It was -5° outside in January, and for some reason we had a hankering for ice cream. You would imagine that any ice cream shop would be a ghost town on a weekday evening during the most bitter cold weather we've had in over a decade in Central Ohio. Maybe, but Shake No.8 was not a ghost town. When we pushed open the doors there were at least a dozen other people bundled up in their winter parkas, enjoying shakes and sundaes. Proof that the ice cream is so good, you'll even walk through a blizzard for it. It was our first visit and the guy working the counter walked us through the menu and showed us photos of the menu items. We decided to keep it simple with a strawberry milkshake and a limited edition Dubai chocolate shake. His hospitality and service is top-notch. You can tell he loves what he does and takes pride in it. The pictures don't even do these shakes justice, they tasted even better than they looked! The pistachio ice cream in the Dubai shake was world-class; creamy, rich with chunks of toasted pistachios mixed in. And a strawberry milkshake with A SIDE OF CHEESECAKE?! I mean, come on. There is nothing more you could ask for. All to say this place is 10/10, no notes. I'll be back for the Biscoff shake. Not even a polar vortex will stop me! read more

Shake No Eight - Strawberry shake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Shake No Eight has some great shakes. We enjoyed their smores shake and Nutella shake which were really great. The place gets very busy on the weekend and orders take time. The place is causal and have cafe like seating read more

See all

The shake was great it was delicious and refreshing . The staff recommended this one and I love blueberries so it was a win win ! The prices were about the normal for a shake spot . I was hoping they had seasonal fruit options like peach but they didn't but I would still go back . read more

See all

When in town for your teenager's science competition, you get giant milkshakes to celebrate afterwards. We are fans of ridiculous sized milkshakes and while most look great the taste doesn't always match. We were pleasantly surprised how tasty the actual milkshake was. Just wished there was a bit more detail and less plain whipped cream on the top of this one. But sweet and salty shake was a good choice for us to share. read more

Shake No Eight - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Ghastly, expensive concoctions more suited for an Instagram post, than a dessert palate. I wanted a simple shake and they covered it with candy sprinkles like a child's cupcake. So the creamy milkshake was filled with unwanted crunchy bits, weeping colorful dye into the drink. The rest of the party got shakes filled with odds and ends, candy, stuff smeared onto the glass. For what it cost to take a party of 4, you could buy your own Hamilton Beach milkshake blender and a gallon of ice cream and milk, and make better desserts. read more

We returned for our annual first day of school celebration and were as impressed as we were before. I still don't understand how they keep the place so clean when it's all messy, sugary treats. We tried new things this time and everything was incredible. The owner was so friendly! We never regret going. read more

Shake No Eight - Oreo's Crepe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Went here a few weeks ago for my friend's birthday party. The staff was very accommodating and the options were tasty! The vibe was cool too. read more

Shake No Eight - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

One of the best milk shakes I've ever had. I got the S'mores and would get it again and again. So good!

I've been to this place four times in a span of two months...And I absolutely love this place. For as long as I go to Ohio State I will be returning here after EVERY midterm. It's absolutely amazing. The inside is cute. The worker that's there every time I go, I believe is Said AlJaafari he's amazing, he puts me onto a new things that's on the menu, lovee the customer service. And it's a shame this place doesn't have five stars. It does not deserve to be empty. It's so good if you've never been here, please go!! read more

See all

The Vegan peanut butter Oreo milkshake and Nutella crape were phenomenal. The perfect treat for any evening. read more

See all

This was my first time trying the vegan blueberry pancake shake, and it was absolutely phenomenal. I also decided to give the eight crape a go, and it was a total hit! The service was top-notch, and the little spot had such a cozy, charming vibe. read more

Shake No Eight - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Absolutely amazing desserts and very creative desserts Very tasty and service is quick Love the place read more

Everything was excellent. Staff was friendly Price was a bit high for what we got. Nearly $50 for 3 milkshakes.

5 of us ordered and we are here an hour later and only 4 of us received our shakes. The shakes were good but 60 minutes is too long to wait. Getting a refund on the fifth order due to the long wait. read more

I was feeling a need to nurse my sweet tooth so I had a shake delivered to my house at 8 pm with the hope that it all came in one piece. These particular shakes are better in person. The pictures were definitely accurate even though I got it delivered. My S'more Shake was delivered after 40 minutes and it was done with contactless delivery which would have been fine had I known what time my shake was delivered. The Yelp app might have a hand with that. I will check out the physical location when I have a free day. 4 Stars! read more

Absolutely amazing, not cheap but totally worth every penny. Made very quickly and the worker was so nice great vide. Very comfortable inside nice comfy seating and I've never had something so delicious if your in town it's a must stop read more

Shake No Eight - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

This place BLEW US AWAY. The milkshake was fast, delicious, and well worth the price. We barely waited 5 minutes and the singular staff was friendly and efficient! The place itself is very cute and super vibey. perfect location near campus and easy parking too. Will be returning with my nieces and nephews! read more

Shake No Eight - Oreo Supreme Cookies N Cream Shake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

There's quite a few caveats to this review. 1. We got here at the right time (230pm on a Saturday) as some of the bad reviews complained about waiting, which we didn't have to do. 2. It ain't cheap. Be prepared to drop $10 for milkshake, but it's as much for the experience and the uniqueness of the shake as it is for the shake itself. 3. It ain't healthy. You will probably be mad at yourself but it's worth it. Not something I'd do every weekend but something unique to entertain family from out of townnor to shake up your dessert rotation. Milkshakes were solid, not life altering but a creamy thick milkshake. And the fancy decorative stuff on top of the Oreo shake is another $3 so be prepared. read more

Shake No Eight - Brewed Awakening - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I got the Cotten candy shake my sister got Ohio Blake out and my mom got the sweet and salty shake they are so good and family friendly. They are very nice people and no line when I was there the service is amazing. read more

Shake No Eight - The shakes - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This dessert is also an entire meal, haha! Absolutely recommend sharing this with someone, but so so yummy. read more

Shake No Eight - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place is disgusting. Don't waste your money! Gross! The quality is poor. I can't imagine how it is open.

The shakes are very creative and have good flavor. They are look very cute and the service is good. It's a little expensive for what it is tho read more

Shake No Eight - Sweet N' Salty Peanut Butter Shake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

My husband and I stopped here on a whim and were not disappointed. I tried the Smores shake w/ all the extras. I especially enjoyed that it wasn't too overwhelming. My husband wasn't feeling adventurous and went with the basic Strawberry shake. He said it was the best shake he's ever had. read more

Shake No Eight - Smores and Strawberry shake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

So let me start off with saying these shakes are as good as the pictures lol. My friend and I were fascinated with all the new businesses around campus. We ordered some pizza from a block over and decided to explore while we wait. Shake No 8 just stood out for some reason so we looked up some information online and was blown away at what they sold and how good it looked! As we walked up to the door we were greeted by Said the owner. He was extremely nice from the moment we entered. He let us know we were his first customers of the day so I just knew we were in for a treat! He explained the coffee options which we definitely needed and some of the shakes. To be honest I was more distracted by the slideshow with different shakes. My friend ordered his shake and it seemed like a lot so I decided not to get one and that I'd share with him because I'm lactose intolerant. When I mentioned that to my friend Said pointed out his dairy free machine which makes dairy free ice cream. I'm not gunna lie I thought it wouldn't taste good but I was so wrong. After we got our delicious shakes we started to take pictures before we dug in. Said came over and talked to us for a while as we smiled and giggled at how tasty our shakes were. I can't wait to bring my family and friends to this gem! read more

Shake No Eight - Brewed Awakening Coffee Shake and Oreo Supreme Cookies N Cream - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The staff was amazing and made our huge order rapidly! The place had a great view of high street with comfy chairs. And my personal favorite was the coffee and crepe' read more

See all

Great shakes, best ones in columbus! Great service and super clean space. Highly recommended! read more

Shake No Eight - Cotton candy shake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

So I was a fan at first but after my recent visit to the restaurant, I'm starting to understand the whole bad customer service theme. So I live in Gahanna, so when I come out here it's a light trek. On one occasion, I showed up an hour and ten minutes before closing, only to be told that they were not going to serve me because they by the time they got to my shake it would be close to closing time. I was in the establishment, there were approximately 8 customers and 3 individuals behind the counter. You mean to tell me that I can't get a shake with those type of stats an hour and ten minutes prior to closing? More recently I was really at a loss for words. I'll tell you what happened, but before I do, let me share what I observed during a previous visit. During the pandemic, I came to this establishment one night to get a shake. While I was waiting for my turn to come up, a group of three individuals received their order. As they proceeded to walk to the table to take a picture, they fumbled the platter and dropped 2 of their drinks on the floor. The workers quickly jumped up and addressed them and told them they would remake their drinks. This time, I'm at the same establishment, but this time, I committed the fumble. When the server handed me my drinks, she gave me a tray with some whipped cream on the side. I didn't see it until I was in mid-step and saw it drop, and my foot slid on it just a smidge; that's all it took for one of my two shakes to fall to the floor. The owner asked begrudgedly if my son and I were okay. I said yes, and that was it. There was no "We'll make you another one" for me. read more

See all

The desserts here definitely look better than the way it tastes. I had the strawberry Nutella (not pictured) and didn't love the texture of the crepes. I felt as though it was undercooked, and not enough of fresh berries you'd want to balance the Nutella with. The milkshake was average, though the presentation was cute. A friend of mine ordered the Oreo crepes and as written on the menu, it said it would include (melted chocolate) but instead he was given Nutella. I wouldn't usually put up a fight about a mistake such as this, but my friend is allergic to nuts, and was excited to read that this did not included Nutella. When I asked the employees if "melted chocolate" meant "Nutella," they explained that they ran out of melted chocolate, so instead replaced it with Nutella. I understand mistakes, and replacing an ingredient that they no longer have to make the dish complete.... but because Nutella includes a major food allergen, they should have specify that. We were not offered a "remake" of that crepe. I don't think I'd be coming back again. read more

Shake No Eight - Oreo milkshake & Oreo crepes - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The shakes are super expensive. They are $10.88 for a regular shake, and to upgrade to all the toppings is $13.88. The shakes are more cold flavored liquid than a milkshake. The line was super long. It took about 15+ minutes to get our order. We ordered regular shakes to go. The staff did upgrade our shakes to include all the toppings because of the wait. The upgrade was very nice. The toppings on the shakes are really cool looking, but the prices are not worth the shakes except for maybe a one time photo opportunity. read more

The service is incredible. The staff is so kind and very quick. Its a very nice modern place, the surroundings are nice. There was a water dispenser and you didn't have to pay for the water. The food was AMAZING. This is an amazing experience. read more

Shake No Eight - The O Shake Cookie Dough Shake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Have been seeing people posting about it and was wondering what the hype is about. For $11, I feel it's not worth it as it taste like a normal mint milkshake. There's peppermint candy pieces in the milkshake too which I do not like. You can add $3 more to 'eight it up' to have the whipped cream and candy toppings. However, I would prefer if we have the option to customize and choose our own toppings as the chocolate mint shake only comes with more peppermint candy pieces and Andes chocolate. read more

Shake No Eight - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I recently took my very pregnant sister in law to get milkshakes because that's all she's been craving. Overall, it definitely met up to our expectations. The location is on the southern part of campus near gateway and parking isn't too bad. For some reason, I had in my mind that this place was large, but it reminded me of the size of a coffee shop with cafe style tables, comfier chairs if a table isn't your thing, and some outdoor seating with umbrellas. I would assume that most people that go here know what they are getting themselves into... overpriced and over the top milkshakes. I got the o' shake which had cookie dough and my SIL got the sweet n salty one. Just because we felt like going all out did we decide to get all the crazy toppings just to be fun but it does add a decent extra charge. I believe for both our milkshakes, I paid around $30 total which is my opinion is pricey. Milkshake can easily be split with someone if that's what you're wanting. I for sure could not finish mine. Just of note, if you sit inside, the milkshakes get put in one of the glass cups, however, on the patio, you can only have it in a clear plastic cup. Overall, did we have an enjoyable time? Yes. Were they the best milkshakes ever? Definitely not. I would only suggest to go if you're wanting the over the top experience. I'm honestly not sure if I will be back again, but I am glad that I did go. read more

Shake No Eight - The O'Shake featuring cookie dough - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

FINALLY. There's finally a crazy milkshake place in Columbus. I've been waiting for this forever. I always see photos of these shakes but I never know where to get them. The shake was incredible. I went with Oreo supreme. It was very delicious. The only downside is covid-19. I walked in expecting a shake in a glass with fun decorations and very photogenic. What I got was a shake in a plastic cup. While it did have an oreo rim, it wasn't the cool crazy photo shake I expected. But it makes sense to do plastic and keep it simple during these times. I enjoyed the shake a lot. Definitely a bit pricey. I'll probably wait to comeback once covid is gone. read more

See all

Super cute over-the-top milkshakes that are very Instagram worthy! There's a lot of places that have milkshakes, but do they have them as cute as this? read more

Shake No Eight - The O Shake Cookie Dough Shake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Place was really good. Great customer service and great vibes inside with chill music and comfortable lounge area. People are only putting negative reviews because the wait is long and are mad they said they can't come in. Once you get over that the experience is worth the wait. Love it. read more

See all

I tried Cotton Candy milkshake this time. When I got the milkshake, I was like wow it looked so cool! It had a strawberry flavor cotton candy, and a stick of sour candy on top. The milkshake was not overly sweet, and it was so fun to eat with other toppings together! Don't forget to order "shake it up" to upgrade your milkshake, have all these fun toppings on it! read more

See all

If you're looking for a fun date night spot, this is your place! One milkshake is enough for 2, or you can each get something different and try each other's! Lots of options, glorified milkshakes! read more

Shake No Eight - Oreo Supreme Cookies N Cream Shake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

So, apparently, after delving into the reviews of this place, horrible customer service seems to be the main problem they were facing. However, they mist have changed staff or something, because when I went, there was only 1 person behind the counter and a help wanted poster on the door. He seemed so eager to have a customer and asked me all about my day, and was willing to explain the different menu options to me. The milkshake itself was just okay, but the 1 employee was so amiable that I give this place 4 stars. The place was barren, and given that the employee was just chilling outside the store before I came in, I think it is a safe bet to say that business wasn't going well. I hope that this business can do a little bit better because it seems that they have new, nicer employees. read more

This place was so good and my Daughters were in heaven. I tried all of them and can't tell you my favorite. Make sure to Eight it Up. read more

See all

I've been wanting to try this place for awhile now and so glad we finally did! I thought the only thing they sold was milkshakes but I was mistaken- lots of different fancy beverage options and some other snacks. We came for the shakes though, and finally settled on an Oreo one. With tip, one shake ended up being about $18, which is obviously quite pricey for a shake. However, I would say it did live up to the hype. The best touch was Oreo crème filling on the outside of the glass with Oreo and sprinkles smattered around. So freaking good. The shake itself was also quite good- the addition of whipped cream and Oreos and fudge really elevated the experience . Definitely bring a friend (or more) to split the shake with; teamwork makes the dream work. The staff was prompt and courteous and so kind to us even though we made a mess that could rival that of small children. read more

Shake No Eight - Oreo Supreme Cookies N Cream. WOWZA. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Columbus, Ohio