When the pizza is good, it is really good. Every now and then you get the wrong maker and it's not so great. The calzone is really good. Some family members also love the meatball sandwich. Great for eat in or takeaway. read more

Love the pizza, absolutely obssesed with the wings. It's a chill spot to have a slice and sit with friends or family.

This pizza is delicious! Always great! The dough has an authentic NY taste. Thin crust with great flavor! The service is always great! read more

Fishhawk Pizza - Yummy! - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

Stopped in for quick bite. 2 slice special on deck! Have always seen this place driving by so I decided to take one for the team! read more

Fishhawk Pizza - Sausage and shrooms! - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

Stopped for a quick bite and order some wings, a Caesar salad, and the calamari. The only thing worth eating were the wings, they were saucy and good. The calamari was cooked too long didn't taste fresh and the Caesar salad was average. Today's staff was not very personable, placed my order for dine in and took 25 minutes and it was packed to go. We wanted to dine in so we ate from the styrofoam boxes. Next time I'll try pizza ‍ read more

Fishhawk Pizza - Calamari -Not very good here you can taste the old ness of the oil and it's chewy - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

See all

Good things : Garlic knots- get them! Real bits of garlic and melted butter Basic Cheese Pizza - delicious, crust is great Large Chef salad - fresh, lots of toppings, big portion Our server was friendly and helpful Not-So-Good - We were assaulted by flies while we tried to eat. The flies almost won. Tables and bathroom little bit dirty. read more

Fishhawk Pizza - a pizza and a side of bread - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

Didn't taste like the good, New York style pizza that I anticipated. Since changing business hands and location some time ago, something has changed in the recipe. I don't mind paying more for a NY style pizza- it's worth it. Unfortunately, they just didn't get it right! read more

The pizza is always good but from a health perspective, there is a lot of work that needs to be had. Start by getting a better AC unit, the employees were sweating and constantly wiping sweat while attending to customers. Additionally, all cooks need to wear a hairnet while making pizzas. The pizza cook was sweating and laying the pizza on his arms, wiping his face on his apron and flipping pizza with an extremely long beard. read more

Local pizza house in Lithia FL, typical of a fast food spot. You can eat in or take out. Menu has varied assortment of typical Italian cuisine but mostly specializing in Pizza. Staff are hard working, pleasant and helpful. Drawbacks are food is served on paper plates, pizza is served without the tower and navigating the uncut spots on the small table using a table knife leaves a little bit to be desired. Pizza is very well prepared and it is tasty and no complaints. Beer and wine is also available. Recommend as a take out more than an eat in. read more

It was ready for me when I got there and the food was good. All together it was fast and easy to order read more

I went in here for the first time despite the bad reviews and ordered 2 pizzas and 2 garlic knots. 1 order was to go and one for dine in We got the garlic knots while we waited 55 mins for the pizza, the garlic knots were stale and old, drenched in this congealed butter sauce that was just thrown on top..... they were honestly the most terrible knots I've ever had. I asked to cancel the second order because I no longer wanted the one to go, the waitress argued about it until I finally told her "I don't want it because they're not good" Still against my better judgement, we waited for the pizza to arrive, I ordered a Sicilian, and the bread was too hard to eat and the sauce had a weird rotten smell. At that point I asked to cancel the to-go pizza as well and she argued with me again, then went to the counter and began talking about my family and my daughter heard them say "those stupid girls" and looked at us. Also I'd like to point out the fact that the staff makes pizzas without gloves and touches everything while in the midst of making pizzas read more

The worst. Disgrace to pizza (and food) everywhere. Ordered the margarita pizza, cheese pizza, eggplant parm sandwich, salad, and okra. Not a single bit was worth the cost or space in my hungry stomach. The pizza crust was thin and limp. Cheese was like concrete and slid right off the crust. Okra was dripping in oil with no seasoning. The lettuce in the salad was brown and inedible. The eggplant parm had two slivers of eggplant that were smothered (not in a good way) in breading on a smushed roll. A true disappointment. I'd question any review stating otherwise. read more

Complete trash!!!! Cheese shifted, cut all off, was ice cold when they delivered it. I called to let them know of the issue and Adam the manager was not accomodating. What a Complete joke. Not going back as the management was lack of and completely ignorant. Thanks again for this junk!!!!! This was not fresh, probably was for slices. You can tell by the slices and delivered too fast. read more

Fishhawk Pizza - Supposedly a well done cheese pizza. - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

So I had ice cream with my neighbors but I was really craving some pizza. So stopped in for a slice of cheese, unfortunately for me they didn't have any slices, but they did have some Sicilian pie slices. So I opted for that instead, best happenstance! This is the best pizza I have had in such a long time! DELICIOUS! The sauce is incredible, and bursting with flavor! This was only part of the experience, while I waited for my pizza to be done in the oven, the young ladies working tonight were very attentive, and provided a complimentary drink, and were just so incredibly pleasant. When my pizza was done, the young ladies ensured I didn't need anything else prior to me taking my pizza home, and were so friendly in their goodbyes. Genuinely, not the fake server personality one often encounters when eating out. read more

Fishhawk Pizza - Slice of Sicilian Pizza - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

Lo and behold, I have found another pizza place like what I'm used to in New York, Brooklyn, growing up. If you're in the area, you have to try it out. But, if you asked for New York pizza "square," they won't know what you mean...if you say give me a square, they probably won't understand. But,if you ask for the individual pizza, You will get authentic New York pizza...check out the photo and this is what you will get. This is exactly, and I mean exactly what is referred to as "New York pizza. " If you want a very attentive waitress, ask for Kendall. read more

Fishhawk Pizza - Dining area - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

See all

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE READ and use caution with Door Dash!!! The driver for Door Dash sent a text and said our food wasn't ready for pickup and she was waiting. The delay was an inconvenience but when the food arrived...what a dumpster fire. The salad was no frills at $12.00. The amazing buffalo sauce and bleu cheese dressing saved it. It was mostly lettuce but I made it work. The fried ravioli was on point. Super good!! Now the pizza, this was the intriguing part of the order. We ordered three small pizzas and they showed up very literally, one on top of the other (see photo). But wait, there's more..... After over an hour of waiting for replacement pizzas, John talked to us on the phone about the issue. We spoke for 11 minutes and he offered to personally deliver the three pizzas. This was above and beyond especially considering their overwhelming delivery and takeout orders. Not only were the pizzas delivered intact, a bottle of wine and amazing ice cream accompanied. We were assured the pizzas were not packaged incorrectly but Door Dash had caused the layered pizza effect. Thank you to the management for GREAT service and care for customers. We know times are stressful and we appreciate all you do for us in the community! read more

See all

I've never had a bad experience at this restaurant. I highly recommend. The last time I was there the AC wasn't working well and was very hot inside but it's Florida and I can handle it. read more

The pizza was just ok to be honest. They could have added more pepperoni and mushrooms because that's all I asked for. So I gave three stars as some people would like the taste read more

Pizza is excellent. Manager,Jason L. rectified a situation with an order and provided excellent customer service. He went above and beyond. I'll definitely be back and happy to give my business to Fishhawk pizza! read more

Ordered some food today for lunch. Went to pick it up. The order was perfect. The food was fresh and delicious.... It really made my day! Thanks Jon! read more

Please clean and fix the dirty ceiling tile that is falling down in the kitchen it looks gross read more

Fishhawk Pizza - Dirty ceiling falling down in kitchen and food prep area , it has been like this for months please clean and fix - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

Awesome pizza and excellent crew working there. You can order online or call in.. we have done both and both times, excellent experiences. Definitely a great pizza place for our area.. Additionally, we have eaten in and they have a great selections of food, all extremely tasty, vegetarian options as well as carnivore options. Their garlic knots that corms with their entrees are out of this world!! Their pasta dishes are also very good.. love the sauce and pasta is not overcooked! Their calzone- huge!!! We got a single as well as large and large is big enough for 3-4 people. Great local place, highly recommend folks to try this place! read more

First pizza I had when we moved here. We went with my sister, brother-in-law and niece. It was average everything. The sausage pizza was a little soggy in the very middle, which made it difficult to pick up, so I folded it Chicago-style. The place was clean, the waiter and service fine. They have arcade games for the kids and it's definitely kid-friendly. My niece had a good time at the arcade with her dad while we waited for our pizzas, and I enjoyed a glass of house wine and chatted with my daughter and sister. The wine was a cheap wine, but it hit the spot. Moving is tiring, especially after a day of unpacking. I NEEDED a drink lol. They also have some IPA beers. I'm more a wine gal than a beer gal :). They do need to wow me and up their game with their food more since the atmosphere isn't anything that stands out as 'different' than Anywhere, Florida. The sausage pizza was just a little too much. It was the one that was soggy in the middle. The plain cheese cooked up much better. They do need a good update cause the 70s are calling them, but I'm not going to dock a star for that. It was A-Ok ;). read more

See all

It's Az Long island Roosevelt Native so I love Pizza and this reminds me of home i love it , it's delicious and great service

Hi, I want thank Fishhawk pizza for going out of the way to deliver the NY pizza. Aren't we blessed to have a New York pizzeria in our neighborhood. We order the Large pie with extra cheese (see pictures below. You know how it with an authentic NY pizza, you fold it, the tip bends forward, a little may drip, with extra cheese dangling and a New York experience right in our backyard taking us (whether you lived or visited) to better time we will see again. I give Fishhawk Pizza 5 stars, I wish I can give them 10. People, Entrepreneurship is at the core of being American. We need to support our small businesses. When this all done, we want to see them there. Whether it restauranteurs, waiters, bartenders, employees at the super markets these folks are at the front trying to keep some normality in these tense days. We need to support our local businesses and their employees. We want them there when this all well and done! Hey if anything ordering or picking up from your restaurants is a way of not depleting your supplies. I am not saying be careless, do everything you feel you need to (keep distance, wash your hands after receiving delivery, sanitized, use gloves, mask, you probably can ask them to even leave the delivery in your front and you leave the cash outside - don't forget the tip). If these amazing people can make it work and support us - I am sure we can as well and support them. See the Yummy photo! God Bless America! FoodieMoy read more

Fishhawk Pizza - Authentic New York City Extra Cheese pizza right here in Lithia, Fl - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

The food is great and the beer is cold. The staff are a great bunch of young folks and the owners are pretty awesome too!!

I just found this place, while riding. It looks like a mom and pops little place. But I have to say. The pizza it's fucking good. I have to say. I am very surprised. I have. Been looking for good NYC style pizza in Tampa. But they have been so far disappointing. This place happens to make it just like i like it. Crunchy crust although out, not too greasy not too dry. Just perfect. Good cheese, good pepperoni !!! It is far as shit from Tampa. But it's worth the drive. Or in this case the ride. I had a lemonade for a drink. And it was warm even tho it had ice. Maybe it just my temperature lol. I also had two meatballs. They were amazin read more

Fishhawk Pizza - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

We ordered the antipasto salad, garlic knots, and chicken parmigiana dinner. The chicken appeared to be undercooked and chewy so we had to toss it. Will not be ordering that item again. The knots and salad were good. read more

First time I have been to this pizza place and must say it is my last time.. Pizza was soggy and not crispy at all..I would not recommend this place to anybody...Save your money.. read more

Food all wrong, nothing ready on time, order placed online not made on time and entire appetizer missing. $87 later told it wasn't their fault but the " online ordering" process, wow. read more

This place has continued to go downward. Do NOT get delivery as they will not get the order fully delivered. This is from multiple experiences. When calling back to get missing items delivered they say they will bring it but don't in any reasonable time. Then when you call back again they tell you they will credit next time you order?? Sure! We will never order or go here again and recommend you do so. There are too many pizza/Italian food choices in the area to waste your time and money here!! This used to be a good local pizza spot but now they are worthless. Spend your $ elsewhere. read more

Went their and had garlic knots. Off the first bite I could tell their was something funky. The second bite I projectile vomited all over the place. I think that their was foreign substance in the butter or it was handled without gloves. Made a comment about it to the caisher and nothing came of it . read more

Ordered calzone dough not cooked. Same as last time with the pizza. Not sure what the deal is but if I order to go... the food should be cooked and I shouldn't have to put it back in The oven. Sorry maybe it's the new ovens. read more

FHP never disappoints. I do suggest you ask for the pie to be done crispy - its the best. Group of 4 split 1/2 and 1/2 between a MEATS and a SPECIAL, we all got to eat at least 1 slice of each. I have tried all other local pizzas at least once and FHP is always my #1 Their salads and wings are also awesome. Cheap drafts too... Worth noting is the fact that the owners are clearly in it for the community. There must have been at least 10 high school kids working that day and the place wasn't packed. Thank you guys for helping our kids and our community. read more

The stromboli is a must have! Flavor, size, and beyond generous portions......nailed it!

Used to work here, owner has a complex of some kind. Walk up to him when he's having a conversation and try to ask a question you'll get a blank stare and a speech about how he doesn't tolerate talking to his own employees. Foods good but not worth the 1-2 hour wait time that's normal for weekend night. Very hostile work place. Please change the oil in the fryer that has been used for many months now it's nasty. Gloves aren't used in the kitchen. Overall really wish the worse for these guys no matter how humble and kind the owners seem on Facebook. Manager joe recently hired doesn't have a clue. read more

Great place! The food is very good and there's a huge selection. Nice place for the family. Arcade for the kids and adult gelato for the parents. I read the other reviews before eating here with my family and was kind of nervous but nothing was served on a paper plate and the booths and restrooms were in good condition. Highly recommend and will be back again ! read more

See all

Food is mediocre and the establishment is just dirty inside and outside. I assure you,that you won't be impressed.

Had a great experience for my first time going today during lunch. Great lunch special for $6 and nice open, bright, and clean interior. Lots of tv's, great area in the back, and even an outdoor patio...btw, the pizza was GREAT and tasty. You will definitely see me here again! read more

Fishhawk Pizza - Pizza by the slice - New American Near Me - Lithia, Florida

Ordered an XL pizza for takeout. Arrived a bit early and the pizza was already ready. Side note, the XL is basically a "party" pizza or sheet pizza. We had 5-6 people eating it and had plenty leftover. Pizza is pretty good, wish we got the Large so it was cut into normal slices, not the squares. Overall, solid pizza. read more