Recommended by Kevin of TeamTaylorNJ (basically Taylor Ham's version of Portnoy's pizza reviews) this month was Scheimers Deli & Catering's Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese sandwich, located on Rt. 10 West in Denville. An impressive score of 9.3 was enough to put it on my radar. Cute little eatery. Very clean and airy inside, with a cool retro decor ambiance and vibe. They also have several outdoor tables if dining al fresco is your preference. It was mine today. The sandwich was very good as reviewed. Plenty of taylor ham, eggs, and oozing cheese. Fresh, soft keiser roll nicely holding it all together. And, the price under $7 is seriously a great bang for your buck. Nice little place. Good food. Friendly service. I'll be back! 08/27/2024 read more

See all

Shake Hands with Sheimer's, the little mom and pop shop where big Sandwich dreams are made, Lol!! Seriously though this place has always been a solid stop whenever I've been in the area and hasn't ever let me down.    My latest visit scored me a Jersey Classic Sloppy Joe Sandwich with Roast Beef, Turkey, Swiss, Coleslaw, and Russian Dressing all piled high on Rye Bread which totally made my day and kept me going all throughout it. Can't ask for anything more than that. . . but wait there's more. Like a heaping pile of their housemade Potato Chips for the win, now that's what I'm talkin bout. Come And Get Your Munch On!! read more

Sheimer's Deli - Housemade Potato Chips Ftw!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Denville, New Jersey

See all

My wife picked up some food from Scheiner's deli nearby and I have to say, this might be the best bang-for-your-buck sandwich in all of NJ. She brought home a great bacon, egg, and cheese for me that was both hearty and filling. Big sandwich for a reasonable price. read more

See all

Not good for pastrami terrible go to Livingston believe this was s not edible .... Do better guys

Nice place. Cozy. Eat in or out. Good food. Good coffee. There was a young man behind the counter, age 21, taking the order and answering questions. He was very polite, educated and well spoken. Sadly those abilities seem to rare among other young people in retail these days. This young fella will go far in life, I'm sure. read more

Friendly staff. Luncheonette atmosphere. Food was fine. If you haven't been before, although it's easy to spot, with good parking, It's on a fast road so i recommend using your gps. If you pass it it's not easy to circle around. read more

Stopped in here for breakfast a few months ago. They weren't even on Yelp at the time. I had mixed feelings about the place. I went with a breakfast sandwich which was good, however, it was on the small side and more expensive than the average place in the area. I also wasn't crazy about the ordering system where you had to go to a machine to enter what you want, rather than speaking with someone. Felt like being at Quick Chek. I'm assuming staff was friendly, however, it felt rushed and disorganized. Hopefully it improved in the last few months. read more

I got the Sheimers and he got the Italian sub. Both were solid. You get a side with your sandwich, we picked onion rings, which ended up being huge full sides. Rings and special sauce were also solid, nice and crispy. Next time we would split a sandwich and side of rings, both are pretty big! The only points off are for the overwhelming grease smell inside (our clothes wreak even after we left) and the bathroom which had a window that was open to a porch where people could see in with no way to shut the shade. The toilet is right in front of the window. read more

Sheimer's Deli - The Sheimer Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Denville, New Jersey

Great service, very fast, and fabulous bang for your buck! I live in town and was eyeing up Sheimer's for years, the problem is they are closed on Sunday's. Finally I got around to coming here and got the Scheimer. I am struggling on a 3 or 4 star rating. The sandwich was good but not great. The bread tasted a day or two old, but still tasted fine. The bacon also taste a day old, but again fine. The four stars really is for the small business aspect. I'll be back to try something else read more

See all

The bungles is the best take out sandwich in this part of the state. You know this. I've also enjoyed a few delicious Taylor ham egg and cheese, which is classic. If you want delicious food with quality service and a can-do spirit--look no further read more

So happy to finally have a decent 21st century deli in my area... first experience in summer was a positive one - 8-10 hot takeout sandwiches, half hour wait and reasonable prices. Friendly staff. Outstanding fried eggplant sandwich with broccoli rabe and mozzarella. Second experience in late November was disappointing. Ate in, ordered eggplant sandwich again and although eggplant itself was outstanding, the bread was disappointing and the mozzarella was not fresh but maybe processed and sliced like cheddar cheese. Ruined the sandwich along with the grocery store balsamic vinaigrette which was nasty. read more

First time going here. A little small on inside but that doesn't matter. A+ for service: young lady was helpful. Fast service. Free side of macaroni. A+ for above average sub roll, not the cheap rolls you find at average pizzerias. Solid fresh sub roll. B++ for the actual sub, typical size fresh turkey, made to specification, but a little light, coulda thrown on a little more meat... But hands down definitely better than any cheapo pizzeria in town. Overall grade: A-. I'll be back. Sorry no pics... read more

I LOVE Sheimer's!! Sheimer's has the best wraps around and for a great price. I am not a Jersey native, so I enjoy taking my friends to this fresh, authentic Jersey deli. With smiling faces to greet me, I'm never disappointed with the food I leave with. read more

Sheimer's Deli - italian sub, wrap instead of sub roll with mac salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Denville, New Jersey

Very good breakfast sandwich and coffee. They have a weekly dinner special for $39.99 that feeds 4-6. They deliver also. read more

Sheimer's Deli - Store sign - Sandwiches Near Me - Denville, New Jersey

If you haven't been to Sheimer's Deli, you're truly missing out. My wife and I recently had the chance to stop in and try the meatball parmesan sandwich and cheesesteak sandwich with steak fries. They were absolutely delicious! The bread that they use is delicious and hold the contents of the sandwiches just right. We ran into one of the owners, Mike, while we were there who actually told us to try both sandwiches we ended up having. He also brought us out some a creation of his own, the thanksgiving surprise bites. Holy cow were they delicious. We will definitely be back to try more food from their extensive dinner, lunch, and breakfast menus! read more

They're sandwiches are not great compared to many others in the area and they also overcharge by quite a margin . For example 26.00 for two subs not even large size and certainly under stuffed . Many better values around read more

Great Deli!! Prices are fair for sandwiches because sides are included. The girls behind the counter are so sweet and always have a smile on their faces. They have other food besides just sandwiches that are delicious. I've been going to this deli for a while and they always seem to do it right. The deli worker Javier makes the best fresh sandwiches and paninis, and he suggested I use Chipotle Mayo on a panini. He wasn't wrong! I crave their homemade chips all the time! Def a place you can't miss! (Their brownies are even to die for) read more

The food was good (breakfast sandwich+coffee). Not a huge fan of the ordering system - felt like a gas station set-up. The order was made correctly and didnt take much time at all. Nicely packaged. Have tried them a few times before providing a review. I would recommend this deli and will return. Parking can be tricky around lunch hour as there always seem to be a lot of cars here. read more

Awesome deli. Great sandwiches. Indoor and Outdoor seating. Macaroni salad was delicious. Will definitely come back.

Someone ordered me a surprise birthday lunch from Sheimers and the food was out of this world good! We got a cheesesteak and Italian sub and both were awesome!! Delivery person was friendly, polite and courteous. Amazing experience, will definitely be ordering from here in the future. read more

As a last minute decision on what to order for dinner we decided to get sandwiches. I called to ask if they were open and was told they close at 5, that was 7 minutes away. The man was very kind and said if we still wanted to order that it wouldn't be a problem, he'd wait. Sandwiches were so delicious & the hubby said the place inside is adorable. This will definitely be our new go to place. Can't wait to try more of what they have to offer. read more

Since Sheimer's is by my house i've gone here for about a year, but with COVID i appreciate them more than ever! They are prompt with their delivery and great for hot sandwiches like paninis or melts. We prefer to get takeout that is reheatable out of an abundance of caution, and their tuna melt was GREAT. Not dry and just the perfect size, it really hit the spot. read more

Sheimer's Deli - The Mabel panini - Sandwiches Near Me - Denville, New Jersey

Excited we have this new spot in our area. I'm impressed by the ingredients - the bread is fresh, the chicken cutlet is the perfect thickness (which is not too thick), the cheese is great and their fries are crispy steak fries. I was hesitant to try them out as there arent many pictures of their sandwiches on yelp, but am very glad that I did. I had the crispy chicken sandwich and my mom had the shemtov panini. read more

We had an afternoon party yesterday catered by Sheimer's. It was delivered right on time (thank you Juan) and everything was delicious. We had a hoagie platter, an antipasto tray, macaroni salad, coleslaw and fruit bowl and tray if chicken fingers. My guests were very happy. And Fran was great helping me estimate how much food I would need based on the number of guests. That was a great help. Will definitely use Sheimer's again and visit for lunch! read more

OK lets start. Fellow coworkers and i have frequented this place since they've opened. The food is always good, when it's right, and on time. Service is extremely spotty. I've called in orders at 11:30, for pickup at 12. Show up and it's not ready, until 15 mins of standing around. I've called in at 11:30 for pickup at 12, shown up at 12 and had the owner question me "are you sure you called in?" No i just showed up to stand around of course i called in! Leading up to me standing around for 30 minutes while they cook my order. No apology, no discount or anything. Not to mention a few times they've messed up my order or forgotten part of my order to pickup for a few coworkers. Now onto their delivery service. We figured since they cant get pickup right, maybe delivery? First few times they were spot on, on time or early. Perfect! 2 months ago we ordered, called in at 11:30 as usual for noon delivery (our company has strict company wide lunch from 12-12:30, so being on time is imperative). 12 rolls around, nothing. 12:15, still nothing. 12:30, we call to see what happened, to be told "it left *click*" No apology or explanation. No call "sorry we're running late". At this point we said screw it not going here again because nearly every time someone gets screwed out of something or lunch is severely late and cold. Fast forward to today. Coworkers and I get a wild hair to give Sheimers another try, why not maybe in the 2 months they've improved their delivery service. NOPE! Call in at 11:30, for noon delivery. 6 sandwiches/paninis. No call, nothing, and they show up at 1:00. My hot panini is room temperature and my fries are cold. Your food is good, when it's right and on time, but if you can't get the service side of the business down, what good is it? If we've had this same experience for the 20+ times we've ordered from there, i can't believe we're the only ones having issues. I can't comment on sit down, as i haven't actually gone in and stayed for food, but on their call in for pickup/delivery, we've given them 20+ times to get it right, and 90% of the time it ends up with twiddling thumbs and growling stomachs. read more

Finally stopped into Sheimer's today! Turkey Sloppy Joe - delish and large enough for two people or two meals. Got a few chicken cutlets and eggplant cutlets "for later". I left the eggplant on the counter when I got home. Everyone who walked by casually ate them until they were - G O N E. The chicken cutlets were freshly fried while I waited. This place....SAVAGE! Will be back for sure, I plan on having the weeknight meal (feed 4 for $40) one night soon. read more

Sheimer's Deli - Turkey and Swiss Sloppy Joe - Sandwiches Near Me - Denville, New Jersey

See all

Best paninis ever very nice place with amazing food! I will definitely be coming back! Very friendly and welcoming.

I waited 40 minutes for one of there daily sandwich specials , people who had ordered after me all got there food before me , got tired of waiting left with no lunch , will never go back, seemed very unorganized, I will not be back , read more

Horrible place, DO NOT GO HERE! There are too many other options in the immediate area that provide better service at a better value. Today was the second time I gave this place a chance. EPIC FAIL ONCE AGAIN! This was the second time my breakfast order was completely screwed. Once again, the eggs were under-cooked, the order was wrong, and the prices are incredibly high. You are better off going to the diner down the street than wasting your time and money at this dump. The way they serve customers is disgusting. This kind of service spells failure for this business. read more

I have been here twice and was very pleased both times. The food is excellent, the portion size was quite large and the prices are very reasonable. I was also very happy with the customer service I received, very pleasant people. I am looking forward to coming back and trying more new foods. read more

Nice new place, completely renovated under new management. Good Luck!