This was my second visit to Two Dog Night Creamery, and while unconventional, they win in my book. The small space is clean and puts off wonderful aromas of fresh ice cream. Two Dog Night uses lots of local ingredients to make a great product. There are many bad reviews for this shop because they do not allow samples, but don't be fooled, everything is amazing. The banana foster crunch and cookie monster were on our list during our most recent visit. The cookie monster is a beautiful shade of blue. It's clear they are not using tons of artificial colors like many other places. It also has tons of cookie chunks throughout. Yum! The banana foster crunch has so much fresh banana flavor. A freshness bomb! There are loads of tables outside in The Barlow's shared space, and there is plenty for the kids to do in the area after they enjoy their ice cream. I think the location is perfect for an ice cream shop. I'm not sure why this place gets so much hate. Two Dog Night Creamery makes great ice cream at reasonable prices with fresh, local ingredients. The service has been fast and friendly on our visits, and the no-sample thing is not a big deal. Just pick a flavor, chill out, and enjoy- they are all great! read more

See all

One of our favorite sweet stops. Plumette (my dog) can't resist their tiny ice cream cones after a spa day. I can't resist it either-my favs: Salted Caramel and Vegan Matcha. So many wonderful flavors. Staff: The service here is always amazing and so welcoming! read more

See all

NO SAMPLES?!? Ice cream quality is five stars. But the no samples was a travesty. I don't understand.

The smell of the waffle cones drew me in! I got a double scoop and opted for a s'mores flavor and mint chip. I topped with brownie bits! The mint chip was really good and my favorite of the two. The mint flavor wasn't too strong and it was very creamy. The s'mores flavor was super disappointing. It didn't really taste like s'mores at all. The ice cream is on the pricier side and the scoops are smaller than at most places. read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

I had high expectations for two dog night since my experiences before have been good. This time I learn they don't allow even a single sample, not a solitary small spoonful to gauge the taste before trying something new. What kind of an ice cream store doesn't allow that? On principle I can no longer recommend two dog night. read more

They have a tiny toddler cone that's perfect for kids but on the pricey side for what you get. read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Interior - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Located in the Barlow this place is nex to the Farmers Wife. The ice cream is super creamy and bomb flavor. I like how they try to use as many local flavors as possible. Definitely worth the stop on a hot day! read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

We walked by and the aroma got us hooked! The place is cute, staff are nice. The waffle cones are not great, it was rather undercooked and not much flavor. The ice cream was great though. We got salted caramel brownie and banana foster and both were fantastic. read more

See all

Their website was not accurate to what they had in store. When we asked about flavors we were not given alternatives and went from feeling excited to visiting to feeling like they didn't care about the customer. read more

Cute place. This was our first visit. The ice cream was good not great. Seemed to have a lot of fun flavors. The employee working was not friendly in the least bit. I wouldn't return especially when Screaming Mimis is so close. read more

FYI no samples served! Owner should place a sign on the door warning customers. Otherwise wish for the best. Price high relative to quality/quantity, over $6 for a single scoop in a cup. Not the friendliest service either. Cannot recommend. read more

The Banana Foster Crunch is my favorite ice cream ever! So therefore I must give this place a great review. :) Thanks for serving tasty ice cream! Just wish you guys did samples. read more

Just bad. They won't give you any tastes first which is unusual for an ice cream shop, but probably a smart business move because we didn't like either of the flavors we got. Flavor was mild and watered down, not at all creamy like we expected. The woman working today was also unfriendly and over charged us by $8 which I then had to go back and get fixed. Save your money and your treats for something better. read more

Super creative seasonal sundaes. Guliana was super informative. No room for sitting, but plenty of room to sit outside. Surprise was that they handmade the peanut butter cream with liquid nitrogen. Super fun! read more

See all

Great ice cream flavors Service was quick and efficient Fun place to hang out. Looked for Waldo while waiting You can sit outside under heaters if you prefer read more

Delicious bananas foster ice cream and almond sprinkles My Mom had heath bar ice cream and heath bar sprinkles read more

There are tables outside where you can sit and enjoy yourself. There were 5 of us and everyone enjoyed the ice cream! Be sure to have a waffle cone! No pictures, because well, we were busy enjoying our ice cream! Everyone was friendly and the service was great! read more

Get the caramel toffee sundae! Hands down the best sundae Ive ever had. I love me some good sweets and love to check out new and different ice cream places and this one here(as opposed to the Windsor location) never fails. This place is always packed but the service is always with a smile and they try to get you out the door while still making you feel welcomed. read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Caramel toffee sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

We really wanted to go to Noble Folk ice cream but decided to give this place a try. We were served by a young man who was not welcoming or friendly. He seemed like he really didn't want to be there. We asked for a sample and he told us they don't do samples. I don't think I've ever been to an ice cream shop that doesn't do samples. (I would think that if you make your own ice cream you would want to flaunt your creations to make customers want to come back for more, but i digress.) We got coffee heath and dark chocolate peanut butter. Not worth the price at all. Long story short: just go to Noble folk ice cream. read more

LAME! Cannot sample anything before selecting. That's OK though...I still bought a single...I will say that the new Salt & Straw offers samples with a smile and much larger scoops. The toddler cup was probably a good rounded two tablespoons at most. The size of the single scoop at this place was so small and they charge $6.25, and although is good,it is not as good as Salt & Straw or Angela's Organic. read more

There were two things I did not like about it - the first was for 6.25 you received a small amount of ice cream. The second is there was only one flavor that appealed to me (which is fine - they had a gone selection) but they do not have any way for you to do a sample taste. I was not sure I would like it but they did not have a way to sample. read more

The perfect nightcap when you're at the Barlow! Two Dog Night offers local organic ice cream made with nitrogen in-store with vegan and GF options. Sizes are small for $5, regular for $7, large for $9 and pint for $11. We all opted for a regular and to try two scoops in each. Here's what we tried: - Vegan snickerdoodle - so light and refreshing but still well-spiced - Dark chocolate peanut butter - rich and dense - Eggnog - so eggnog-y without being too heavy - Mint Oreo - such a good combo - Peppermint - bright pink and perfectly pepperminty - Coffee Heath bar - my mom's favorite, awesome combo You also get one topping free with the regular, so we got either almonds or Andes mints! Great friendly service, helpful recommendations, and a super cute spot inside. It would be helpful if they did samples but that's okay - all of ours were delish and a fun surprise! read more

See all

The smell of the waffle cones drew us in as we had time to kill before our pizza was ready. Both my kids enjoyed their ice cream. My daughter had the bananas foster and my son had the mint Oreo in a waffle cone. They have had their share of ice cream and it was good, just not the best they've had. It did hit the spot. If craving ice cream this will fit the bill if in the area. read more

See all

The ice cream here is fun and even has vegan options! The store front is really small so the line often goes out the door on busy nights and weekends. The scoops are fine but the main selling point at the Sundaes. You get so much ice cream and mix ins, it's perfect to share. read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Extremely bad service, don't come!!! Ice-cream is very expensive but doesn't taste good

Yum!!! My SO and I came here kind of randomly. We were tasting at Crooked Goat and Golden State Cider and it caught our eyes. I decided we "needed" to try some ice-cream and I'm glad we did! I had the mint sundae with their Oreo mint ice cream, Andies chocolates, Oreo, and chocolate syrup on top. It was SO good and had every bit of that farm to table vibe. Very well thought out ice cream creation! My SO ordered a scoop of the coffee health bar ice cream, and it tasted so fresh. It didn't taste like artificial flavoring, but rather tasted as if it was made from fresh coffee beans. Yum! The young man working was super friendly and helpful, too! Such a breath of fresh air to find! read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Forgot to take the pic before, just had to dig in! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

What better way to end a day exploring the Barlow than at Two Dog Night Creamery?!? They are known for their delicious fresh and creamy ice cream! They focus on creating quality ice cream that is made in-house daily using locally sourced ingredients from Straus creamer. They offer a range of ice cream flavors as well as various toppings to choose from. I love their mint Oreo ice cream with Oreo crumbles. It's my favorite and I can't visit them without getting a scope of this! They also have seasonal flavors you won't want to miss! In addition to making hand-made ice cream daily, they also make the waffle cones fresh daily too. These smell amazing when you walk into their shop! The shop doesn't have room inside for seating but there is plenty of seating located just right outside their door. read more

Creamy ice cream on homemade waffle cones?! Oh yeah, I'm all about that life! Two Dog Night makes some incredibly tasty ice cream. I have to give it up to my friend for putting me up on game. I had never been to the Barlow or ever heard of Two Dog Night before my recent visit. But now, I'm already trying to plan another visit here soon. After having an amazing dinner at Gravenstein Grill, I was in the mood for something sweet. My friend suggested that we go to Two Dog Night Creamery in the Barlow. Best decision of the night! The ice cream here is so incredibly fresh, creamy and delicious! All of their ice cream is made in-house daily using organic Straus cream that's locally sourced. I always love supporting a business that also supports locally! Two Dog Night uses liquid nitrogen to freeze their ice cream which makes for a dense and super creamy texture. And trust; you can definitely taste the difference! This is some of the creamiest ice cream that I've had in a long while. They have some wonderful ice cream flavors on deck as well as several different toppings to choose from. If you can't decide on just one flavor but don't want large double scoops (for my dieters out there), they offer split scoops here too. I ended up getting a small split scoop of Banana Foster Crunch and Cake Batter on one of their homemade waffle cones. Loved both flavors, but my gaaaawdd... that Banana Foster Crunch was HITTIN'! SO delicious!!! It was so rich and dense. That plus the wonderful waffle cone just sent me. It was so damn yummy. Their little shop is tiny, but luckily there's lots of tables and open space in the Barlow. You can enjoy your ice cream at one of the many picnic tables (weather permitting). I honestly feel like I've just come up on a gem. Looking forward to my next visit when I'm back in Sebastopol. read more

See all

Ice cream at its best! Lots of flavors to choose from. Coffee and vanilla are my favorite. I also really like their waffle cone. Staff very friendly and kind. Highly recommend! read more

I had vegan cherry chip and it was so good. Great location, service, and lots of outdoor seating. read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Vegan cherry chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Creamy, smooth, flavorful. You can feel that this is the good stuff. Way beyond Baskin-Robbins or even Hagen-Daz. Ate a scoop of Coffee chocolate chip and vanilla with crumbled heath bar. I savored every spoonful. My ice cream gold standard is Strauss creamery. Is this Two Dog as good? Wellllllll.... It's a miniscule step below in luxurious velvety mouth feel and sticky gooey butterfat. When you eat ice cream isn't it all about the maximum caloric indulgence? Rhetorical question. This is top tier boutique ice cream. I like the name of the business because I live with two dogs. Are you in the Barlow as you read this? Are you having tacos at Barrio or a Pizza at ACRE? You need dessert. Check out this ice cream. read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

After seeing that they use Strauss milk I knew it'd be good. And it totally was. Definitely going back to try a few more flavors, but I thought that it was pretty dang delicious. I think I'll try a Sunday next time. Last time I got a shake. Yummerz read more

fantastic ice cream - my favorite is the b-day cake. i buy pints of it when i'm in town. I just found out that they no longer make it. I'm not sure why because it's soooo popular. bring it back please! read more

Looking for delicious ice cream? Two Dog is your answer! They always have such amazing flavors and offer vegan ice cream that is actually so freaking good. They also have fun items like an ice cream taco that will bring you back to your childhood and the smell right when you walk in will make it so you never want to leave. Love love love Two Dog!! read more

I got the smores shake. This place smelt so amazing, you can smell it from the outside as you approach the shop. Nice staff very friendly and cheerful. My ice cream shake cup exploded a little and I got ice cream all over my hands. The lid was put on, I think a little too much shake was poured into the cup, but accidents happen, still 5 stars. Delicious and amazing smell. I want to come back and try an ice cream in a waffle cone. read more

See all

A few years ago, we found Sub-Zero and were delighted with the unique presentation of the fresh made custom nitrogen ice cream. When we returned to the Barlow a couple weeks ago, we thought that it was still there, however it had a different name with a similar concept so we gave them a try. The day that we arrived, it was horribly hot outside, and a massive group of people were around and not abiding to the covid protocol. I decided to order one scoop of the s'mores and one scoop of the chocolate peanut butter and hubby decided to go for the Cookie monster which is colored blue with spirulina. We were disappointed to see that they don't actually make the ice cream right there for you, which was part of the magic of Sub-Zero. We knew that the ice cream would be expensive compared to conventional, given that it's made in this special way and it's made with organic milk. That said, when I dove into my scoops, I felt that the extravagance I was experiencing previously had paled with this new take on the Sub-Zero model. Although it was creamy, I felt like the flavors were really muted and honestly I couldn't even taste the s'mores flavor- It was just sort of creamy/sweet. After reading some reviews on yelp from my friends, I've noted that they've said similar things: they're disappointed they don't make the ice cream fresh for you right there, and the flavors are not very impactful. I chose coming here over going to Screaming Mimi's because I remembered Sub-Zero being so good. After this experience however, I think I'll probably go back to Screaming Mimi's because their flavors are unapologetic/fresh/bold and I think overall they do a better quality job for the price. read more

See all

Never had heard of 2 dog night! Super cute, great location in the Barlow! Service underwhelming and so was the ice cream! We had toffee crunch, eggnog, and peanut butter and chocolate. Won't be going back read more

Cute spot to grab some ice cream and chill outside. We got the banana foster, and it was delicious. The banana flavor was overpowering at all. Quick service. read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Banana foster. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Something smelled wonderful and we followed it to 2 dog night creamery. The sundaes are amazing we got the toffee crunch sundae, chocolate mint and Dutch chocolate ~ did not disappoint!!!! So cream deliciousness in a cup! read more

Two Dog Night Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Located at the heart of the Barlow which was very convenient. Banana foster tasted great! Peanut butter one was a tad too sweet.