An Upper East Side staple! I've never been upset with any flavor I've chosen here, honestly. They have an incredibly expansive menu AND just a note that they have some additional flavors beyond what's in the showcase typically - like mint chocolate chip and some of the liquor/wine flavors! Their sprinkle-and-chocolate laden cones are delightful. My only complaint would be that the shop is kinda small so it's more of a pickup and go kind of place - so keep that in mind if you're looking for a sit-down situation. read more

I have a hard time finding orange sherbert - I'm so happy they have it even in the fall. The service is fast and friendly and they seem to really pack the containers :) I saw people comment on the staff attitude and maybe they came on a different day, but the two men working this evening were great! I will definitely return since I live close by and I finally found orange sherbert read more

All the flavors that I tried at this place were very good. I would say it was on a little bit of the pricier side for the amount that was given, but the ice cream was very good. They had a wide variety of fruity flavors to coffee flavors to chocolate related flavors. Overall, I would probably go back again. One thing I wish is that they would have more flavors for cones or more types of cones, but the cones that they had were also very good. They had red velvet. They had peanut butter crunch and many other flavors too. They also had specialty ice cream flavorsthat you can try and boozy flavors too. read more

Sedutto - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

i've been going here my entire life, phenomenal ice cream, and almost everything else. However, the reason I'm giving four stars is because I ordered hot chocolate with cookies, as they say on the blackboard that the Hot Chocolate comes with free cookies. They truly might as well erase that, because whatever those things were, you cannot call them chocolate chip cookies. They were hard as a boulder, stale, tasteless, and almost white, completely colorless. Made my mouth extremely dry. Quite honestly, it felt like an insult, "yeah hey here you go I'll be generous and throw in some cookies for you and I'm making sure I choose the absolute shittiest ones I can get" read more

Tasty ice cream, but severely overpriced! Such a shame, a great neighborhood spot, but I'm sorry two decent sized scoops and one topping should not be $11.50. Staff is friendly, but any ice cream over $10 is ridiculous. read more

Wonderful ice cream, with over 30 flavors, also many sorbet flavors. The staff is always friendly .

What a cute ice cream shop! It's very small though - there's only 2 tables. I got a single scoop of strawberry cheesecake in a wafer cone ($6). They have so many flavors!!! I also tried cinnamon cookie butter which was yummy. They offer a punch card as well. I'll definitely be back to try more flavors. read more

See all

Not my favorite ice cream place but definitely gets the job done. Got the peach and the strawberry cheesecake PEACH Bits of peaches throughout for peach flavor but they're kind of hard and feel like canned/preserves peaches. The fresh peach flavor doesn't really run through the base ice cream as much as I would have liked STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE Hard to go wrong with this one, would have liked more of a graham cracker component and again wish there was more of a fresh strawberry flavor running through the base ice cream. read more

Sedutto - Peach / Strawberry Cheesecake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Good find for ice cream on the UES, open late till 11 PM, perfect for fulfilling my after-dinner sweet tooth! Staff was friendly, portions are good for the $. Got a small but you're able to get 2 flavors which is awesome. Only not giving a 5/5 because we asked for cookie dough and it was just vanilla ... no cookie dough was found :( read more

Sedutto - Cookie dough and moose tracks ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

came for a quick scoop, and thank god I had cash. they don't accept card for anything under $10! they apparently have a lot of flavors in the back, but I quickly chose the coffee oreo on display, which felt more like coffee chocolate chip than anything. a kids scoop with a sugar cone was $5 flat, which is a pretty decent price for the area and the size of the scoop wasn't bad. would come back to try the other flavors as long as I have cash. they're also nice abt samples! read more

There are million flavors at this ice cream shop! The price point is very reasonable compared to its competitors. Tastings available. Kiddie sized cup available and a good portion. The ice cream was creamy and rich and not too sweet. I will definitely be back! read more

Sedutto - kiddie size - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Tasty ice cream on a hot summer day. We got two small cones ($5 each) to share, though one cone was bigger than the other: Moosetracks (4/5) - chocolate yogurt ice cream with mini peanut butter cups. Loved the pb cups for the crunch and taste. I do wish the ice cream itself was more creamy. Also, this cone was a lot smaller (inconsistent serving size) Pirate treasure (4.5/5) - caramel ice cream (not too caramelly) with oreos and m&m's. Great combo but very sweet read more

Sedutto - Moosetracks (chocolate with mini peanut butter cups) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Lots of flavors and offerings here. Rainbow sorbet has always been a childhood favorite so I love treating myself to it. Got the red velvet waffle cone with strawberry cheesecake ice cream last time and the cone was WORTH. Don't forget to collect + get a stamp card! read more

Sedutto - Rainbow Sorbet on Sugar Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Really really good ice cream... and froyo. It's Simply that good. Taste bud overload, good. I love NY. read more

Sedutto - Raspberry frozen yogurt with dark chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious ice cream! I have lived in this neighborhood for 10 years and only just discovered this gem! They must have about 40 flavors... I have gone 3x in 4 days. Don't judge! The ice cream tastes homemade and I love the wide variety they have. I am a huge chocolate lover so I like that they had a lot of choices for me. They also offer frozen yogurt and that will be what I try next. I loved the Smores, Chocolate Fudge Brownie and Midnight Oreo. I will be back to try some others. Great neighborhood spot!! read more

They have so, so many different flavor options for scoops here. Mostly traditional ice cream, but also soft serve, frozen yogurt, and more. You can choose from a wide variety of toppings as well as hot fudge. If you are not overwhelmed by choice yet, they also have various different specialty waffle cones (although I usually get a cup.) This is a great place when simple chocolate or vanilla is not enough. There is pretty much something here for everyone! The place is small and was really more of a takeout option even before COVID. They have a couple of tiny tables, but this is best as a grab-and-go. read more

Tiny spot with a massive variety of ice cream and other frozen treats. They only have a few flavors on display, however they have a ton in the back. I tried one of their unique flavors (salted caramel with Oreo and chocolate chips), however I was not a fan. Since the space is so tiny they do not have any seating inside, however they do have a few benches outside. The people are very friendly 6.5 read more

This is the best ice cream I've found in the city that I've tried (and I've tried a lot). The number of flavors is impressive but the texture and actual flavor of each one was amazing. I've found that a lot of ice cream scoops end up just tasting like vanilla ice cream with some mix ins - not here!! I got hotel black bottom pie (rum based with graham crackers) and s'mores, both were incredible. Scoop sizes are big and the price is very reasonable. This is worth the trip and line. read more

See all

Favorite neighborhood ice cream spot - tons of flavor options as well as milkshakes/floats/sundaes & more read more

Sedutto - Kiddie size cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I had the best ice cream I've ever had in my life here today the graham central station. I actually got trash can flavor which was good but not mind blowing. My husband got graham central station. I tried his, ate most of it, and ended up buying a quart of it to go. Amazing flavor!!! It reminds me of van leeuwen honeycomb flavor but 10X better. read more

The yogurt was inedible. I had to throw it out. It tasted like poison.what a rip off.

Stopped by here for a quick ice cream and was pleasantly surprised. Great prices and friendly service. Ice cream got the job done but nothing blowing me away. If you're a baseball fan, recommend to go on Sundays as you can get your ice cream in a batting helmet bowl of your favorite team. Solid spot! read more

$6 dollars and it was worth every cent! We could hear it being microwaved so you'll believe my surprise when I couldn't believe how delicious it was! Wish it was topped with ice cream but for that price you can afford to add some. They had so many flavors of ice cream, will definitely try one when I come back! read more

Sedutto - Lava Cake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I tried to order ice cream with toppings and the genius working here refused to add the toppings to my ice cream so instead he put each topping in its own individual cup. Why are so wasteful? Why are you so incompetent? Who wants to have 4 cups with each topping separate? Who hired this person that can't even put toppings on ice cream properly?!? This is is unacceptable. I'm 100% sure this guy ate a crap ton on their boozy ice cream. 1-give this guy a breathalyzer 2-inventory your supply 3- fire this guy for ruining the only good thing left in a world where trump is president! Did you really have to ruin the one good thing left?!? Ice cream - you ruined ice cream! read more

Sedutto - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

The ice cream/froyo is exceptional, definitely 5/5 If you're here for the service, don't bother, 2/5 But I know most people don't go to dessert places for exceptional service, so I'll skip over to the dessert itself. Firstly, there are tons of flavors. They have hard ice cream, hard frozen yogurt, but DELISH. Blueberry oat crumble (froyo) and caramel cookie crunch (ice cream) were absolutely amazing. The other thing they have is different soft serve froyo flavors which I'll have to try next time. ALSO they have amazing cones-i tried the chocolate chip cookie cone, and it's a thick cookie like cone, and worth getting! I'll have to come back for more, maybe use it as a meal replacement read more

Sedutto - Mostly check out this chocolate chip cookie cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Not my favorite. I prefer my ice cream a little bit thicker consistency, theirs melted too fast. I tried the mocha almond fudge and butterscotch pralines. Perhaps will try a new/exciting flavor if I got a chance to visit again. Friendly staff and great experience otherwise! read more

Sedutto - Small cup with mocha almond fudge and butterscotch praline - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

5 Star - Ice Cream 1 Star - Staff You go for the ice cream I get it but damn the staff doesn't give you the time of day. We got the Hard Frozen yogurt - vanilla peanut butter with some Oreo toppings in a cone. (Cone was a little sub par) & Same cone with regular chocolate. They were both absolutely delicious and we loved it. Deff going back when we're in the area! read more

Nothing special, but it wasn't bad either. Stopped by after dinner for dessert and got a scoop of salted caramel ice cream. Overall, quite tasty. I liked caramel was well mixed into the rest of the ice cream. The texture was smooth. I even enjoyed how the chocolate was salted in addition to the ice cream, which was a nice touch. The ice cream was a little too sweet to my taste. It tasted exactly like what you'd get out of a grocery store. Nothing to complain about, but also nothing to brag home about. read more

Sedutto - Salted Caramel Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Sedutto's got SO MANY ICE CREAM FLAVORS! There's even more in the back in addition to the front freezers!!! After sampling the midnight cookies & cream & ginger i settled on the ginger but both were good!! ---ginger ice cream: mmm with real ginger pieces! Super friendly staff and unique flavors... If only i lived closer read more

Sedutto - Scoop of ginger ice cream. YUM! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

If you're looking for a cool ice cream spot with some unique flavors, I'd check out Sedutto! It's a small shop, but they have a few tables and chairs to sit inside and a bench outside you can sit at too! If you go later in the day though, some of their more popular flavors may run out. I really like their blueberry flavor, as well as all their chocolate based flavors and the birthday cake! read more

Walking by this small ice cream joint on the far reaches of the UES you can't avoid it's neon glowing decor. Walking in you see the menu board listing all the great flavors. you literally can find something for anyone. Flavors are bold, and the ice cream is creamy. Never a line here, even in warm weather. Some tables and chairs to sit at and enjoy your cup or cone, but many times it seems they don't have any air conditioning. At least during the times I have been here. Better to grab and go! Hard ice cream, soft ice cream, fat and sugar free, good toppings, great flavors. A real neighborhood gem that it seems no one knows about. read more

Not my favorite place to go to for ice cream. The flavors we had (butter pecan & birthday cake) were OK nothing special. I may go back for the wine ice cream though! There really aren't that many places for ice cream in the area so if you're out of options, Sedutto is not bad by any means. However, if you can, I would explore other ice cream shops. read more

Sedutto - Birthday cake & butter pecan - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped by after work with my coworkers since I was finally able to convince them to get ice cream here. We came with excitment for pumpkin ice cream and that did not go well. They ran out! So we decided to be adventurous and go for a random flavor - they basically ran out of everything cool. That was lame.. So I went with the green tea and coffee, per usual, and it wasn't that bad but it's not something to fancy for since it tasted fake. The service was terrible. They are so rude! They gave the wrong ice cream flavor to my coworker and wasn't willing to give the correct order. When we all stood in awkward silence, he took the cone, tossed it in the sink and scooped out with frustration, the initial order. I couldn't believe how horrible that went. read more

Sedutto - Green tea and coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

My favorite ice cream place in New York. Although the shop is small, it's very clean and the owners are really friendly. There's always a line out the door on hot summer days and even on some winter evenings. Tons of flavors to choose from plus standard toppings and deluxe dipped cones. My favorites: vanilla bean, vanilla chocolate chip, coffee, mint chip, and double chocolate chunk. They also serve ice cream sandwiches and soft serve ice cream too. 100x better than any artisanal ice cream trend store in nyc. read more

This is a nice little ice cream shop on 1st Avenue, away from the hectic 2nd Avenue. Sedutto has a lot of flavors of ice cream (wine ice cream as well) as well as a variety of different cones and toppings. The line moves pretty quickly and the staff is friendly (especially the older gentleman who I think manages it). Price is fair for NY and there are plenty of unique flavors. Only negatives are the dearth of dairy free options (they have 3 to 4 flavors of sorbet which are very good, but no lactose free ice cream). I wish theybhad more options for the lactose intolerant besides sorbet. read more

Beth V and I were on our way to some adventure of ours, and were stopped dead in our tracks by the sign that read: cupcake ice cream. Say what? Apparently, you can order any of their ice cream flavors, and pick a cupcake: vanilla or chocolate. And they'll scoop out the core of the cupcake and replace it with your choice of frozen delight. We decided at the end that we'd like our cupcakes and ice cream separate, but both are good here. Yay green tea ice cream. read more

Sedutto - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Plenty of flavor choices with several staff members ready to serve you in this neighborhood fixture. Located in a small storefront, only two small tables offer seating but one can get lucky. Toppings are robust. In my opinion, Sedutto ice cream is on a par with Hagen Daz. Enjoy! read more

Great service, friendly employees and a multitude of delicious flavors to choose from

This will be a very short review. The Apple Pie ice cream is everything that is good in the world. Straight up apple pie a la mode in a convenience of a cup or cone. Toothsome bits of apple in an creamy base. Delicious. They have so many flavors. You can really spend a half-hour getting tastings of them all. I was worried about making a pest of myself. No worries. They are well staffed to handle a crowd. There's two tables that sit three each inside and two benches under an awning outside. If that's not good enough, walk a few blocks to the East River Esplanade. I still had quite a bit of my cone after a leisurely walk. A lovely way to end a lovely day. Ahhhhh..... read more

My husband and I enjoy ice cream once a week (it's the best treat of all time, can you blame us?). We vary between a few different places in our Upper East Side neighborhood, Sedutto being one of them. While we love all of our ice cream shops for different reasons, Sedutto is by far the BEST ice cream that there is.... on the Upper East Side, and I might say in the entire city, but I'm not sure I've tried enough just yet to make such a claim.. :) It's creamy. It's PACKED with delicious bites. For example, when I get my favorite flavor, S'mores, I am getting TONS of huge chocolate chunks and bites of marshmellowy goodness. This ice cream does not skimp on the good stuff. The employees are so nice. The flavors (that we've tried) are all so good. You can't go wrong. It's that kind of ice cream that will have you saying... "Oh my God, this is the best ice cream I have ever tasted," after every bite. read more