Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Starters American Eatery

    4.7 (7 reviews)
    Updated 2 months ago

    Order Starters American Eatery Takeout or Delivery

    Starters American Eatery Salad Restaurant Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Starters American Eatery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    10 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    It's pretty new spot Great bar food , burgers, fried pickles tater tots been a couple of times now and the food is always spot on

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Starters American Eatery

    You might also consider

    Kevin’s Restaurant - Spring Roll appetizer

    Kevin’s Restaurant

    4.7(20 reviews)
    5.1 mi

    For an appetizer we had the crab/lobster cakes, with a nice mango relish in the middle and tasty…read moresauce. For dinner I order the French pork chop saltimbocca with spinach, mushrooms, and marsala sauce topped with fontina cheese. Very very good, thick pork chop also. This dinner also had a potato croquette, stuffed with potato, and a smokey cheese. Delicious! Samantha who was working our table was superb with a nice personality.

    This is my second time coming to Kevin's restaurant and both times the food was good. I honestly…read moredon't remember what I had the first time but it was for dinner and I know I really enjoyed the meal and the service. This time I went for lunch with my wife. We ordered the French onion soup and it was excellent. I knew the soup would be great as Kevin is a chef and takes pride in every aspect of his creations. My wife had the hanger steak salad which is served on top of large plate of leafy green with fresh vegetables and some wedge fries, it was solid! This was one of the daily specials and did not disappoint. I had another one of the specials an oyster po-boy. The bread was delicious and they must make it in house. The greens were fresh and the tomatoes sweet however there were only two small oysters on each half of the sandwich? Very small and really unnoticeable give the size of the sandwich. I was really disappointed because I love oysters and was surprised that they didn't add more to the sandwich. It was served with a nice spicy mayonnaise and homemade fries. Maybe they were running out of oysters, which they should have just taken it off the menu. Either way I'd rather have a traditional Po-boy loaded with oysters and less of the greens and tomatoes. The taste was on point but disappointing for the lack of oysters. I will definitely go back but I won't order this item again. See photo! The staff was very attentive and the atmosphere was cozy.

    Photos
    Kevin’s Restaurant - Dining area with small bar

    Dining area with small bar

    Kevin’s Restaurant - Dip

    Dip

    Kevin’s Restaurant - Orange Roughy stuffed with Crab Meat

    See all

    Orange Roughy stuffed with Crab Meat

    Chopped and Pressed - Turkey Wrap and garlic bread with cheese and pepperoni

    Chopped and Pressed

    3.1(33 reviews)
    22.0 mi

    Decided to give this place a try after all my coworkers were raving about it. I ordered the falafel…read morebowl and it was pretty good. The flavors were all clean and fresh. It was a nice to order takeout from a place that didn't consist of heavily fried or carby foods. The dish came with 3 falafels, kale, kale hummus, quinoa, and marinated carrots. I actually really enjoyed the carrots and the kale was perfectly cut (easy to put it on my fork and eat it). I ordered my food ahead of time and it was ready for me when I came to pick it up! I would probably order from here again! I'm interested in trying more! I just wish they had a few more vegetarian options!

    Gas stations seem to have best delis lately, and here is definitely great. Got my food in no time…read moreand the people made sure my order was correct. So for the turkey wrap, honestly one of better turkey wraps I had, plenty of thick cut home cooked turkey and sliced deli turkey, pretty cool they use two types. Plenty of cheese and love the chipotle ranch sauce for it. Now the garlic bread with cheese and pepperoni pretty much sucked,I think they used too much garlic and butter for the bread, so it ended up being soggy and cheese was bit off in taste. The sliced sandwich pepperoni was only saving grace of the bread honestly. Will come back for the wraps, but maybe stay away from the appetizers.

    Photos
    Chopped and Pressed - A rest stop that guarantees fresh food, great coffee, low prices, and premiume service to get you back on the road

    A rest stop that guarantees fresh food, great coffee, low prices, and premiume service to get you back on the road

    Chopped and Pressed - The Upstate Grilled Cheese and Tomato Basil Soup

    The Upstate Grilled Cheese and Tomato Basil Soup

    Chopped and Pressed - Don't settle for a microwaved or mass produced lunch, CP will handcraft your lunch with fresh ingredients and get you back on the road

    See all

    Don't settle for a microwaved or mass produced lunch, CP will handcraft your lunch with fresh ingredients and get you back on the road

    Vitality Bowls - Tropical Bowl

    Vitality Bowls

    3.9(63 reviews)
    39.8 mi
    $$

    Awesome spot right off the main road perfect for a hot day when you're in desperate need of a pick…read moreme upper. After a car wash, decided I needed some fuel. It was a super hot summer day so nothing pairs better than a nice smoothie. I was highly craving a smoothie bowl but sadly didn't have much time to enjoy one. I always feel like if you don't sit down properly to enjoy a smoothie bowl, you just end up with a brain freeze. So I went for the next best thing: a power protein smoothie! They have a vegan version with pea protein and almond milk which was awesome! I happily took this to go but this Vitality Bowls location is a complete vibe to come hang out and do some work or stop in for a quick lunch break. Love their fire place and cute neon sign. I'm a sucker for neon signs hehe. The window tints keep this place nice and cool and you can sit by the window and people/car watch. Plus it's so conveniently located and great as a post grocery run if you go to Aldi. Overall, great spot for a healthy treat. They have $6 wellness Wednesday smoothies!

    Stopped by for an açaí bowl because I heard great things. Luckily I got here right before the lunch…read morerush and put my order in. Right after me, about 15 people came in in the next 10 minutes, and there was only ONE person working. He was so overwhelmed with the in-person orders and online orders.. I felt bad that they were understaffed and he was running around. It took minimum 30 min for anyone to get their order. The tropical açaí bowl was tasty but at $13.50, very pricey. Probably won't come here again given the LONG wait and steep prices.

    Photos
    Vitality Bowls - Inside

    Inside

    Vitality Bowls - To go bowls

    To go bowls

    Vitality Bowls - Power Protein Smoothie

    See all

    Power Protein Smoothie

    Giovanni's Subs & Pizzeria - (Worst pork) Roast pork on garlic bread!

    Giovanni's Subs & Pizzeria

    3.7(50 reviews)
    1.2 mi
    $

    Giovanni's has been in business for about 45 years and under the current owner for about 35 years…read more The cold sub sandwich recipe has not changed in all that time - because it works. The secret, beyond fresh veggies, olive oil and wine vinegar, is that the meats and cheese are freshly cut for each sandwich - not pre sliced which allows the surface area to dry out and get nasty. Fresh is best. They've been my (and lots of others) go-to when passing through Monticello for decades. The only similar sandwich I've come across is Jersey Mike's - also fresh sliced provisions.

    This place is totally taken and nose dive. I will never ever come back here again. Came in ordered…read morea tuna sub extra sweet pepper, tomatoes, lettuce, mayo, oil and vinegar. Sorry sir we're out of tomatoes. OK could you put extra onions and peppers on that for me sure no problem get my sandwich. Nothing but a huge amount of lettuce a teeny amount of tuna no onions and two slices of pepper. This is a total disgrace. This place was a cherished place to come to get a godfather. Today I'm hungry for a tuna sandwich and if I wasn't so hungry, I would just leave it on the counter and walk out. Not to mention $15 later for that small sub and a fountain beverage. Don't come to this establishment. They just hit the brick wall. I haven't been here in a while and I'm glad I haven't!!!! I believe the only thing that can improve about this place is them closing their doors.

    Photos
    Giovanni's Subs & Pizzeria - Counter

    Counter

    Giovanni's Subs & Pizzeria - Veal parm sub cut into strips

    Veal parm sub cut into strips

    Giovanni's Subs & Pizzeria

    See all

    Starters American Eatery - salad - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...