It's slightly better than dominoes and 3x as expensive. Might be a fun place if it were bumble****…read moremiddle America, but this is long island where pretty much any generic pizza place staffed by teenagers is always a good choice. If you want to pay $70 for one app and two small dry pies with minimal cheese/toppings and tough mediocre crust this is your place I guess. That being said, it's still pizza so it was fine. Go to Rosas instead and significantly better and cheaper pies with high quality ingredients, but if you must have an "artissinal" pie, head over to Ella's. Still not worth it but much better.

We went to the dead chefs society supper club event at this restaurant…read more Wow. Mini preview of lasts night. Dead Chef's Tasting Menu at At 1654 Pizza Company - A Gold Coast Supper Club Experience Last night on Long Island's Gold Coast, I had the pleasure of experiencing something truly special: Dead Chef's tasting menu at At 1654 Pizza Company in Huntington. What unfolded wasn't just a dinner, but a full-on culinary performance that transformed the idea of a neighborhood pizza spot into a hidden gem supper club. The evening unfolded course after course, each dish layered with creativity, bold flavors, and a touch of surprise. From refined takes on comfort food to plates that made you pause and savor every detail, it was clear that this wasn't a typical night out--it was a carefully curated journey meant to linger in memory. The atmosphere matched the menu: intimate, buzzing with energy, and elevated by a sense of discovery. Every dish felt like a conversation, and the storytelling behind the flavors was as captivating as the food itself. Outstanding is the only word that fits--yet still feels like an understatement. This wasn't just a meal; it was an experience that makes you excited for what's next.

This is one of the nicest sit down pizza places ive been to on the north shore of long island! the…read moreslice i had was kind of crispy which is a plus for me but might not be for others. the rice balls were generously filled with beef and the restaurant was very warm. amazing prices too! please try this place out they're a gem

Great pizza in a really nice atmosphere. Easy parking. Will definitely be returning again and againread more

Amazing and unique take on a pizza slice. It's a small cash only joint but worth it to try. Their…read morecold slice pizza as it's known is a plain slice with fresh mozzarella drizzled on top. It melts while you eat it. Soooo good! It's a self serve spot and no frills. Iced tea is a great pairing to the pizza.

Nice pizzeria right on New York Ave. Mom and pop place which is nice. I grabbed two slices to go…read morebut there was seating there and the store is right on the corner. Slices came out quick and they were good but they were a little on the small side. Good place to grab a couple of slices though.

Service was good! Wine was great. The food came pretty quick. I loved those egg rolls. I can't…read moreremeber the name but if I remember correctly it's under spring rolls even tho it's an egg roll lol. Either way I enjoyed them with the sauce. The pizza was good as well just needed a little salt. I would go back! It's a small location. The bar literally can only fit 2 people.

Truly one of the best restaurants we have ever gone to. Amazing service, and even better food. We…read moretried 6-7 different plates each better than the next. Super cozy and family oriented inside as well. Cannot wait to go back and recommend to others!!

From 4 stars to 5. Best pizza around. Go get yourself some - too good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!read more

We haven't ordered from this restaurant in over a year due to my health. We ordered two hero's…read morewhich cost over 40 dollars! I'm well aware prices have gone up but 43 dollars! I felt the quality of the food was disappointing my wife felt her chicken was inedible. This use to be goto restaurant I'm sorry I won't be back

Great rice balls. Greek salad pie. I love their pastas too. Will definitely go back to try other…read moreitems

Normally they are very on point with quality and portions. My mom got the Hot antipasto and…read morespaghetti with shrimp. Hers was perfect as usual. Unfortunately my long island cheesesteak was way to watery with sauce and one side barely had any meat it was onions peppers cheese and sauce only. And my stromboli was skimpy beyond skimpy barely any meat and burn to no end. The edges aren't edible at all its so burnt. Again they normally are on point, and everybody has a bad day. So i will eat there again but i will move on if happens again.

I just gobbled down two of Rosa's vodka slices and they were out of this ever-lovin' world! I…read morecannot even describe how good the sauce was, and how the slice held together, unlike a lot of real soupy and slidey vodka slices, but the absolute best thing about these slices was the SIZE!! Longer than a square, they were like French bread length. It was like getting 3 slices for the price of 2... Absolutely delicious!! I can't recommend Rosa's high enough! GET THERE!!!

This pizza was just okay. The crust was quite thick and the toppings were generous though almost…read moretoo heavy. The grandma slice was much greasier than expected and kind of difficult to bite. The veggie pizza was piled high but with very little seasoning on them, making the pizza slightly watery. Many pizzerias to pick from - won't be returning here.

Both the food and the service were top notch. Food was reasonably priced and served hot and fresh…read more First time we have eaten there and will most definitely be going back soon.

This place is a gem. Anthony's 'Grandma' pie is so great, I would suggest moving to Huntington, if…read moreat all possible, so you can have it a few times a week. Although I live in LA (retired screenwriter), I know LA is not the top city for pizza, but I am originally from New York, and I believe New York is in that top slot, and I feel that Junior's Pizza, on New York Ave in Huntington is about as good as pizza gets-- anywhere. I used to drive 75 miles from Manhattan with my friends to Trenton, NJ to eat pizza at DeLorenzo's which was our #1 spot for years. When it closed, Junior's in Huntington became our #1 spot. This is a simple, warm place with an owner who knows how to bake a pie. He has studied his craft, and has perfected it. I don't get to NY too often, but when I do, eating Anthony's 'Grandma' pie at Junior's makes the trip worth it. No place like it.