We tried this place last night with family. The service was amazing and bery friendly. The food on the other hand was not. I love Shepherds pie and have eaten it as well as made it for my own family. The Shepherds pie at this Itish pub was not very good. The plate was hot but the food was just warm. The carrots were canned the meat overcooked and the mashed potatoes were stif not creamy. This is an Irish pub that that should only serve drinks and appetizers read more

I was searching for traditional Irish dishes. Upon ordering the appetizers and our drinks, we were informed that the items we had hoped to experience were no longer available. The bangers and Mash, shepherd's Pie, and the Irish stew. The good: our server poured a good Guinness. read more

This place is so unassuming but damn is it good. The inside seating section is small but they have outdoor seating options too. We would 100% come back. Service was great and food was outstanding. read more

See all

We stopped here for dinner on a Sunday evening. We weren't sure what to order, but Bailey told us the burgers were excellent. We were expecting "bar burgers" but these were terrific. Thanks Bailey, and a BIG THANK YOU to the Chef. You did a GREAT job. read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Hamburger and Onion rings. - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

8/26/23. Whenever we want to go to a sports bar we come here. It's small but if it's good weather there is an area outside too. The food is good but then we usually get wings and beer...lol! There are several large screens for viewing so it's fits our needs. read more

See all

Great place: nice people, really good food (not your average bar cuisine) Love that they are using aluminum cups rather than plastic: too much landfill trash is being generated by the bars and restaurants on our beautiful island. Now let's start either reusing (best) or recycling those aluminum cups, rather than trashing them! read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Aluminum bar ware - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Overtime is in a pretty non-descript location on 8th St. It's worth a stop, though. We went for dinner on a Thursday night. The bar is small, and there's an 8 table dining area next to the bar with multiple TVs on any wall. I could see enjoying a fabulous football Sunday in that room! We ordered the Thai jalapeño poppers to start. They were fairly standard jalapeño poppers, served with a Thai spiced chili glaze and a creamy dipping sauce. They were properly crispy and not greasy, as poppers can be. They hit the spot. We then had the buffalo wings (served as whole wings, which can be cut in the kitchen if desired, and which we had done) served with house made blue cheese dressing. They were super crispy, and not heavily breaded (which I despise). The wings were big, meaty and juicy; examples of the genre. I had the fried grouper sandwich. I wanted their house made tots, but they were out (next time for sure!). I got the chilled Thai noodles as a side; they were a refreshing and delicious change from the usual "fried, fried and more fried" side dishes. The fish was super fresh, crispy, greaseless, and HUGE, served on a toasted brioche bun with lemon/dill tartar sauce. It was an absolute home run. Highly recommended for a very casual lunch/dinner on Amelia Island! read more

See all

Wow the fish and chips were delicious and wife had corned beef and cabbage that was one of the best she has tried. Waitress was very pleasant and helped on the beer offerings. Casual Irish Pub ambiance to go along with menu. Will definitely be coming back to try more. read more

See all

Great service.. Food is top notch. I had the Rueben sandwich. Generous corned beef. Did I mention grear service! Will be back to try other menu items. read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Nice bar with some food. The locals love the burgers. Our experience wasn't that great- lots of confusion with the folks taking orders- not many people inside or outside, yet they all seemed to walk by the two of us for quite a while. I needed to head over the bar to request someone take our order. Burger was ok. Not on my list of places to go to again. read more

Service was great. Sat outside lots of truck traffic. Had fish and chips. Not so good chips were french fries fish had hard crust

This is the place to go for the best buffalo wings on the island. They are real wings, just like in Buffalo, huge!!!!Group also really enjoyed the grilled Chicken salad, Reuben and more. If you are a Bills fan they even make Beef on Wick during football season. The owner is a super great guy. Go support this new business read more

Well, our experience started off pretty good. We are Kilkenny seekers. Like finding a good properly poured Guinness is difficult, finding a properly poured Kilkenny is more difficult. When we first arrived the guy (found out we was one of the owners later) poured our Kilkenny, did great tasted great, could there be some improvements, sure, but over all he did good. Then the "main" owner came in like hell on wheels, bit him about everything "the guys" didn't do on closing and how messy the bar was. Then we watch her try to pour two Guinness for other people....this was where the shit went down hill fast. She didn't open up her Guinness line fully and I'm not doing that the one glass ( which she only poured about 3") was flat and no nitro settling. Then she proceeded to do a 3 part pour! Not a 2, but a 3. She also was going back and forth with forward pull and backward pull, which changes speed and nitro, all within the "main" pours. Then it was our turn for our Kilkenny. She poured forward backward forward, and also a three part pour. We tried to correct her and were told "honey I know how to pour a Guinness"..... Then blamed it on her lines being tonsils and explained how... She also began to get more defensive and said Kilkenny doesn't even have to be on Nitro but that was a an extra line that was there.... Hold on, yes it does...Kilkenny is exclusive to Nitro. This is not Kilians Irish red, which is what I think she was thinking of. She was the owner and unwilling to have a proper discussion on what she was doing wrong. This doesn't even begin to explain the incompetence in the conversation including thinking Guinness and Kilkenny foam.... No honey that's the nitro settling when you pour it correctly. Silver haired partner who she talked crap about did a good job and we would have a positive review if he poured them. Oh and over $10 for a 20oz! read more

Great local place. Food and service was good. Craft beer good. Like a local sports bar. We had the poutine, Philly Cheesesteak and black blue burger all were good. Would recommend this place. read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Black blue burger with sweet potato fries - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Great place for beer and Euro Cup! Sweet potato fries my favorite along with Corn Beef Egg Rolls. Highly Recommend! read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Great place for beer and Euro Cup Soccer! Sweet potato fries my favorite! Highly recommend. - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Great service and atmosphere. Come with your boys or friends for a sports game. It has pool, putt putt, cornhole and great family owns it. Highly recommend read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Had wings and a few nice cold beers as I watched Monday night football . This is a nice local bar with snappy service and a small but current menu. My food was hot and was served promptly. The wings were very good and tasty. I sat outside and enjoyed the large scree Tv and the game. read more

Went there for trivia night and had the Rueben which was awful. I can't even identify what kind of meat was in it. The fries were soggy as well. I don't think this place will survive, although trivia was fun. read more

If you want a beer and some FANTASTIC food and service, this is your place. Family owned bar and restaurant with owner and son in the kitchen. Taylor to great care of us and we left FULL!! Food was cooked as ordered and house made sauces were cherry on top. Don't sleep on this gem. read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

One of my top places to go when I just want no frills great food. Service is always superb and a all around great place to relax and relax.

If you want a place to watch a game and have a couple of beers, it's got that vibe. Good selection of Irish beers. Service was attentive and I think they want to get better. That's why 2 stars . The food was dripping with grease. The egg rolls had chunks of fat off the corn beef. Fries were okay. But every thing was dripping with grease. This feels like the perfect place for Bar Rescue to film. My advice.. fire the kitchen staff. Have the kitchen deep cleaned. Hire people that know how to cook and corn your own beef. We both felt ill after and still not great this morning. For people looking at reviews .. this place rebranded March 2024. Older reviews are another place. read more

WE CAME FOR THE TRIVIA We keep coming back because the food is really good and the trivia is fun! Great staff read more

Great place to have a beer and watch a game. Surprisingly good elevated bar food. Fried mushrooms were excellent, crispy and juicy. Keto veggie platter with chicken added was tasty and slightly spicy but in a good way ! Both were generous portions. read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Fried mushrooms - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Haven't been here in a while and went out with friends for dinner. You probably think "a sports bar"... not so much, but you've got to give it a try!! Food was great! Had a cheeseburger with sweet potato fries My friends had grouper sandwiches and they said they were great too! Staff was friendly. They even had live music outside. read more

Small family-run place with friendly bartender/server and delicious food! Tried the hot honey mustard wings to start. These things are smoked first, then fried. These are pterodactyl sized wings and so good. For entree, got the pork belly burgers with the tots. Burger...OMG. Big and delicious. Tots are homemade and crispy. Definitely will be back when in the area. read more

See all

This place with good. They took my order pretty late and still managed to give great food. The fries were awesome. The burger cooked perfectly. My favorite was the tater tots and spicy ketchup. Can't wait to go back read more

See all

Best wings on the island, wait... Best wings in Florida! Smoked, then fried for crispy skin and sauced with some awesome house sauces. (be sure to try the house made Bleu cheese) That's just the beginning. In the mood for a burger? They have beautiful big burgers cooked to order and topped with fresh goodies of your choice. They also have these amazing tater tots made from scratch. OMG Service is awesome, lots of tvs to watch sports, cold beer and a full bar menu. Plus a pet friendly patio. What else do you need? Out of the way, but worth the stop. read more

See all

Great Beer! Kilkenny! Nice owner lady. Food was good. Friendly vibe. Highly recommended

Stopped in for some lunch on a Sunday after golf with two friends. Bartender greeted us as she was closing out the only tab in the place. She continued to chat with the patrons that were done for an additional 10 minutes. Didn't offer us a menu or any other acknowledgement until we got up to walk out. There were no other customers in the entire place. I will never step foot in that place again. read more

What an amazing gem we found. The food is outstanding and the service is amazing, friendly and very accommodating for special request. We asked them to make an item that was a special several weeks ago, not on the menu the day we went and they made it for us. It was just as amazing as the first time we had it. I especially want to call our their nachos. They make their own chips which takes them to the next level. They are truly the best I have ever had. The cheese, flavorful chicken and sausage are seasoned perfectly for a perfect bite. Many times over the years at various restaurants, even here in FB, I have tried Shrimp and Grits and honestly I am not a fan. Until I tried the Shrimp, sausage gravy and grits at Overtime. OMG!!! To die for delish. My only regret is I did not take any photos to post. So unlike me honestly I always take pics of food for myself, I wanted to give a shoot out anyway. It is a really low key restaurant with loads of personality, worth checking them out. Writing this review has me wanting another trip to Overtime very soon. read more

Excellent service super good food. Every since football season this is our go to place on a Sunday! read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Crab cake sandwich w/ Thai noodles - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

A nice spot. Cozy little bar and restaurant. Friendly staff. Loved the buffalo wings.

Nice local pub. The burger was solid and the crowd was friendly. The waitress did an excellent job.

Love everything.. wings always good, pretzel bites, tuna, drinks, servers do a good job read more

O'Brien's Irish Pub - Ahi tuna and Thai noodles - Chicken Wings Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

All throughout the island there are menus that have Asian fusion, mainly Korean influenced. None of them did it as well as Overtime. As you can tell by the picture we had a lot of plates to try. There wings are deliciously saucy, but didn't pack as much heat as we were warned. Slightly disappointed, but not deterred from trying more options. You can definitely taste the love in the smoking process, everything was rich in flavor and juicy. I know it's frowned upon, BUT we were licking our fingers all night. Even though the chili is from a can, we could tell at first bite.. I look forward to coming back the next time we visit. read more

See all

New to the area and my wife and I went to the beach and stopped here after. It was absolutely great. Small family owned bar with outstanding food. The boneless wings were perfectly done and fresh. My wife got the burger with pork belly and it was very flavorful. The service staff is extremely friendly and make you feel right at home. It will be a must when I'm in the area. read more

Would give zero stars if I could. The lack of service and professionalism should be noted... crap bar food that needs salt and pepper. Ps watch out for waitress Lauren probably the worst I have ever had.... read more

Blackened burger was awesome as well as the fries. Chicken sandwich was way over breaded and not much chicken. Could not eat it all due to that. Place will be much more enjoyable when it is warmer. Outside looks like fun. Good beer specials. Service was good read more

We got the Reuben sandwiches and broccoli salad, to go. The broccoli salad is simply delectable, with raisins, sunflower seeds, cranberry, Parm cheese and some sort of sweet dressing. Gotta tell ya, it was yummy! And the sandwich was a treat, exactly as it should be made, corned beef sliced thick and piled high on grilled marble rye, w dressing, Very pleasant surprise! We live here, and we will be back for this! read more

It's O'Brien's now. Disgusting they don't even know what real corn beef and cabbage is. There version corn beef and only cabbage no potatoes or carrots. The cabbage tasted pickled my wife and I ordered same thing. Mine came out. The corn beef was put on the grill to heat it up. My wife's never came ordered appetizer never came and overcharged for the drinks while we were waiting. Paid for drinks and left, not a very good opening two days. To the owner of O'Briens step up the game if you want to be Irish learn what it is. read more