seasonal flavors like lavender. Give it a try if you're visiting the area. You won't be disappointed. I do miss their old way of weighing the ice cream and charging by weight. You had the option to add some more of a specific flavor if you wanted to. I really dislike that they went with what all other ice cream shops do and just go by "size". read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Classic banana split. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

I am so happy to be back here. I used to frequent this place when it was close by. I am glad to report it is still the same, with all it's glory. Just even busier now, maybe. The ice cream was delicious and the service is awesome. I always love when staff let's you try the ice cream before deciding on the flavors ( I have in places that they don't!) Highly recommend to check it out when you are in the area and to try the seasonal flavors when they are available ! read more

See all

I recommend the Mimi's Mud flavor - huge chunks of real fudge, just like I remember from childhood when my family would take me here! I live in New York City now and we have a lot of good ice cream, but Screamin' Mimi's is better than any other place I've been. read more

Stopped by here after grabbing ramen two doors down. Cashier was really nice and there were plenty of options. Wifey got a chocolate with a cake cone and I got a vanilla affogato. All reasonably priced as well. Will be making this a stop next time we're in Sebastopol and looking to satisfy our sweet tooth. read more

See all

Super yummy ice cream! I like how it was a nice walk from the Barlow- helped us digest to make more room for ice cream haha The kid's size is nice for those who want a big (pricey) spoonful size, so if you want more, get the bigger size! We sat outside since it was so nice that day. The sidewalk isn't the widest so when a throng of people waited outside, it got quite crowded next to our seats. They have a speaker outside so you can wait outside and still hear your number being called. Overall would definitely come again! read more

My family has been coming to Screamin Mimi's for many years. I could not imagine Sebastopol without this establishment. This little corner ice cream shop is super cute. They have very colorful merch, and besides their ice cream they also do ice cream cakes and pies! The ice cream here is all made in-house. They use a lot of local ingredients and natural flavors to make their ice cream. On this particular visit, I was very much in the mood for Fall flavors. I tried their vegan pumpkin mud with their pumpkin spice caramel sauce. The caramel is not vegan for those who are wondering, but it's so good! The vegan pumpkin mud has fudge pieces and cookie pieces. It is really delicious. My wife loves trying their fruity sorbets and their olive oil when they have it. She loves to combine their Cassis sorbet and their olive oil ice cream together. My daughter always gets a vanilla sundae with hot fudge and whipped cream. The service here is always friendly and helpful. We love Screamin Mimi's! read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Vegan Pumpkin mud ice cream with pumpkin spice caramel sauce - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Cute shop with creative and classic flavors alike. Staff were very friendly and patient as we had a very hard decision to make. Definitely worth the price and a great stop for a sweet treat! read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Tonight's order was Absolutely Almond, Mimis Mud and Cherry Bomb . Service was fast and friendly. Was busy but didnt have to wait. read more

See all

What a wonderful ice cream shop! Honestly, I was a little skeptical because of the name and the decor, but this proves that you should never judge a book by its cover. The ladies inside were so kind- I was able to try a few flavors and the coolest part is- even for a small size, you're able to have as many flavors as you want in it! (Granted, the more flavors, the less the scoop will have). I got the English toffee (coffee base but the toffee really shone!), cookie break (yum- give me all the cookies and all the texture), and Mimi's mistake (peanut buttery!). There were a few other flavors I tried but I was already happy with those 3 and the serving was pretty generous for a small. Overall- this spot is one of my top ice cream spots in the Bay and I'm looking forward to the next time we go back! read more

This is shop is a gem and a local favorite for good reason; the quality and taste are top notch. The standards are done exceptionally well; the strawberry ice cream is made with fresh strawberries sourced from a local farm just down the road. If you drove on highway 12, you passed it coming or leaving Screamin' Mimi's and the farmstand on it's own has a big following. My personal favorite is the Mimi's mud as it's a fun take on mud pie. I also find the price of the hot fudge sundae to be one of the best values in the county. On a beautiful sunny day, you will encounter a line and it's for good reason and worth the wait. Anytime I have out of town guests, I make a point to bring them for a treat as they have a variety of fantastic standards and some fun unique flavors. read more

tasty strawberry ice cream. indoors is a little cramped but it's right in downtown so lots of places to walk read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - local strawberry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

I love coming here for the Mimi's mud. There's nothing better and I always crave it! My favorite ice cream spot and flavor I've ever had is here. I try to stop here whenever I'm in town. read more

Screamin' Mimi's is definitely unique and popular -- it's clearly an older shop with a lot of local history. The furniture and décor feel outdated, giving it a quirky, retro vibe that's charming in its own way, though not modern or polished. We tried the Mocha Shake and the Black & White. The Mocha Shake was good, though nothing particularly memorable. The Black & White, unfortunately, was one of the worst drinks I've ever had -- extremely bitter and tasting not much different from a generic can of sparkling soda, which makes sense since it's essentially an Italian soda. I recommend letting the ice cream melt first for a slightly more enjoyable drinking experience. Overall, I can see why people love Screamin' Mimi's for the nostalgia and its long-standing presence in Sebastopol. With so many items on the menu, I'm sure there are some excellent options -- I just haven't found the right one for me yet. read more

They had quite a few flavors that we were interested in. We had come back in 2018 and they had the double headed cone, that is no more! :( picture for reference. They had a lot of flavors. I think I got pineapple sorbet and it was lacking in flavor. Just another ice cream shop. read more

See all

I had great hopes... My husband and I dropped in on a Thursday night - I got one of the coffee flavors, and asked for a taste of the raspberry sorbet. I got that taste as a SCOOP mixed in with my Coffee - not a good combo. Several other people that came in later were actually given tastes - so that was disappointing. I also asked for the big "fresh waffle cone" with it - they have a sample small cone and big fresh cone at the counter. The fresh cone I got was the size of the small cone - but we were charged for the big one. Also disappointing. The Raspberry sorbet was - almost flavorless!?!?! SUPER disappointing. I'll be honest, the Talenti sorbetto tastes more like raspberry, and you can get it in the grocery store. The mocha was good, but not great - I was hoping for that rich, creamy, homemade ice cream flavor and texture - it was not really that. Huge chunks of chocolate in it, which overwhelms the coffee flavor. My husband got three flavors, and said the dark chocolate was excellent - but the other two were nothing different from good quality grocery store ice cream. To add to it - for some reason, they are VERY SLOW. There were two orders ahead of us, and each one took a couple of minutes to do 2 or 3 bowls of ice cream - I guess they weigh EACH serving to make sure they don't give over than 5.5 or 7.5 or whatever ounces? I wanted to go in back and give them some procedures to move things along a bit quicker. I also noticed after we ordered - they DO give tastes - for some reason my request got short circuited. And they got really busy after we ordered, so the slow scooping became a real problem, and when they'd call out an order, multiple people tried to grab it. Overall, some of the ice cream seems to be good, and my husband would come back JUST for the dark chocolate. Me personally, not sure I'd return, I've had much better ice cream. Hoping we just caught them on a bad night, because they do seem popular!? Update - the owner contacted me - it sounds like we got them on a bad night, so we will definitely give it another try! Always appreciate a business owner who is professional and cares... read more

There is usually a line for an excellent reason. The line goes fast - worth the wait.

Always worth going to. The pints are really convenient, and an excellent way to indulge later.

Classic ice cream place with seasonal and local ingredients. Always delicious and pretty quick when not crowded. 10 tables with 3 outside. Friendly service and lots of options including vegan and sorbets. read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Local strawberry and Mimi's mud ice cream. Flavors change with the seasons and what's fresh - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Always a line, today was not too bad. The ambience, as usual, was busy with steady flow of customers. I don't come here often but in the past l recall unique and impressive flavors that stood out. I saw on the menu, double espresso chip, usually my favorite I've cream flavor that i get from Haagen dazs (coffee chip). And i got raspberry sorbet on the bottom of the home-made cone that i wanted to try because you can smell them baking. I got the regular size ice cream, even though i realize it was more than i wanted, but the gal said it fit better. It appears they no longer offer tastes, like other premium ice cream parlors still do in the County. I was disappointed in the double espresso because the description made it sound like a sort of coffee ice cream with espresso infused chocolate chips. It tasted much like vanilla ice cream with very slightly coffee infused chocolate chips; i thought they errored giving me simple chocolate chip but they said no it was correct. The raspberry sorbet was nice and refreshing. The cone was average tasting; similar in taste to a regular waffle cone but it looked nicer, a little thicker. I used to think this place was the best in the county; Well, they've got competition now. The still might be best in sebastopol though, as I've not seen another real parlor in that town. read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - People waiting to order inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Cute ice cream place in downtown Sebastopol. It is popular too and has seating inside and outside. I tried to experiment with a local flavor - Bees knees- lavender with chocolate honeycomb bits. The ice cream texture is nice and creamy. The honeycomb was yum too. I wasn't a fan of the floral flavor but it was a good try. My family tried waffle cones with blueberry and mint chocolate chip ice cream and enjoyed it. I hope to try another flavor when I'm back :) read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Their banana split is LOADED! The flavors I ordered were local strawberry, chocolate chip cookie dough, and their seasonal pumpkin mud...that pumpkin mud is a MUST! Their inside seating area is small so you may have to eat in your car or standing up outside but their ice cream is very much worth it. Prices are reasonable, and possibly cheaper than larger ice cream chains. read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Banana Split - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

I really enjoyed the ice cream here! It's a cute spot in Sebastopol. They had many flavors and great staff. read more

See all

Mint stick ice cream was quite good. I love the texture of the ice cream. Very thick and gooey. Service is fast and friendly. The ice cream shop is very traditional and comfortable. read more

Love this place! Flavors are amazing, my favorite are the sorbets. Sweet staff, the ambience will either be hectic or calm. read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Really, really good vegan ice cream (and regular too, I hear). I love that they don't (or rarely) use soy as a base, and their texture has gotten really great. Love the flavors they come up with too. Some places do vegan ice cream just to appease vegans, but dont really make the effort with flavors and textures. Screamin' Mimi's does! Great Sorbet, too! Super friendly staff and a really delightful atmosphere. Super cheerful and colorful. Reminds me of Lisa Frank. read more

Seasonal choices: Pumpkin Mud and Pumpkin Spice Latte Awesome ice cream place! Service was excellent and only outdone by their own ice cream! The store is fun! read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Pulling Spice Latte ice cream with a double espresso and a single pumpkin mud - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Great ice cream and service! Lots of flavors and good ingredients. I miss the pre-covid dining setup though, it's so cramped inside the shop now. I also miss the cute pet contests and pin map... could the pet pics come back?! read more

3.5 This is an adorable ice cream parlor with a variety of fun flavors and dessert concoctions. I was impressed by all the flavors they offered. The Thai Tea ice cream was pretty average to me. The consistency was a lot creamier than I was used to, which wasn't necessarily a negative thing. I would still come back to try other flavors, such as the Local Strawberry, which appeared to have great reviews. read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Mmmmm super delicious ice cream with unique flavors that you can't find elsewhere like passionfruit or ginger! I got their strawberry and espresso flavor! read more

I always love coming here. One of my favorite local ice cream shops. So many wonderful flavors and good prices. I usually get their root beer float with vanilla ice cream! THE BEST. I think their vanilla and strawberry is the best around. But you can't go wrong with any of the flavors here, especially the Mimi's Mud, and get it with one of their waffle cones. read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

My brother and sister-in-law took us to Screamin' Mimi's on our way back from dinner at the coast. We learned that it's a local institution; an independent creamery. They have so many creative flavors that it must be really hard to choose if you are having regular ice cream. I appreciate that they also have some non-dairy options. Not as many, but enough to offer some choices. More sorbets than many places make, in addition to some vegan flavors. Bravo! It's a crowded, chaotic kind of place if you go when it's busy. Which it may very well be often. The reputation keeps 'em coming, and the creamy deliciousness makes 'em return. Finding a place to sit after you get your order can be challenging; there's not a lot of seating inside or outside. We were able to snag a bench out front. We were there about two months ago, and I'm slow to write this review. I don't remember the flavor I chose, but I do recall that I enjoyed it. The flavors and innovation would entice me to go back when in the area again. The ambiance was a bit too something for me. I'm usually good with words, but Mimi's vibe sort of escapes me by way of trying to describe it. Colorful and bright, it is that. Lot of yellowish orange on the walls, and some unique artistic décor, too. Be sure to check it out for yourself! read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Part of the menu. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Wonderful little ice cream shop. I got the classic ice cream sundae, which was loaded with all sorts of add-ons. The banana chocolate chip ice cream was especially tasty. read more

I had the best ice cream I've had in a very long time at Screamin' Mimi's. We were following a local's recommendation who raved about the abundance and quality of ice cream flavors, and the shop was a 5-minute walk from the microbrewery where we ate dinner. Plus, we couldn't resist the adorable ice cream cone sign hanging above the shop. Upon entering the shop, we were greeted with the aroma of fresh waffle cones. The shop had a long list of flavors for every type of craving, and it was really hard to decide what to order. The best part was that we were not limited to one flavor per cone; they would attempt to squeeze in as many scoops as possible into whatever size you chose. I ordered the mini waffle cone with one scoop of Cookie Break and one scoop of Mimi's Mud. Both flavors were phenomenal. Mimi's Mud might have been my favorite since there was a generous brownie to ice cream ratio, but I would definitely order both flavors again. The fresh waffle cone took the experience to the next level. If I was less full after dinner, I would have gotten the bigger cone to try more flavors. I guess I'll have to come back! read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Can't miss the sign above the shop! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

It was my first time trying this place, and I was a bit overwhelmed by all the flavors! The aroma of the freshly made waffle cones is irresistible. I ordered the cookie break and strawberry ice cream with a waffle cone on the side. The cookie break had bits of Oreos and graham crackers--basically a cookies and cream which is always a win! The strawberry ice cream had real strawberry pieces, offering a refreshing balance of sweetness and tartness. The waffle cone added a delightful crunch to the ice cream. I would recommend this spot, especially if you are craving something sweet ;) read more

Taste: higher cream content so richer taste. The flavors were ok. Size: big portion Price: a bit pricier than what I expected Line moved quick enough and there were a couple tables inside. read more

I have been coming to Screamin' Mimi's for years usually on a very hot day like yesterday (91 degrees!). I walked in around 530pm and was next! I ordered a small cup of lavender and vanilla cherry. My hubby ordered a medium cup of watermelon sherbet which was like shaved ice. They were both refreshing for a hot, summer day. The lavender tasted like the plant! The cherry was creamy and fresh with cherry bits. I love the fresh, local ingredients. You get the vibes of a small, local family business and I'm happy to support them! It makes me happy every time when I get ice cream from here! read more

Screamin' Mimi's Ice Cream - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

So charming and super large portions! We had the top selling muddy road and loved every bite! Definitely worth a visit when driving through Sebastopol :) read more