Great spot to get a drink and watch the game with friends. The bartenders were great and friendly. Tiffany made the perfect Guinness pour!

I had a few things I wanted to try, but when I saw shaved corned beef on their Reuben, I decided that's what I wanted. When I gave my order to the server, I specified how I was excited to try it because it was shaved, and he told me it was his favorite, but he could never finish it. When the food came, I was very nervous because not only was the rye bread seeded, and I don't like seeded rye bread typically, the meat was clearly not shaved, but sliced. Once I took a bite, all of those concerns were gone! Not only was it such fresh and delicious bread that I am certain they must make or get fresh from a bakery, the corned beef had to be the most tender I've had in a very long time. There was not one chewy piece throughout the sandwich. Now, those fries...they are now my absolute favorite fries! I can see myself craving those. I didn't even get through half of the sandwich because it was a lot. My husband really enjoyed the smash burger as well. He said his bun was also very fresh and delicious, the burger was great, too! The pub itself it very cute and just was you would expect to see and a friendly atmosphere to go with it. read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Smashburger - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Drinks, dinner, delicious! What a great little spot off the main strip. We've been down here many times before but have never discovered Scullys Irish pub until today. Two cocktails two appetizers one being the special oysters Rockefeller and two entrees and another entree to go! $90 without the tip. Amazing for today's economy and honestly the quality and taste of everything did not lack. I wish I had more photos but everything was too amazing not to just get into it. My partner had the Irish smash burger and I the Rueben with the shepherd s pie to go which as of right now I cannot attest too but everything was great. Coming from Yonkers NY and the infamous McLean Ave it was on par! Will absolutely be back service was also great. Cannot rave more! read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Rueben - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

My traditional Irish food quest continues with this interesting dish. A friend of mine across the pond, who displays his version of the Bangers and Mash on the regular, and I wanted to try it. This is my first visit here. This area has a great deal to offer for culinary types like me. When you walk in and are greeted, you will be handed a menu quickly and asked to place your order and pay before being seated. I felt rushed with this process, as you are requested to provide a tip before receiving services or even experiencing the food. This was odd. Upon seating, I visited the restroom and could point out that it had to have been the cleanest restroom I have seen. The restrooms have either been remodeled or are that particular, which says much about what comes out of the kitchen. Outside seating and limited seating are available inside with high tops, tables, and the bar. I ordered the pretzel bites to start and the Bangers and Mash. The pretzels are okay bar food, and the bangers and mash are what I was here for. The presentation was odd, but you could smell the seasoning and the onion gravy. I dive into the bangers and grab a bite of the four ingredients. Pleasant to see the mash is real, not instant, bangers (2) are seasoned well and full of flavor, the peas were el' dentè as though they appear to have been frozen, blanched, and served. The onion gravy was present, but limited green onions were added for decor rather than having onions present in the gravy. Overall a decent plate, left overs went into a cardboard box instead of styrofoam. . read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Bangers and Mash - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Well Shepherd's Pie is always a draw for me. Small quaint place with a good menu of Irish fare. Hi top or sit down tables. Bar seating. Lots of conversation going on. Fiddle music over the sound system. Shepherds Pie was good but far from the best I have eaten. May be back to try something else on the menu. read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

My husband & I love Scully's! They have Happy Hour every Monday-Friday from 3-6. Our favorite day to go is Wednesday because they have $1 wings which are fantastic. The staff is very friendly & the atmosphere is great. Good place to catch a game & very conveniently located in downtown Fernandina. I absolutely recommend Scully's if you're looking for an Irish pub type of vibe. read more

4.5 rounding down The ordering is kinda wonky for this layout atmosphere Many options on the .enu I would greatly try and the Guinness Pie was great (minus that there is no bottom crust for the pie My Wife had the chicken sandwich (it and the fries were amazing) Paper straws and biodegradable utensils, but plastic cups and lids (weird) read more

See all

Food, service and went there one day when very loud music was playing to an empty courtyard. Maybe consider neighbors and how that's perceived by potential customers read more

Good food and great atmosphere. Enjoyed trivia! Will definitely be back!! Great service! read more

Super great good. Nice casual spot to eat. Prices are amazing for Fernandina. You really can't beat it. My wings were just a touch salty but the food is really good. My husband got a smash burger and enjoyed it. The fries are awesome. Perfect location. Friendly staff. read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Green goddess salad, wings with timotis Cajun dry rub - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Delicious in the downtown. Fun ambiance. Great staff and delicious food served fresh. The fries were crispy and the burger was juicy. read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Bar - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Came back for second time to carry out the Guinness pie. Sooo delicious!! And the service is terrific! I'd go 6 s if they were available. Will be back soon. Thanks!! read more

Cute Irish pub in Historic downtown Fernandino Beach. They have 8 tables outside, with a fountain and umbrellas and nice music on the speakers. Order at the counter and they bring it out to you. I had the chicken sandwich and fries and they were both delicious. Coke products including Coke Zero! Paper straws are a downside. read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Dining room - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

My husband and I stopped by for drinks one night and liked the menu so we went back today. I had a Rueben sandwich with fries along with a hard cider on draft. I have tried Rueben's all over the US and this Rueben, hands down, was the best I have ever had. It was perfectly prepared and simply divine. I big thank you to the chef. It was by far the best food I have had on the island. The hard cider was also perfectly chilled and refreshing on a hot summer day. My husband had a Guinness Pie which he described as delicious and very filling. Everything in it was cooked to perfection. He also enjoyed a perfectly poured Guinness Stout. The restaurant and bathrooms were clean and the service was great. Bravo Scully's! Keep up the good work. It's not without effort and your effort shows. read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Freshly poured Guinness, Guinness Pie and Rueben Sandwich - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

I love this place! It is my absolute favorite spot on Amelia Island! Their Shepherds Pie is the real deal. And their staff make you feel like a regular once you've been there more than a couple times. The outdoor eating area is so pretty! A private garden.... Highly recommend for your visit & every local should be a regular there. read more

On the one hand, the vibe is pretty much what you get from every Irish pub; on the other hand, if you want that vibe they do everything you want from an Irish pub really well: friendly bartenders and staff, drinks done well, and solid food. Better than just solid were the Irish smashburger (basically the contents of a Reuben on top of a well-executed crisp-edges smashburger) and a "corned beet" sandwich, basically a Reuben with sliced beets in place of meat. read more

Awesome service, food and Guinness! Will be back ! I Highly Recommend. Outside has a nice tree covered Courtyard.

Great stop for our family of five (teens!) The food was wonderful, Drinks were tasty, And the kids could play darts out in the garden area while we waited for our food. The setup is a little different. You go inside to the counter, order and can sit inside in the bar area or outside in the garden while you wait for your meal to be prepared and brought to you. Fun little dining experience! read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - The Orleana - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

+ Trivia Inferno on Tuesdays is awesome + Food's amazing + Best Irish coffee in town - Please buy metal cutlery read more

We had the chance to try Scully's yesterday with a couple of our lucky charms - my wife's parents. It was a good day to enjoy the Scully's patio, where we witnessed a squirrel eating a Scully's French fry. It the squirrel posts a Yelp review, you can just disregard this one. When you choose to eat on the patio, you walk in to place your order at the counter, then they bring the food out to you. All of the staff involved in the process were friendly and attentive. Amongst us, we ordered a couple of Reubens, fish and chips, and fish chowder. I really liked the Reuben, and the fish chowder my In-Laws ordered looked pretty tempting. Although sharing is caring, I held off on asking for a sample. We'll be back to check out more of the menu and the bar area (fa' sho'). I-rish I was having another Reuben and trying a McGillicutty (one of their specialty drinks) today. read more

See all

Great outside eating! Food is good and the servers are attentive although the ordering process could be better...

The Guiness Pie was amazing! Great, friendly service and good music. Definitely recommend!

It's an order at the counter and take a seat sort of place. Wedge salad was romaine instead of iceberg, and was ok. Potpie was salty but good. Onion tangle was not good. Smash burger was fabulous. Reuben was amazing. Beef stew was really good. Colcannon was good but would be better with some kind of meat in it. Pretzel bits were decent. Brisket fries were really good. Nice atmosphere. read more

See all

Nice casual spot for lunch. We sat outside in the courtyard next to the fountain to enjoy the beautiful weather. You order at the counter inside and they bring your food to you. Staff was very friendly and helpful. The Shepard's pie was delicious and paired with the green goddess salad was the perfect lunch to share with my 9 year old son. The salad was very fresh and dressed just right. My husband had the fish and chips which he enjoyed. The slaw that came with it was very tasty as well. Prices were affordable and portion sizes were just right. read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Shepherd's Pie - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Amazing service: great people: love playing trivia here: they have great daily specials as well! Definitely recommend.

What a great surprise. This seems about as authentic as you can get without cig smoke. Charles behind the bar was cordial and talented, our food was great, especially the Guinness pie. Looking forward to going back soon. read more

Scullys has great food. Pretzels bites with cheese is great. And the smash burger is delicious and with the big steak fries. The staff are very attentive. If your looking for place to enjoy the atmosphere and get away from hustle with great food. This place is for you. I strongly recommend this restaurant! read more

Enjoy the food every time we visit. The outdoor courtyard is very nice to enjoy a beautiful day. Loved my Guinness stew. The beer selection is very good. Service is attentive. read more

I'm an old Fernandina Beach visitor and just came across this new Irish Pub. New to me. Great atmosphere, inside and outside seating, and a proper bar. Staff know how to run a pub and treat customers. Food was outstanding! Shepherd's pie was some of the best I have had. Will be back. If you're looking for the Irish Pub type of joint, this is it. read more

Good food in a pub vibe. Order at the counter and they'll bring foot to your table. Always have a game on and it's a fun environment. Just wish they had a potato leak soup on the menu. read more

Great food and drinks! Fish chips are great and the stew. Awesome staff!!! Great location.

AMAZING drinks and food! Service is excellent! The ambiance and atmosphere is so chill.

PITIFUL Ruben! All filler! 2 minuscule pieces of wafer thin meat . NEVER AGAIN . $12.00 read more

My family came here for a quick lunch. The staff was great and accommodating. The fish and chips were really good. I loved the espresso martini too! read more

Great place to relax with friends. Great food and service. Great atmosphere. It will be a great spot to celebrate St-Patty's Day! Cheers! read more

Had been here once before with friends. Brought my 93 year-old dad here on a cold wet night. Had the potato skins, they were hot and crunchy . Guinness pie and the Shepherds pie did not disappoint. The Guinness pie had tender beef and a flaky crust. The Shepherds pie was piled high with all the good stuff topped with mashed potatoes. And the live music was a welcome bonus! read more

We went there in a cold day after Thanksgiving. The place was very cozy with a pub vibe, serving Guinness and others! The Shepard's Pie was delicious and filling, perfect for a cold winter night. My family also ordered corned beef and smashberger which were excellent too! The pub definitely would be a good hang out place with friends in the future. Price is reasonable too. Will definitely hang out with friends there next time! read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Shepherds pie - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Food overpriced. LImited seating and owner does not support locals. Avoid this place. Check with other local business nearby as to many other wonderful restaurants downtown to patronize read more

I don't mind ordering food and drinks to be delivered to table. Food was excellent. I had Brisket and Fried Pickle and Hubby had Smash burger and steak fries. Prices are very fair and Irish Cream Ale and Harp beer so refreshing!!! Only thing I didn't like was paying tip up front. Prefer to leave on table based on server. read more

Sat outside in courtyard. Weather was perfect! This is the best juiciest corned beef and cabbage I've ever had!!! read more

Scully's Irish Pub & Eatery - Corned Beef and cabbage - Irish Pub Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida