Popped in for lunch on a Saturday and had a wonderful time. Service was fantastic and our food was delicious. The sauce accompanying my calzone was tasty and the calzone was perfectly baked. Oh and the wine slushy was yummy! I'll definitely go back. read more

See all

Nice place, yummy pizza and love the icecream pints they have! Very tasty icecream will be visiting again soon!

Got catering from here two days in a row based off of my sister in laws recommendation. The entire crew was very happy with it the first night, so we figured we would try something different from the same place. They ended up giving us the same thing on accident. When I called, the owner immediately fixed the issue by delivering some delicious pizza and offering a partial refund. We are planning on ordering from them again. The harvest salad is yummy and so is the chicken parm. Penne pesto had a lot of flavor surprisingly. read more

Well, I understand everything getting to cost more so $27 for a pizza is what it is, but the OVER SALTING is just crazy . way too much salt way too much! Not sure if you're trying to Pickle me but my lips are still burning. Love ya there but just too much salt it ruins the pizza! The young ones in the back they need to test their foods.. read more

My friends took me for dinner at Sirna's pizza and this is another restaurant that I will return to when I visit again. The owner Craig and server Kinzi are very friendly and helpful. Since my friends are regulars shortly after seating we were served fried calamari and sautéed mussels. I guess my friends always orders these because they came without us ordering them. Big portions and the squid was so moist and juicy with a nice crispy coating. The garlic and butter mussels were addicting. The fig and date pizza was different but delicious. My go to is always a supreme pizza and Sirna's did not disappoint. The supreme was excellent with generous amounts of meats topping the pizza. Craig gave me a bottle of their horseradish pickles to take home to Hawaii and I think these were the best pickles I've ever had. The horse radish was mild but tasty. I only wish I bought more to take home. Oh well, next time. read more

See all

Our 17 year old son orders their gluten free pizza crust and loves it! Orders at least once a week!

Seven of us had the opportunity to dine here yesterday. We started with the boneless and traditional chicken wings which were delicious. The homemade wing Sauce is plenty full and delicious . The table also ordered an array of pizzas, pasta and salads. The pizza was amazing. Everything is fresh and directly from their farm only a few minutes away. All the pasta noodles and Sauces are made in house and are delicious. This is a local family owned and run business. Great place to take the family. read more

Charged 180.00 for us to dine in after a funeral. That was on top of the cost of food. Cost 30.00 a person for pizza and salad. So disappointed! Per plate at a wedding is the same and you get varity. Will never go back!! read more

Did a hike at Punderson State Park and decided to give Sirna's a try since it was Pizza Week. Located near the Routes 44 and 422 Sirna's Pizza is a free standing building on Washington Street. Inside is a order counter, display coolers and a socially distanced dining room. Pizza Week offerings were a variety of 10" pizzas, I choose the White Garden; a white pizza with veggies. Although the wait was a little long for the pizza, it was well worth it since the pie was excellent. The crust is thin, but sturdy enough to support the toppings, flavorful and chewy. The white sauce was perfectly garlicky, just enough flavor to set off the other ingredients without being overpowering. The cheese was nicely balanced and the veggies were fresh and crispy. The pizza comes together well and was the perfect size for a single meal. Sirna's makes a really good pizza, this is a fine example of a thin crust pizza. If you are East of Chagrin Falls; visiting La Duc Reservoir or otherwise in the area well worth a visit. read more

See all

Slow when we arrived. Getting much busier past 6pm. Got loud once it filled up. Still can hear your table's conversation. Servers were appropriately attentive. Pastas are made fresh here. No bread served with dinner. That was odd. We had ordered cheesy bread. No pic. We were hungry. Great sauce with it. Same red sauce on the chicken parm. Red sauce is sweet and chunky. Very clean place. Two single person restrooms - love that they are unisex. Food was good. Will return to try something else. read more

Sirna's Pizza - Prosciutto aglio e olio - Italian Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

See all

The boy is back to running Track on Saturdays so I need to find a bunch of Pasta places for Friday night dinner. Saw this place on Yelp and was like, I've never been there let's try it. We arrived about 5ish on a Friday evening and there was not very many people in the dining room. I was a little concerned with that. We ordered the meatballs as an appetizer. They were firm, good size, and full of flavor. I didn't get the recipe, but there was a combo of ground meat, pork, and maybe veal in there. All I know is they were delicious. The boy and I created our own pasta dish. Fresh made spaghetti, red sauce, and a some veggies for me. The boy got the bacon and chicken with the red sauce. Pasta was good, its a thicker spaghetti noodle. The red sauce was sweet, with some tang to it. Good seasoning within it as well. The boy enjoyed the red sauce and his chicken, but not the bacon. He's the captain of the crispy bacon club, this was more of a pork belly and not as crispy. I loved it. The bill was about par for a pasta place, which is usually a little on the expensive side. I also purchased a dozen farm fresh eggs, and some really good home made ice cream on the way out. I'll be back to try the pizza. :-) read more

Sirna's is excellent! What a difference farm fresh makes in the ingredients. Even their wings are local and the options for sauces and rubs are locally made as well. Homemade pasta daily. The prices are reasonable and worth our 30 minute drive for the awesome food.. We always order the veal Marsala with homemade cavetelli . So good. While you're there pickup a dozen of farm eggs they are incredible! As well as their homemade pickles. Highly recommend! read more

Sirna's Pizza - May special salad. SFG! - Italian Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

See all

Pizza is delicious, and Keto friendly with the cauliflower crust! The staff are friendly!

Vegan & Gluten-free pizza, cauliflower crust, pesto sauce (only sauce with no oil), fresh mushrooms, spinach and tomatoes. The pizza was delicious, but not hot enough. I ordered my pizza a day in advance for 3pm pickup. Then I called back at noon and asked to change my time to 3:30pm. I was disappointed that my pizza was not hot, even though I used an insulated bag. If I try this place again, I will order my pizza right before I am ready to pick it up, hoping I will get a hot pizza. Everything else about the pizza I loved. read more

Sirna's Pizza - Vegan & Gluten-free pizza, cauliflower crust, pesto sauce (only sauce with no oil), fresh mushrooms, spinach and tomatoes. - Italian Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

Great meat lovers pie tonight! Delivery Keep up the good work farm fresh for sure Great local farm products. Awesome surnames. Keep it up

Fantastic gluten free pizza the pasta sauce is delicious. The service is friendly and welcoming. The ambiance is basic. Could use some plants or soft surfaces to absorb the sound and make it feel warmer. Overall, great pizzas! I recommend it. read more

The food at Sirnas is so good. Service is quicker (way quicker) than any DoorDash. Very good local feel. The ambiance is a delight. Ain't that far from my house a about 5 minutes! Boneless Wings are the bomb! read more

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. Local family and they use local products! Their pasta is by far my favorite as well. Craig is so friendly and always talking with customers. read more

Great food - lots of goods locally sourced and is very consistent. Service is great in a very relaxed atmosphere.

The atmosphere kinda sucks as it's more in line with a fast food place rather than an Italian restaurant, but the food is phenomenal and super fresh read more

Stopped with some friends for Italian food. Shared a pizza and we where not disappointed. I rated on the one bite scale at a 7.3 very good pizza! We also shared a salad and again very very good. Fresh ingredients and a balsamic vinegar dressing that was a game changer for some as it was their first time trying a salad dressing like it. I picked the stuffed peppers with spaghetti. All the pasta is homemade and what a difference that makes. I was very happy with my selection. The other folks got either the chicken parmesan or the veal. Everybody was pleased with their selection also. I posed the question " would you come back?" And everyone said absolutely. read more

Sirna's Pizza - 12" cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

Came back had their Tuesday special Prime rib dinner . Delicious prime rib serviced with redskins mashed potatoes & Asparagus. I'd recommend any one trying it. read more

We love Sirnas! We've been customers for years and their food is the best! Friendly and courteous staff! Always willing to figure out how to accommodate a special need if necessary to help everyone feel at home! read more

Great pizza. Really great Italian food in general. Had them make the food for my rehearsal dinner. Homemade past is really great too! My whole family loves this place. read more

Came back had their Tuesday special Prime rib dinner . Delicious prime rib serviced with redskins mashed potatoes & Asparagus. I'd recommend any one trying it. read more

We came here for gluten free pizza lunch and were not disappointed! The food was pretty good, service was fantastic and we'll be back next time we're in the area. read more

First time stop in for us even though been in the area for some time. Great sit down restaurant with great service had a couple apps and a Pizza that was excellent! Will be making it a regular place for us. read more

Very disappointed, once again! Before ordering the "lunch pizza special", I inquired as to whether they had pepperoni pizza or not. I was assured they did, so I placed my order. After waiting five minutes, I was then told that they were out, but making more. I explained that I couldn't wait and would like a refund. Another worker came out (the one always wearing a backward baseball cap) and stated they didn't have the authority to process that, as Craig wasn't in. She is been there every time I go in and has never been very pleasant! I explained that I had specifically asked before ordering if that pizza was ready and suggested they could refund cash, as again, if I had time to wait for Craig to return, I would've had time for them to make pizza! This is not the first time I've been told to wait after placing the "ready to go" lunch special. Twice before, after waiting for the pepperoni pizza, I've returned to my office only to I realize they just stuck a couple pieces of pepperoni on a cheese slice; certainly not the same as when it's baked on. I've also ordered the wings before to take home for dinner for the family. They were RAW inside and the buffalo sauce was not good. read more

My girlfriend ordered 3 pizzas 24 hours in advance. I got there at the pick up time and they had lost the order. After they found it i waited another 45 minutes. I went back to the counter to ask about the order. The young girl said " you are going to be mad. They haven't even started it yet!" I gave her the address and told them to deliver it because I did not want to sit there another hour. It took ANOTHER 2 hours for delivery. If it was my order and not my girlfriend's daughter's birthday party I would have cancelled it. read more

Tony is the man. The pizza is fantastic!! You gotta check these guys out, worth every penny

We ordered thin crust pizza and the dry rub wings last night. Everything was amazing!! Nice crispy wings and the pizza dough was chewy and delicious. Delivery driver was prompt and very kind. I will definitely be ordering from here again!!! read more

AMAZING! we love the service the food and the atmosphere. It's our go to when we want a meal that rates home cooked with love. Everything is farm to table and tastes so fresh. It's perfect! read more

Took forever for our food. They were taking too many online orders. Mot worth the wait.

Love this place. Gluten free options are great. My favorite is the White Garden Pizza!

Absolutely the best pizza in the Chagrin Valley!!! reasonable prices, and a friendly staff also. highly recommended. I would give it 10 stars if I could. Ms. Fender was extremely professional! read more

This is the second time I ordered their signature veggie pizza with cauliflower crust because it is so delicious! Its topped with thinly sliced onions, and green peppers, along with artichokes and mushrooms and the crust is a perfect, a slightly chewy, crunchy crust. Their homemade meatballs and red sauce are a favorite too!! read more

Great pizza, friendly staff, and nice new building. They had yummy red wine slushies too. You pay more for things there, which is why we don't go too often and it's a special treat. read more

IMHO, the best pizza in the Chagrin Valley. Non-pizza items are interesting and adventurous, staff are always friendly and professional

The food is always great. We absolutely love the gluten-free chicken fingers. The honey mustard is divine for dipping.

Have enjoyed there carry out pizza a few times and this was our first time dining in at their newer facility. Arrived early enough to get seated right a way in the comfortable country style setting. Server was prompt in getting the order process rolling but that all fell short for the rest of the meal. Nice enough young gal (likely inexperienced) but nothing again until all at once, boom, everything came to the table...salads, appetizer and dinners. While we managed with the situation as it was, the offering of food was delicious. Keeping this hidden little gem a secret doesn't help in supporting local, small business. So if you're in, around or traveling through the area, yes, I certainly recommend giving them a try. Know doubt we'll be back too! Four and a half stars! read more