The pizza is good but good luck getting one! They do not operate by their posted hours. They're consistently shutting the kitchen down before "closing time" and when they decide they feel like making food for you they're pretty rude about it. read more

Got a Hawaiian pizza, was cooked well, would have been more robust if I asked for more of their sauce.... The sauce is sweet and the recipe hasn't changed... So worth it read more

My nephews are big fan of the cheesy garlic bread. I thought it was good too. We also tried the chicken parm calzone which I enjoyed

Absolutely the best pizza I have ever tasted. I always recommend everyone I know here, the customer service is great and amazing!

Sebastian's Pizza is a total go-to. The pizza is always spot on -- perfectly cooked crust, great sauce, and generous toppings every time. It's the kind of pizza you crave and never regret ordering. On top of that, the buffalo chicken arancini deserves a special shoutout: crispy on the outside, packed with flavor on the inside, and just the right amount of heat. Add in fast service, friendly staff, and that classic Gloucester pizza place vibe, and it's an easy favorite. Highly recommend. read more

To start the woman on the phone had absolutely no personality and if I had to guess she hates her job. With that said we went to Sebastian's because we are in town and their pizza was a staple of my growing up. Never did it fail if someone in our family died, not 2 hours after Sammy and Cathy hearing there was 20 pizzas being delivered to the door out of pure sympathy. I was looking for some nostalgia but what I got was a Digiorno box pizza with Sebastian's famous sauce (the sweet sauce). So I ordered a large pepperoni and went to pick it up in 30 minuets. I pulled up to the curb and my son went in. When he came back to the car he said "I don't think that woman likes her job". Not great that the customers see it. The pizza dough like I said was large like a digiorno supermarket pizza. The cheese was plentiful maybe a little too much. Now for the pepperoni. Everyone wants more of everything but with pepperoni too much becomes a greasy mess. The pizza undercarriage was non existent. It flopped and everything followed and all you were left wiry was a soggy piece of crust with sauce on it for your first bite. Sometimes you just have to come to the realization that some things are just gone. For something good to say the salads were the bomb just to show this isn't a bias review. If you come here get a salad and steer away from the pizza. Oh and they were out of Arrancinni (rice balls) read more

See all

I really used to love this place but we just got the most disgusting pizza from Sebastian's (3 strikes and they're out.) There must have been a least 1/2 can sliced black olives on it and almost as many mushrooms. Super sloppy with raw crust on bottom. Such a shame. Used to be our go-to pizza parlor. Highly inconsistent, we won't be going back. read more

Sebastian's Pizza - You can see how many olives we picked off. Gross. - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester, Massachusetts

I ordered a buffalo chicken calzone and expected sum buffalo chicken. This was really js sad and disgusting i even tried it cuz maybe it would be alright after looks but no it tasted like old chicken and horrible texture. read more

Sebastian's Pizza - sad asf - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester, Massachusetts

sebastian's is all about the bread it should be fresh bread. I just stopped in for a meatball sub which was on special.. the meatballs, the sauce the provolone were excellent. The bread was stale.. this was on a Monday. I assume that the bread was at least two days old. read more

Great pizza! good price and service. True east coast pizza , the dough was amazing. Generous Pepperoni servings as well. I'm trying to make up more words for the review so yelp accepts the freaking thing ! read more

Schiacciata: for the win Learned a new food today. Never heard of schiacciatta... and man do I wish someone told me sooner. It's a cross between a calzone, pizza, and sandwich. It's a 10. And I don't give out 10s easily. Crispy focaccia bread... delicious cheese and Italian meats, a nice oil and seasoning .... Served warm. One is enough but I want 10 Absolute work of art. Cannot recommend this enough. The rice balls looked awesome. Gonna try next time. read more

Sebastian's Pizza - Schiacciata: - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester, Massachusetts

See all

Definitely the best pizza in town. I love the sweet sauce and we've never had a problem with an order before. We used these guys for our kid's birthday party and all the parents could identify it was Sebastian's (and were glad it was). Meanwhile the last time I had Poseidon's (definitely the worst in town but my tasteless toddler likes it) I bit into a nice lil black hair baked in. read more

I'm from north of Boston on 93. Work in Gloucester on weekends. Bought a couple pizzas last weekend for me and my co workers. Have to say. Very good pizza. I've been to over 75 pizza joints probably in my life and this pizza was pretty darn good. Workers where busy but courteous and polite. Id give them A 5 star ! Nice job guys. Especially set week when it was hot out. Even by the ocean ! read more

Touch and go. If you go there when the owner is making the pizza, it's great. If she is not there, don't go. My experience has been disappointing. I ordered to pizzas that I had to basically throw out, that has never happened with the previous owner. You have to make sure that she is working otherwise it's Russian roulette. read more

I've tried and tired since new ownership. This pizza taste no where near the way it use to which was the pizza and sweet sauce I grew up with ... despite other changes of hands it still was Sebastian's, and this time it's not... the owners need to go back to the original owners and ask for more training or recipe because unfortunately something is very missing read more

This is our favorite pizza in town fr fr. Wicked good. Sweet sauce, pepperoni yum yum yum. Plain onion also gooooood. Onion and pepperoni zzzzzooommmgggggg bruh. So good. We love getting pizza here. Yum yum yum yum. read more

Stopped for a slice at noon on a Saturday. No cheese slices in the case so I said I'd wait. Can you believe they ran out of sauce and are not making any more pizza for the day! That's a pizza joint in serious trouble read more

I've eaten here one hundred times, if not more, and I just have never gotten used to two things: the sweet sauce and the undercooked pie. I always ask for a "thin crust we'll cooked" and I always get the pizza home with a sloppy raw middle. Why? So I either put the pizzas back in my oven or we let them completely cool and eat after the cheese has hardened. Recently we have been getting take out a Santarpios in Danvers. It's a hike and the pizza is only warm when we get it home, but omg is it fabulous. We get three pizzas and it's less Than Sabastian's. I'd hoped that new ownership at Sebastian's would have changed the sauce, but apparently there's a huge following and I'm glad for them. We only ate there so often because we lived on Summer Street, so 50 yards away, and all other pizza in Gloucester is junk. Santarpio's is the benchmark along with Flatbreads. read more

Yummy pizza! Love the sweeter sauce and thicker crust. A local favorite for many years.

I order the North End every time it's our favorite. I order the Large instead of X Large now because we would finish it at one sitting either size and after eating Large I have less regrets that I ate the whole thing... read more

BEST PIZZA I've ever had! And I've been to Italy. The sauce is sweet, and I cannot even describe the cheese - fresh and creamy. The crust was amazing. Small place, mostly take out. I ate in and the owner was so friendly and chatted with us. I wish they would deliver to Worcester County! read more

I grew up going to this pizzaria. I love it. I think the taste has stayed pretty consistent although maybe the sliiiightest reduction in quality. I still think it's delicious. I still love eating there and chatting with the current family that owns the place. NOTE that this is a thicker crust/bready pizza. Thick layer of molten cheese that will burn the roof of your impatient mouth. Slightly sweeter sauce. It's definitely a different type of pizza than you may be used to. I love it and have never found a pizza like it anywhere else. I will always go back as long as it is there. read more

Pizza smelled good and may taste as good after I fix it and add some cheese but the woman at the counter tipped it and dumped everything to one side. After a long day I was not going to wait for another. read more

Sebastian's Pizza - A pizza a worker tipped after pulling it off the oven and saw the sauce splash out of the box. - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester, Massachusetts

I enjoy their pizza but it's not always consistent. This place has changed hands a few times. Right now the pizza is very good and they offer homemade Italian pastries which are delicious. read more

Besides the ocean and sea breeze, the one thing I miss living away from Gloucester now is the great sweet pizza and sub shops. I can't manage to get comparable subs anywhere in this area and there's no where that I've found that serves sweet sauce pizza. I was visiting my mother and we needed pizza so my first thought was yes, we can order from Sebastian's! I haven't found a good up to date menu anywhere online but they have every topping you can think of. I called in and got a large with mushrooms, kielbasa and artichoke hearts. It was done on time and huge. No complaints from anyone - we all enjoyed the delicious toppings and sweet sauce. Their large truly is large - I think we had 8 slices and only $16. Worth the money for sure! read more

This sauce is fantastic. I've never met a sauce lighter or sweeter in all the pizza history of my life. It almost tastes as if it's sweetened by cane sugar or pineapple juice. It's result is that you want to eat more with the salty sweet combo. However, it can be a little annoying when you want a simply base sauce without the sweetness for your pizza. read more

I love there pizza. Hadn't eaten there in years and had heard that "it wasn't as good as it used to be".... Not true, pizza is the best of cape ann read more

Was nervous at first, NÉW OWNERS!!! But we were relived when we went there to try a slice to make sure. It's still soooo good! Damm good pizza!!! No rice balls though, work on that please, the old owner always ran out of them also. Thank you for not changing anything. A lot of restaurants in the area over the years have changed hands and it was not for the better in my opinion. We will be ordering a pie for the ride back to NY read more

Gonna keep this short. The pizza here is amazing. Best pizza I've had in a long time. Sweet sauce and cooked to perfection. Will definitely be back. read more

Really good pizza! Delivered earlier then forecasted and thankful for that. Extremely friendly delivery guy. Would order again and ask for a thinner crust! Greek salad was terrific!!! read more

This place has been around forever. While it takes a minute to get used to the sweet sauce, it mixes quite well with the generous cheese, airy and stretchy, lightly crunchy crust and if something different is just too much for you - go light on it. The staff has always been really nice, even when they are slammed. The delivery has always been somewhat on time. Their salads are fresh and well made. Whenever I visit my family I have to order a pizza from them. Pro-tip: to go with the sweet sauce, order savory / spicy things for the top of your pizza. read more

This is the best pizza Gloucester has to offer, probably the best in the north shore region. (I like Virgilio's but they close before dinner) Sebastian's have those Arancini rice balls too - but they are limited batches and I haven't seen them at dinner time. read more

Sebastian's Pizza - Current 2019 menu prices - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester, Massachusetts

I ordered a large cheese pizza and a large garlic cheesy bread for delivery. The cheesy bread comes in pizza form with sauce on side for dipping. The cook obviously used small pizza doughs and attempted to make my large orders with them. They were so stretched out and overcooked and swimming in grease. The tops of both were dark brown and bottoms burnt. You couldn't decipher where the crust ended and the cheese started. I cannot fathom the cook and counter people sending that order out the door believing it was edible. 30 dollars down the garbage disposal. Shame read more

Only got a mini pizza from here. I thought the pizza was pretty good, a place that has sweet sauce for their pies. The pizza I got was a thick crust, more like a bread loaf almost. The guy I ordered with got a size up, and his looked more typical of a pizza. I had a slice if his, I found I actually liked the thicker crust. Point being, pizza is inconsistent. read more

Now this is good pizza. Yes the sauce is on the sweet side but just the right amount, not overwhelming. Perfect dough-y crust with anything you want on it. Definitely one of the better pizza places on the island. Parking can be a pain but it's worth it! read more

My wife and buddy just haphazardly stumbled upon Sebastians the other day after skipping over Mexican for some unknown reason. It was fantastic! Their Arancini (Italian rice balls) where the best I have ever had. What I had was made fresh made that day and not salty. You don't feel like you biting into some overly spiced product like would find in Faneuil hall or a mall. The Sfinciuni (Sicily pizza) was great authentic taste, something that I have not tasted since being in Palermo Sicily. It light with a fresh dough and killer even with coffee. The place is small with just a handful of tables and real mom and pop-ish. Uber-Uber care free vibe... Looks like one of tables completely resided to just pizza boxes. Nothing special about the outside and as result can easily be over looked. I have not been there in years and Kind of forgot about them...(What a mistake) Enjoy read more

Love their pizza (especially w/that sweet sauce paired w/breaded eggplant!), calzones, subs, & their arancini (rice balls). --Very small & casual place that's great for delivery, take-out, or a quick stop-in for a bite. Watch their math, though, as I was overcharged a couple times for multiple arancini. http://www.udine4less.com/sebastians/ read more

Pretty bummed out with my service last night. I've always loved Sebastian's pizza. I called in a large cheese pizza last night as I do several times a year. They told me that it would be about 25 minutes. I drove there to pick it up 25 minutes later, and they didn't have my pizza. The woman working there was very rude and told me that I must have called somewhere else. I assured her that I had not, and I told her my order number. She said that I definitely had not called Sebastians. I again promised her that I had. She went to check the slips and realized that I had ordered it. Whoops! Unfortunately, she had given my pizza to someone else. She asked me if I wanted to wait 25 minutes for another pizza. No thanks, lady. Maybe offer me a discount or something. I'll be sticking with Capt Hooks from now on, which has better pizza anyway. And they don't treat their paying customers like idiots. read more

I stopped in here for a Rice Ball. I am now in the process of building a time machine so I can go back and just keep driving... it was so disgusting, I'm sure they probably have good food... but not the rice balls for sure. read more

Excellent first choice for pizza in Gloucester! The reviews were correct.. Amazing pizza! Greek salad was perfect too! Pizza toppings were plentiful and fresh. Sauce was probably the best I've had. Friendly staff. Will be back! read more

Sebastian's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester, Massachusetts